Tag: relationships

Quaritch and Varang: Avatar: Fire and Ash’s Complicated Storm

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

I try to learn more about “popular” characters to understand why they are well-liked. But in order for me to dedicate an editorial to those characters, they need to capture my undivided attention. Colonel Miles Quaritch and Varang did just that as I listened to commentary discourse on Avatar: Fire and Ash. Those discussions about the 2025 film yielded constant praise about Varang and Quaritch’s relationship. Some people claim Quaritch and Varang were the best part of the third film, let alone the Avatar franchise. In fact, they’ve become so popular that Varang received her own unofficial theme song (MONTAGEM BUDA by DYGO). The choir of Varang and Quaritch’s admirers singing their praises genuinely confused me. However, because Quaritch and Varang are the villains of Avatar: Fire and Ash, I decided to write an editorial about their relationship similar to when I wrote about Lestat and Akasha’s relationship (from Queen of the Damned) and Top Dollar and Myca’s relationship (from The Crow). I assumed Quaritch and Varang’s relationship was equally or more toxic than those relationships. Even though they make villainous choices throughout Avatar: Fire and Ash, their relationship is, surprisingly, healthier than some of the problematic relationships from movies I’ve reviewed in the past or I’ve written about on 18 Cinema Lane. In this editorial, I will contrast Varang and Quaritch’s relationship with a handful of other film (and even television) relationships to prove my point. To support my argument, I will utilize examples, screenshots, and quotes from or related to Avatar: Fire and Ash, as well as referencing the other media in question.

My editorial introduction image created by me, Sally Silverscreen. Original image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Who are Quaritch and Varang?

Quaritch and Varang are the villains of Avatar: Fire and Ash, as well as the Avatar franchise. For readers who haven’t seen these films, I will introduce them to Varang and Quaritch. Colonel Miles Quaritch (portrayed by Stephen Lang) has remained an important character through all three Avatar films. In the first movie from 2009, Quaritch was the commander of the RDA’s (Resources Development Administration) security division. He also led the charge in Pandora’s war, attempting to remove the Omatikaya Na’vis from their home in order to provide more space for humans on Pandora. But in Avatar’s final battle, Quaritch was shot and killed by Neytiri, one of the Na’vi from the Omatikaya clan. He returned in the franchise’s second film, Avatar: The Way of Water, which takes place fifteen years after the events of the first movie. This time, however, Quaritch appears as a Na’vi Recombinant with the neurological information from his human self, such as his memories. In both the second and third film in the Avatar franchise, Quaritch maintains his objectives of providing space for humans on Pandora and holding Jake Sully (his former Corporal) accountable for abandoning the RDA in the first film. Quaritch’s second objective becomes disruptive for Jake and his family as the film series progresses.

Left picture: Portrait of Quaritch as a human in 2009’s Avatar. Image created by 20th Century Fox, Dune Entertainment, Ingenious Film Partners, Lightstorm Entertainment, and Walt Disney Studios. Right picture: Portrait of Quaritch as a Na’vi Recombinant in Avatar: Fire and Ash. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Quaritch and Varang (portrayed by Oona Chaplin) meet in Avatar: Fire and Ash. She is the Na’vi olo’eykte (clan leader) and the tsahìk (spiritual leader) of the Mangkwan clan, known for having their home destroyed by a volcanic eruption prior to the events of the third movie. Believing Eywa (the Na’vis’ goddess representative of their belief system) abandoned the Mangkwan clan after the aforementioned volcanic eruption, Varang leads her clan through trauma, anger, and survival. While the Mangkwan Na’vis see her as the glue that’s kept their clan together, other Na’vis see Varang (and the Mangkwan clan) as a threat to Pandora’s society.

Portrait of Varang from Avatar: Fire and Ash. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Varang and Quaritch vs. Achara and Jack

Achara and Jack (from the Lost episode ‘Stranger in a Strange Land’) is the only relationship from a television show included in this discussion. Jack becomes frustrated that Achara won’t share what her “gift” is with him. He becomes so hyper-fixated on learning what Achara’s “gift” is that Jack not only doesn’t take the time to learn more about Achara and the world around her (besides trying Thai food and meeting Achara’s brother in one scene), but he also defines Achara by that one aspect of her life. Throughout her month-long relationship with Jack, Achara remains hesitant to share her “gift” with him. This decision implies she doesn’t fully trust Jack. When Achara eventually reveals what her “gift” is, which is being “able to see who people are” and creating definitive (not decorative) tattoos, Jack forces her to give him this desired explanation. He also forces her to give him a tattoo by forcibly pulling her toward and placing her in a chair by her tattooing station. While Jack is in his drunken fueled aggression and frustration, Achara refuses his request. She cites Jack’s status as an “outsider”, saying that she isn’t allowed to give him a tattoo and giving Jack a tattoo would go against her people. But when Achara’s brother eventually discovers Jack received a tattoo from Achara, he and his friends beat Jack up. Achara’s brother then orders Jack to leave Thailand. Meanwhile, Achara tearfully looks on while this confrontation takes place.

The ash and burnt trees hold proof of the trauma Varang (and the Mangkwan clan) endured. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Varang leads the Mangkwan clan through trauma, anger, and survival after her people’s home was destroyed by a volcanic eruption. This information isn’t revealed in Avatar: Fire and Ash until Varang willingly brings it up when she invites Quaritch in her yurt (tent) during their second interaction together. While recounting her traumatic past, Varang tells Quaritch the following:

“The fire came from the mountain when I was little; burnt our forest. It took everything. My people were starving. They cried for help, but Eywa did not come. So I went to the fire, and I learned its way”.

She also shares with Quaritch how she, along with the rest of the Mangkwan clan, responded to Eywa’s abandonment of them, saying:

“I am the fire! By my hand, my people grow strong! We do not lie down and die just because Eywa turns her back on us! We turn our back on Eywa! A weak mother for weak children. We do not suck on the breast of weakness”.

The fact all this information isn’t brought up in the movie until Varang herself shares it implies she doesn’t freely offer this information, especially to those outside of the Mangkwan clan. During this same interaction, Varang chose to tell him, “I see you” (which has been established in the Avatar franchise as the equivalent of saying “I love you”) and “You have a strong heart. No fear” (which seems to be a term of endearment). For Varang to openly share all this information with Quaritch on her own terms (and within her personal space) shows that she has developed full trust in him. Another example of Varang’s trust in Quaritch takes place in Bridgehead City. When Quaritch arrests Jake and takes him to Bridgehead City, Varang travels there with them. She immediately recognizes how being in an unfamiliar environment and surrounded by more humans than she’s ever interacted with before can be overwhelming. She even tells one of the attending Mangkwan warriors, “Do not show fear”. Yet, while in Bridgehead City, Varang is shown peacefully sleeping in her tent within the Mangkwan camp. Meanwhile, Quaritch is right outside the tent the whole time. People are likely to sleep more soundly if they feel safe. Varang sleeping peacefully inside her tent shows how she trusts Quaritch to keep her safe.

The two photos on the left show Varang’s awareness of how overwhelming coming to Bridgehead City can be. The photo on the right shows Varang telling one of the Mangkwan warriors, “Do not show fear”. Her quote is circled for emphasis. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Varang sleeping peacefully shows the trust she’s placed in Quaritch to keep her safe in an unfamiliar place. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Quaritch and the group of Mangkwan Na’vi are circled in this picture to emphasize how close Quaritch was to Varang. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Throughout Avatar: Fire and Ash, Quaritch is shown trying to understand Varang and the world around her. He teaches her how to use a gun and a flamethrower, providing resources and skills the Mangkwan clan are interested in receiving. While in Bridgehead City, Quaritch speaks with Varang in the Na’vi language. He interacts with other members of the Mangkwan clan besides Varang during his time in Bridgehead City. Quaritch adopts the appearance of a Mangkwan Na’vi, even sporting the clan’s war paint toward the end of the film. Unlike Jack’s confrontation with Achara’s brother and his friends in ‘Stranger in a Strange Land’, Quaritch never faces animosity from the Mangkwan clan whenever he attempts to learn more about Varang and her world. It should be noted that some of Quaritch’s war paint appears to mirror Varang’s, implying her direct influence over their design. With all that said, Quaritch is not disrespecting the cultural boundaries of the Mangkwan clan, a mistake Jack made in the aforementioned Lost episode. Even when Quaritch introduces Varang to a human named General Ardmore in Bridgehead City, he refers to Varang as “Tsahìk of the Mangkwan”. This simple decision highlights three things:

  1. Quaritch is honoring and respecting Varang’s culture, as well as her role within it
  2. He refuses to define Varang by his perception of her (such as referring to her as “my girlfriend” or “my soulmate”), especially after General Ardmore calls Varang Quaritch’s “little missy”
  3. Quaritch believes he doesn’t have to prove his and Varang’s relationship to anyone, as his actions and choices should speak for themselves
The arrows in these photos are pointing out the similarities in Varang’s and Quaritch’s Mangkwan war paint designs. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
These pictures show Quaritch interacting with some of the Mangkwan Na’vis in Bridgehead City. The Mangkwan Na’vi shown in these pictures, including the one with their face circled, do not present animosity. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Quaritch and Varang vs. Top Dollar and Myca

In 2021, I wrote an editorial analyzing the toxic relationship of Top Dollar and Myca from The Crow. One of the takeaways from that editorial was that Myca and Top Dollar’s incestuous relationship is likely the result of an absent/dysfunctional family unit, as well as likely being exposed to dark and harmful things from a young age by their father. Another major takeaway was how Top Dollar and Myca’s enablement of each other was contributed by their likely long-term exposure to dark and harmful things being their “normal”. But when I wrote and published that editorial five years ago, I didn’t realize how Myca and Top Dollar lacked awareness for who they are and what they do, which kept them in a constant cycle of toxicity. When Varang shares her traumatic past with Quaritch in Avatar: Fire and Ash, she recollects what caused her to become the leader she is and how the Mangkwan clan responded to the tragedy. Varang expressing self-awareness doesn’t excuse or condone her aggressive and violent behavior toward others. However, it shows that change, as well as healing, seems realistically possible for her. Varang’s steps toward healing consist of a) she willingly opened up to Quaritch about her traumatic past and b) she willingly opened up her heart to Quaritch after closing her heart off for so long, to the point where it dictated how she walked. Oona even commented on how Varang’s walk was developed, saying, “Varang’s trust is broken and so what happens when you close the heart”. Only time will tell if Varang wants to heal from her trauma, let alone change her villainous ways.

This awareness of Varang’s trauma is also acknowledged by the creative team behind Avatar: Fire and Ash. During an interview with Youtuber Bryce Edward Brown, James Cameron (the director of all three Avatar films) said, “I think that as a little girl the powerlessness and the loss and that she felt and and is playing out through PTSD and trying to recapture power and control the things that that she couldn’t control as a child”. When Oona was interviewed by Bryce Edward Brown, she explained, “The reason that she [Varang] is the way that she is is because she has been hurt in a really really deep place. And it’s, like, the classic, you know, architype of ‘hurt people hurt people’”. In an interview with ABC News, Oona addressed how “She’s [Varang’s] gone through a lot of trauma”, elaborating on that statement by saying, “But she’s gone though a lot of grief, you know, she lost her land, her whole way of life, her family, and, and, her great mother, the, the source of all of her faith, so she has suffered a lot of loss”.

The picture on the left shows how Varang walks, influenced by her broken trust. The picture on the right shows Varang demonstrating to Quaritch how she is “the fire”. During this demonstration, anger toward Eywa can be heard in Varang’s voice. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

One of the reasons why Varang is considered a villain in Avatar: Fire and Ash is because she uses her kuru (neural queue/braid) to forcefully connect to other Na’vis’ kurus, using that connection to mentally manipulate her victims. Based on the context within the film, she does this as a form of interrogation as well as to gain an upper hand. After Varang and Quaritch become a couple, however, Quaritch has stood back and watched Varang continue to mentally manipulate others with her kuru. Initially, I was confused why Quaritch would do this, especially considering a) Varang mentally manipulated him when they first met and b) Varang willingly opened up to him about her traumatic past, as well as expressing self-awareness for why she is the way that she is. I wondered, “shouldn’t Quaritch be trying to help Varang heal from her trauma”? This confusion led me, at first, to speculate if Quaritch had adopted Top Dollar and Myca’s “I don’t care because it’s none of my business” attitude/mindset, the same attitude/mindset they used to enable each other to hurt themselves or other people. But Quaritch is the same man who has gone out of his way to try to understand Varang and the world around her. In Bridgehead City, when General Ardmore called the Mangkwan clan “savages” and Varang Quaritch’s “little missy”, Quaritch (and Varang) appeared uncomfortable by what General Ardmore said. Quaritch even tells General Ardmore, “Don’t be a jackass, General”. What I said shows how Quaritch does care about Varang and her world because he’s made that his business. Though there are better ways Quaritch could have shown he cares about Varang, like preventing her from using her kuru for harmful purposes.

These collection of pictures show Quaritch and Varang’s reaction to what General Ardmore said about Varang and the Mangkwan clan. It’s obvious how they do not look pleased. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

In an interview from the Youtube channel, Film Stories, Stephen responds to a question about where Quaritch fits in within the conflict of humanity versus Na’vi. He says, “What he [Quaritch] recognizes is that he can no longer, the idea of making the planet come to him, the moon come to him doesn’t work. He’s got to go to it. He’s got to adapt to it”. Stephen’s quote can be applied to Quaritch’s relationship with Varang. Varang willingly opened up to Quaritch about her traumatic past, as well as willingly opened up her heart to him. During his interaction with Varang in her yurt, Quaritch reminds her how she wants an “equal” (something she’s never had). With that said, he recognizes how Varang has not only carried her unresolved trauma for a long time, but has also lived her life a certain way for a long time. Quaritch recognizes as well how Varang’s new chapter in her life (developing a relationship with her “equal”) will take some adjusting to. So, as Varang’s “equal”, Quaritch’s decision to stand by and watch her continue to mentally manipulate others with her kuru is not about intentional enablement like Myca and Top Dollar not caring about what the other does. Quaritch acknowledges and respects where Varang is in her life, as well as her healing journey, and meeting her there instead of forcing her to do something she either doesn’t want to do or isn’t ready to do. However, I do wish Quaritch had intervened and encouraged Varang to make better choices that don’t involve hurting other Na’vis.

In these two photos, Varang continues to mentally manipulate Na’vis with her kuru. Meanwhile, Quaritch just stands by and watches the events unfold instead of intervening. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

When I wrote and published my editorial about Top Dollar and Myca’s relationship, I discussed how both their conversations in The Crow were not meaningful. As I explained in that editorial, words aren’t utilized to address emotions, leaving feelings and personal turmoil bottled up and unresolved. Concerns and basic needs are ignored as well. In Avatar: Fire and Ash, Varang and Quaritch share only one conversation, which takes place during their interaction in Varang’s yurt. Despite this, their conversation is meaningful because of how much it accomplishes. Like I’ve already said, Varang willingly opened up to Quaritch about her traumatic past, showing how she not only trusts Quaritch, but also how change and healing seem realistically possible for her. Varang sharing her backstory allows Quaritch (and the audience) to learn more about her as well. Meanwhile, Varang learns more about Quaritch by asking him questions, such as why he came to see her in the first place. Even when Quaritch tells Varang, “You want to take on Eywa? You need me”, he confirms how he’s actively paying attention/listening to what Varang is saying. Though he was under the influence of a hallucinogenic powder she gave him earlier in their interaction, potentially affecting his judgement. The most important thing Quaritch and Varang’s conversation accomplishes is establishing their relationship. They no longer see each other as a threat like they did when they first met. As their conversation goes on, their tone of voice becomes friendlier. Varang even gently strokes Quaritch’s chin and kuru, though she did cut his chest prior to that, which could have given Quaritch mixed messages on her feelings for him. But when Varang tells Quaritch, “I see you”, he responds by telling her, “Damn right you do”, while appearing relaxed and speaking with a confident and matter-of-fact tone of voice. This response, and the fact Quaritch doesn’t appear surprised or caught off guard by what Varang told him, emphasizes his acceptance of her love, as well as doubling and tripling down on that idea.

The top two pictures show Varang gently stroking Quaritch’s chin and kuru. Though she did cut his chest before that, which could have given Quaritch mixed messages. The bottom left picture shows Varang right after she told Quaritch, “I see you”. Meanwhile, the bottom right picture shows Quaritch right after he tells Varang, “Damn right you do”. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Varang and Quaritch vs. Akasha and Lestat

I wrote an editorial in 2019 about Lestat and Akasha’s relationship (from Queen of the Damned), discussing why it was problematic for Akasha to possess more control in the relationship. One of her missteps was not making an effort to get to know Lestat. Akasha assumes she knows Lestat based on his image as a musical performer, even though being a musical performer only plays a small role in his life. This assumption leads her to give him a royal title he did not desire. Had Akasha taken the time to ask Lestat what he wanted, she would have known all he wanted was to walk in the light and not hide in the shadows. In Avatar: Fire and Ash, Varang doesn’t make Akasha’s mistakes. I brought up earlier how she learns more about Quaritch by asking him questions, such as why he came to see her in the first place. Varang even asks him, “What do I want”, when Quaritch claims she doesn’t want to keep him as a slave. Her asking this question shows how she’s interested in hearing his answer instead of assuming what he’ll say is incorrect. It also shows how she’s willing to change her mind about how she sees Quaritch, though her entertaining the idea of keeping him as a slave is concerning. Before giving Quaritch the hallucinogenic powder I referenced earlier in this editorial, Varang tells him, “First, I must see your soul”. Then, before telling Quaritch, “You have a strong heart. No fear”, Varang says, “Only true words will come from your tongue”. These examples illustrate Varang making a strong effort in getting to know Quaritch instead of falling for a fabricated image of him. Sadly, this is the only time Varang is shown learning more about Quaritch, which could give the impression her efforts aren’t strong.

The left picture shows Varang as she’s asking Quaritch, “What do I want”. The picture on the right shows Varang asking Quaritch questions. That picture is from Quaritch’s perspective while under the influence of the hallucinogenic powder she gave him. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Akasha doesn’t seem to see Lestat as an equal, but instead as something she can control. Akasha refers to Lestat by his name on less than three occasions. She also talks at him, not to him, as well as purposefully leaving Lestat out of the process of building their “kingdom”. Because Akasha forced Lestat into their relationship and possesses more control within it, he doesn’t feel their relationship is worth investing in. Once again, Varang refuses to repeat Akasha’s mistakes. In Avatar: Fire and Ash, when Quaritch brought up how she wanted an “equal”, Varang never objects or claims Quaritch is wrong. In fact, she tells him “I see you” after he reveals how an “equal” is what she really wanted. Any time she communicates with Quaritch (talking to him, not at him), Varang refers to him by his name. The only times she didn’t do that is when she didn’t know his name, hence the reason why she called Quaritch “Sky Man”. Since forming their relationship, Varang and Quaritch are rarely seen apart, as they recognize how valuable their time and company is. This is just one example of how their relationship contains equal investment. Meanwhile, Quaritch shows how he is an active participant in his relationship with Varang. In Avatar: Fire and Ash, during his interaction with Varang in her yurt, Quaritch explains what he can give her, such as “guns”, “comms”, and “RPGs”. But Varang recognizes the nontangible things he can give her as well, like security and peace of mind. This portion of their conversation highlights how Quaritch is willing to share and be a provider in his and Varang’s relationship. As I’ve said, Quaritch tries to learn more about Varang and her world. Because Varang has willingly provided these learning opportunities to Quaritch, he has received chances to grow closer to her.

