The residents of Benson Hills will move back home after the Harvest Festival. But in this seasonâs finale of When Calls the Heart, some of Elizabethâs students from Benson Hills are hesitant to return home. This is because theyâll miss the friends theyâve made in Hope Valley. Elizabeth reassures these students they are always welcome to return to Hope Valley, saying, âA community doesnât dissolve just because we donât see each other every dayâ. Her quote is the perfect way to describe When Calls the Heart. Hope Valley and its residents havenât dissolved because the show airs for a certain period of time. The creative team thinks of new ways to continue to story. Filming and editing are completed in between seasons. In the context of the story itself, Hope Valleyâs residents are living their lives to their fullest. With a fourteenth season on the way, the world of When Calls the Heart will continue to stay.
Just a reminder: If you did not see the season finale of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 13
Episode: 12
Name: Harvest Moon
LJ is still disappointed he isnât allowed to travel to Parsonâs Peak. Nathan creates an alternative by giving LJ an opportunity to climb to the top of Hope Valleyâs water tower. Not only does Nathanâs plan work, other children want to climb the water tower too. Meanwhile, Nathan tries to find the perfect time to propose to Elizabeth. But Bill advises Nathan to propose when the moment feels right. Nathan lets Allie know this is how his proposal will go. While the Harvest Festival is going on, Nathan takes Elizabeth to the top of Hope Valleyâs water tower and finally proposes to her. Elizabeth accepts this proposal, meaning a wedding is in her future.
On her last day of school before going home to Benson Hills, Gwen wears the dress Rosemary made for her toward the beginning of the season. But the dress becomes dirty and ripped during a baseball game. Gwen is upset by the destruction of the dress, believing she ruins everything. But Rosemary insists Gwen has brought so much joy to the lives of the Coulter family. Before going back to Benson Hills, Gwen gives each member of the Coulter family a gift. Lee receives a fishing hook, Rosemary gets a hand-carved picture frame, and Goldie is given a pair of dolls.

Edie returns to Hope Valley to help collect insurance claims for the rest of Benson Hillsâ residents. Lucas sees this as a second chance to share his feelings for Edie. At the Harvest Festival, Lucas announces heâll be stepping down as Governor. However, he will give his support to Maisieâs campaign. Maisie is unsure whether she should run for Governor in the upcoming election. But Mike gives her encouragement, which helps Maisie accept Lucasâ nomination. Meanwhile, at the Queen of Hearts, Lucas and Edie have a heart-to-heart conversation about their relationship. Not only do Edie and Lucas share a kiss, Lucas also agrees to go to New York with Edie, where sheâll be going to help the Franklin And Sons Foundation.
Angela surprises her family by coming back home to Hope Valley. The Canfield family surprises Angela not only with the cafĂŠâs new name, Minnieâs CafĂŠ, but also an official cafĂŠ sign in Braille. During her visit to Hope Valley, Angela reconnects with Allie. At the Harvest Festival, Angela senses Allie and Oliver like each other. Allie claims she and Oliver are just friends. But Angela respectfully disagrees, believing thereâs something more to Oliver and Allieâs relationship.

Some thoughts to consider:
- Last December, Hallmark confirmed Lori Loughlin would return to When Calls the Heart in six of season fourteenâs episodes. These creative decisions were divisive due to Hallmarkâs response to Loriâs involvement in 2019âs college admissions scandal. Whatâs even more divisive is making Loriâs return to the show the âcliffhangerâ/major selling point for season fourteen. While some Hearties are supportive of Loriâs return, other Hearties will not agree with this decision. Therefore, I think the aforementioned creative choices could divide When Calls the Heartâs fanbase more than the love triangle between Elizabeth, Lucas, and Nathan did. I also believe Loriâs return could cause When Calls the Heart to lose instead of gain viewership.
- When Iâve talked about When Calls the Heart, I sometimes brought up the creative teamâs habit of making promises to their audience they knew they couldnât keep. Rosemaryâs Playhouse is the most recent example. As I said in the introduction of season thirteenâs premiere re-cap post, I have been waiting for Rosemaryâs dream of opening a theater to come true for over ten years. It was bad enough taking the Playhouse away from Rosemary before it was shown on screen. But whatâs even worse was the script spending more time reminding the audience of the Playhouseâs destruction than trying to restore Rosemaryâs dream. As a long-time fan of When Calls the Heart, I find these creative decisions cruel and unnecessary.
- The best aspect of season thirteen, in my opinion, was the introduction of Fernando. In my re-cap post for this seasonâs sixth episode, I said I really hope Fernando becomes a series regular on When Calls the Heart. But throughout season thirteen, he only appeared in three episodes. Plus, within the context of the showâs story, Fernando wasnât given much to do. With all this said, I wonder what the intended purpose was for his incorporation in season thirteen? Plus, if When Calls the Heartâs creative team always planned on having Edie and Lucas develop a romantic relationship, why would Fernando be included in that dynamic between himself, Edie, and Lucas?
- Now that season thirteen has concluded, I can express my honest opinion on the season as a whole. Personally, I think itâs a mixed bag. Episodes one through six were strong because they prioritized the mystery surrounding the fire. When I watched those episodes, I honestly thought season thirteen would be one of the best seasons of When Calls the Heart. But from episode seven to the season finale, the priority shifted toward stories with lower stakes. The suspenseful and intriguing momentum built up within the first six episodes stalled in favor of stories like Rosemaryâs silent movie and LJâs memory scavenger hunt. Because of this, season thirteen felt like it ended on a whimper.

What are thoughts on When Calls the Heartâs season thirteen finale? Do you think Lori Loughlin should return to the show? Let me know in the comment section.
Have fun in Hope Valley.
Sally Silverscreen












