Sunset Over Hope Valley: Keeping Secrets

On June 6, 2024 By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

It seems like almost every character is keeping a secret in
this episode of When Calls the Heart. Lucas wants Montague’s hotel bid
to be kept under wraps. Nathan wants to protect Allie from the truth about her
biological father. Faith prolongs telling Lilly about her grandmother’s
recovery. But, sometimes, keeping secrets is not a bad thing in Hope Valley.
Earlier this season, Elizabeth keeps Nathan’s surprise party a secret. In this
episode, Bill has a surprise for Jack Jr. When it comes to keeping secrets on When
Calls the Heart, it depends on the character and the context of their
secret. The secrecy can cause a conflict within an episode’s story or give the
audience a certain perception of a character. What is not a secret is how kept
secrets in a television show adds intrigue and gives viewers a reason to still
watch. When these secrets are finally revealed, it can, sometimes, be
satisfying.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

*When Calls the Heart* season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 11

Episode: 9

Name: Truth Be Told

Major stories:

Montague returns to Hope Valley to discuss his hotel bid
with Lucas. During their meeting, Lucas reveals how an acceptance of the bid
equals an acceptance of 50% of the hotel’s profits. When Montague brings up his
desire to receive 60% of the hotel’s profits, Henry denies that request. Meanwhile,
Rosemary and Bill discover Montague’s return to Hope Valley. They even approach
Montague and question his involvement in the mystery surrounding Lucas’ injury.
Montague claims he had nothing to do with shooting Lucas. After learning how
Lucas is strongly considering working with Montague on the hotel, Rosemary
struggles with whether to share this news with Hope Valley. She ultimately decides
to write about Montague and Lucas, despite Lucas wanting to keep Montague’s
hotel bid a secret. When her article is published, Lucas is very upset about
Rosemary sharing his secret with the town, believing she broke his trust. Rosemary
stands by her decision, as she feels the residents of Hope Valley have a right
to know what’s happening in their town. But shortly after Rosemary’s article is
published, Montague is attacked in Hope Valley’s stables. Due to the attack, Montague
receives a concussion and his arm is put in a sling. Montague not only still
denies shooting Lucas, he also refuses to work with Lucas on the hotel,
thinking the project will put his life further into danger.

Allie’s family album makes her curious about her biological
father. This is because there are no pictures of him in this family album. When
Allie asks Nathan about her biological father, Nathan refuses to share any
information about him. Upset by this secrecy, Allie turns to Elizabeth for
advice. Elizabeth tells Allie how her search for her father is up to her, but
she shouldn’t shut Nathan out. Nathan also turns to Elizabeth for advice,
revealing how Allie’s father, Dylan, showed up in Hope Valley back in season
eight. Elizabeth tells Nathan how he should trust his gut as well as know when
the timing is right. Later in the episode, Nathan shares the truth about Dylan
with Allie. This information does not deter Allie’s desire to meet Dylan, as
she believes people can change. Allie is so determined, she learns how to
contact Dylan while volunteering to work the phone board at the Mercantile.

Newspaper image created by Zlatko_plamenov at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-psd/newspaper-mockup_1386098.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/mockup”>Mockup psd created by Zlatko_plamenov – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor story:

Dora, Lilly’s grandmother, calls Faith to tell her how she
has finally recovered from her medical issues. This means she will retrieve
Lilly in the following days. While Faith is happy Dora has recovered, she is
also sad that Lilly will soon leave Hope Valley. She turns to Joseph because
she doesn’t know how she will share this recent news with Lilly. Joseph
suggests giving Lilly a perfect day in Hope Valley, so Lilly will always
remember the good times she had in this town. Taking Joseph’s advice to heart,
Faith makes this perfect day a reality. From a trip to the hair salon to an
afternoon in the park, Lilly has a smile on her face the entire time. Faith
even shares with Joseph how she plans on asking Dora if she will allow Faith to
stay in Lilly’s life. Later in the episode, Faith comes clean about Dora’s
health with Lilly. Even though Lilly is happy to see her grandmother again, all
she wants is to have another perfect day with Faith and her grandmother.

Close-up of pony image created by Flatart at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background photo created by flatart – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

·
When Allie shares her desire to learn about her
father with Angela, Angela tells Allie how Jacob recently called and invited
her family to spend Christmas with him. As soon as Angela said this, I thought
this story could lend itself to a Christmas movie! I know the creative team
behind When Calls the Heart doesn’t create movies in between seasons
anymore. But if Hallmark is looking for ideas for this or a future Christmas
season, I think a Christmas movie about the Canfield family could work,
especially since the movie would already have a built-in audience.

·
I know no character is meant to be everyone’s
cup of tea. But out of all the seasons Lucas has been on When Calls the
Heart, he was his most unlikeable in this episode. While he had his heart
in the right place, he was too narrow-minded and stubborn about his “grand
vision”. It got to the point where, in this episode, his plans seemed
underhanded. As a Heartie, I’d like to see this hotel brought to life in season
twelve. However, I don’t think the hotel is worth losing friends over.

·
In my re-cap’s introduction, I mentioned Bill
having a surprise for Jack Jr. This surprise is a pony, as Jack Jr. has
expressed his wish to ride a horse. When Calls the Heart has a history
of recruiting cute animals to appear on the show. But I can’t help mentioning
how adorable Pal the pony was in this episode! In fact, this pony looked like a
giant stuffed animal.

Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? How
do you think Lucas’ “grand vision” will be resolved? Tell me in the comment
section below!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Let the Show Go On

On May 28, 2024 By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

In this episode of When Calls the Heart, the plans of Hope Valley’s choir fall through. They don’t go to Salt Lake City as originally expected. To help Tom as well as other choirs, a new idea is put in place where everyone benefits. This isn’t the first time things didn’t work out in Hope Valley. But I’m willing to guess the show itself has experienced hiccups along the way. Making a television show is a huge creative endeavor. When working on a large project involving multiple people, there’s always a chance things could go wrong. Most fans don’t think about these possibilities, as they just see the final product. From the perspective of a long-time Heartie, though, the solution in this episode of When Calls the Heart made me reflect on other likely behind-the-scenes conflicts and how they were resolved. Because as the saying goes, “the show must go on”.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 11

Episode: 8

Name: Brother’s Keeper

Major stories:

Nathan contacted the police in New York in an attempt to track down Mr. Sweeney. The New York police were able to arrest Mr. Sweeney and retrieve the $65 from Hope Valley’s choir. Unfortunately, Mr. Sweeney gambled the $300 collected from Benson Hills’ and Jamison’s choir. In an emergency choir meeting, Tom comes clean with all this news. Helping Tom save face, Nathan and Elizabeth quickly come up with the idea of hosting their own music festival to raise money for the aforementioned choirs. However, they allow Tom to take full credit for their idea. Maisie is not happy when Rosemary shares all this information with her. She believes Tom should be arrested, but Nathan reassures Maisie that the money will be raised. The festival itself is not the only way Hope Valley raises money. Several stalls selling food and valuable items are sparkled throughout the town. The Voices of the Valley festival is a success, with over $200 raised. But during the financial count, the choir discovers they are just under $300. When Lucas learns this, he takes money from his cultural fund and donates it to the festival. Before leaving Hope Valley, Tom makes the sad realization he’ll soon have to find a new job.

Just in time for the Voices of the Valley festival, Jacob Canfield arrives in Hope Valley. He still expects an apology from Joseph, but Joseph has no idea what he should apologize for. This angers Jacob and makes him consider leaving Hope Valley. While Minnie tries to coax Jacob to stay in town, Jacob reveals he hasn’t attended church or sang in over ten years. When Minnie shares this information with Joseph, he feels bad that whatever he did caused his brother to pull away from God. As he tries to figure out what he did wrong, Joseph turns to Henry for advice. Henry says that no matter what Joseph did, Jacob was hurt and Joseph should apology for hurting his brother. Later in the episode, Joseph does apologize to Jacob. When Joseph finally learns why Jacob is upset, he discovers that Jacob felt abandoned after he married Minnie. Though Jacob got the apology he wanted, he is still upset because he doesn’t believe the apology will change anything. Joseph disagrees, as he believes there is still hope for his and Jacob’s relationship. Right before Hope Valley’s choir performs “Amazing Grace”, Jacob becomes the missing tenor the choir was looking for. Both Canfield brothers later confess how much they’ve missed each other.

As promised, Nathan allows Clayton Pike to stay in Hope Valley during his prison transfer so Rosemary could interview Clayton. But when given the opportunity to interview Clayton, Rosemary, as well as Bill, find no luck. This is because Clayton refuses to reveal the identity of who really shot Lucas. Even when Lucas has a one-on-one conversation with Clayton, Clayton still remains silent. The next day, Clayton shares that the man responsible for Lucas getting hurt is so powerful, even the Mounties can’t intervene. Later, at the Queen of Hearts Hotel, Henry confronts Lucas about his decision to, possibly, accept Montague’s hotel bid. Henry addresses how Montague doesn’t have a good reputation with the people of Hope Valley due to decisions he made in the previous season. Lucas confesses how the Benson Hills Oil Company recently closed, causing hundreds of employees to lose their jobs. When Henry brings up Jeanette’s hotel bid, saying it looked legitimate, Lucas shuts out that possibility, simply asking Henry to trust him on that choice.

Money plant image created by Dooder at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/infographic”>Infographic vector created by Dooder – Freepik.com</a>. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/watering-the-coin-plant_1076121.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Similar to season eleven’s seventh episode, “Facing the Music”, there are no minor stories in this episode.

String of musical notes image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/pentagram-vector_710290.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

In the previous episode, Tom went on a date with Faith at The Café. Toward the end of this episode, at the Voices of the Valley party at the Queens of Hearts Hotel, Tom gets asked by Faith to dance before Elizabeth asks Nathan to dance. I like the idea of Tom and Faith sharing a romantic relationship, especially since Max Lloyd-Jones and Andrea Brooks had nice on-screen chemistry. But if these characters are going to share a relationship, one of two things have to happen; either Tom needs to make more frequent appearances on the show or Faith needs to live closer to Tom.

Similar to last week’s episode, this episode of When Calls the Heart was stronger than other episodes this season! The featured stories were intriguing and weren’t as drawn out as season eleven’s previous episodes, so far. With only four episodes left, it makes me wonder how some of these stories will be resolved?

In my re-cap for this season’s second episode, I mentioned how curious I was to see how Henry’s story turned out in season eleven. This thought came after witnessing Henry adopting a happier and calmer personality, as well as developing a genuine interest in Hope Valley’s agriculture and foliage. Now that Henry starting working for Lucas, he has become Hope Valley’s Voice of Reason. In my opinion, this is a pleasant new direction for Henry’s story! It gives him a sense of purpose while acknowledging how far Henry has come.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you like Henry becoming Hope Valley’s Voice of Reason? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Waiting for Tom Thornton

On May 20, 2024 By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Last September, I wrote a list sharing which ten characters
I’d love to see return to When Calls the Heart. My number one choice was
Tom Thornton, as his last appearance was all the way back in season five. So,
when I discovered Tom was returning to the show, my interest in the rest of
season eleven piqued! When Tom told Elizabeth and Jack Jr. what he did for a living,
he said he “sold happiness”. I would like to point out how Tom has been doing
that all along. Though I can only speak for myself, Tom has always made me
happy whenever he appeared on the show. Despite his more recent appearances
being brief, these moments were special and cherished. Looking back on Tom’s
story, I’m starting to realize how his and Henry’s story share several similarities.
Both characters had a troubled past, made a conscious effort to change, and now
have brighter futures!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 11

Episode: 7

Name: Facing the Music

Major stories:

Tom Thornton has returned to Hope Valley in honor of Jack’s
birthday. After visiting his brother’s grave, Tom reconnects with familiar faces,
like Faith and Elizabeth, and meets new ones, such as Allie, Angela, and
Nathan. Tom’s career has taken a new path, this time selling sheet music for a
man named Mr. Sweeney. When the members of Hope Valley’s choir discover Tom is
looking for acts for an upcoming music festival, they become interested in
participating in the event. Tom informs them how only one spot remains in the
festival, so they would have to audition. The choir agrees to audition over the
phone, with the audition itself being a success. Because the choir received the
aforementioned last spot in the festival, Tom tells them they have to pay the $65
entry fee. Even though the choir agrees to chip in five dollars each, Elizabeth
and even Nathan are concerned by how quickly things are happening. When Nathan
and Elizabeth confront Tom about the entry fee, Tom reassures them how the
entire endeavor is legitimate. However, a phone call from Mr. Sweeney at the
Mercantile indicates how things are not going according to plan. Toward the end
of the episode, Elizabeth discovers Tom checked out of the Queen of Hearts
hotel and is on his way to Union City. She and Nathan find Tom waiting at the
train station. Tom confesses Mr. Sweeney not only stole the $65 dollars from
Hope Valley’s choir, but has stolen money from the festival’s other
participants. Tom turns to Elizabeth and Nathan for help with this situation.

Rosemary and Bill bring their lead on Luca’s case to Nathan.
Nathan would like to look into Clayton Pike’s connection to Union City
Holdings, but states how the Mounted Police are working on other cases.
Rosemary still cannot speak to Clayton himself, but feels the next best thing
would be to speak to his mother, Hazel. With Hazel living in Union City, Nathan
agrees to help Rosemary organize an interview. He also informs Bill and
Rosemary how Clayton is transferring prisons soon, so he’ll try to get an
interview for Rosemary. The original plan was for Rosemary to travel to Union
City for her interview with Hazel. But plans change when Hazel ends up visiting
Rosemary in Hope Valley. During the interview, Hazel claims she and Clayton
were at a political event around the time Lucas was shot. She even shares how
Clayton was taking care of her after she had injured her hip. Hazel received
money for surgery a week before Lucas became injured. She says a friend of
Clayton’s gave her the money, sharing how Clayton and the friend met at church.
While Hazel was at the hospital, Montague paid her visit and gave her flowers.

Lucas is having difficulty finding investors for the hotel.
Though Montague’s and Jeanette’s offer are still on the table, Lucas would
rather not work with them. Out of desperation, Lucas asks Lee to help find
investors. Though Lee agrees to help, he even has no luck finding a solution. As
a last resort, Mr. Mitchell, who now works for Lucas, suggests using an
emergency fund to start the hotel. Henry, who has recently started working for
Lucas, believes this is a bad idea. His belief is based on how the money in the
emergency fund came from the people of places like Hope Valley. Henry tells
Lucas to step away from the hotel if no other options are available. But toward
the end of the episode, Lucas ends up calling Montague.

Since Tom Thornton came back to *When Calls the Heart*, I figured adding this picture of Tom and Jack to my re-cap made sense. Image created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel.

Minor stories:

Because so much emphasis was placed on the major stories,
there are no minor stories in this episode.

Birthday party set-up image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/food”>Food photo created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

· Last month, Net (from It’s a Wonderful Movie)
shared an announcement about two new Signed, Sealed, Delivered movies.
One of these movies, currently titled “Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon
and Back”, revolves around the POstables going on a road trip to find a rock
star. You’re probably wondering what this Signed, Sealed, Delivered
movie has to do with this episode of When Calls the Heart. During his
time in Hope Valley, Tom briefly sang a song at the Queen of Hearts hotel. I’m
not sure if Max Lloyd-Jones sang in that scene or if the singing belonged to a
voice double. But if Max sang himself and if Signed, Sealed, Delivered’s
creative team wanted to utilize more talent from Hallmark’s community, I hope
Max stars in “Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back” as the
aforementioned rock star!

· I’m disappointed the music festival ended up
becoming a scam. With When Calls the Heart receiving a twelfth season, Hope
Valley’s choir traveling to Salt Lake City could have served as a two-part
season premiere. If When Calls the Heart’s creative team was interested
in creating movies again, the music festival may have been the plot of the
film. According to the trailer for the next episode, it looks like Hope Valley
will host their own music festival. With all this said, it feels like the show’s
writers forced the original music festival to fall through just to keep the
story in Hope Valley.

· This episode is, so far, the best one from season
eleven! It was great to see Tom come back to the show. But it was also great to
see the script less drawn out than other episodes this season. There was more intrigue
from each featured story, which kept me invested in what was happening on
screen. I’m definitely looking forward to seeing how the story plays out in
next week’s episode!

What are your thoughts on this episode? Are you excited to
see Tom Thornton return to Hope Valley? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Very Important Hope Valley People

On May 14, 2024 By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Shortly after Lee became Mayor, Rosemary suggests organizing
an event to allow Hope Valley’s residents to have a one-on-one meeting with
Lee. She creates a list of notable people who she’d like to invite, calling
these folks “Very Important Hope Valley People”. While some of these “Very
Important Hope Valley People” include Mike, Mei, and Ned, this quote from
Rosemary brings up an excellent point. There are several characters on When
Calls the Heart that have returned season after season. Over the years,
characters like Elizabeth, the Coulters, and Lucas have become beloved within
the Heartie community. Well liked characters, such as Tom Thornton, Jesse, and
Clara have left a memorable impression during their time on the show. An
argument can be made how every character, whether they’ve made a brief
appearance in Hope Valley or have made the town their permanent residence,
makes up the “Very Important Hope Valley People”. The talents, skills,
personalities, and connections of every character make When Calls the Heart
what it is today!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 11

Episode: 6

Name: Believe

Major stories:

With the Jack Thornton School being integrated into the
valley school district, Elizabeth is expecting a visit from Mr. Wilcox, the valley
school district’s superintendent. Plans change when Thomas Higgins becomes the
new superintendent and pays Elizabeth a visit instead. The purpose of the visit
is to inform Elizabeth of the “guidelines” schools in the valley district must
follow. Because there is a history between Thomas and Elizabeth, he tries to
use intimidation to get Elizabeth to make certain choices. In a meeting about
these “guidelines”, Elizabeth addresses the use of standardized tests. She
fears these tests will limit her students’ academic potential, as she believes
her students learn best with more individualized teaching methods. Thomas doesn’t
agree with Elizabeth, suggesting how some students should be placed in
specialized schooling instead. Shortly after this meeting, Thomas meets Anna,
who is still working alongside Elizabeth. Later in the episode, Anna agrees to
go back to teaching college with Thomas. Anna explains to Elizabeth how Thomas
is organizing a recruiting opportunity for her career after college. Concerned
for Anna’s safety and Thomas’ constant intimidation, Elizabeth turns to Nathan
to share her history with Thomas. While attending teaching college, Elizabeth
caught Thomas’ attention. Since Thomas was the head of the teaching college at
the time, he possessed power and influence. At first, Elizabeth was flattered by
the attention she was receiving from Thomas. But over time, he became more obsessed
with Elizabeth, to the point where he adopted unprofessional behavior. With
this information in mind, Nathan and Elizabeth organize a meeting in an attempt
to get Thomas to confess to his poor choices. This plan works and Nathan warns
Thomas of the charges he’ll be given. To utilize the power he has, Thomas turns
to Lucas and shares this meeting between him, Elizabeth, and Nathan. Lucas
states how he believes Elizabeth as well as the other women that were
intimidated by Thomas. Because Thomas tries to intimidate Lucas into taking his
side, Lucas informs Thomas of other charges he will receive. Thomas leaves Hope
Valley a less powerful man than before he came to town.

While organizing a meeting between Lee and Hope Valley’s
residents, Rosemary is still investigating Lucas’ case. One day in town, she makes
a trip to town hall and delivers more documents relating to Pike. Rosemary
shares with Bill how she made a request to speak with Pike in jail, but the
request was denied by the judge. Later
in the episode, Rosemary visits Bill at the saloon with an important piece of
information. According to Pike’s employment records, he worked for Union City
Holdings, the company Montague owned in season ten. This fuels Bill and
Rosemary’s belief that Montague may have played a role in Lucas’ case.

Magnifying glass image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/magnifying-glass-with-fingerprint-in-flat-style_2034684.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/flat”>Flat vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Joseph attempts to write a letter to his brother, Jacob. His
attempts haven’t been fruitful, the words not coming to Joseph easily. In order
to help her husband, Minnie asks Joseph what he’d like to tell his brother.
Joseph shares how he would like to go back to the way things were. He also isn’t
aware of how his feud with Jacob started. Meanwhile, Mei is missing her
brother, who is a Merchant Marine. At the café with Mike, she reflects on her
mom’s cooking. This reflection inspires Mei to create a home cooked meal for
Mike. Though she has to specially order some ingredients and borrow a wok from
Florence, Mei accomplishes her goals and hosts a dinner date. Mike is not only
impressed with the food itself, he’s also impressed with Mei’s efforts to make
the date special. Mike proclaims how he’d like to be a part of Mei’s whole life.

Traditional Chinese dragon image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/design”>Design vector created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

·
As I mentioned in this re-cap, Anna leaves Hope
Valley to return to teaching college with Thomas. Before she leaves, Anna
explains to Elizabeth how Thomas is organizing a recruiting opportunity for her
career after college. But during this explanation, Elizabeth doesn’t warn Anna
about the kind of person Thomas is. She also doesn’t share her story with Anna,
in the hope of preventing Anna from being in harms way. Even though Elizabeth
confronted Thomas, I wish Elizabeth had said something to Anna before she left
Hope Valley, especially since she knew what Thomas was capable of.

·
With the eleventh season of When Calls the
Heart at the halfway point, I’d like to make an observation. It seems like
there are more sibling related stories this season compared to past seasons.
First, we have Mike dealing with the sibling rivalry of his sister, Maisie. Then,
Angela and Cooper worked through a feud after hearing a story about Joseph and
Jacob. Mei brought up her brother in this episode and Tom Thornton will come to
Hope Valley in the next episode. This overarching theme is one I definitely did
not expect this season!

·
In my re-cap for this season’s first episode, I
commented on how the sign for the café changed from ‘Abigail’s Café’ to ‘The Café’.
This is not the only establishment in Hope Valley to receive a new sign. The
day care was given their own sign and the ‘Queen of Hearts Saloon’ is now the ‘Queen
of Hearts Hotel’. It makes me wonder if any more signs in Hope Valley will
change?

What are your thoughts on this episode? What do you think
Mike and Mei’s next date will be? Tell me in the comment section below!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Celebrating 40 Years of ‘Murder, She Wrote’ with the Blogathon; Cabot Cove-thon!

On May 5, 2024August 8, 2024 By 18cinemalane13 Comments

When I signed up for the It’s In The Name of The Title Blogathon, one of the movies I chose to review was Harry & Son starring Robby Benson. When I think of Robby, I think of how he voiced Beast in the 1991 animated film, Beauty and the Beast. Remembering how Angela Lansbury also starred in that film, I always thought it was a missed opportunity for Murder, She Wrote to not promote the 1991 movie, especially since the show was still a popular program at the time. This led me to realize Angela and Robby have another thing in common; they both starred in a project released in 1984. In Angela’s case, that program was Murder, She Wrote! In honor of the show’s 40^th anniversary, I’m hosting Cabot Cove-thon! Because Murder, She Wrote is a multifaceted program, there are many ideas for blogathon participants to choose from. Here is a list of possible subjects:

Cabot Cove-thon banner created by me, Sally Silverscreen. Original picture found on IMDB.

Murder, She Wrote episodes
Characters, locations, or stories from the show
Actors, Actresses, behind-the-scenes team members, etc. who worked on Murder, She Wrote
Murder, She Wrote made-for-TV movies
Murder, She Wrote books
The Murder, She Wrote theme park attraction at Universal Studios Florida
Movies, tv shows/tv show episodes, or books taking place in a location featured on Murder, She Wrote (example: a movie set in Maine)
Movies, tv shows/tv show episodes, or books released between 1984 to 1996
Programs Angela Lansbury starred in (example: 1991’s Beauty and the Beast)

If you’re interested in joining Cabot Cove-thon and found an idea you’re interested in writing about, please read the official rules before signing up for the event.

Please be respectful to your fellow blogathon participants and the subject you’re writing about
Only new entries are allowed
Participants are able to publish a maximum of four entries
Only two blogathon participants are allowed to write about a blogathon subject (example: no more than two people can write about a specific Murder, She Wrote episode)
Creativity and fun are encouraged
Blogathon entries must be submitted between September 27^th to October 1^st
If you plan to publish your entry earlier or later than the blogathon week, please let me know before the event
If you’d like to join the blogathon, share your blogathon ideas in the comment section of this announcement post
Feature one of the five blogathon banners anywhere in your entry

Cabot Cove-thon Participants

— Sally from 18 Cinema Lane — Editorial about Why Universal Orlando Resort Should Host Murder, She Wrote Weekend, Review of Murder, She Wrote: Dying to Retire by Jessica Fletcher and Donald Bain

— Kristen from Hoofers and Honeys — Review of The Harvey Girls (1946)

— Rebecca from Taking Up Room — Review of Death on the Nile (1978)

Take 3: Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans Review

On April 28, 2024 By 18cinemalane1 Comment

Despite Hallmark Mystery creating less mystery series, the Curious Caterer series is, in my opinion, the strongest film collection the network currently releases. While I found the first and third film to be fine, I quite liked the second film. So, I was very excited when I discovered Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans was on the horizon! What intrigued me about the newest chapter was how the story revolved around a costume party. There have been costume parties featured in other Hallmark Mystery productions. However, these parties have played such a minor role in the overall story. Based on the film’s promotional photos and trailer, it looked like the set and costume design were being taken seriously by Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans’ creative team. But I didn’t want to get my hopes up too high, as Hallmark Mystery’s presentations have, so far, been underwhelming. Was Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans Hallmark’s “diamond in the rough”? The only way to solve this mystery is to read my review!

*Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans* poster created by Timeless Pictures, Basset Hound Distribution, and Hallmark Media

Things I liked about the film:

The acting: Throughout the Curious Caterer series,
Nikki Deloach and Andrew W. Walker have had consistently strong on-screen
chemistry. What has made this chemistry work is how Nikki and Andrew give solid
performances individually and together! Now that Goldy and Tom’s relationship
has progressed to being a dating couple, there are more romantic, even flirty
interactions between the characters. A great example is when Goldy is setting
up the appetizers at the costume party. Attempting to impress Goldy, Tom recites
Shakespearian poetry. But during the recitation, Goldy discovers the poem is written
on Tom’s hand. The interaction was not only humorous, but also a sweet moment
shared by Tom and Goldy. This sweetness
feels genuine, as smiles and a mutual fondness are presented through the
expressions and emotions Nikki and Andrew share on screen!

Besides the main stars, the supporting cast gave good
performances throughout Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans. One performance I
was really impressed with came from Brock Morgan! Introduced in Curious
Caterer: Fatal Vows as Detective Dave Trach, Brock reprises his role in
this new chapter of the series. Between these two films, Brock consistently
presented Dave with a serious persona. In Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans,
emotion was incorporated in more subtle, yet effective ways. While pursuing a
suspect, Dave’s father becomes injured. As the wound is being treated, Dave
shares a conversation with his father. If you look closely, you can see Dave is
shaking during this conversation, showing how the situation affected him.
Another scene shows Dave receiving terrible news. Throughout that scene, Dave
is visibly upset, his mouth formed into a frown and his eyes showing a look of discouragement.
But as the scene progresses, tears slowly appear in Dave’s eyes. After watching
this movie, I wish Brock Morgan was given a starring role in a Hallmark
production!

The mystery: As I brought up in the introduction, the story
of Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans revolves around a costume party. But
during this party, a snowstorm forces the guests to stay in a castle with
little to no technology. These elements create a locked room mystery, with the
characters utilizing the skills and tools they have at their disposal. While
trying to piece the mystery together, Goldy and company use tapestry as a
mystery board. Name cards, antique looking paper, and even caricature drawings
make up profiles for each suspect. Because Tom, Dave, and even Mason are guests
at the party, they don’t have their detective supplies with them. However, they
are able to use some of Goldy’s kitchen utensils, such as disposable gloves,
mason jars, and tweezers, to solve the case. The ways the characters adapt to their environment
showcase the creativity of the film’s writing!

The incorporation of fencing: The costume party in Curious
Caterer: Foiled Plans was a fundraiser for Elk Park Prep Academy’s fencing
team. There were even fencing matches held during the party. Though it was
given a smaller role in the story, I liked the incorporation of fencing. In my
opinion, fencing is such an underrated sport, especially in the world of Hallmark
movies. Because the fencing team’s coach was one of the mystery’s suspects,
some brief insight into fencing was provided in the script. This served as a
short introduction of the sport for the film’s audience.

The humor: Adding humor to a Hallmark mystery program can be
tricky. Not enough humor may make a film too serious in nature. But incorporate
too much humor and the movie might feel too goofy. With Curious Caterer:
Foiled Plans, the overall humor was sprinkled throughout the story. This gave
the audience breaks from the darkness of the mystery while allowing the script
to be taken seriously. After the mystery had been introduced, Tom wonders who
among his group has a notebook with them. Because of the snowstorm, they can’t
reach their cars to retrieve a notebook. As everyone denies having a notebook
with them, Mason tells Tom how his pants don’t have pockets. This random comment
was funny because Mason answers Tom’s question without answering his question.

Castle photo created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/old-castle-in-the-mountians_1286237.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/tree”>Tree image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What I didn’t like about the film:

A random attraction: When Dave Trach was introduced in Curious
Caterer: Fatal Vows, he did not like Goldy’s friend, Marla. This dislike
was caused by Marla helping Tom with a case. In Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans, however, Marla and Dave act really friendly with
one another. They are so friendly, it feels like they are in a dating
relationship. To me, this attraction felt random because, from what I remember,
there were no hints that Dave and Marla were romantically interested in each
other. My guess is the film’s creative team made a weak attempt of including
the “enemies to lovers” trope.

Things that don’t make sense: After the story’s murder
victim was discovered, Dave’s father instructs the party’s guests to travel through
the castle in pairs. Later in the movie, Goldy’s daughter, Olive, finds a key
clue in the case. When this discovery was made, Goldy criticized Olive for
wandering the castle. Yet Olive did follow the instructions of Dave’s father,
as she made the case’s discovery while exploring the castle with a friend from her
school’s fencing team. This is just one example of parts of the story not
making sense.

An overshadowed crowd: A snowstorm causes the party’s guests
to remain stuck in the castle. The longer the mystery is drawn out, the more
frustrated the guests become. But this frustration isn’t really highlighted in
the story. Instead, the script focuses on the frustrations of the mystery’s
suspects. Because the crowd itself isn’t given as much attention in the story,
the magnitude of the crowd’s feelings is not felt. Though Goldy calms the crowd
by baking cookies and making hot chocolate, the crowd’s collective emotions remain
the same for most of the movie.

Magnifying fingerprints image created by Balintseby at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/glass”>Glass vector created by Balintseby – Freepik.com</a>. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/fingerprint-investigation_789253.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

My overall impression:

When I reviewed Crimes of Fashion: Killer Clutch, I
shared how, at the time, I wasn’t impressed with Hallmark’s new mystery movies.
I was also not impressed with One Bad Apple: A Hannah Swensen Mystery,
as I found the film disappointing. After almost four months of underwhelming
productions, Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans was a much-needed breath of
fresh air! There are so many things this movie got right, such as the
creativity of the mystery itself. Other elements of the film were also well
delivered, like the set and costume design. I would say Curious Caterer:
Foiled Plans is the best chapter in this series. In fact, I’d say this is the
best mystery movie Hallmark has released this year, so far! Because the bar was
raised so high in Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans, I’m not sure how Curious
Caterer’s creative team will be able to top this film. But not matter where
the story goes, I’m pretty sure the Curious Caterer series will maintain
the momentum they’re currently traveling on!

Overall score: 8 out of 10

Have you seen Curious Caterer: Foiled Plans? Would you like to see more movies in the Curious Caterer series? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun at the movies!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Solving the Equation

On April 23, 2024 By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

In my last Sunset Over Hope Valley re-cap post, I brought up the subplot of Toby and Cooper studying for an upcoming math test, where Toby believed he didn’t have to study for the test because the test questions were the same as the math homework. At the time, I thought this subplot was random, as it wasn’t resolved in the episode. However, it was resolved in this episode, providing an explanation for Toby’s attitude toward the math test. As I watched When Calls the Heart, I thought about how creating a television show is like trying to solve a math equation. Every season, new characters are added to the story. A show’s creative team figures out how to utilize their funds, subtracting money from the show’s budget. Over time, a show attracts more fans, multiplying its viewership. But there are instances when a show’s creative team makes a controversial decision, which divides the fans. In order for a television show to be successful, and even stand the test of time, a creative team needs to work through the equation to find an answer!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 11

Episode: 3

Name: Steps Forward

Major stories:

Lucas has returned to Hope Valley to finalize the sale of the saloon. The sale is a success, with Lee signing the official papers. While most people are excited about the new hotel, some Hope Valley residents are not pleased with the changes coming Hope Valley’s way. One of these residents is Jay Campbell. He shares with Lee his frustrations about how busy Lucas has become, believing he hasn’t been heard. Jay turns toward Rosemary in an attempt to catch Lucas’ attention through The Valley Voice. While Rosemary agrees to publish Jay’s thoughts, she also contacts Montague, hoping to not only get an official statement about the new hotel, but to also question him about Lucas’ case. Days later, Rosemary and Lee visit the site for the new hotel, along with Edwin, Lucas, Elizabeth, and her students. The purpose of this visit is to capture photos for an upcoming article. Randall, Rosemary’s rival reporter, attends as well to take pictures for his article. During this visit, Randall reveals how the site actually belongs to Benson Hills, a detail that slipped through the cracks. In this episode, Lucas receives a hotel bid from Montague, but turns it down.

Bill takes a trip to Capitol City in order to prove a theory. Through an experiment, Bill discovers how Pike wouldn’t have enough time to reach the gun’s hiding place, shoot Lucas, and get away in a short amount of time. This leads Bill to speculate a second person was involved. When Bill returns to Hope Valley, he shares his findings with Rosemary. She confesses how she’s planning on questioning Montague under the assumption the phone call is meant to capture Montague’s official statement about the new hotel. During the phone call, Rosemary and Bill learn Montague was at a party at the time Lucas was shot. He claims over a hundred people saw him at the event. Later in the episode, Bill acquires the train schedule from the night Lucas was shot. Rosemary found a newspaper article featuring a picture of Montague from the aforementioned party, with the photo taken after Lucas was injured. Despite the evidence claiming Montague was not involved in the case, Rosemary and Bill agree to not rule him out.

Chalkboard image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/mathematical-operation-written-on-blackboard_1357576.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

After school, Elizabeth confronts Toby about his math test. She shares how he didn’t get a good score. This encourages Toby to confess why he didn’t study for the test, stating how he can’t grasp the concept of math, specifically division. Elizabeth promises to help him with his academic issue. Later in the episode, Elizabeth finds Toby crying in the library. He tells Elizabeth how he fears he’ll never understand math. Until she and Toby figure out how to tackle the math issue, Elizabeth suggests not giving Toby any more math tests. Toby is not the only student of Elizabeth’s struggling with a problem. In the Canfield family, Cooper and Angela have a feud. This feud started because Cooper’s baseball was destroyed and Angela’s hair ribbon was used as a slingshot. The sibling’s feud leads Joseph to tell his children about his brother, Jacob. He shares how a feud caused them not to speak to each other. Joseph’s story encourages Angela and Cooper to apologize and replace the damaged items.

Mike and Mei celebrate their five-month anniversary. They want
the day to be special, so they brainstorm ideas. A few days later, Mei comes up
with the perfect date. She surprises Mike with a picnic, taking place on the
spot where the new hotel will be built. Their date is interrupted by the photo
shoot hosted by Rosemary and Randall. In Hope Valley, Faith feels it’s unsafe
to look after Lilly at the infirmary, as she can’t divide her time between
taking care of Lilly and treating her patients. Some of Hope Valley’s women
suggest starting a day dare center, with the idea quickly agreed upon. Henry
even gives the women his former office for free. After the day care’s
establishment, Lilly confesses how she doesn’t have an aunt. Faith allows Lilly
to call her “Auntie Faith”.

Preschool classroom image created by Vectorpocket at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by vectorpocket – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

·
The longer a television show has been on the
air, the more inconsistencies will appear on the program. When Calls the
Heart is no exception to this statement. After Jack Jr. was born, Elizabeth
relied on babysitters to look after her son. These babysitters have either been
the Coulters or one of her students. But when the day care is established,
Elizabeth takes advantage of the day care’s services by placing Jack Jr. in the
day care. She also makes it seem like finding a babysitter has been a struggle.
During Jack Jr.’s time on the show, Elizabeth has never expressed a problem
with recruiting a babysitter for Jack Jr. With Elizabeth’s attitude toward the
day care, it makes her story seem kind of inconsistent.

·
In season six, an orphan named Spencer stayed
with the Coulters. Because he was traveling with Grace, the co-owner of an
orphanage, his time with the Coulters was limited, lasting only two episodes.
This reflection made me realize how long Lilly’s story has, so far, lasted. Not
only is she staying at The Café under Faith’s care, a day care was established
because of her and she now calls Faith “Auntie Faith”. These observations have
made me wonder what is the creative team’s ultimate goal for this story?
Perhaps something will happen that will cause Lilly to be adopted by someone in
Hope Valley?

·
When reading the title names of When Calls
the Heart’s episodes, I’m sometimes left confused by how a title relates to
an episode’s story. The next episode serves as the perfect example. This season’s
fourth episode is titled “Along Came a Spider”. In this episode’s synopsis, the
first line reads “It’s Easter in Hope Valley”. Maybe the connection between the
title and the story will reveal itself when the episode airs. But as of the
publication of this re-cap, I question what spiders have to do with Easter?

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you think Montague
hurt Lucas? Tell me in the comment section below!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Lend a Helping Hand

On April 15, 2024 By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

This episode of When Calls the Heart shows Elizabeth planning a surprise party for Nathan. Because planning a party can be overwhelming, other residents of Hope Valley volunteer to help Elizabeth. Lending a helping hand is a common theme on the show. Hearties have witnessed individual characters act selflessly, from Rosemary donating bridesmaid dress material for bandages to Lucas sharing the magic of movies with Hope Valley’s residents. But when Hope Valley’s residents join together, Hearties see how anything is possible. Complications have reached solutions because the characters have worked together, putting their differences aside to reach a common goal. The help Hope Valley’s residents provide is genuine, coming from a place of goodness and charm. For me, this is what has made When Calls the Heart enjoyable to watch!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 11

Episode: 2

Name: Tomorrow Never Knows

Major stories:

Elizabeth is reminded by Rosemary how Nathan’s birthday is just around the corner. When Elizabeth mentions this to Nathan, Nathan is convinced he’ll receive a surprise party due to Allie’s random decision to go fishing. After school one day, Elizabeth questions Allie about her plans for Nathan’s birthday. Allie confirms her plans only consist of going fishing. These plans change to both a fishing trip and a party because Nathan is still suspecting a party. Rosemary volunteers Elizabeth to plan the party, believing Elizabeth is capable of making this party a reality. As more residents find out about the party, they agree to help with party preparations. On Nathan’s birthday, he and Allie go fishing, where they don’t catch any fish. This works in Allie’s favor as she suggests having dinner at the saloon. At the saloon, Nathan is pleasantly surprised at how many people attended the party. He’s also surprised when Lucas later shows up.

Due to Lucas’ plans for the resort, he decides to sell the saloon. He feels hanging on the saloon would be a conflict of interest. This news makes Mike concerned for his job as saloon manager. When Lee looks at the saloon’s books, he discovers how profitable the establishment is due to Mike’s management. Lee plans on buying the saloon, but allowing Mike to continue managing it. Explaining this plan to Rosemary for the first time causes Rosemary to feel she and Lee don’t spend enough time together due to putting work first. He later explains to Rosemary how purchasing the saloon but allowing Mike to manage it would actually give them more time to spend together. Rosemary agrees to co-own the saloon after hearing Lee’s plan. She even suggests adding a stage to the saloon. When Mike learns of Lee and Rosemary’s plans, he is excited to keep his job.

Birthday cake image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/chocolate-birthday-cakes-collection_765437.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/birthday”>Birthday vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Rosemary is frustrated at being “scooped” by another newspaper reporter. While some of Hope Valley’s residents are impressed with the competition, Rosemary reads between the lines, discovering how Lucas’ case’s official statement was copied word for word. She figures her problem is how she lacks a source. So, Rosemary turns to Bill for help. Bill questions Rosemary’s interest in Lucas’ case, wondering if all she cares about is creating an exciting headline. Rosemary reassures Bill how she just wants to protect Lucas because he’s her friend. Later in the episode, Rosemary receives a mystery board from Lee.

Bill calls Mei and Mike “newlyweds” as he passes by the pharmacy. Mike and Mei appear a bit uncomfortable by this comment due to how their relationship hasn’t become serious yet. After this comment, Mei has been distant with Mike. Mike thinks he did something wrong, but Mei is afraid to engage in a serious romantic relationship because to a past relationship, as she confesses to Faith. At Nathan’s birthday party, Mei shares her fears with Mike. But all Mike wanted to do was ask Mei to dance.

Faith has her hands full not only running the infirmary, but
also looking after Lily. She is sometimes frustrated by how frequently Lily
changes her mind about things. However, Faith recognizes how much joy Lily has
brought to Hope Valley. While Faith reads a story to Lily, Lily questions where
the parents of the story’s protagonist are. Faith explains how the story’s
protagonist went to live with her aunts. This encourages Lily to ask about her
grandmother. Faith tells Lily how her grandmother is being taken care of at the
hospital. When Lily asks how long her grandmother will stay in the hospital,
Faith suggests Lily close her eyes and picture her grandmother, trying to help
Lily overcome her homesickness. While Lily takes Faith’s advice, Faith closes
her eyes and pictures Fiona.

Happy reading place image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

·
I’ve always been confused on how to spell Allie’s
name. In When Calls the Heart’s promotional material, I have seen Allie’s
name spelled ‘Allie’ and ‘Ally’. To maintain consistency and prevent confusion
for my readers, I will be spelling Allie’s name ‘Allie’ for the remainder of
these re-caps.

At the café, Cooper and Toby study for a math test. Toby shares with Cooper how the test questions are the same as their math homework, so he feels he doesn’t have to study. Later in the episode, Minnie addresses what she overheard with Elizabeth as she’s grading the aforementioned math test. But this part of the story was not resolved. Toby is not confronted by Elizabeth and no lessons are learned. Because of everything I said, this subplot felt random.

·
Henry comes back to Hope Valley! While talking
with Elizabeth, he shares how he visited Abigial and how Abigail wanted him to
be happy. Henry also volunteers to help the Canfields tend the trees in the café’s
backyard. During this episode, I noticed how much happier and calmer Henry
appeared. He seems to have adopted a genuine interest in Hope Valley’s agriculture
and foliage. Therefore, I’m curious to see how Henry’s story turns out this
season!

What are your thoughts on this episode? How many changes do you
think the saloon will endure? Please tell me in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Nathan’s Standing Ovation

On April 9, 2024April 15, 2024 By 18cinemalane3 Comments

In this season premiere of When Calls the Heart, there were so many things that were inspiring enough to talk about in my re-cap’s introduction. However, I decided to focus on a quote I’ve referenced on my blog before. In the book, Wonder, the protagonist, Auggie, stated “Everyone in the world should get a standing ovation at least once in their life because we all overcometh the world.” After a criminal was caught by Nathan in this episode, everyone wants to give Nathan his “standing ovation”. But Nathan doesn’t feel he deserves it, as he thinks he just did his job. The idea of a worthy individual receiving a “standing ovation” is a nice one. However, in order for a “standing ovation” to take place, the person in question has to want it. This is a concept that isn’t explored often in stories. Therefore, I’m glad Nathan’s story gave me something to think about!

Just a reminder: If you did not see the season premiere of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 11

Episode: 1

Name: When Stars Align

Shortly after becoming Governor, Lucas gets shot by someone
he knows. When Bill learns of this news, he informs Nathan and Elizabeth of
what happened. During a phone call, Edwin, Lucas’ campaign assistant, shares
with Elizabeth how Lucas had to have surgery in order for the bullets to be
removed. After learning this, Elizabeth and Bill go to Capital City to visit
their friend. Lucas not only survives his ordeal, he is eager to start his new
journey as Governor. However, he doesn’t remember who shot him. While Lucas is
in the hospital, Henry pays him a visit. Lucas offers him a position on his
team. Though appreciative of Lucas’ offer, Henry turns it down. Later in the
episode, Lucas calls Rosemary and Lee. He informs them of an upcoming radio
announcement and thanks Lee for giving him a patch of land. On the day of the
announcement, Lucas reveals he will build a resort near Hope Valley, using the
land Lee gave him. It is a part of Lucas’ plan to improve Hope Valley and its
surrounding communities.

Four months after Lucas was shot, Nathan arrested Pike, a
man who confessed to shooting Lucas. A gun with Pike’s prints is also
discovered. Believing justice was served, everyone in Hope Valley congratulates
Nathan for saving the day. Everyone except Bill. He feels Lucas’ case was
solved too quickly. Bill also finds it odd how Montague was overlooked as a
potential suspect. During a private discussion, Bill shares his concerns with
Nathan. Nathan confesses how he has his own hunch about the case, as well as
requesting the case remain open. Nathan’s request was denied. Meanwhile,
Rosemary is desperate to become involved in the mystery. By questioning Bill,
she discovers his doubts about the case’s outcome.

Illustrated image of bicycle created by Freepik at freepik.com. Background vector created by freepik – www.freepik.com

Through a telegram, Faith learns Fiona has permanently moved
to Nashville. This news causes Faith to become lonely. She shares her feelings
with Minnie, who reminds Faith how she isn’t alone. In this same episode, Faith
takes care of a patient named Dora. Troubled by Dora’s cough, Faith listens to
Dora’s lungs. Discovering her patient has breathing issues, Faith prescribes
Dora medication. But the following day, Dora experiences a cardiac episode.
Concerned for her patient’s well-being, Faith calls the hospital in Benson
Hills. Because Dora came to Hope Valley with her young grand-daughter, Lilly,
Faith is worried about who will look after the girl. After Dora is sent to
Benson Hills, Dora sends a telegram informing how, during her recovery, Faith
she should look after Lilly.

Because of Fiona’s departure from Hope Valley, Mei has been
tasked with looking after the barber shop. Along with this responsibility, she also
has to maintain the pharmacy. Overwhelmed by everything on her plate, she asks
Mike for his help. He agrees to help, quickly taking note of Mei’s stress.
Offering another helping hand, Mike gives Mei a bike as a gift. He explains to
her how the bike will allow Mei to travel in a shorter amount of time. The
basket on the bike will also give Mei more room to store mud from Hope Springs.
Mei is appreciative of Mike’s gift. Their interaction causes Ned to comment how
Mike and Mei act like an old married couple.

With Lucas recovering in the hospital, Elizabeth reflects on
everything that happened in the four months since he was elected Governor. She
comes to the conclusion that life shouldn’t be taken for granted, as anything
can take place in the blink of an eye. In order to put actions to words,
Elizabeth decides to get a hair-cut. But with Fiona now in Nashville, Elizabeth
thinks the hair-cut will have to be postponed. Being the good friend that she
is, Rosemary volunteers to cut Elizabeth’s hair. Elizabeth accepts her friend’s
offer, but wants a hair-style that is simpler. The next day, Elizabeth reveals
her new hair-style with several of Hope Valley’s residents. The change with
Elizabeth’s hair receives positive results.

Colorful galaxy image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/lovely-hand-drawn-galaxy-background_2943080.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:
This season premiere of When Calls the Heart was pleasant! Even though some of the stories were stronger than others, there are things to look forward to for the rest of the season. However, I found this episode’s trailer to be a bit cruel. Within this commercial, there was a clip of Lucas from the previous season. When this clip appeared, a voice-over stated how Lucas doesn’t remember anything. I can only speak for myself, but I thought Lucas had developed amnesia. However, this episode revealed how Lucas doesn’t remember anything about being shot. This isn’t the first time When Calls the Heart’s marketing tried to make its audience assume the worst about Lucas. Plus, Lucas’ fans are likely still disappointed by his and Elizabeth’s break-up from season ten. Personally, I found that part of the trailer to be an unnecessary way to spark an emotional reaction over Elizabeth’s relationships.

When Abigail Stanton was on the show, her café was called Abigail’s Café. Since she owned this establishment, it made sense for it to be named after her. But after she left Hope Valley and the Canfields bought her half of the café, I always wondered why the café was still named after Abigail. While watching the season premiere, I noticed in one scene how the café now boasts a sign stating ‘The Café’. Because this restaurant has been a staple of Hope Valley since, practically, the show’s beginning, it makes sense for the café to not feature any person’s name in the title, as the establishment, figuratively, belongs to everyone.

During one of Elizabeth’s classes, Elizabeth tells her
students how, in the following days, Venus and Jupiter will align in the sky,
causing them to be visible from Earth. I found this part of the story to be an
interesting coincidence because this episode premiered the day before April 8^th’s
solar eclipse. This isn’t the first time a story on When Calls the Heart has
been unintentionally relevant with the time it aired on television. In the
seventh season’s fourth episode, ‘Sweet and Sour’, Hope Valley’s chickenpox
outbreak coincidently paralleled 2020’s Coronavirus.

As I mentioned in this re-cap, Lucas shares how he will
build a resort on the land Lee gave him. Even though I’m excited to see this
resort come to fruition, I hope Lucas plans on building a theater on that land.
At this point, it’s a pipe dream for Rosemary to receive her theater. But I’ve
always been hopeful of Rosemary’s dream finally coming true. If any character
is going to make that dream a reality, it’s Lucas. Not only does he have the
funds and resources, he did introduce Hope Valley’s residents to movies through
his saloon.

What are your thoughts on season eleven’s premiere of When Calls the Heart? What are you looking forward to seeing this season? Let me know in the comment section below!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Take 3: The 39 Steps Review

On April 6, 2024 By 18cinemalane11 Comments

For the first annual Master of Suspense Blogathon (hosted by Maddy from Classic Film And TV Corner), I wrote about the 1955 film, To Catch a Thief. While I addressed how it was a “pretty looking movie”, I found To Catch a Thief prioritizing style over substance. In this year’s event, I have selected the 1935 production, The 39 Steps, which was recommended by Maddy from Maddy Loves Her Classic Films! There are several titles in Alfred Hitchcock’s filmography that have gained popularity over the years. But The 39 Steps has been overshadowed by Alfred’s more well-known projects. In fact, before signing up for the second annual Master of Suspense Blogathon, I knew very little about the film. However, I was familiar with Alfred’s forte for mystery and suspense, assuming I was, at least, going to see a creative concept come to life on screen. Was I correct in my assumption? Keep reading my review of The 39 Steps to find out!

*The 39 Steps* poster created by Gaumont British Picture Corporation and Gaumont British Picture Corporation of America

Things I liked about the film:

Robert Donat’s performance: Throughout The 39 Steps, I found the acting performances ranging from fine to well-done. However, I did like Robert Donat’s portrayal of Richard Hannay! What stood out to me was how at ease Robert appeared on screen. A perfect example is when Richard shares some of his family history with Pamela, who was portrayed by Madeleine Carroll. While telling Pamela about his family, Richard was comfortable giving this information, despite barely knowing Pamela. His body language appears relaxed and his facial expressions presented on his face effortlessly. The story itself rolled off Richard’s tongue as if he had told it multiple times. During this conversation, Richard was also yawning, indicating how tired he was by the events surrounding him during the film’s story.

The set design of Alt-na-Shellach: During the movie, Richard visits Alt-na-Shellach, the home of a man named Professor Jordan. The only room shown on screen was the sitting room, where a party was taking place. Despite appearing in only one scene, the room boasted nice set design pieces! Characters were greeted by a large, carved, wooden door. These carvings were intricately detailed, showing how much care went into creating that door. A big, ornate rug covered the majority of the floor, nicely complimenting the space. But the showstopper was the huge window overlooking a nearby river and featuring stained glass designs. I wish more scenes had taken place at Alt-na-Shellach, as I’m pretty sure other rooms would have looked great on screen too!

The mise-en-scène: For those who aren’t familiar with the term, mise-en-scène, it means how a scene is presented in a movie. In The 39 Steps, mise-en-scène was utilized in clever and visually intriguing ways. A great example is when Richard boards a train. On this trip, Richard is sitting across from two men. To avoid eye contact, Richard hides his face behind a newspaper. Wondering if the two men are watching him, Richard peeks over the top of the newspaper, where the audience can only see the men’s eyes. These visuals symbolized how Richard was hiding something behind the windows of his soul, how the eyes are sometimes described.

The Second Master Of Suspense Blogathon banner created by Maddy from Classic Film And TV Corner

What I didn’t like about the film:

Limited sense of urgency: Based on Alfred Hitchcock’s films I’ve seen, I’ve come to expect his stories to be filled with mystery and suspense. Because of these elements, I also expect a given story to contain a strong sense of urgency. While there were suspenseful, urgent moments sprinkled throughout The 39 Steps, these moments were not consistent. This made the story take its time being told instead of getting straight to the point sooner. During these suspenseful, urgent moments, there was no music playing in the background. A low amount of adrenaline and excitement was present in these moments partly due to the lack of music.

The “Insta-love” trope: In my recent review of Easter Parade, I explained what the “insta-love” trope was and why it was a major flaw in the 1948 movie. The “insta-love” trope was a major flaw in The 39 Steps as well. Richard and Pamela do not like each other. Even after being arrested, they continue to dislike one another. When they check into a hotel and pose as a married couple, Pamela and Richard’s dislike carries on. But hours later, they act like they’ve always been in a romantic relationship. The inclusion of the “insta-love” trope caused Richard and Pamela’s attraction to be abrupt, with the abruptness preventing on-screen chemistry between Robert and Madeleine.

An over-shadowed mystery: As I just mentioned in this review, I have come to expect stories filled with mystery based on Alfred Hitchcock’s movies I’ve seen. Because of those selected titles from Alfred’s filmography, I expect the mystery to be the story’s primary focus. In The 39 Steps, however, the story’s mystery was overshadowed due to the film’s creative team emphasizing Richard being on the run from the authorities. The mystery taking a backseat in the movie means the mystery itself wasn’t solved until the very end of the film. A longer wait time for answers causes The 39 Steps to feature a limited amount of intrigue.

Essentials of Scotland image created by macrovector_official at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by macrovector_official – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

My overall impression:

Alfred Hitchcock has obtained a reputation for creating memorable productions. Whether it’s incorporating “modern” technology in The Birds or showcasing a pretty location in To Catch a Thief, Alfred’s movies have boasted his stamp of approval through various creative ideas. But out of Alfred’s films I have seen, and even reviewed, The 39 Steps is the most “meh” title from his filmography. The 1935 picture had such a limited sense of urgency and intrigue, I almost fell asleep while watching it. Richard and Pamela’s relationship was heavily affected by the “insta-love” trope, causing the relationship to feel like it belonged in a different film. This is a movie that seems longer than an hour and twenty-six minutes, creating a slow and boring build-up to a reveal that feels kind of ridiculous and anti-climactic. With all the flaws I discussed in this review, it’s a shame The 39 Steps turned out this way. That’s because there were aspects of this movie I liked, such as Robert Donat’s performance.

Overall score: 5 out of 10

Have you seen The 39 Steps? Are there any films of Alfred Hitchcock’s you like or don’t like? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun at the movies!

Sally Silverscreen