Varang’s response to Quartich’s reminder of how she wants an “equal” doesn’t show her disagreeing with him. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

While reflecting on Lestat and Akasha’s relationship, as well as the other relationships discussed in this editorial, I noticed how their displays of affection are not consistent, whether these displays have been publicly or privately. It seems like those couples’ problematic behavior was the primary focus. Though Quaritch and Varang display villianous behavior in Avatar: Fire and Ash, their displays of affection are shown consistently throughout the film as well. Varang and Quaritch hold hands on two separate occasions; in Bridgehead City (after Quaritch introduces Varang to General Ardmore) and after Quaritch teaches Varang how to use a flamethrower. Quaritch has referred to Varang by endearing names like “baby”, “sugar”, and “darling”. Any time he touches her, Quaritch has continually been gentle with Varang. Meanwhile, Varang gently touched Quaritch’s arm in Bridgehead City. As I mentioned in this editorial already, Varang gently strokes Quaritch’s chin and kuru, which she does before Quaritch brought up how Varang wants an “equal”. But what I’ve noticed is how Varang only blinks whenever Quaritch is around or when something connected to Quaritch is around. Because this behavior is so patterned around Quaritch, I believe blinking is Varang’s way of showing affection for him. These times are the following:

  • While examining the deceased body of one of the Mangkwan Na’vi, Varang becomes interested in a bullet lodged within it. After digging out the bullet, Varang blinks as she bites into the bullet. Bullets typically come from the RDA, which Quaritch is associated with.
  • After Quaritch teaches Varang how to use a gun, she blinks as she tells him, “I do not need you now, Sky Man”.
  • Varang blinks as she notices the guns Quaritch brought to her Mangkwan village
  • Varang blinks immediately after Quaritch reminds her how she wants an “equal”
  • When Jake surrenders to Quaritch, Varang blinks three times during that situation: when Quaritch suggests Neytiri be arrested too, right before Jake refers to Varang as Quaritch’s “new girlfriend” and as Varang is looking up at Quaritch
  • Varang blinks twice when Quaritch introduces her to General Ardmore: when General Ardmore refers to Varang as Quaritch’s “little missy” and as Quaritch is introducing Varang as “Tsahìk of the Mangkwan”
  • When Neytiri infiltrates Varang’s tent in the Mangkwan clan’s camp in Bridgehead City, Varang blinks when Neytiri threatens to cut off Varang’s kuru. This incident takes place after Varang and Quaritch formed a tsaheylu (an intimate bond that lasts for life formed by mates connecting kurus). When Quaritch and Varang first met, she forcefully connected his kuru with hers in order to mentally manipulate him. However, an argument can be made that, in this particular situation, Varang did this in self-defense, as Quaritch had a gun pointed at her head when he was helping Jake rescue his children from the Mangkwan clan.
In these photos, Quaritch teaches Varang how to use a flamethrower. Quaritch’s hand is circled to emphasize how gently he touches Varang. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
In this picture, Varang’s hand is circled to emphasize how gently she’s touching Quaritch’s arm. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Varang and Quartich’s hands are circled to highlight that Quaritch and Varang are holding hands. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Quaritch and Varang vs. Oscar and Lily

One of the worst movies I ever reviewed on 18 Cinema Lane is Twentieth Century. A reason why I don’t like this movie is how abusive Oscar and Lily’s relationship is. Oscar grows jealous and obsessive of Lily over the course of the film. The worst thing he does is use his mortality as a manipulation tactic. Not only does Oscar threaten suicide if Lily doesn’t stay with him, he also fakes his death to trick Lily into signing his contract. Quaritch and Varang, on the other hand, never do that in Avatar: Fire and Ash. The only time Quaritch uses language to manipulate a situation is when he tells Varang, “You touch me with that thing again, I’ll kill you”. Before he said that, Varang was attempting to mentally manipulate Quaritch with her kuru for a second time, even though he came to her village delivering guns for her people. Therefore, Quaritch’s threat was a self-defense tactic, as he still saw Varang as a threat. It should be noted how Varang also still saw Quaritch as a threat during this interaction, as Varang continues to hold her kuru. This is a response to Quaritch holding a gun to her head when they first met, as he was trying to help Jake rescue his children from the Mangkwan clan. Meanwhile, during Quaritch and Varang’s interaction in her yurt, Varang’s mortality is never a topic of discussion. Even though she could have used her mortality to manipulate Quaritch, she instead chooses to share her traumatic past with him, as well as asking him why he came to see her in the first place.

In this picture, Varang’s kuru in her hand is circled to emphasize how, in this moment, she still sees Quaritch as a threat after their first meeting. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Despite being treated horribly by Oscar, Oscar’s friends try to help him fix his relationship with Lily. They even go as far as blaming Lily for Oscar’s failures. Varang and Quaritch never do that either in Avatar: Fire and Ash. When Neytiri infiltrated the Mangkwan clan’s camp in Bridgehead City, Varang is more preoccupied with obtaining Neytiri’s heart than blaming Quaritch for the camp’s breach in security. Later in the movie, when General Ardmore permanently grounds Quaritch after Jake and another character named Spider escape Bridgehead City, Quaritch doesn’t blame Varang. Instead, he stays focused on recapturing Spider and Jake. Quaritch is even pleased he can utilize Varang mentally manipulating Neytiri to lure Jake and Spider, with Quaritch telling Varang, “Thanks, baby”. These examples I brought up show how Varang and Quaritch don’t take their frustrations out on each other because they possess the maturity and emotional understanding to recognize which battles are worth choosing, as well as what is within that other person’s control. At the same time, however, Quaritch and Varang don’t hold each other accountable if they do something wrong.

Even when Quaritch shows up to help Varang capture Neytiri, Varang remains focused on obtaining Neytiri’s heart. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
After Quaritch uses Varang’s mental manipulation toward Neytiri to lure Jake and Spider, he tells Varang, “Thanks, baby”. But he doesn’t hold her accountable for her treatment toward Neytiri. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Varang and Quaritch vs. Nancy and Bill Sikes

Though I have reviewed 1968’s Oliver!, I never talked about how awful Nancy and Bill Sikes’ relationship is. Similar to Lestat and Akasha’s relationship, Nancy is more invested in her relationship with Bill. But, unlike Akasha and Lestat’s relationship, Bill is someone Nancy actually cares about. Unfortunately for her, Bill sees Nancy more as a nuisance than a girlfriend. When she asks Bill if he loves her, he angrily tells Nancy, “Course I do. I live with you, don’t I”? Bill also takes Nancy for granted, never showing gratitude whenever Nancy does something nice for him, like serving him food. He even becomes violent toward Nancy. Bill tries to physically intimidate Nancy by threatening to choke her when she refuses to bring Oliver back into a life of thieving. Bill also slaps Nancy so hard, she falls to the floor. After Nancy is beaten to death by Bill, Bill blames her for the predicament he put himself in. He expresses more concern for being caught by the police than remorse for the way he treated Nancy.

As he makes his way back to his and Varang’s tent, Quaritch says, “Hey sugar, join the party”. This highlights how he wants to spend more time with Varang. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Quaritch is never shown becoming angry at Varang. Even when Varang mentally manipulated him with her kuru or cut his chest, Quaritch doesn’t express anger or resentment toward her. However, Quaritch ignoring Varang’s aggression toward him could give her a mixed message on how to treat him. Quaritch has continually been gentle with Varang any time he touches her. In fact, the closest to aggressive Quaritch has ever been toward Varang is when he pointed a gun at her head. In that moment, however, Quaritch saw her as a threat, as Quaritch was trying to help Jake rescue his children from the Mangkwan clan. Throughout his relationship with Varang, Quaritch never takes her for granted, proving this by taking the time to learn more about Varang and her world. Out of all the ways he could have chosen to spend his time in Bridgehead City, Quaritch chose to spend it with Varang and the Mangkwan clan. What I said about Quaritch can also be applied to Varang. She stops being aggressive toward Quaritch when their relationship is established, as Varang saw Quaritch as a threat before that. Varang doesn’t take Quaritch for granted either, with her proof being how interested she appears in learning how to use a gun and flamethrower. Quaritch and Varang are rarely seen apart when their relationship is formed. They recognize how valuable their time and company is.

These two pictures show Quaritch’s response to Varang’s aggression toward him. Though he holds no anger or resentment towards Varang, Quartich choosing to ignore her aggression could give Varang mixed messages. Images created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
These two photos show how interested and eager Varang is to learn from Quaritch. Image created by 20th Century Studios, Lightstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Conclusion

What led to the creation of this editorial was trying to figure out why Quaritch and Varang were so popular. Through my research, I think I found an answer. In the Avatar franchise, Varang and Quaritch seem to be the only two characters who subvert expectations. In entertainment media, when expectations are subverted, that can spark curiosity and intrigue from the audience. If you had told me back in 2009 that Colonel Miles Quaritch would eventually adopt the appearance of a Na’vi and fall in love with a Na’vi woman, I definitely would not have believed you. Then, in 2025, if you had told me the first Na’vi villain in the Avatar franchise would fall in love at all, let alone fall in love with Quaritch, I also would not have believed you. But, before publishing this editorial, if you had told me Quaritch and Varang’s relationship was healthier than some of the problematic relationships from movies and tv I’m familiar with (like Lestat and Akasha and Top Dollar and Myca), I certainly would have thought you were joking.

My editorial outro image created by me, Sally Silverscreen. Original image created by 20th Century Studios, Lighstorm Entertainment, TSG Entertainment, Canadian Film or Video Production Tax Credit (CPTC), and Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Though this editorial highlights how Quaritch and Varang’s relationship is healthier than some problematic relationships from entertainment media, their relationship isn’t truly healthy. Because they are the villains in Avatar: Fire and Ash, their villainous behavior is on full display. They treat other people terribly, from Quaritch destroying Na’vis’ homes in his search for Jake Sully to Varang and the Mangkwan clan sparking unprovoked violence toward other Na’vis. There are also a lot of aspects of their relationship that are up for interpretation. I mentioned earlier how Varang and Quaritch formed a life-long bond called tsaheylu. Even though Varang is more educated about Na’vi culture than Quaritch, it’s unknown if she explained the significance of tsaheylu before they formed this bond, which would have allowed Quaritch to make an informed decision about whether he wants to spend the rest of his life with her. Despite the flaws in their relationship, however, Quaritch and Varang treat each other better than I expected. As of the publication of my editorial, the fourth film in the Avatar franchise has not officially been greenlit, though the release date has already been chosen. If that film does come to fruition, I hope Varang and Quaritch acknowledge how good they have it when it comes to their relationship. Because if my editorial stresses anything, it’s how some people aren’t so lucky.

References:

From 18 Cinema Lane –

Travel Lessons I Learned from Movies and TV

Toxic Valentine: Why Lestat and Akasha’s relationship is very problematic in Queen of the Damned (2002)

We Need to Talk About the Toxic Relationship of Top Dollar and Myca from ‘The Crow’

Take 3: Twentieth Century Review

Youtube Videos and Shorts –

‘Why Varang Is Working With Quaritch and the Humans of the RDA in James Cameron’s Avatar’ (short from Youtube channel, Bryce Edward Brown)

‘I Interviewed Stephen Lang and Oona Chaplin About Quaritch and Varang’s Future in Avatar’ (video from Youtube channel, Bryce Edward Brown)

‘Candid interview with James Cameron and cast of ‘Avatar: Fire and Ash’’ (video from Youtube channel, ABC News)

‘Stephen Lang on AVATAR: FIRE AND ASH!’ (video from Youtube channel, Film Stories)

‘Avatar Fire and Ash Cast Talk About Their Band & Na’avi Phrases & Fan Edits’ (video from the Youtube channel, Hits Radio)

‘The Cast of ‘Avatar: The Way of Water’ on Reuniting, Diving Underwater, and Date Nights’ (video from the Youtube channel, Fandango)

‘Avatar: Fire and Ash’s Oona Chaplin on Crafting Her MENACING Strut (Exclusive)’ (video from the Youtube channel, Entertainment Tonight)

Articles –

https://screenrant.com/how-quaritch-returns-in-avatar-way-of-water-explained/

https://james-camerons-avatar.fandom.com/wiki/Varang

https://james-camerons-avatar.fandom.com/wiki/Miles_Quaritch_(Recombinant)

https://james-camerons-avatar.fandom.com/wiki/Miles_Quaritch

Films and Television –

Avatar franchise (Avatar, Avatar: The Way of Water, Avatar: Fire and Ash)

Oliver!

Lost: Season 3, Episode 9 — ‘Stranger in a Strange Land’

Comparing with the Critics – Best of 1978 – Autumn Sonata

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

This review is from my series, Comparing with the Critics. If you’d like to learn more about the series, click on the link below.

Introducing my new series, Comparing with the Critics!

March’s theme for Genre Grandeur is “Oscar Losing Movies (Oscar nominees that failed to garner even one win)”. Upon learning this theme, I was going to select a movie nominated for the 76th Academy Awards, when The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King won a history-making eleven awards. But after researching which films were nominated the evening of February 29th, 2004, I discovered other pictures besides The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King walked away with a trophy. This discovery meant there weren’t as many Oscar “losers” as I initially believed. So, as I continued my research for March’s Genre Grandeur, I learned Autumn Sonata was nominated for two awards at the 51st Academy Awards. These categories were Best Writing and Best Leading Actress. Sadly, Autumn Sonata lost both categories to a movie titled Coming Home. I have heard of Autumn Sonata prior to choosing it for this particular review. Not only was the film recommended to me by Virginie (from The Wonderful World of Cinema), it was also featured in ‘The Best Films of 1978’ episode of Gene Siskel’s and Roger Ebert’s show, Sneak Previews. In that episode, both Roger and Gene admitted to placing Autumn Sonata on their lists of the ten best films of 1978. Now that I’ve seen the movie for myself, I can understand why it would find a place on their lists. I can also understand why Autumn Sonata was nominated for its respective categories at the 51st Academy Awards in 1979.

Autumn Sonata poster created by Persona Film, Suede Film, Incorporated Television Company (ITC), Svensk Filmindustri, Constantin Film, ITC Film Distributors, and New World Pictures

As I just mentioned in this review’s introduction, Autumn Sonata was nominated for two awards at the 51st Academy Awards. One of these categories was Best Leading Actress, with Ingrid Bergman as one of five actresses to receive a nomination. While discussing Autumn Sonata in Sneak Previews’ ‘The Best Films of 1978’ episode, Gene called Ingrid’s portrayal of Charlotte Andergast “riveting”. Even after a scene featuring Ingrid and Liv Ullmann (who portrayed Charlotte’s daughter, Eva) is presented in the episode, Gene says “Again, some real pain there”, referring to the emotions on display through Liv’s and Ingrid’s performance. Though I agree with Gene’s assessment of Ingrid’s portrayal of Charlotte, the word I’d use to describe it (as well as Liv’s portrayal of Eva) is captivating. In one of the best scenes from Autumn Sonata, Charlotte shares with Eva how her close friend, Leonardo, passed away. Throughout her recount of Leonardo’s last days in the hospital, Charlotte has a pained, disgusted look on her face. With a glossy, teary-eyed stare and a drawn-out frown, Charlotte is heartbroken over the loss of her friend. When I saw that scene, I wasn’t watching an actress portraying a character. I was witnessing a woman experiencing grief, with Ingrid’s performance possessing a strong sense of realism.

String of musical notes image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/pentagram-vector_710290.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com. 

Like I also said in my review, Liv Ullmann’s portrayal of Charlotte’s daughter, Eva, was captivating. This is because Liv was able to go toe-to-toe with Ingrid, acting-wise, understanding how to utilize emotion to her character’s advantage, as well as when to increase or decrease the intensity of those emotions. As I previously mentioned, there was a scene from Autumn Sonata featuring Ingrid and Liv in Sneak Previews’ ‘The Best Films of 1978’ episode. In that scene, Charlotte and Eva share an emotionally explosive conversation over the reasons why their relationship is strained. Eva states how she didn’t like Charlotte’s desire to turn her daughter into someone she wasn’t. During her reflections of her past, Eva is visibly distraught. With gritted teeth and eyes overflowing with tears, even shaking at one point, Eva confesses how Charlotte’s decisions have deeply impacted her and her life choices. Because of her performance in Autumn Sonata, I wish Liv Ullmann had been nominated for an Oscar as well.

Image by macrovector on Freepik

During their discussion of Autumn Sonata in ‘The Best Films of 1978’ episode of Sneak Previews, neither Roger nor Gene brought up the film’s screenwriting. This is a shame, as the screenwriting was one of the movie’s strengths. Autumn Sonata is a character-driven, “slice of life” story. However, the quality of the dialogue made conversations between characters sound emotionally deep and thought provoking. In one scene, Eva asks her husband, Viktor, if he thinks she’s an adult. Viktor responds by telling her, “I guess being an adult is being able to handle your dreams and hopes, not longing for things”. He could have simply given his wife a “yes” or “no” answer. But Viktor’s response gives Eva, as well as the audience, meaningful insight about growing up, managing expectations, and even gratitude. Later in Autumn Sonata, Charlotte confesses one of her realizations to Eva. She says, “I have never grown up. My face and my body have aged. I acquire memories and experiences but inside all that I haven’t even been born.” Similar to Viktor’s aforementioned quote, Charlotte’s quote addresses growing up. In Charlotte’s case, however, her reflections sound more regretful. Disappointment can even be heard in her voice, with those pent-up feelings finally being addressed through words. As I stated in this review’s introduction, Autumn Sonata was nominated for the Best Writing category. Through a thoughtfully crafted script, that nomination was, in my opinion, earned.

Envelope with hearts image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/hearts-and-pink-envelope-for-mothers-day_1950691.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/love”>Love image created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

While continuing their discussion of Autumn Sonata, Roger tells Gene about a call he received from a reader who was interested in seeing Autumn Sonata. Roger then says the reader told him, “I couldn’t make head or tail of it. What is it about?” Meanwhile, Gene claims “the conflict is how do you reconcile your public career with your personal responsibilities to your family”. Based on my experience watching Autumn Sonata, I think it’s not just about balancing a public and personal life. I think it’s also about the brutal honesty of strained familial relationships. When Eva and Charlotte talk about the past, no figurative punches are held back. They tell each other exactly what’s on their minds and hearts, no matter who’s feelings get hurt. It would have been easy for Autumn Sonata’s creative team to paint either Charlotte or Eva as the “villain” of the story. Instead, both women are not only flawed, they have valid points to their sides of the narrative. How the story plays out kind of reminds me of The Royal Tenenbaums, where the strained relationship between Eva and Charlotte is the result of little things culminating over time. The acting performances and the screenwriting successfully bring a sense of realism to Autumn Sonata.

Norway’s past and present image created by Macrovector at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/poster”>Poster vector created by macrovector – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

According to IMDB, Autumn Sonata was filmed in Norway. Based on the scene where Charlotte drives to Eva and Viktor’s house, the Norwegian scenery looked like a beautiful painting. But the majestic hills, mountains, and large body of water from Norway wasn’t incorporated into Autumn Sonata beyond that one scene. I wish the “autumn” in Autumn Sonata played a larger role in the story, perhaps visually representing some of the movie’s themes. Another aspect of the story I wish had been utilized more was Eva’s sister, Helena. When Charlotte first arrives at Eva and Viktor’s house, Eva reveals how Helena is now living at their house instead of at a hospital. Throughout Autumn Sonata, Helena deals with an illness that greatly affects her mobility. I thought she was intended to be a bridge between Eva and Charlotte, helping them find a more peaceful middle ground. One reason for this belief came from Helena falling out of her bed during an emotionally explosive conversation between Charlotte and Eva. Sadly, it seems like Helena was in Autumn Sonata just for the sake of it.

Comparing with the Critics banner created by me, Sally Silverscreen. TV show title cards created by WTTW National Productions, WTTW, Public Broadcasting Service (PBS), Lifetime Television, Tribune Entertainment, Buena Vista Television, and Disney-ABC Domestic Television

Prior to reviewing Autumn Sonata, the only movie I agreed with Gene and Roger on was 1984’s Amadeus. I could also see why the film was, at least, nominated for an Oscar. Now I can confidently say that Autumn Sonata is the second film I agree with Roger and Gene on! While I typically don’t gravitate toward “slice of life” stories, the 1978 movie works because of the strength of the screenwriting and acting performances. Similar to The Royal Tenenbaums, the brutal honesty woven into the script brought a sense of realism when to came to addressing strained familial relationships. The story itself was emotionally deep and thought provoking because of the effort put into it by Autumn Sonata’s creative team. I understand why the movie is titled Autumn Sonata, as music plays an integral role in Charlotte’s life. However, I wish the “autumn” in Autumn Sonata was utilized more in the story, especially considering how beautiful the Norwegian landscape was in the film. The movie also doesn’t have a high rewatchability rate due the some of the heavier subject matter incorporated into the story. But I can honestly say that Autumn Sonata is one of the best films I’ve seen in 2026, so far!

This review was brought to you by

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: The Ring Makes It Real

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Nathan plans on proposing to Elizabeth. In this episode of When Calls the Heart, he tries to figure out Elizabeth’s ring size so he can purchase an engagement ring. As Ned shows Nathan and Allie the engagement rings available to purchase, Ned tells them, “the ring makes it real”. When Ned said this, it made me think about how rings are more than just a statement piece or an item from a jewelry collection. It can be an extension of a person’s life story. Class rings or engagement rings symbolize the achievement of a major milestone. Mood rings make a wearer’s mood more visual. Even decorative rings or costume jewelry can hold a personal meaning to the person who owns that ring. It fascinates me how such a small piece of jewelry can represent so much. Now, when I see a character wearing a ring, I will wonder what the story behind it is.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season thirteen poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 13

Episode: 10

Name: Blessings

Major stories:

Nathan shares with Ned how he’s planning on proposing to Elizabeth. But in order to propose to Elizabeth, Nathan needs to get an engagement ring that fits her. For most of the episode, Nathan, as well as Allie, try to find a way to measure Elizabeth’s ring. When Allie and Oliver visit the pharmacy/ice cream parlor and walk in on Mei and Mike making clay bowls together, Allie develops an idea. She invites Elizabeth to a pottery class Mei is hosting at the ice cream parlor/pharmacy. During the pottery class, Allie suggests everyone close their eyes as they knead the clay. While Elizabeth has her eyes closed, Allie uses a small piece of clay to create an impression of Elizabeth’s ring (which she removed at the beginning of the pottery class). Allie and Nathan are able to use the clay to choose the perfect engagement ring. Later in the episode, Nathan asks for Charlotte’s blessing, as Charlotte has extended her stay in Hope Valley. He also asks Jack Thornton for his blessing, even taking Charlotte to the graveyard with him to visit Jack.

While figuring out where to take the fire investigation next, Nathan comes up with an idea to prove the alliance between Pioneer Electric and National Insurance. He believes if one company receives information about the fire, that information will be passed to the other company. For this idea to work, someone needs to give the information to one of these companies. Nathan, Georgie, and Bill select Rosemary to go undercover for them. They create a script for Rosemary about how she’s trying to obtain an insurance claim for her playhouse. Using her script during her meeting with Mr. Throckmorton, from National Insurance, Rosemary tells him how she heard a local farm called LeVeaux Farms was conducting a controlled burn around the time the forest fire at Goldie National Park started. Later in the episode, Mr. Whitaker, from Pioneer Electric, comes to Nathan with the information Rosemary gave to Mr. Throckmorton. This proves Nathan’s plan worked, giving him, Bill, and Georgie evidence of National Trust’s and Pioneer Electric’s alliance.

Fancy jewelry image created by Freepic.diller at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/wedding”>Wedding photo created by freepic.diller – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

The minor stories in this episode of When Calls the Heart are focused on relationships. First, Mike becomes interested in pottery after Mei shows him a bowl she and her grandmother made. This interest not only leads to Mei and Mike making clay bowls together, it also leads to Mei hosting a pottery class. Later in the episode, Mei expresses her gratitude to Mike for caring about her past. Meanwhile, at the Queen of Hearts, Lucas has a heart-to-heart conversation with Lee about his feelings for Edie. Lee tells Lucas how he shouldn’t let his past experiences get in the way of what makes him happy now. He even shares with Lucas how he didn’t let his past mistakes prevent him from falling in love with Rosemary. Toward the end of the episode, Bill expresses his interest in pursuing a romantic relationship with Georgie. At first, Georgie is hesitant because she thinks the relationship won’t work out. But she becomes more open-minded to the idea of being in a romantic relationship with Bill when they agree to be honest with each other.

Heart image created by Dashu83 at freepik.com <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Dashu83 – Freepik.com</a> <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/happy-valentines-day-and-heart-card-with-happy-valentines-day-and-heart_1747001.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> Image found at freepik.com

Some thoughts to consider:

  • As I said in this re-cap of When Calls the Heart, Charlotte has extended her stay in Hope Valley. During this stay, Charlotte admits to Elizabeth how she hasn’t been to Jack’s gravesite, let alone gone to the funeral. This piece of dialogue was a good way to address the continuity of Brooke Shields reprising her role as Charlotte for the first time since season three.
  • If a character is getting married in a Hallmark program, their wedding dress will sometimes not be revealed until the wedding takes place. This creative decision delivers a sense of surprise for the groom as well as the audience. One of the main stories in this When Calls the Heart episode revolves around Nathan’s plan to propose to Elizabeth. When he and Allie select an engagement ring for Elizabeth, their choice isn’t shown on screen. That creative decision is similar to the aforementioned wedding dress; giving a moment of shared surprise for Elizabeth and the audience.
  • In the commercial for the next episode of When Calls the Heart, Henry, through Rosemary’s radio show, encourages Christopher to come home. Within the context of the thirteenth season, Christopher has been missing for several weeks. With that said, why didn’t anyone think of using Rosemary’s radio show to contact Christopher sooner? I hope this potential plot hole is addressed in this season’s eleventh episode.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode of When Calls the Heart? How do you think Nathan will propose to Elizabeth? Let me know in the comment section below!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Just Like in the Book, But Real

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Ava is a new character introduced in this episode of When Calls the Heart. She claims she wanted to come to Hope Valley to experience what Elizabeth wrote about in her book. In a conversation with Elizabeth, Ava says the town is “just like in the book, but real”. Though Ava’s adventure is not as simplistic as she expected. While the story of When Calls the Heart (and its respective source material) are fictional, the time period the characters exist in actually happened. Places like Hope Valley did exist; where neighbors looked out for each other, children grew up, and people fell in love. It can, sometimes, be easy to forget these facts because most of When Calls the Heart’s audience is far removed from the 1910s to 1920s and the Hearties are so caught up in what is happening on screen. What’s also easy to forget is how different life was during the early 20th century. But the timelessness of family, friendship, and community can thrive in any era! Another thing that can thrive is good-storytelling.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 12

Episode: 5

Name: Mom’s the Word

Major stories:

Nathan confirms the mysterious coin is from the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907. Jed also confesses where he received the coin; from a man named Toddy Davis in a poker card. As Rosemary and Bill brainstorm how to reach Toddy for information, Nathan volunteers to go undercover. For about half the episode, Bill and Rosemary create a new identity for Nathan. Before leaving Hope Valley for his undercover mission, Nathan adopts the backstory of an estate dealer trying to reclaim his wealth. Within the second half of the episode, Nathan loses a poker game to Toddy. But after the game, when Nathan brings up the coin, Toddy confesses how rare coins are one of his interests. He even gives Nathan one of his business cards.

Lee and Lucas are still avoiding each other. This friction between friends bothers Joseph and Mike. So, they come up with a plan to bring Lucas and Lee together. Joseph tricks Lee into going on a hike. Meanwhile, Mike lies to Lucas about taking him on a horseback riding trip. Once all four men reach a spot next to a river, Lucas and Lee quickly realize what’s going on. But before they can do anything about it, Mike and Joseph leave with all four horses, instructing Lee and Lucas to walk back to Hope Valley and work out their differences. So, Lucas and Lee do as they’re told. During this walk, Lee shares how he didn’t like it when Lucas took Edwin’s advice over his own. Lucas confesses how Lee’s sudden departure from Capitol City caught him off guard. Back in Hope Valley, Rosemary visits the Queen of Hearts saloon, looking for Lee. A few seconds later, Lucas and Lee are shaking hands, agreeing to work together again.

Horse with saddle photo created by Topntp26 at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/stallion-black-equine-race-sky_1104246.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Topntp26 – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Elizabeth introduces project-based learning to her students. Even though the primary theme is nature, the students are eager for Elizabeth’s idea. Since Allie is still interested in the Great Timber Wolves, her project is about finding a way to bring them back around Hope Valley’s surrounding areas. Oliver even volunteers to help Allie with the mapping portion of her assignment. Before introducing the concept of project-based learning, Nathan shares his concerns with Elizabeth about Allie developing a crush on Earl. Elizabeth insists she isn’t getting involved in business that is not hers. She says the exact same thing when Rosemary suggests Elizabeth become a mother figure to Allie. Nathan’s concerns are confirmed when Allie asks Earl to go on a picnic with her. This is when Earl tells Allie he doesn’t like her in a romantic sense. When Allie shows up at Elizabeth’s house, Elizabeth senses Allie is upset. Allie eventually tells Elizabeth what Earl told her. Understanding Allie’s heartbreak, Elizabeth says how “the right one” will, indeed, come along someday. She also encourages Allie to call her “Elizabeth” at home.

Fiona comes back to Hope Valley! While the town’s residents are excited about Fiona’s return, Fiona doesn’t plan to stay long. In a conversation amongst Mei and Faith, Fiona shares how she is in the process of selling the barber shop. She also says she plans on marrying a man she’s been corresponding with some quote some time. Fiona didn’t come to Hope Valley alone, providing Ava with a ride to town. Ava claims to be a debutante whose parents are on vacation. She also claims all her luggage, including her money, was stolen. So, for the time being, Ava stays at the Queen of Hearts hotel, where her bill becomes concerning. The reason for Ava’s trip to Hope Valley is to experience what Elizabeth wrote about in her book. Ava shares how she wants to become a teacher as well. Elizabeth invites Ava to join her class on a nature walk. Unfortunately for Ava, this trip turns sour because Ava walks into poison oak. Despite this mishap, Elizabeth encourages Ava to stay in Hope Valley.

Breaking heart image created by Kjpargeter at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/broken-heart-valentine-background_1041991.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Kjpargeter – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • In the commercial for the next When Calls the Heart episode, it was announced there was a scheduling change. This upcoming episode will premiere on February 8th at 10pm/9c. I first learned this information on the blog, It’s a Wonderful Movie. So, if you haven’t seen It’s a Wonderful Movie’s announcement or When Calls the Heart’s commercial, I wanted to inform other Hearties so they didn’t miss the episode.
  • When I re-capped last week’s episode, I wondered if When Calls the Heart’s creative team wanted to create another love triangle featuring Allie, Earl, and Oliver. With Earl expressing no interest in dating Allie, there won’t be any more love triangles anytime soon. I have to give When Calls the Heart’s creative team credit for avoiding a second love triangle. But I also have to give some credit to Earl. Allie could have started dating Earl, only to have that relationship be strung along and Allie receive false hope. But Earl decided to be honest about his feelings and tell Allie the truth.
  • So far, the coin mystery is one of the best parts of season twelve! It has prevented episodes from becoming complete “filler”, consistently giving me something to look forward. But the more Rosemary is involved in the case, I wonder where she will find the time for her radio show? Rosemary did such a good job with her first episode, gathering various perspectives on comic books. I hope the radio show makes a return this season.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you like the show’s new character, Ava? Tell me in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: These Precious Years

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

The season eleven finale of When Calls the Heart shows Minnie confronting Elizabeth about Angela’s desire to go to teaching college in Hamilton. Though Minnie is concerned about the distance between Hamilton and Hope Valley, Elizabeth reminds Minnie how Angela still has a few years before she has to make a decision about her future. Minnie then states to Elizabeth how their children’s childhood are precious years. The statement Minnie made in this episode was reminiscent of the “precious years” the show has aired on Hallmark Channel. Time, like childhood, is fleeting. So, the memories made over time are important. As a Heartie, there are so many memories that come to mind as I write this re-cap of season eleven’s finale. Just in this season alone, fans have seen Tom Thornton return, Lily find a home, and Nathan singing a song with Allie. They’ve also witnessed Henry transform into Hope Valley’s Voice of Reason and Lee become the town’s mayor. Throughout When Calls the Heart, a quilt of memories has spread over the story, connecting each character by the thread of friendship. With the chapter of season eleven closing and season twelve’s chapter beginning, it will be exciting to see what new memories will be made on When Calls the Heart!

Just a reminder: If you did not see the season finale of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 11

Episode: 12

Name: Anything for Love

Major story:

Mei and Mike prepare for their upcoming wedding. One surprise is the return of Fiona, who delivers Mei’s dress from the Mercantile. Her arrival is the result of being chosen as Mike’s Best Woman. Before he and Mei get married, Mike claims he is traveling to Benson Hills to share tea with his family. But he actually has other plans. The next day, hours before the wedding, Mike is nowhere to be found. While the men in the wedding party search for the groom, Fiona and the women from the wedding party help Mei get ready for her big day. Eventually, Mike returns to Hope Valley. However, he didn’t come back empty handed. Before the ceremony, several residents of Hope Vally arrive at the café with traditional Chinese drums and gongs. Mike surprises Mei with an engagement ring and the return of her brother, who shares how he ended his shipping contract early. Both the wedding and the reception are a successful time for everyone involved.

Wedding cake image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/enjoyable-wedding-card_953556.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/frame”>Frame vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com. 

Minor stories:

Elizabeth and Nathan want to go on a picnic, hoping to spend some more time together. When Jack Jr. overhears the idea of a picnic, Nathan and Elizabeth decide to invite Jack Jr. and Allie. Over the course of the episode, Elizabeth and Nathan tell their children about their new relationship. While Allie is supportive, Jack Jr. likes the thought of seeing Allie and Nathan more often. One evening, Nathan and Elizabeth share one secret to each other. Elizabeth tells Nathan how she didn’t want to like Nathan at first because she was still missing Jack. Nathan reveals he almost took an inspector job because of Elizabeth. At the end of the episode, a Mountie with a higher ranking approaches Elizabeth and Nathan. Originally, this Mountie wanted to speak with Nathan in private. But after Elizabeth expresses interest in what the Mountie has to say, the Mountie shares how his news relates to Jack Thornton.

After Jeanette’s arrest, Lucas’ approval is declining. Lucas loses confidence in his ability to be a good Governor. Wanting to help Lucas in his time of need, Lee comes up with a solution to replace the cancelled hotel. At the Queen of Hearts Hotel, Rosemary and Lee share the idea of creating a national park. This idea came from wanting to give Goldy and her generation a legacy of their own. Despite the national park providing fewer job opportunities and less revenue than the hotel would have, Lucas is open to the idea. In fact, Lucas invites Lee to come to Capital City to work on this national park project.

During Fiona’s visit to Hope Valley, she reconnects with Faith and Mei. She shares her experience with the Suffragette Movement in Nashville. Because the movement is still looking for more women, especially those that are doctors, Fiona invites Faith to join her in Tennessee. At the wedding reception, Faith tells Fiona she’d love to come to Nashville with her friend. However, Lily has become her purpose for staying in Hope Valley.

Traditional Chinese dragon image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/design”>Design vector created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • Looking back on the eleventh season, this chapter of When Calls the Heart was enjoyable to watch! However, the season’s second half was stronger than the first half, as the writing was tighter and the stories wrapped up sooner. The biggest critique of season eleven is the pacing of the stories, as some of the them lasted longer than necessary. In next year’s season, I hope the writing is more consistent.

  • As I mentioned in this re-cap, Mei’s brother shared how he ended his shipping contract early. This reveal makes me wonder if Mei’s brother will become a series regular in When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season? If he does make consistent appearances in Hope Valley, perhaps Mei’s brother and Faith could form a romantic relationship? It’s way too early to speculate any answers, especially since the twelfth season hasn’t received a release date yet. My hope is Mei’s brother, as well as Mei herself, receiving opportunities to create new memories on the show!

  • I know Lee’s idea for a national park will likely serve a plot for the twelfth season. But, in my opinion, this part of the story doesn’t make sense. The hotel project was indefinitely cancelled because of the danger of Casimir Shaw. But now that Casimir and Jeanette were the same person and Jeanette, as well as her henchman, was arrested for the committed crimes, there is nothing preventing people from placing bids for the hotel. Montague could even reconsider placing his bid and working alongside Lucas. One of Lucas’ reasons for creating a hotel was to provide more job opportunities for the Benson Hills residents who recently lost their jobs. As I mentioned in this re-cap, the national park will have fewer job opportunities and generate less revenue. To me, this seems like a step away from Lucas’ “grand vision”. Based on what was presented on screen, the land Lee gave Lucas isn’t big enough to host a national park. Personally, I think finally giving Rosemary her long awaited theatre would have been more beneficial not just for Hope Valley, but for the neighboring towns as well.

  • One of the biggest surprises of this season finale was the Mountie’s news about Jack Thornton. Because the news itself was not shared, the information could be anything. During the commercials for this episode, Erin Krakow and Daniel Lissing’s new Christmas movie, Santa Tell Me, was advertised. I wonder if Jack will return to When Calls the Heart, with the aforementioned Christmas film testing the waters to see if Hearties would welcome Jack’s return? Again, it’s way too early to speculate any answers. But I’m curious if the viewership numbers for Santa Tell Me have any influence over the creative process of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this season finale? What is your wish for the twelfth season? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Stars in a Lantern

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

To help Lily feel more at home in Hope Valley, Minnie gives Lily Cooper’s lantern from when he was younger. This golden lantern is covered in stars, lighting up the ceiling with bright star-shaped images. When we think about stars, the idea of a collection of stars existing in the night sky usually comes to mind. Within that collection, the stars come together to make the sky brighter. The aforementioned idea could also be applied to the residents of Hope Valley. Each character is a star, shining in their own right. But when they either come together for a special occasion or work together to solve a problem, the town as a whole becomes a brighter place. Characters coming back to the show after an extended period of time are like shooting stars. Their return is so memorable, they captivate the audience’s attention.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 11

Episode: 11

Name: Run to You

Major story:

Bill and Nathan recruit Lee, Henry, and even Mike to not only protect Lucas, but Hope Valley as well. They agree to guard the town from outside, waiting for Casimir Shaw to show up. Jeanette returns to Hope Valley to warn Lucas of Casimir’s arrival. However, in one scene, Jeanette is shown shining her compact in the sun, signaling Casimir himself. Frustrated by the lack of information, Rosemary wants to know what’s going on in town. But she’s not the only curious person. Randall, Rosemary’s rival reporter, also wants answers. His quest for answers is fueled by his family being threatened by his source. After Randall shares this information with Rosemary, they discover Randall’s source and Jeanette possess the same handwriting. Rosemary goes to the Queen of Hearts Hotel to share this news with Lucas, only to fall into Jeanette’s trap and become a hostage. Elizabeth also becomes a hostage because she went to the hotel looking for Rosemary. During this situation, Rosemary realizes Jeanette and Casimir are the same person. She confronts Jeanette with this realization. Meanwhile, outside of Hope Valley, Randall shares his and Rosemary’s findings with Bill, Nathan, and Lucas. The men return to Hope Valley in order to rescue Rosemary and Elizabeth. At first, there is a struggle at the hotel that causes Bill to get hurt. But after Lucas talks Jeanette into turning herself over to authorities and Elizabeth gets away by jumping into a pile of hay with Nathan, the situation de-escalates. Multiple Mounties arrive to take Jeanette to jail.  

Mountie face image created by Bakar015 at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/a-set-of-canada-icons_1050671.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/food”>Food vector created by Bakar015 – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

One day, Lily shares with Faith how, when she lived with her grandmother, she and Dora used to look at the stars from her bedroom window. Faith is suddenly reminded how Lily’s room window at The Café doesn’t have a good view of the sky. In order to solve this problem, as well as helping Lily feel more at home, Minnie offers Cooper’s lantern that was referenced in this re-cap’s introduction. Joseph even provides an electric bulb for the lantern. Later in the episode, when Faith is reading a story to Lily, the lantern works as intended. Meanwhile, Mei receives a letter from her brother. The letter reveals Mei’s brother will be in Cape Fullerton. Originally, Mike and Mei plan to meet Mei’s brother in an out-of-town trip. Instead, Mike suggests having Mei’s brother come to Hope Valley. Mike suggests this because he wants to marry Mei. He shares his feelings to Mei in an official wedding proposal. Mei accepts the proposal, despite not receiving a ring.

Colorful galaxy image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/lovely-hand-drawn-galaxy-background_2943080.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • At the beginning of the episode, Mollie and Florence talk about the recently cancelled hotel. This discussion causes Minnie to ask about the upcoming merger between Benson Hills and Hope Valley. Now that the hotel seems to not be moving forward, there is little to no reason to merge these towns. But if that plan gets cancelled too, what will serve as the overarching plot for season twelve? I’m pretty sure the creative team behind When Calls the Heart will think of something. However, I would be disappointed if Hope Valley and Benson Hills didn’t merge.

  • This episode of When Calls the Heart was very well written! Having Jeanette and Casimir be the same person is one of the most clever decisions this show’s creative team has made in quite some time. I also like how the tension built up over the course of the episode, leading to a climactic and suspenseful moment. Now that this story has wrapped up, I’m curious to see how season eleven ends, as well as what cliff-hangers will be left in preparation for season twelve!

  • When I first read the synopsis for When Calls the Heart’s season finale, I discovered a wedding was on the horizon. Out of all the characters that were eligible to get married, I figured the aforementioned wedding would be Mei and Mike’s. This decision makes sense, especially since the hints throughout this season have not been subtle. At the same time, I think Mike and Mei’s relationship is moving a little too fast, considering they just became a couple in season eleven. I understand the show’s creative team needed a big event to close out the season. But when it comes to any of the characters get married, I wish the creative team waited at least one more season to host another wedding in Hope Valley.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Are you looking forward to the season finale? Share your thoughts in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: How Did We Get Here?

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

While waiting for the arrival of Jeanette, Lucas asks Henry “you ever find yourself asking how you got here”? Henry responds by telling Lucas, “Just about all the time”. Lucas’ question was a very poignant inclusion in this episode. As When Calls the Heart is close to wrapping up their eleventh season and will soon embark on a twelfth season, it can be easy to think about and ask a question similar to Lucas’. Fans of a television show are so invested in what is happening on screen, they may not realize how much time has passed.  When that realization dawns on a fan, they might wonder “where has all that time gone”? I guess Lucas’ question is a testament of the longevity of When Calls the Heart. Captivating stories and memorable characters have made each episode feel shorter than an hour.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 11

Episode: 10

Name: What Goes Around

Major stories:

Allie still has her heart set on meeting her father, Dylan. Though she has money for a train ticket, Angela gives Allie more money to afford a hotel room if necessary. At the Jack Thornton School, Elizabeth organizes a day to restock school supplies, with some of her students volunteering to help. But when Allie doesn’t show up, Elizabeth and Nathan become concerned with Allie’s whereabouts. Angela confesses Allie’s plan to Nathan and Elizabeth. Nathan finally realizes why he received a phone call about Grandville prison earlier in the episode. When Elizabeth and Nathan arrive at the prison, they find Allie in tears. Allie tells Nathan Dylan didn’t want to see her. This crushing reality hurts Allie for most of the episode. As she wonders why her own father would reject her, Nathan explains to Allie how Dylan made a mistake by refusing to see his daughter. Nathan also stresses how lucky he has been to have received the opportunity to raise Allie. Toward the end of the episode, Nathan thanks Elizabeth for supporting both him and Allie. Elizabeth tells him how she will always to there for them.

As a last resort, Lucas agrees to meet with Jeanette about her hotel bid. Even though Henry claims everything seems legitimate, Lucas still has his doubts. Similar to his meeting with Montague, Lucas wants to keep this meeting a secret. This secrecy concerns Lee and he turns to Maisie to share these concerns. For the first time, Maisie and Lee agree on something. They come together to create a statement pulling their support for the hotel. After Lucas receives this statement, he regains his memory. Lucas not only remembers Jeanette visiting him the night he got shot, he also remembers a man named Casimir Shaw shooting him. When he confronts Jeanette about these memories, she confesses how Casimir forced her to work with him. Jeanette shares Casimir’s involvement in the hotel bid as well. In response to all this news, Lucas cancels the hotel indefinitely. He also encourages Jeanette to leave Hope Valley in the middle of the night.

Small, western town image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Faith spends one more day with Lily before Dora comes to retrieve her. One of the things they do is have ice cream at the Ice Cream Parlor. Later in the episode, Dora arrives in Hope Valley. Though Lily is excited about her grandmother’s return, she’s also heartbroken about leaving “Auntie Faith”. Seeing how upset Lily is about saying goodbye to Faith, Dora and Faith come to a mutual agreement: Lily will permanently stay with Faith. Dora also agrees to visit Lily from time to time.

At the Queen of Hearts Hotel, Maisie tells Mei how her and Mike’s mother would love to meet Mei. Brother and sister agree for Mei and their mother to meet over dinner in a few days. Despite being put on the spot, Mei accepts the offer. While Mei comes up with a meal plan for the dinner, Mike confesses to Mei how Maisie invited the whole family to meet Mei. Even though she receives unexpected news, Mei still agrees to the dinner. When the dinner finally arrives, Mei not only meets Mike and Maisie’s mother, she also meets Maisie and Mike’s sisters. After all the curve balls during the planning process, the dinner itself is a success.

Railway Train image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/hand-drawn-train-retro-background_1112415.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • In my last Sunset Over Hope Valley re-cap post, I stated how the hotel was not worth losing friends over. I still stand by that statement. But from a production perspective, it seems like the creative team behind the show made a promise they likely couldn’t keep. As I said in one of my re-cap posts from this season, creating a television show is like trying to solve a math equation. One aspect of that equation is figuring out how to utilize funds and manage a budget. Building a set piece, whether it’s the Jack Thornton School or a hotel, costs money. The longer a television show stays on the air, the more money required to keep that show running. With all that said, I wonder why the show’s creative team would entertain the idea of a hotel if they probably couldn’t afford to create one?
  • Back in season five, one of the overarching subjects was the creation of a train depot. Since this depot had been heard but not seen, I honestly didn’t think it would ever appear on the show. However, this is the second episode this season where Hope Valley’s train depot was featured! It actually looks like a nice location. Plus, the train depot proves how Hope Valley has become a desirable travel destination since the show began in 2014. With Hope Valley and Benson Hills merging in the future, I wonder what will happen to the train depot?
  • Strong acting performances have been showcased throughout the lifespan of When Calls the Heart. But in this episode, I thought the strongest performances were Kevin McGarry’s and Jaeda Lily Miller’s! One of the best scenes this season was when Nathan explains to Allie why Dylan didn’t want to see his daughter. The emotion expressed between these characters appeared genuine. The sincerity of Allie and Nathan’s emotions and expressions were the result of Jaeda and Kevin’s acting talents!
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? How do you feel about the hotel being indefinitely canceled? Share your thoughts in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Keeping Secrets

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

It seems like almost every character is keeping a secret in
this episode of When Calls the Heart. Lucas wants Montague’s hotel bid
to be kept under wraps. Nathan wants to protect Allie from the truth about her
biological father. Faith prolongs telling Lilly about her grandmother’s
recovery. But, sometimes, keeping secrets is not a bad thing in Hope Valley.
Earlier this season, Elizabeth keeps Nathan’s surprise party a secret. In this
episode, Bill has a surprise for Jack Jr. When it comes to keeping secrets on When
Calls the Heart, it depends on the character and the context of their
secret. The secrecy can cause a conflict within an episode’s story or give the
audience a certain perception of a character. What is not a secret is how kept
secrets in a television show adds intrigue and gives viewers a reason to still
watch. When these secrets are finally revealed, it can, sometimes, be
satisfying.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 11

Episode: 9

Name: Truth Be Told

Major stories:

Montague returns to Hope Valley to discuss his hotel bid
with Lucas. During their meeting, Lucas reveals how an acceptance of the bid
equals an acceptance of 50% of the hotel’s profits. When Montague brings up his
desire to receive 60% of the hotel’s profits, Henry denies that request. Meanwhile,
Rosemary and Bill discover Montague’s return to Hope Valley. They even approach
Montague and question his involvement in the mystery surrounding Lucas’ injury.
Montague claims he had nothing to do with shooting Lucas. After learning how
Lucas is strongly considering working with Montague on the hotel, Rosemary
struggles with whether to share this news with Hope Valley. She ultimately decides
to write about Montague and Lucas, despite Lucas wanting to keep Montague’s
hotel bid a secret. When her article is published, Lucas is very upset about
Rosemary sharing his secret with the town, believing she broke his trust. Rosemary
stands by her decision, as she feels the residents of Hope Valley have a right
to know what’s happening in their town. But shortly after Rosemary’s article is
published, Montague is attacked in Hope Valley’s stables. Due to the attack, Montague
receives a concussion and his arm is put in a sling. Montague not only still
denies shooting Lucas, he also refuses to work with Lucas on the hotel,
thinking the project will put his life further into danger.


Allie’s family album makes her curious about her biological
father. This is because there are no pictures of him in this family album. When
Allie asks Nathan about her biological father, Nathan refuses to share any
information about him. Upset by this secrecy, Allie turns to Elizabeth for
advice. Elizabeth tells Allie how her search for her father is up to her, but
she shouldn’t shut Nathan out. Nathan also turns to Elizabeth for advice,
revealing how Allie’s father, Dylan, showed up in Hope Valley back in season
eight. Elizabeth tells Nathan how he should trust his gut as well as know when
the timing is right. Later in the episode, Nathan shares the truth about Dylan
with Allie. This information does not deter Allie’s desire to meet Dylan, as
she believes people can change. Allie is so determined, she learns how to
contact Dylan while volunteering to work the phone board at the Mercantile.

Newspaper image created by Zlatko_plamenov at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-psd/newspaper-mockup_1386098.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/mockup”>Mockup psd created by Zlatko_plamenov – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor story:

Dora, Lilly’s grandmother, calls Faith to tell her how she
has finally recovered from her medical issues. This means she will retrieve
Lilly in the following days. While Faith is happy Dora has recovered, she is
also sad that Lilly will soon leave Hope Valley. She turns to Joseph because
she doesn’t know how she will share this recent news with Lilly. Joseph
suggests giving Lilly a perfect day in Hope Valley, so Lilly will always
remember the good times she had in this town. Taking Joseph’s advice to heart,
Faith makes this perfect day a reality. From a trip to the hair salon to an
afternoon in the park, Lilly has a smile on her face the entire time. Faith
even shares with Joseph how she plans on asking Dora if she will allow Faith to
stay in Lilly’s life. Later in the episode, Faith comes clean about Dora’s
health with Lilly. Even though Lilly is happy to see her grandmother again, all
she wants is to have another perfect day with Faith and her grandmother.

Close-up of pony image created by Flatart at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background photo created by flatart – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

·       
When Allie shares her desire to learn about her
father with Angela, Angela tells Allie how Jacob recently called and invited
her family to spend Christmas with him. As soon as Angela said this, I thought
this story could lend itself to a Christmas movie! I know the creative team
behind When Calls the Heart doesn’t create movies in between seasons
anymore. But if Hallmark is looking for ideas for this or a future Christmas
season, I think a Christmas movie about the Canfield family could work,
especially since the movie would already have a built-in audience.


·       
I know no character is meant to be everyone’s
cup of tea. But out of all the seasons Lucas has been on When Calls the
Heart, he was his most unlikeable in this episode. While he had his heart
in the right place, he was too narrow-minded and stubborn about his “grand
vision”. It got to the point where, in this episode, his plans seemed
underhanded. As a Heartie, I’d like to see this hotel brought to life in season
twelve. However, I don’t think the hotel is worth losing friends over.


·       
In my re-cap’s introduction, I mentioned Bill
having a surprise for Jack Jr. This surprise is a pony, as Jack Jr. has
expressed his wish to ride a horse. When Calls the Heart has a history
of recruiting cute animals to appear on the show. But I can’t help mentioning
how adorable Pal the pony was in this episode! In fact, this pony looked like a
giant stuffed animal.

Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? How
do you think Lucas’ “grand vision” will be resolved? Tell me in the comment
section below!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Let the Show Go On

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

In this episode of When Calls the Heart, the plans of Hope Valley’s choir fall through. They don’t go to Salt Lake City as originally expected. To help Tom as well as other choirs, a new idea is put in place where everyone benefits. This isn’t the first time things didn’t work out in Hope Valley. But I’m willing to guess the show itself has experienced hiccups along the way. Making a television show is a huge creative endeavor. When working on a large project involving multiple people, there’s always a chance things could go wrong. Most fans don’t think about these possibilities, as they just see the final product. From the perspective of a long-time Heartie, though, the solution in this episode of When Calls the Heart made me reflect on other likely behind-the-scenes conflicts and how they were resolved. Because as the saying goes, “the show must go on”.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 11

Episode: 8

Name: Brother’s Keeper

Major stories:

Nathan contacted the police in New York in an attempt to track down Mr. Sweeney. The New York police were able to arrest Mr. Sweeney and retrieve the $65 from Hope Valley’s choir. Unfortunately, Mr. Sweeney gambled the $300 collected from Benson Hills’ and Jamison’s choir. In an emergency choir meeting, Tom comes clean with all this news. Helping Tom save face, Nathan and Elizabeth quickly come up with the idea of hosting their own music festival to raise money for the aforementioned choirs. However, they allow Tom to take full credit for their idea. Maisie is not happy when Rosemary shares all this information with her. She believes Tom should be arrested, but Nathan reassures Maisie that the money will be raised. The festival itself is not the only way Hope Valley raises money. Several stalls selling food and valuable items are sparkled throughout the town. The Voices of the Valley festival is a success, with over $200 raised. But during the financial count, the choir discovers they are just under $300. When Lucas learns this, he takes money from his cultural fund and donates it to the festival. Before leaving Hope Valley, Tom makes the sad realization he’ll soon have to find a new job.

Just in time for the Voices of the Valley festival, Jacob Canfield arrives in Hope Valley. He still expects an apology from Joseph, but Joseph has no idea what he should apologize for. This angers Jacob and makes him consider leaving Hope Valley. While Minnie tries to coax Jacob to stay in town, Jacob reveals he hasn’t attended church or sang in over ten years. When Minnie shares this information with Joseph, he feels bad that whatever he did caused his brother to pull away from God. As he tries to figure out what he did wrong, Joseph turns to Henry for advice. Henry says that no matter what Joseph did, Jacob was hurt and Joseph should apology for hurting his brother. Later in the episode, Joseph does apologize to Jacob. When Joseph finally learns why Jacob is upset, he discovers that Jacob felt abandoned after he married Minnie. Though Jacob got the apology he wanted, he is still upset because he doesn’t believe the apology will change anything. Joseph disagrees, as he believes there is still hope for his and Jacob’s relationship. Right before Hope Valley’s choir performs “Amazing Grace”, Jacob becomes the missing tenor the choir was looking for. Both Canfield brothers later confess how much they’ve missed each other.

As promised, Nathan allows Clayton Pike to stay in Hope Valley during his prison transfer so Rosemary could interview Clayton. But when given the opportunity to interview Clayton, Rosemary, as well as Bill, find no luck. This is because Clayton refuses to reveal the identity of who really shot Lucas. Even when Lucas has a one-on-one conversation with Clayton, Clayton still remains silent. The next day, Clayton shares that the man responsible for Lucas getting hurt is so powerful, even the Mounties can’t intervene. Later, at the Queen of Hearts Hotel, Henry confronts Lucas about his decision to, possibly, accept Montague’s hotel bid. Henry addresses how Montague doesn’t have a good reputation with the people of Hope Valley due to decisions he made in the previous season. