When an actor or actress is celebrating a birthday, I will sometimes write about a project from their filmography and publish that article on their birthday. This has given me an excuse to check out a movie or television show I haven’t seen before. Because July 11th is Stephen Lang’s birthday, I found a perfect opportunity to finally see the 1993 western, Tombstone! This is a movie I not only have heard of before, I have heard the movie receive consistent praise over the years. It’s even earned the coveted title of “classic” within the western genre. Though I have covered some movies from this particular genre on 18 Cinema Lane, I had no idea how Tombstone was going to stand out among those other titles. Now that I’ve seen the 1993 picture, I found an answer to that question. But you have to read my review to discover what that answer is!
Things I liked about the film:
Historical accuracy: In my recent review of Young Washington, I praised the film’s creative team for effectively executing their project’s historical accuracy. Because of how well-done that storytelling element was, the creative team behind Young Washington successfully created an illusion of immersion. Tombstone also possessed the illusion of immersion due to the efforts of that movie’s creative team. From the construction of the town itself to the artwork on a wall at the Bird Cage Theatre, the appearance of the film and its finer details effectively reflect Tombstone’s respective time period of the late 1800s. An example of how this particular time period was brought back to life was through the characters’ wardrobe. In a scene where Wyatt Earp goes for a horse ride with Josephine, Josephine wears elegant yet practical riding attire. Sporting a black tailored jacket and a long black skirt, she adds a black and white polka dot scarf as well as a black top hat adorned with black and white ribbons. Finishing the ensemble is a pair of simple black gloves. Josephine even rode side-saddle, what would have been the appropriate way for a woman to ride a horse at that time. The example I presented in this review visually represents the research and attention to detail that went into Tombstone’s presentation!
Interconnected stories: Tombstone is a movie known for its large cast of characters. At the beginning of the film, the characters are shown engaging in their own separate part of the story. Whether it’s the Cowboys rudely interrupting a wedding or Doc Holliday winning a poker game, the first minutes of Tombstone let the audience know everyone who is featured in the movie has an important role to play. As the film progresses, each separate story becomes interconnected. Characters who may seem like strangers are actually revealed to be friends. The actions caused by one character greatly impact another character. And crossed paths develop consequences. These interconnections between characters allowed on-screen interactions to contain a strong sense of intrigue. That intrigue kept me invested in what was happening in Tombstone!
The acting: Because Stephen Lang is the reason why I’m reviewing Tombstone, I have to talk about his performance first. Though he appeared in the film for a limited period of time as Ike Clanton, Stephen’s portrayal was very memorable! This memorability was due to his expressiveness and animated reactions. Yet, Stephen’s animation never came across as over-the-top or too “cartoony”. Instead, he effectively utilized a variety of emotions which helped him stand out among the ensemble cast. One of Stephen’s best moments in Tombstone is when Ike is watching a play involving Faust, the confused look on Ike’s face appearing completely genuine. I also liked Sam Elliott’s portrayal of Virgil Earp, Wyatt’s brother. In a scene where Virgil receives bad medical related news, a combination of fear, anger, and sadness are present in his eyes, through the frown on his mouth, and even within the muscle control throughout his face. Virgil’s wife, Allie (portrayed by Paula Malcomson), is also upset by the news Virgil receives. Her tear-streaked face says so much without saying anything at all. Even as she yells at Wyatt, the anger in her voice holds an intensity that forces Wyatt (and the audience) to take her seriously. But besides these three performances I brought up, the cast as a whole gave solid portrayals throughout Tombstone!
What I didn’t like about the film:
Glossed over parts of the story: There were a few parts of Tombstone’s story that became glossed over as the movie progressed. One of those glossed over parts involved Wyatt’s wife, Mattie. Toward the beginning of the film, Mattie seeks to receive laudanum in order to cure a headache. Yet, she refuses to visit a doctor when Wyatt suggests it. Later in the movie, Mattie is seen drinking a bottle of opium. These displayed behaviors imply she is battling an addiction. But none of the other characters, including Wyatt, address Mattie’s concerning issue. In historical/period stories like Tombstone, a storyline involving addiction will sometimes be woven into the script. Usually, these storylines will not only be addressed in that respective story, they will also be treated with a sense of respect, as addiction is a serious, real-world topic. With everything said, I wish Mattie’s part of the story had received some more attention within Tombstone’s overarching story.
The underutilization of Billy Zane: In movies containing ensemble casts, an actor or actress may sometimes become underutilized due to how much screen-time the cast needs to share. The case of Tombstone shows Billy Zane as an underrated performer within the film. Portraying a stage actor named Mr. Fabian, Mr. Fabian represents something beautiful that came to the ugliness of Tombstone, according to Josephine. Billy’s appearances in Tombstone were so limited, he was present in only three scenes within the first half of the movie. He doesn’t show up in the film again until toward the end of the story, when the actions of the Cowboys and Wyatt’s group have taken their toll on Mr. Fabian. Taking Josephine’s words into consideration, I was disappointed Mr. Fabian wasn’t utilized more in the story, as a way to achieve peace within Tombstone. But I guess as a stage actor, there was only so much he could have done to find a solution to the town’s conflict.
Half of the story feeling “slice of life”: The overarching conflict of Tombstone involves the Cowboys and Wyatt alongside his brothers and Doc fighting over control of Tombstone. But this conflict doesn’t really become the story’s central focus until the second half of the movie. In the film’s first half, the emphasis is placed on the “slice of life” aspect of the characters residing in Tombstone. While it was interesting to catch a glimpse of life within the late 1800s, the intrigue wasn’t as consistent in the movie’s first half as it was in the second half. In fact, as I watching the first half of Tombstone, I honestly wondered why this story wasn’t a television show instead of a movie?
My overall impression:
As I said in the introduction of this review, I chose to write about Tombstone in honor of Stephen Lang’s birthday. Therefore, I was looking forward to seeing his performance in this movie. While I did witness a very memorable portrayal of Ike Clanton, there is so much more this film gave me. The cast as a whole was strong, which made each performance enjoyable to watch. The research and attention to detail put into Tombstone’s historical accuracy allowed the movie’s creative team to achieve an illusion of immersion. Interconnections between characters’ stories added intrigue to characters’ on-screen interactions. Though the film gave me an enjoyable movie-viewing experience, there were flaws that held it back from being stronger. I wish the overarching story had consistently focused on the conflict for control over Tombstone. I also wish Mattie’s part of the story had received some more attention in the script. Seeing Billy Zane’s talents become underutilized was disappointing as well. But despite these flaws, I can recognize why Tombstone is highly regarded by fans of the western genre!
Overall score 7.3-7.4 out of 10
Have you seen Tombstone? Are there any films from the western genre you’d like to see me review? Let me know in the comment section!
Have fun at the movies!
Sally Silverscreen
18 Cinema Lane 