As I stated in my last re-cap post, the premiere of this episode of When Calls the Heart aired on a different day at a different time. Even though this change in schedule was temporary, it likely gave the fans quite a surprise. But Hearties were not the only ones who had to change their plans. In this episode, Nathan and Elizabeth wanted to go to the hot springs before autumn arrived. Their trip never happened, as Elizabeth developed a cold. Every television show has experienced a change in plans at least once. When Calls the Heart has been no exception. What matters, though, is how one adapts to their plans changing. From Daniel Lissing departing from the show to working around the Writers’ and Actors’ Strikes of 2023, When Calls the Heart’s creative team has adapted the best they could. The show’s ability to adapt has rewarded them with twelve seasons and a devoted fanbase. That has been one of the many strengths of When Calls the Heart!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 12

Episode: 6

Name: When Autumn Leaves Begin to Fall

Major stories:

Allie is upset the salmon from a nearby river haven’t spawned. She claims if the salmon don’t spawn, the bears and wolves will have nothing to eat. Oliver volunteers to help Allie solve this mystery. When they get to the river, it is discovered cows from a pasture close by have been using the river for drinking water, causing the silt to rise and disturb the salmon. During their trip, while hiding in a ‘no trespassing zone’, Allie and Oliver witness two men covering up cow tracks located next to the river. After the men leave, Oliver confesses how he chooses to follow the rules because his mother is in prison. Later in the episode, Allie makes a guest appearance on Rosemary’s new radio segment; The Daily Dialogue. On the inaugural segment, Allie raises her concerns about the salmon with Lucas. She even shows him a map of where the cows have traveled. When Allie visits Oliver at the stables, she shares how Lucas will look into the salmon situation. Allie also tells Oliver how her father (not Nathan) is currently in jail.

A forensic investigator named Georgie McGill comes to Hope Valley to help Bill solve the mystery of the coin. Because she’s been working on the case of the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907 for years, Georgie is eager to lend a helping hand. She and Bill agree to visit a prisoner named Sonny, who they believe could give them information about the coin and/or Toddy Davis. Once they get to prison, the duo learn more from Sonny. According to the prisoner, Toddy hosts operations in stolen goods in Fullerton and Union City. He also works with rare coins, like the one that mysteriously arrived in Hope Valley. Bill and Georgie made a step in the right direction. But now the question remains; where did Toddy get the coin?

Minor stories:

Joseph receives an informative brochure about a school Angela is interested in attending. He has also requested a tour of the school. When Minnie discovers the brochure, she doesn’t like how she and her husband haven’t discussed it first. She also shares her concerns about Angela being in a new environment all by herself. Joseph, on the other hand, has an open mind when it comes to his daughter’s future. Eventually, Minnie checks out the brochure for herself. After being impressed with the school’s accolades, Minnie confesses to Joseph how all she wants is for Angela to live a good, independent life. Joseph reassures his wife how intelligent and confident their daughter is. They agree to pray about Angela’s educational journey. Meanwhile, Ava’s trunk has been found at a station in Buxton. But when the trunk arrives at the Queen of Hearts hotel, the trunk is filled with men’s clothing.

At the beginning of the episode, Elizabeth and Nathan plan on taking Jack Jr. and Allie to the hot springs before autumn begins. But the very next day, Elizabeth develops a cold. Throughout the episode, Rosemary and Nathan take turns caring for Elizabeth. From time to time, Elizabeth dreams about Nathan and her being together. Rosemary also volunteers to substitute Elizabeth’s class, where her students create get well cards. While Elizabeth, Rosemary, and Fiona read the cards, Elizabeth shares her project-based learning idea with Fiona. When Fiona suggests Elizabeth write about her teaching idea and publish her work, Elizabeth takes this suggestion into consideration.

Some thoughts to consider:

• Ever since Earl Wyatt came back to Hope Valley, some of the characters have talked about him antagonistically. Even in this episode, the way Allie was talking about going on a hike with Oliver seemed like she was intentionally trying to make Earl jealous. Personally, I don’t understand the dislike toward Earl. Throughout his time in season twelve, he has, so far, done no wrongdoing. In fact, the first thing Earl did when he returned to Hope Valley was apologize to Opal for bullying her all those years ago. As of the half-way point of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season, the negativity toward Earl Wyatt doesn’t seem warranted.
• Based on fan reception, Ava hasn’t received a warm welcome on the show. Hearties don’t trust her and think she’s up to no good. However, I could see Ava’s story going either way. Sure, she could be a scammer, especially since her arrival in Hope Valley conveniently mirrors Elizabeth’s introduction. But maybe Ava is, indeed, telling the truth. Like I mentioned in this re-cap post, Ava’s trunk is filled with men’s clothing. Perhaps this was a genuine mistake, as another traveler could have had a trunk similar to Ava’s. If Ava is being honest, I wonder if she’ll become a series regular on When Calls the Heart?
• As I said in this re-cap post, Oliver shares how his mother is in prison. This is the reason why he chooses to follow the rules, as he doesn’t want to prove his doubters right. Oliver also tells Allie how he’s never had a birthday party. The more Oliver’s backstory is revealed, the more it feels reminiscent of Perry Miller’s story from the television show, Emily of New Moon. Not only was Perry’s mother in prison, he also tried to create a better future for himself, like Oliver. Come to think of it, I don’t recall Perry ever having a birthday party on Emily of New Moon.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Who do you think gave Toddy the mysterious coin? Please let me know in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen