The Winter Wonderland Book Tag!

At first, I was going to create a post about a Valentine’s Day book tag. But the Valentine’s themed book tags I found either heavily emphasized romance books or I couldn’t find an answer to all the provided questions. So, I decided to write about a winter themed book tag instead, as Valentine’s Day takes place within the winter season. When I came across the Winter Wonderland Book Tag, I could immediately think of answers for each question! Even though one of the questions mentions Christmas, the majority of the questions simply relate to the season of winter. Within these six questions, I will talk about books that have either been brought up on 18 Cinema Lane or books that haven’t been mentioned before. Now, let the book tag begin!

Ski lodge during winter-time image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/ski-station-background_3423830.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

1. What book is so happy & sweet that it warms your heart?

    As soon I read this question, I immediately thought of The Christmas Child by Linda Goodnight! Having read this book back in 2018, I remember how sweet this story was. It, honestly, felt like I was reading a Hallmark movie. What I mean by that is The Christmas Child was heart-warming and wholesome. There were emotional moments woven into the text, but the book never felt too emotionally heavy. Plus, the relationship between Kade and Sophie was sweet!

    2. What is your favorite book with a white cover?

    Because there’s a lot of snow on the cover of David Baldacci’s The Christmas Train, that’s the book I’ll choose for this question. This is one of the few books I’ve ever given five out of five stars to! Though it’s been years since I read The Christmas Train, I recall how intriguing the mystery was and how distinctive the characters were. In fact, I think this book serves as a good introduction to David Baldacci’s literary work! I would also recommend the Hallmark Hall of Fame adaptation, as I remember how respectful it was toward the source material.

    3. You’re sitting in a nice comfy chair, wearing a onesie, with a lovely warm hot chocolate but what MONSTER read are you reading?

    When I read the term, “MONSTER read”, I interpreted it as a book with a large page count. Due to that interpretation, I chose All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr. Even though I thought the book was just ok, I liked the author’s use of descriptive imagery and attention to detail. Like I said in my review of All the Light We Cannot See from 2022, I, as a reader, could picture the story in my head because of the aforementioned elements. It also helps how each part contained a collection of shorter chapters, giving the book a steadier pace.

    Snowboarder on the slopes image created by Freepic.diller at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/woman-in-ski-suit-looks-over-her-shoulder-going-down-the-hill-on-her-snowboard_1620624.htm’>Designed by Freepic.diller</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/tree”>Tree image created by Freepic.diller – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    4. It started snowing so you decided to have a snowball fight! What fictional character would you love to have the snowball fight with?

    My favorite character from Murder, She Wrote: The Fine Art of Murder is Victorio! He not only has a fascinating backstory, he also has a lively personality. Victorio was such a memorable character, I wish he received his own spin-off series. When participating in a snowball fight, it helps to surround yourself with people who have a good sense of humor and don’t take things too seriously. With everything I said, I would choose Victorio for this question!

    5. Sadly, your fire is beginning to go out. So what book would you tear the last few chapters out to throw into the fire?

    If you’re going to create stories for a younger audience, you need to be mindful about the content incorporated into that story. This is due to how impressionable a younger audience can be. In Smoke Screen by Amy Goldman Koss, I found some poor lessons found among the text. A few examples are it’s ok to not be a person of your word, breaking promises is fine as long as it benefits you, and making compromises is a waste of time. It also does not help how Mitzi, the protagonist, is a static, self-centered, and entitled character throughout the book. If younger readers were to read this book, they may get the wrong idea about how the world, problem-solving, and interactions with other people work. So, to answer the question, I would select the last few chapters of Smoke Screen and recommend a better ending.

    6. What book is so close to your heart that you would gift to someone this Christmas who hasn’t read before but wants to get into reading?

    Last year, I talked about The Princess Spy by Larry Loftis on more than one occasion. The book was featured in my post about the Finally Fall Book Tag and in my annual Movie Blogger’s Christmas Wish-List. Larry Loftis’ book, The Princess Spy, was the best book I read for last year’s Eurovisionathon readathon! As I said in the Finally Fall Book Tag, it was both educational and entertaining, showcasing the research and literary skill Larry incorporated. I would recommend The Princess Spy to readers who like nonfiction books or stories taking place during WWII. If one wants to read about WWII from a woman’s perspective, this book would be a good choice.

    Snowy mountain image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/landscape-background-of-snow-track-and-mountains_968656.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    Have fun during Winter!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Sunset Over Hope Valley: Change of Plans

    As I stated in my last re-cap post, the premiere of this episode of When Calls the Heart aired on a different day at a different time. Even though this change in schedule was temporary, it likely gave the fans quite a surprise. But Hearties were not the only ones who had to change their plans. In this episode, Nathan and Elizabeth wanted to go to the hot springs before autumn arrived. Their trip never happened, as Elizabeth developed a cold. Every television show has experienced a change in plans at least once. When Calls the Heart has been no exception. What matters, though, is how one adapts to their plans changing. From Daniel Lissing departing from the show to working around the Writers’ and Actors’ Strikes of 2023, When Calls the Heart’s creative team has adapted the best they could. The show’s ability to adapt has rewarded them with twelve seasons and a devoted fanbase. That has been one of the many strengths of When Calls the Heart!

    Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

    When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

    Season: 12

    Episode: 6

    Name: When Autumn Leaves Begin to Fall

    Major stories:

    Allie is upset the salmon from a nearby river haven’t spawned. She claims if the salmon don’t spawn, the bears and wolves will have nothing to eat. Oliver volunteers to help Allie solve this mystery. When they get to the river, it is discovered cows from a pasture close by have been using the river for drinking water, causing the silt to rise and disturb the salmon. During their trip, while hiding in a ‘no trespassing zone’, Allie and Oliver witness two men covering up cow tracks located next to the river. After the men leave, Oliver confesses how he chooses to follow the rules because his mother is in prison. Later in the episode, Allie makes a guest appearance on Rosemary’s new radio segment; The Daily Dialogue. On the inaugural segment, Allie raises her concerns about the salmon with Lucas. She even shows him a map of where the cows have traveled. When Allie visits Oliver at the stables, she shares how Lucas will look into the salmon situation. Allie also tells Oliver how her father (not Nathan) is currently in jail.

    A forensic investigator named Georgie McGill comes to Hope Valley to help Bill solve the mystery of the coin. Because she’s been working on the case of the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907 for years, Georgie is eager to lend a helping hand. She and Bill agree to visit a prisoner named Sonny, who they believe could give them information about the coin and/or Toddy Davis. Once they get to prison, the duo learn more from Sonny. According to the prisoner, Toddy hosts operations in stolen goods in Fullerton and Union City. He also works with rare coins, like the one that mysteriously arrived in Hope Valley. Bill and Georgie made a step in the right direction. But now the question remains; where did Toddy get the coin?

    Detective work image created by Photoroyalty at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/investigation-background-design_1041877.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Photoroyalty – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    Minor stories:

    Joseph receives an informative brochure about a school Angela is interested in attending. He has also requested a tour of the school. When Minnie discovers the brochure, she doesn’t like how she and her husband haven’t discussed it first. She also shares her concerns about Angela being in a new environment all by herself. Joseph, on the other hand, has an open mind when it comes to his daughter’s future. Eventually, Minnie checks out the brochure for herself. After being impressed with the school’s accolades, Minnie confesses to Joseph how all she wants is for Angela to live a good, independent life. Joseph reassures his wife how intelligent and confident their daughter is. They agree to pray about Angela’s educational journey. Meanwhile, Ava’s trunk has been found at a station in Buxton. But when the trunk arrives at the Queen of Hearts hotel, the trunk is filled with men’s clothing.

    At the beginning of the episode, Elizabeth and Nathan plan on taking Jack Jr. and Allie to the hot springs before autumn begins. But the very next day, Elizabeth develops a cold. Throughout the episode, Rosemary and Nathan take turns caring for Elizabeth. From time to time, Elizabeth dreams about Nathan and her being together. Rosemary also volunteers to substitute Elizabeth’s class, where her students create get well cards. While Elizabeth, Rosemary, and Fiona read the cards, Elizabeth shares her project-based learning idea with Fiona. When Fiona suggests Elizabeth write about her teaching idea and publish her work, Elizabeth takes this suggestion into consideration.

    Breakfast tray image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/composed-healthy-fruit-and-coffee-on-tray_1441643.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    Some thoughts to consider:

    • Ever since Earl Wyatt came back to Hope Valley, some of the characters have talked about him antagonistically. Even in this episode, the way Allie was talking about going on a hike with Oliver seemed like she was intentionally trying to make Earl jealous. Personally, I don’t understand the dislike toward Earl. Throughout his time in season twelve, he has, so far, done no wrongdoing. In fact, the first thing Earl did when he returned to Hope Valley was apologize to Opal for bullying her all those years ago. As of the half-way point of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season, the negativity toward Earl Wyatt doesn’t seem warranted.
    • Based on fan reception, Ava hasn’t received a warm welcome on the show. Hearties don’t trust her and think she’s up to no good. However, I could see Ava’s story going either way. Sure, she could be a scammer, especially since her arrival in Hope Valley conveniently mirrors Elizabeth’s introduction. But maybe Ava is, indeed, telling the truth. Like I mentioned in this re-cap post, Ava’s trunk is filled with men’s clothing. Perhaps this was a genuine mistake, as another traveler could have had a trunk similar to Ava’s. If Ava is being honest, I wonder if she’ll become a series regular on When Calls the Heart?
    • As I said in this re-cap post, Oliver shares how his mother is in prison. This is the reason why he chooses to follow the rules, as he doesn’t want to prove his doubters right. Oliver also tells Allie how he’s never had a birthday party. The more Oliver’s backstory is revealed, the more it feels reminiscent of Perry Miller’s story from the television show, Emily of New Moon. Not only was Perry’s mother in prison, he also tried to create a better future for himself, like Oliver. Come to think of it, I don’t recall Perry ever having a birthday party on Emily of New Moon.
    Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    What are your thoughts on this episode? Who do you think gave Toddy the mysterious coin? Please let me know in the comment section!

    Have fun in Hope Valley!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Take 3: Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery Review

    Last month, I wrote a Word on the Street story about the Hallmark Mystery film, Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery. While I figured there would be interest in this new installment, I was pleasantly surprised by the article’s response. As of the publication of this review, my Word on the Street story received over a thousand views! With that positive reception, I thought it would make sense to write about Hallmark Mystery’s latest presentation! I have been watching the Murder, She Baked/Hannah Swensen series since the very beginning. But I’ve only reviewed one movie from this series; Carrot Cake Murder: A Hannah Swensen Mystery. Since I found that film disappointing, I was discouraged from reviewing the other Murder, She Baked/Hannah Swensen chapters. However, I did find A Sprinkle of Deceit: A Hannah Swensen Mystery an ok movie. Has this series turned things around by giving their fans a stronger film? The only way to solve this mystery is by reading my review!

    Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery poster created by Hallmark Movies & Mysteries

    Things I liked about the film:

    Stand-out performances: As I watched Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, there were a few performances that were so impressive, they stood out to me. One of those performances came from Gavin Langelo! In this movie, Gavin portrayed Hunt Bantry, a member of a cooking show’s crew. During his performance, Gavin showcased strong camaraderie and was consistently charismatic. A perfect example of this is when Hunt and Hannah are having a conversation at a local restaurant. Throughout this conversation, Gavin appeared at ease and comfortable in his role as well. The exchange between Hannah and Hunt felt realistic partly due to Gavin’s performance. It’s a shame Gavin received such limited screen time because I genuinely believe he has what it takes, talent-wise, to, one day, lead a Hallmark movie.

    A behind-the-scenes look at television: The main plot of Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery involves a cooking show filming an episode in Hannah’s bakery. Toward the beginning of the story, viewers get to witness how the show’s episode comes to life! Various camera angles of either the host or the food itself are captured by a near-by film crew. Giant cue cards help the host know exactly what to say to their audience. Even when the cameras weren’t rolling, Hannah was observant enough to point out missing ingredients or incorrect baking procedures. I’d also like to point out how the production of the episode looked realistic! Even the show’s introduction appeared to have come straight from a real-life program!

    Characters working together: I mentioned in my list of the top ten worst movies I saw in 2024 how I was disappointed by One Bad Apple: A Hannah Swensen Mystery. One reason why was the characters working separately when it came to solving the movie’s case. In Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, the characters worked together to solve the film’s mystery! This was achieved by Hannah, along with her family and friends, collaborating on the case and discussing various theories and motives. Even though Chad was trying to solve his own mystery, Hannah helped him from time to time. A way she helped Chad was providing information whenever necessary. Characters working together to find a case’s resolution felt reminiscent of Hallmark Mystery’s presentations from yesteryear!

    Cupcake with hearts image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/delicious-cupcakes-illustrations_779154.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/food”>Food vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    What I didn’t like about the film:

    Humor that feels forced: Adding comedic elements to a mystery film is not a new contempt for Hallmark Mystery. Several of their productions, including the Murder, She Baked/Hannah Swensen series, have incorporated humor into a given story in order to prevent the overall tone from becoming too dark. When the Murder, She Baked/Hannah Swensen series changed its name from Murder, She Baked to Hannah Swensen, the overall comedic quality regressed. It, honestly, feels like the series’ creative team is trying too hard to be funny. This was the case in Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery. Any time Delores was involved in the story, her antics and gimmicks came across as too over-the-top and silly. Delores’ interactions with other characters felt like they belonged in a sit-com, such as when she makes her grand entrance before the cooking show episode began filming. Moments like that one made me wonder why a laugh track was missing?

    Lack of urgency: There were two mysteries in Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery: the murder of a cooking show’s producer and the mystery behind a series of burglaries. The mystery of the burglaries was written into the film as a court case, where Chad has to prove the guilty party is, indeed, guilty. However, the case itself is taken to court in only one scene. Meanwhile, Hannah occupies herself with solving the murder mystery. But so much emphasis was placed on conversations among characters instead of gathering clues and making connections on a mystery board. Both mysteries lack a sense of urgency. This flaw not only gave the mysteries a slow pace, the movie’s run-time felt a bit drawn-out. The story’s overall intrigue was also weaker.

    An underutilized subplot: Delores spends her time rehearsing for an upcoming theatre production. At various moments in Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, Delores, as well as other actors, are either reading through their lines or dressing the stage for a given scene. Hannah even delivers baked goods to the theatre production’s cast and crew. In the overall story, however, this subplot was underutilized. The theatre production’s opening night didn’t take place in the movie. Plus, the subplot didn’t have a strong connection to the story’s mysteries. While Delores participating in a theatre production makes more sense, story-wise, than becoming a private investigator, this subplot did not receive a conclusion.

    Masks of comedy and tragedy images created by freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    My overall impression:

    I mentioned earlier in my review how I was so disappointed by Carrot Cake Murder: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, I was discouraged from reviewing the other Murder, She Baked/Hannah Swensen movies. As I also stated in this review, One Bad Apple: A Hannah Swensen Mystery disappointed me. Sadly, Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery is continuing that pattern. Since the Murder, She Baked/Hannah Swensen series changed its name from Murder, She Baked to Hannah Swensen, the overall quality of the series has decreased. In this newest film, the humor felt forced, making some moments feel like they were straight from a sit-com. Both mysteries lacked a sense of urgency and a subplot was underutilized. There were aspects of Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery I liked, such as the behind-the-scenes look at television. However, I can think of better films with this same concept, like Cooking with Love. It’s gotten to the point where the Murder, She Baked/Hannah Swensen series has become less enjoyable to watch. This latest chapter doesn’t make me excited for future installments.

    Overall score: 5 out of 10

    Have you seen Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery? What are your thoughts on the Murder, She Baked/Hannah Swensen series? Tell me in the comment section!

    Have fun at the movies!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Sunset Over Hope Valley: Just Like in the Book, But Real

    Ava is a new character introduced in this episode of When Calls the Heart. She claims she wanted to come to Hope Valley to experience what Elizabeth wrote about in her book. In a conversation with Elizabeth, Ava says the town is “just like in the book, but real”. Though Ava’s adventure is not as simplistic as she expected. While the story of When Calls the Heart (and its respective source material) are fictional, the time period the characters exist in actually happened. Places like Hope Valley did exist; where neighbors looked out for each other, children grew up, and people fell in love. It can, sometimes, be easy to forget these facts because most of When Calls the Heart’s audience is far removed from the 1910s to 1920s and the Hearties are so caught up in what is happening on screen. What’s also easy to forget is how different life was during the early 20th century. But the timelessness of family, friendship, and community can thrive in any era! Another thing that can thrive is good-storytelling.

    Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

    When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

    Season: 12

    Episode: 5

    Name: Mom’s the Word

    Major stories:

    Nathan confirms the mysterious coin is from the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907. Jed also confesses where he received the coin; from a man named Toddy Davis in a poker card. As Rosemary and Bill brainstorm how to reach Toddy for information, Nathan volunteers to go undercover. For about half the episode, Bill and Rosemary create a new identity for Nathan. Before leaving Hope Valley for his undercover mission, Nathan adopts the backstory of an estate dealer trying to reclaim his wealth. Within the second half of the episode, Nathan loses a poker game to Toddy. But after the game, when Nathan brings up the coin, Toddy confesses how rare coins are one of his interests. He even gives Nathan one of his business cards.

    Lee and Lucas are still avoiding each other. This friction between friends bothers Joseph and Mike. So, they come up with a plan to bring Lucas and Lee together. Joseph tricks Lee into going on a hike. Meanwhile, Mike lies to Lucas about taking him on a horseback riding trip. Once all four men reach a spot next to a river, Lucas and Lee quickly realize what’s going on. But before they can do anything about it, Mike and Joseph leave with all four horses, instructing Lee and Lucas to walk back to Hope Valley and work out their differences. So, Lucas and Lee do as they’re told. During this walk, Lee shares how he didn’t like it when Lucas took Edwin’s advice over his own. Lucas confesses how Lee’s sudden departure from Capitol City caught him off guard. Back in Hope Valley, Rosemary visits the Queen of Hearts saloon, looking for Lee. A few seconds later, Lucas and Lee are shaking hands, agreeing to work together again.

    Horse with saddle photo created by Topntp26 at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/stallion-black-equine-race-sky_1104246.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Topntp26 – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    Minor stories:

    Elizabeth introduces project-based learning to her students. Even though the primary theme is nature, the students are eager for Elizabeth’s idea. Since Allie is still interested in the Great Timber Wolves, her project is about finding a way to bring them back around Hope Valley’s surrounding areas. Oliver even volunteers to help Allie with the mapping portion of her assignment. Before introducing the concept of project-based learning, Nathan shares his concerns with Elizabeth about Allie developing a crush on Earl. Elizabeth insists she isn’t getting involved in business that is not hers. She says the exact same thing when Rosemary suggests Elizabeth become a mother figure to Allie. Nathan’s concerns are confirmed when Allie asks Earl to go on a picnic with her. This is when Earl tells Allie he doesn’t like her in a romantic sense. When Allie shows up at Elizabeth’s house, Elizabeth senses Allie is upset. Allie eventually tells Elizabeth what Earl told her. Understanding Allie’s heartbreak, Elizabeth says how “the right one” will, indeed, come along someday. She also encourages Allie to call her “Elizabeth” at home.

    Fiona comes back to Hope Valley! While the town’s residents are excited about Fiona’s return, Fiona doesn’t plan to stay long. In a conversation amongst Mei and Faith, Fiona shares how she is in the process of selling the barber shop. She also says she plans on marrying a man she’s been corresponding with some quote some time. Fiona didn’t come to Hope Valley alone, providing Ava with a ride to town. Ava claims to be a debutante whose parents are on vacation. She also claims all her luggage, including her money, was stolen. So, for the time being, Ava stays at the Queen of Hearts hotel, where her bill becomes concerning. The reason for Ava’s trip to Hope Valley is to experience what Elizabeth wrote about in her book. Ava shares how she wants to become a teacher as well. Elizabeth invites Ava to join her class on a nature walk. Unfortunately for Ava, this trip turns sour because Ava walks into poison oak. Despite this mishap, Elizabeth encourages Ava to stay in Hope Valley.

    Breaking heart image created by Kjpargeter at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/broken-heart-valentine-background_1041991.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Kjpargeter – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    Some thoughts to consider:

    • In the commercial for the next When Calls the Heart episode, it was announced there was a scheduling change. This upcoming episode will premiere on February 8th at 10pm/9c. I first learned this information on the blog, It’s a Wonderful Movie. So, if you haven’t seen It’s a Wonderful Movie’s announcement or When Calls the Heart’s commercial, I wanted to inform other Hearties so they didn’t miss the episode.
    • When I re-capped last week’s episode, I wondered if When Calls the Heart’s creative team wanted to create another love triangle featuring Allie, Earl, and Oliver. With Earl expressing no interest in dating Allie, there won’t be any more love triangles anytime soon. I have to give When Calls the Heart’s creative team credit for avoiding a second love triangle. But I also have to give some credit to Earl. Allie could have started dating Earl, only to have that relationship be strung along and Allie receive false hope. But Earl decided to be honest about his feelings and tell Allie the truth.
    • So far, the coin mystery is one of the best parts of season twelve! It has prevented episodes from becoming complete “filler”, consistently giving me something to look forward. But the more Rosemary is involved in the case, I wonder where she will find the time for her radio show? Rosemary did such a good job with her first episode, gathering various perspectives on comic books. I hope the radio show makes a return this season.
    Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you like the show’s new character, Ava? Tell me in the comment section!

    Have fun in Hope Valley!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Take 3: The Chalk Garden Review + 505 Follower Thank You

    For last year’s We Are Family Blogathon, my original plan was to write about both the Diagnosis Murder episode, “Guardian Angel” and 1964’s The Chalk Garden. But as I explained in my review of hoops&yoyo’s Haunted Halloween, my plan to discuss the movie fell through. Despite this setback, I had always wanted to feature The Chalk Garden on my blog. Recently, I received a second chance to review the film! So for the first Blog Follower Dedication Review of 2025, I thought the 1964 production was the perfect title for this occasion! The Chalk Garden was recommended by Maddy (from Maddy Loves Her Classic Films) when I reviewed Marriage on the Rocks five years ago. In total, I have written about seven of Deborah Kerr’s films, with her best picture being The King and I. How will this eighth movie compare to those seven? Keep reading to find out!

    The Chalk Garden poster created by Quota Rentals Limited, Ross Hunter Productions, and Universal Pictures

    Things I liked about the film:

    The acting: The Chalk Garden is a character-driven story where part of the script serves as a character study. For these types of movies, it’s important to recruit a cast whose talents are strong enough to help make the characters interesting. While watching the 1964 film, I was invested in the story from beginning to end. One reason why is the quality of the acting performances! This is a movie where it’s difficult to choose a favorite performance, as each one was good for different reasons. Hayley Mills’ portrayal of Laurel incorporates a variety of emotions and animated expressions. These aspects of her performance showcase just how complex Laurel is. Meanwhile, Deborah Kerr’s character, Miss Madrigal, was a no-nonsense woman who subtly expressed emotion. Through her acting talents, Deborah found a way to present her character as nurturing and a promoter of “tough love”. As for John Mills’ portrayal of Maitland, his character’s consistently welcoming persona put the other characters at ease. Maitland’s laid-back personality and calm way of approaching situations reminded me of Mr. Rogers from Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood.

    Mrs. St. Maugham’s residence: The story of The Chalk Garden takes place at Mrs. St. Maugham’s house. Since Mrs. St. Maugham was a woman with a financially comfortable life, her house perfectly reflected this. The sunroom was introduced in the movie’s first five minutes. Wrap-around windows looked out to a view of a large grassy hill. Plants filled the inside of the sunroom. In the center of the area, four white metal chairs were set around a smaller table. The furniture looked like it came straight out of an old-fashioned ice-cream parlor. On Mrs. St. Maugham’s property was her backyard shed. Though this space was not frequently shown in The Chalk Garden, I really liked its interior design! Underneath a window was a white wicker desk housing some potted plants. A wicker table was surrounded by wicker chairs of varying sizes. The white stone walls and differently shaped windows helped make the backyard shed a quaint and classy space! These finer details successfully captured Mrs. St. Maugham’s sophisticated taste!

    The dialogue: Toward the beginning of The Chalk Garden, Miss Madrigal arrives at Mrs. St. Maugham’s house to be interviewed for the available governess job. When Maitland greets her at the door, he asks Miss Madrigal if she’s worked as a governess before. She cleverly replies with a question of her own, asking “do you usually interview applicants in the doorway”? This was the funniest moment in The Chalk Garden because of how well-written and delivered this exchange was! After Miss Madrigal accepts the governess job, she moves in to Mrs. St. Maugham’s house. While Miss Madrigal unpacks her belongings, Laurel explains how she doesn’t like to be told “good morning”. Her reasoning is “what is a good morning to someone else is rarely a good morning to me”. When people tell each other “good morning”, they are typically saying that in the hopes the other person has a good morning. But unless we consider things from the other person’s point of view (yes, that To Kill a Mockingbird reference was intentional), we don’t know if that person has, indeed, had a good morning. So, I found Laurel’s quote to be thought-provoking. The examples of dialogue I provided display the quality screenwriting within The Chalk Garden! How memorable the dialogue was is a result of that quality!

    Good sailing day image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/summer-landscape-with-a-houselight-and-a-boat_866882.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/design”>Design vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    What I didn’t like about the film:

    A quickly resolved conflict: Throughout The Chalk Garden, Mrs. St. Maugham is at odds with her daughter, Olivia. Their relationship is so strained, Mrs. St. Maugham wants to obtain sole custody of her granddaughter, Laurel. This conflict lasts the entire movie. While I will not spoil The Chalk Garden, I will say the conflict was resolved within the film’s last ten minutes. The way it was resolved was too abrupt. As a result of this abrupt resolution, Laurel’s change in attitude and behavior happened too quickly. The reason for these flaws is how the second half of the story focuses on unearthing secrets.

    Unanswered questions: There were times in The Chalk Garden when characters would make a claim, only for that claim to not be met with confirmation or denial. One example shows Laurel telling Miss Madrigal about the aftermath of when she was attacked in the park. Laurel says even though the police never got involved, it was an “open and shut case”. Before this conversation, however, Maitland warns Miss Madrigal how Laurel has a penchant for lying and fabricating the truth. Did the incident in the park actually take place or was Laurel bending the truth to get a reaction? This is one of the claims in The Chalk Garden that should have been clarified.

    An unresolved metaphor: Along with being Laurel’s governess, Miss Madrigal is the resident gardener. This is because Mrs. St. Maugham lacks a “green thumb”. Miss Madrigal uses Mrs. St. Maugham’s garden as a metaphor for Laurel, even referring to it as “a chalk garden”. In order for the metaphor to work, the garden’s growth should have paralleled Laurel’s personal journey. Unfortunately, the garden itself makes infrequent appearances in the film. It also doesn’t help how Mrs. St. Maugham never puts Miss Madrigal’s words into practice, making the metaphor seem unresolved.

    Paint palette image created by Freepik at freepik.com <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/hand-drawn-artsy-tools_836777.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/hand”>Hand vector created by Freepik</a> Image found at freepik.com

    My overall impression:

    Before I share my overall impression on The Chalk Garden, I want to take the time to thank the followers of 18 Cinema Lane. The support my blog receives still amazes me, even seven years after 18 Cinema Lane began! While I appreciate 18 Cinema Lane’s followers, I also appreciate when my blog’s readers provide film recommendations. This is why I try to write about these recommendations whenever possible. As I mentioned in this review’s introduction, The Chalk Garden was suggested by Maddy (from Maddy Loves Her Classic Films). I’m thankful to have not only been recommended the movie, but to also have finally checked it out! The 1964 production is part character study, part mystery. Because of the strength of the acting performances and screenwriting, this story worked! Liked I said in my review, I was invested in the story from beginning to end. The characters were interesting and the mysterious elements were intriguing. Though I wish some questions had been answered and a major conflict hadn’t been resolved so quickly, The Chalk Garden did more things right when it came to film-making. I can, honestly, say I would recommend this movie for those looking for a good cinematic story!

    Overall score: 7.8 out of 10

    Have you seen The Chalk Garden? What is the best movie you’ve been recommended? Let me know in the comment section!

    Have fun at the movies!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Sunset Over Hope Valley: Fearlessly Trying Something New

    In this episode of When Calls the Heart, multiple characters are trying new things. Two notable examples are Elizabeth and Lucas. In preparation for Allie’s birthday party, Elizabeth agrees to teach Allie and her friends some new dance moves. Meanwhile, Lucas tries being a ranch hand, in order to rescue a runaway calf. Even though trying these new things prove challenging for both Lucas and Elizabeth, they share something else in common; they take on their respective challenge fearlessly. Instead of staying overwhelmed by the complicated dance steps, Elizabeth turns to friends to help her put her best foot forward. For Lucas, confidence and patience allowed him to save the day. Reflecting on this episode and When Calls the Heart as a whole, I remembered how fearlessly trying new things has always been a part of Hope Valley’s identity. This component is one way the show has remained consistent.

    Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

    When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

    Season: 12

    Episode: 4

    Name: Dancing Teens

    Major stories:

    Allie is excited for her upcoming birthday party. While she knows what type of party to host and what she’ll wear, Allie is missing one major piece; the dance steps. Allie and her friends ask Elizabeth to teach them some dance moves, preferably those from newer dance styles. Even though Elizabeth agrees to this request, she feels overwhelmed by how complicated some of the dance steps are. Eventually, Elizabeth turns to Rosemary and Mei to become the best dance teacher she can be. Meanwhile, Nathan is caught off guard when he finds out about Allie’s dance party from Lee, not Allie. When Nathan confronts Allie about the party, Elizabeth intervenes and helps father and daughter agree to have chaperones at the event. As the party draws closer, Mollie believes the party should be cancelled, as the event will lead to hurt feelings and bad behavior. The party is still on the schedule, however, after Allie, Elizabeth, and Nathan successfully argue in the party’s favor. When Allie’s party arrives, it proves to be a wonderful event! But before Oliver can present a gift to Allie, Earl shows up to give Allie a bouquet of flowers.

    Bill confirms the coin from the previous episode is, indeed, one of the missing twenty thousand from the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907. He also believes the Garrison Gang may have been responsible for the robbery. The mystery of how the coin ended up in Hope Valley still remains. So, Rosemary and Bill agree to ask Ned and Florence if they remember any customers making a purchase with that coin. At the Mercantile, Bill and Rosemary learn the coin amounts to one dollar. They also learn three customers spent a dollar on hazelnuts. When they find out Mollie was one of those three customers, Bill and Rosemary confront her at the Queen of Hearts saloon. Unfortunately for the duo, Mollie denies everything. Toward the end of the episode, at Allie’s birthday party, Jed, the owner of a local fruit stand, confesses to Mollie how he used the coin to purchase hazelnuts. Mollie encourages him to tell Rosemary and Bill the next day.

    Birthday cake image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/chocolate-birthday-cakes-collection_765437.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/birthday”>Birthday vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    Minor stories:

    Lucas and Lee are still at odds over the national park project. Both gentlemen want to give each other space and will wait for the other to talk to them. While Lucas visits the allotted land, he crosses paths with Edie. She’s on her way to her uncle’s ranch, inviting Lucas to join her. When they arrive on the ranch land, Edie explains to Lucas how important the land and her uncle is to her. Edie shares how her uncle became her guardian after her parents passed away. He cared for her so much, he even paid for Edie’s law school expenses. As for the land, Edie talks to Lucas about how it is vital for the economy. Later in the episode, Edie needs help finding a runaway calf. Despite having no ranching skills, Lucas volunteers to find the calf with Edie. After locating the calf, Lucas and Edie have difficulty catching the baby cow. But Lucas eventually rescues the calf by lassoing it on his first try. It’s around this moment Lucas discovers the wedding ring Edie always wears is missing. Edie then confesses how she used to be engaged, but the engagement didn’t last. So, now she wears a wedding ring to turn away potential suitors.

    Despite the excitement of Allie’s birthday party, Angela feels insecure. This is not only due to Angela never attending a dance party before, but also her belief that she’s different. At the library, Angela confesses to Elizabeth how her belief that she’s different makes her feel like no one understands what she’s going through. To lift Angela’s spirits, Elizabeth gives Angela a braille copy of one of Helen Keller’s books. Angela also shares her feelings and insecurities with Joseph. He tells his daughter dancing is more about how you feel than how you look, teaching Angela how to waltz. Before she attends Allie’s birthday party, Angela confesses to Joseph that even though she’s now looking forward to the party, she wants to meet people who are also blind. This is the reason why Angela wants to attend a college for blind students.

    Some thoughts to consider:

    • I know that on When Calls the Heart, accomplishing any goal takes time. But the more the national park project is included in the overall story, the more it feels reminiscent of the hotel project from season eleven. What I mean by this is the characters spend more time talking about completing the project than actually completing the project. This makes me wonder if the drawn-out nature of these projects could be the result of the show’s creative team having limited funds?
    • As I mentioned in this re-cap, Oliver is about to give Allie a gift at her birthday party. He doesn’t give her this gift because Earl shows up to give Allie a bouquet of flowers. That moment made me wonder if When Calls the Heart’s creative team want to create another love triangle, but among Allie, Earl, and Oliver this time? I really hope this isn’t the case. Since Allie made her debut in When Calls the Heart’s sixth season, she has experienced two major heartbreaks; when her mother passed away and when her biological father rejected her. Personally, I don’t want to watch Allie potentially get her heart broken a third time.
    • Toward the end of this episode, Allie’s birthday party is shown on screen. The color palette was purple and gold, reflected in the balloons and streamers. A collection of streamers created a canopy near the ceiling, presenting the illusion the party took place within a tent. String lights were also found near the ceiling and on the railing of the saloon’s stairs. These lights caused the space to appear dim, but bright enough to navigate the dance floor. Whoever on When Calls the Heart’s creative team designed that set should be acknowledged!
    Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you want to see another love triangle on When Calls the Heart? Let me know in the comment section!

    Have fun in Hope Valley!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Sunset Over Hope Valley: Knock Three Times

    As a piece of advice to Lucas, Minnie says in order to seek reconcile, you have to knock three times. This was Minnie’s way of encouraging Lucas to reach out to the person he had a disagreement with. Despite not hearing Minnie’s advice, Earl Wyatt came back to Hope Valley and “knocked three times”, seeking reconcile for bullying Opal years ago. But reconciliation is not the only reason characters, figuratively, knock on each other’s doors on When Calls the Heart. Sometimes, it’s in search of help, like when Oliver sought Elizabeth’s guidance on his Mountie writing sample. Other times, characters “knock three times” to find answers. One example is Rosemary’s quest for the origin of a valuable coin. The idea of characters, figuratively, knocking on each other’s doors shows how the residents of Hope Valley, and even guests, rely on each other when it matters most. This is an example of the kind of place Hope Valley is.

    Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

    When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

    Season: 12

    Episode: 3

    Name: All That Glitters

    Major stories:

    Oliver’s one-month evaluation is fast approaching. The only step left is his writing sample. After Oliver submits the writing sample, Nathan takes note of its weak writing quality. When Elizabeth makes this discovery, she volunteers to help Oliver improve his writing sample. At the Jack Thornton School, Oliver shows up for his first tutoring session. He claims he attended a school in Hamilton called Briarcliff. But later in the episode, Elizabeth finds out the school closed five years prior to Oliver’s arrival in Hope Valley. This fact, along with Oliver’s decision to resign from the Mounties, raises alarm in Nathan. So, he and Elizabeth confront Oliver at the stables. Oliver confesses he lied about attending Briarcliff. His reason is how he sought a better life for himself, due to being a foster child. Oliver also reveals how he didn’t finish school because his foster parents believed working on their farm was more important. He explains to Nathan his decision to resign from the Mounties was due to not wanting Nathan to get in trouble. Oliver’s loyalty gives Nathan a reason to not give up on Oliver. Later in the episode, Superintendent Hargreaves arrives for the one-month evaluation. Oliver passes with flying colors.

    Rosemary has two mysteries on her hands. The first is why Lee is so secretive. She becomes curious after being told Lee created a will and recently had a doctor’s appointment. As Rosemary shares her concerns with Elizabeth at the Mercantile, they overhear Lee telling Ned he’s going on a hike. So, Elizabeth and Rosemary follow Lee and Mike into the forest. After Mike and Lee discover the women’s hiding place among the bushes, Rosemary and Elizabeth learn the purpose of the hike; so Lee could create a hiking trail named after Goldie. Lee explains how he hopes the trail will remind Lucas of the national park’s importance. The second mystery revolves around a coin bearing a double headed bird. When Ned discovers a rare coin, Rosemary makes it her mission to track down its original owner. She writes an article about the coin in The Valley Voice. But no one comes forward. Bill volunteers to help Rosemary crack the case. After he retrieves the Mountie file about the coin, Bill shares with Rosemary how the coin was one of twenty thousand coins stolen in the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907.

    Silver coin image created by Welcomia at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/american-one-dollar-coin_1180385.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/money”>Money image created by Welcomia – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    Minor stories:

    At Capitol City, Edwin and Lucas learn Jeanette’s trial is coming up. Edwin encourages Lucas to leave Capital City to avoid more negative press. Lucas takes Edwin’s advice and goes back to Hope Valley. On the train ride home, Lucas learns Edie is also headed towards Hope Valley, in order to take care of her uncle’s ranch. Once in the town, at The Café, Edie reveals to Lucas how she’s considering opening a law firm in Hope Valley. But those plans are on hold because she can’t find the space.

    Earl Wyatt returns to Hope Valley and apologizes to Opal for bullying her when she was younger. Earl’s arrival intrigues Allie, as he shares how his father works for the railroad, allowing him to travel wherever he wants. Before meeting Earl, Allie tries to decide what she wants to do for her upcoming 17th birthday. What she does know is she wants to host a party among her friends. At the Queen of Hearts saloon, Allie and some of her friends hear dance music. When she sees Earl dancing, Allie chooses to have a dance party for her birthday.

    String of musical notes image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/pentagram-vector_710290.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com. 

    Some thoughts to consider:

    • You’re probably wondering why I spelled Goldie’s name with an ‘ie’ instead of with a ‘y’ like I usually do. That’s because her name is spelled G-O-L-D-I-E in this episode. When it comes to characters’ names, I try to spell them how the show’s creative team intended. So, from now on, I will spell Goldie’s name with an ‘ie’ in future re-caps.
    • Thinking about the mystery of the coin and Earl Wyatt’s return to Hope Valley, I wonder if Earl’s family has something to do with the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907? As I mentioned in this re-cap, Earl said his father works for the railroad. Plus, Earl’s arrival and the discovery of the coin took place around the same time. This would explain why Earl and his family left Hope Valley all those years ago.
    • In this re-cap, I said Rosemary becomes curious after being told Lee created a will and recently had a doctor’s appointment. In a scene where Lee pays Faith a visit, it’s revealed Lee’s father died of an unnamed medical condition. Lee is not only concerned about developing this medical condition himself, he’s also worried about leaving a legacy behind for his daughter. Faith reassures him that he has a clean bill of health. However, I wonder if Lee’s medical history will become an overarching story this season?
    Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    What are your thoughts on this episode? Who do you think is behind the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907? Let me know in the comment section!

    Have fun in Hope Valley!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Word on the Street: New ‘Hannah Swensen Mystery’ Movie on the Way!

    When I talked about One Bad Apple: A Hannah Swensen Mystery in my list of the top ten worst movies I saw in 2024, I said I hope Delores receives better story ideas if there are more Hannah Swensen films in the works. Days after that list was published, Hallmark revealed another movie in the Hannah Swensen series! On Hallmark Mystery’s website, an official page has been created for Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery. The film will premiere on February 6th and the story is about the following:

    “Hannah’s favorite reality show takes over The Cookie Jar. When the producer is found dead, Hannah and Norman team up to track down the killer. Chad invites Hannah to court”.

    According to the film’s official page, Alison Sweeney, Victor Webster, and Barbara Niven will return to reprise their roles. Even though Norman was mentioned in the synopsis, it’s unknown, at this time, if Gabriel Hogan will also return to reprise his role.

    Magnifying glass image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/magnifying-glass-with-fingerprint-in-flat-style_2034684.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/flat”>Flat vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

    There are some noticeable observations coming from the official page of Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery. Looking at the release dates for this movie and The Jane Mysteries: A Deadly Prescription, Hallmark’s new mystery titles will premiere on Thursdays instead of Fridays like last year. Norman’s involvement was limited in One Bad Apple: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, not only when it came to solving the case, but also within the overall story. The synopsis of Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery states, “Hannah and Norman team up to track down the killer”. This statement assumes Norman will play a larger role in the 2025 movie. Ever since Chad was written into this series, he and Hannah don’t work together as consistently as Hannah and Mike did. However, Chad still finds a way to have a presence in Hannah’s life. A perfect example is brought up in Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery’s synopsis, which states “Chad invites Hannah to court”. Everything I just said makes me wonder if the creative team of the Hannah Swensen series wants to create a love triangle between Norman, Hannah, and Chad?

    What are your thoughts on this piece of movie news? Are you looking forward to the premiere of Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery? Please let me know in the comment section!

    Have fun at the movies!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Referenced official page of Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery: https://www.hallmarkmystery.com/reality-bites-a-hannah-swensen-mystery

    The Top Ten Worst Movies I Saw in 2024

    While 2024 was, for me, a better year for movies, I still saw some movies I didn’t like. Similar to my worst movies list of 2023, most of the films on this year’s list were disappointing or average. But, unlike 2023, the top four titles are from different genres. The dishonorable mentions section has returned! This time, however, there are more DNFs (did not finish). Like I have said in past lists, my top ten worst movies I saw in 2024 list is not intended to be mean-spirited, negative, or disrespectful. It’s just a list of my own, honest opinion. Since I reviewed some of the movies on my list, I will provide the links to those reviews in this article.

    Dishonorable Mentions

    The Reluctant Debutante, The Gambler: Luck of the Draw, Jazz Ramsey: A K-9 Mystery, Million Dollar Lethal Listing, CrimeTime: Freefall (I turned it off after about forty minutes), Mermaid Down (I turned off this movie after about twenty minutes), Blood, Sweat and Cheer (I turned it off after about eighteen minutes), and Temptation Under the Sun (I turned off this movie after about twenty-two minutes)

    Image by starline on Freepik

    10. Crimes of Fashion: Killer Clutch

    In the 2020s, Hallmark has come up with story ideas that worked well enough for a stand-alone mystery movie, but unsustainable for a multi-chapter series. One of these ideas came from Crimes of Fashion: Killer Clutch. This film made the same mistake as Mystery Island: not allowing the protagonist to use her skills to solve the case. For Lauren, the main character in Crimes of Fashion: Killer Clutch, her psychology skills were so underutilized, she seemed more like an over glorified intern. Thick French accents making several characters difficult to understand is another major flaw of the film. It prevented me from being fully invested in the story. Crimes of Fashion: Killer Clutch was, in my opinion, a disappointing movie. But compared to the other titles on 2024’s worst of the year list, Hallmark’s production was, simply, ‘underwhelming’.

    Take 3: Crimes of Fashion: Killer Clutch Review

    9. Boy in the Walls

    When I first read the synopsis for Boy in the Walls, I thought the film would be a spookier version of 2016’s Boy in the Attic. Sadly, this was not the case. The 2023 Lifetime presentation contained a mystery that was drawn out for too long. It also doesn’t help how the protagonist made one dumb decision after another. Without spoiling the film, all I’ll say is the title is misleading. If you haven’t watched either referenced movie, I’d recommend Boy in the Attic.

    8. The 39 Steps

    In my review of The 39 Steps, I said the 1935 picture was the most “meh” title from Alfred Hitchcock’s filmography. This statement was made due to the limited sense of urgency and intrigue within the story. As I also said in my review, The 39 Steps seems longer than an hour and twenty-six minutes. The drawn-out nature of the movie created a slow and boring build-up to a reveal that feels kind of ridiculous and anti-climactic. While romance has been incorporated in some of Alfred’s films, it didn’t work in The 39 Steps. Richard and Pamela’s attraction for one another was too abrupt, welcoming the presence of the “insta-love” trope. Even though The 39 Steps was a disappointing movie, I gave it a lower placement on my list. Comparing the 1935 film to Alfred’s other productions, Hitchcock’s filmography shows how much he improved as a director.

    Take 3: The 39 Steps Review

    7. Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Pack of Lies

    There are some movies that, in my opinion, should have been documentaries instead. The 1987 Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation, Pack of Lies, is just one example. This film in the Hallmark Hall of Fame collection is based on a true story. While “based on a true story” movies can be engaging, intriguing, and even thought-provoking, Pack of Lies was disappointing. Like I said in my review of the 1987 production, the film was a two hour slow and tedious build-up to a resolution that was underwhelming and anti-climactic. The creative team’s decision to choose telling over showing caused other flaws, from little lapse in time to things not making sense. Pack of Lies proves Hallmark Hall of Fame movies are not created equally. However, there are other Hallmark Hall of Fame presentations from the 1980s I like, such as the adaptations of The Secret Garden and A Tale of Two Cities.

    Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Pack of Lies Review

    6. One Bad Apple: A Hannah Swensen Mystery

    While A Sprinkle of Deceit: A Hannah Swensen Mystery was slightly better than One Bad Apple: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, I was still disappointed in the latter film. For starters, Victor Webster and Alison Sweeney had no on-screen chemistry. A character (not Hannah) solves the mystery by making an assumption about the case and being conveniently correct. But the worst part about One Bad Apple: A Hannah Swensen Mystery was Delores’ subplot. Up until this film, Delores was very against Hannah getting involved in cases, as well as dating Mike. So, for Delores to become a private investigator and seem to treat her new job as a joke completely went against her character. In fact, this was such a bad creative idea, Delores’ private investigating career was barely mentioned in A Sprinkle of Deceit: A Hannah Swensen Mystery. If there are more Hannah Swensen films in the works, I really hope Delores receives better story ideas.

    Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Pack of Lies poster created by Hallmark Hall of Fame Productions, Robert Halmi, and CBS

    5. My Life Is on the Line

    This Lifetime movie had one of the network’s most creative story ideas. The 2024 picture was about a woman who tried to solve a mystery on her computer at her office cubicle. But the longer I watched this movie, the sooner I realized that aforementioned idea wasn’t sustainable for a feature-length production. Instead, the novelty of how the mystery was solved got old very quickly. My Life Is on the Line is yet another Lifetime film where the protagonist makes a collection of dumb choices. Her decision-making is so bad, other characters in the story, including her boss, call her out for it. Lifetime’s 2024 presentation was, for me, the most disappointing movie of the year.

    4. Network

    Network holds the honor of not only being the first film I reviewed for my Comparing with the Critics series, it’s also the first film I disagreed with the critics on. Even though Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert placed the movie in their list of the top five films from 1976, I would call Network one of the “Dogs of the Year”. For me, it was more of an endurance test, where the story’s first half was a drawn-out search for a resolution to the movie’s conflict and the second half was a yelling contest. Being a pretentious picture by taking itself too seriously and telling a dry, boring story didn’t work in Network’s favor. There are movies from the 1970s I like. Unfortunately, Network isn’t one of them.

    Comparing with the Critics – Best of 1976 – Network

    3. Mount Hideaway Mysteries: Exes and Oh No’s

    It’s ironic that Mount Hideaway Mysteries: Heartache and Homecoming became the third worst movie of 2023 and now Mount Hideaway Mysteries: Exes and Oh No’s became the third worst movie of 2024. When you look past this irony, you’ll see how Mount Hideaway Mysteries: Exes and Oh No’s shares some of the same flaws as its sequel, like not understanding how technology works. Mount Hideaway Mysteries: Exes and Oh No’s contains its own flaws, with poor special effects as one example. While this movie is so bad, it’s, at times, unintentionally funny, I do acknowledge how challenging it can be to create a cinematic project. In fact, the best way to sum up Mount Hideaway Mysteries: Exes and Oh No’s is the quote, “Mistakes are proof that you are trying”.

    Take 3: Mount Hideaway Mysteries: Exes and Oh No’s Review

    2. Revenge Best Served Chilled

    This Lifetime movie from 2022 had a very misleading title and synopsis. Not only is there no revenge in the story, there’s also nothing being chilled throughout the film. According to a plot summary I read, Revenge Best Served Chilled is about a series of murder mysteries taking place at a wine expert competition, with the protagonist trying to clear her name and solve the mysteries. The movie actually emphasizes the wine expert competition to the point where there is little to no mystery involved. Like Boy in the Walls and My Life Is on The Line, the protagonist, Emily, makes so many dumb decisions. I, honestly, should have turned this movie off after Emily doesn’t lock her family’s restaurant’s front doors as she’s spending the night at the restaurant. But I naively thought Revenge Best Served Chilled was going to be a better movie.

    1. Frankenstein (2004)

    I referenced this movie while reviewing the Hallmark adaptation of Frankenstein, as I was pointing out a technical error on Wikipedia. When I saw the version of Frankenstein starring Vincent Perez, I immediately knew it was going to be the worst movie I saw in 2024. While this movie contains some interesting ideas, those ideas are bogged down by other ideas. The excessive number of ideas made the story feel like a series of vignettes either loosely connected to each other or not connected at all. What also makes the overall story weak is how nothing is explained. The ending is one of the most “sequel bait” endings I’ve seen in a long time. I would strongly discourage readers from checking out this version of Frankenstein. More time will be spent being frustrated than entertained.

    Mount Hideaway Mysteries: Exes and Oh No’s poster created by Glass House Distribution

    Have fun in 2025!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Take 3: Dial M for Murder Review

    For this movie review, I chose to write about the 1954 film, Dial M for Murder, for two reasons. The first is how I selected this specific title for The 6th Wonderful Grace Kelly Blogathon, as Grace Kelly stars in the film. The second reason is how, prior to this review, I had never seen Dial M for Murder. Grace and Alfred are no strangers to 18 Cinema Lane. As of mid-November, 2024, I have reviewed two of Grace’s films; High Society (which I thought was fine) and To Catch a Thief (which I found just ok). Meanwhile, four of Alfred Hitchcock’s movies have been covered on my blog. Out of those titles, Strangers on a Train is, in my opinion, still the best one. But how does Dial M for Murder compare to any of Alfred’s films featured on 18 Cinema Lane? Find out by reading my review!

    Dial M for Murder poster created by Warner Bros.

    Things I liked about the film:

    The acting: Since Grace Kelly is the reason why I chose to review Dial M for Murder, I will talk about her performance first. Out of her movies I’ve seen, I’ve noticed how her character portrayals have appeared at ease. Her performance in Dial M for Murder is no different, as her adopted mannerisms and reactions came across as realistic! While sharing a conversation with Mark (portrayed by Robert Cummings), Grace’s character, Margot, seems comfortable in his presence. She effortlessly moves around her apartment and, at times, stands close to him. But when she talks with Mark about how her husband, Tony, has changed, Margot appears to stare into the distance. The combination of her aforementioned stare and frown indicates how Tony’s behavior has troubled her. It also shows the audience how effective Grace’s acting talents are!

    As I just said in this review, Robert Cummings portrays Mark, a close friend of Margot. Though they shared only a few scenes together, Grace and Robert displayed nice on-screen chemistry! The strength of Robert’s and Grace’s acting abilities helped their characters appear to truly get along with each other. While I liked Robert’s performance in Dial M for Murder, I was also impressed with Ray Milland’s performance! Similar to Grace’s portrayal of Margot, Ray’s portrayal of Tony showcases how adaptable his acting skills are. For example, Tony looks annoyed while at a restaurant with Mark. From the tone in his voice to constantly checking his watch, Tony clearly appears impatient. A few scenes later, as he’s on the phone with Margot, his demeanor quickly changes to concern due to what he hears over the phone. Throughout his performance, Ray effortlessly brought his character to life!

    The use of lighting: Over the course of his career, Alfred Hitchcock has received the title of “Master of Suspense”. One reason why he was given this title is because of how he utilizes lighting to stir up a mood, present visually interesting concepts, or add suspense. In one scene, someone enters Margot and Tony’s apartment. This moment takes place at night, so the only light comes from the fireplace in the living room. An orange glow only providing light to certain areas of the room creates a suspenseful environment, giving the intruder places to hide. I brought up earlier in this review how Mark and Margot shared a conversation. Their conversation takes place in Tony and Margot’s apartment. Right before Tony returns home, Margot’s and Mark’s shadow departs from each other, keeping the closeness of their relationship a secret.

    The use of color: Dial M for Murder’s opening credits reveal how the film’s creative team used “WarnerColor” in their project. I’m glad this movie was presented in color because it gave the creative team opportunities to utilize this visual technique to their advantage! Sometimes, the color red was incorporated into a character’s wardrobe. This ranged from Margot wearing a red dress at the beginning of the movie to Tony sporting deep red suspenders. One of the pieces of décor in Margot and Tony’s apartment were dark green curtains. In these examples, color was chosen to draw the audience’s attention to a person, object, or location in the room.

    The 6th Wonderful Grace Kelly Blogathon banner created by Virginie from The Wonderful World of Cinema and Emily from The Flapper Dame

    What I didn’t like about the film:

    Exposition heavy: At the beginning of the movie, Margot shares with Mark how she recently lost her purse. She also tells him when her purse was returned, a letter Mark wrote her was missing. But shortly after Margot made this confession, an exposition heavy scene revealed the letter’s whereabouts, as well as who the story’s perpetrator was. Because this information was revealed so early in the movie, it took away a lot of the story’s suspense. So much exposition given within the film’s first ten minutes may also overwhelm the audience, possibly missing important information if they don’t actively pay attention to the dialogue.

    A mystery that isn’t interactive: While talking about Dial M for Murder’s exposition heavy story, I said the perpetrator was revealed so early in the movie. This creative choice takes away the audience’s opportunity to solve the mystery of whodunit alongside the characters. What Dial M for Murder became was a story of how the perpetrator would get caught, similar to programs like Columbo and Diagnosis Murder. That creative decision forces the audience to simply watch the characters solve the story’s mystery. With everything I said, the mystery in Dial M for Murder wasn’t interactive.

    A less intimidating antagonist: In some of Alfred Hitchcock’s movies, the antagonist is an intimidating person for a variety of reasons. Their intimidation can add suspense and intensity to a given film’s story. I will not spoil Dial M for Murder. However, I can honestly say I did not find the movie’s antagonist intimidating. Throughout the story, the antagonist kept making dumb decisions, which distracted from their attempts to be an intimidating character. It also didn’t help how the exposition heaviness of the film’s first ten minutes took away a lot of the story’s suspense. If anything, the antagonist in Dial M for Murder was annoying.

    Colorful image of key created by orchidart at freepik.com. Flower vector created by orchidart – www.freepik.com

    My overall impression:

    As of the publication of this review, I have seen eight of Alfred Hitchcock’s films. While I was disappointed by The 39 Steps, I ended up liking Strangers on a Train. When it comes to Dial M for Murder, though, the movie lies somewhere in the middle. Grace Kelly’s performance was, once again, one of the best parts of the production! Her portrayal of Margot was so strong, her reactions and expressions appeared realistic! The use of lighting and color gave Alfred and his creative team ways to present visually creative ideas. But what held Dial M for Murder back from being a more intriguing project is how the first ten minutes of the story was exposition heavy, with this decision impacting the film’s suspense. The mystery not being interactive also takes away some of Dial M for Murder’s intrigue. Alfred’s film felt reminiscent of shows like Columbo and Diagnosis Murder, where the audience simply waits for the perpetrator to get caught. Personally, I prefer mystery stories where I’m left guessing whodunit.

    Overall score: 6-6.1 out of 10

    Have you seen Dial M for Murder? Which movie of Alfred Hitchcock’s would you like to see me review next? Tell me in the comment section!

    Have fun at the movies!

    Sally Silverscreen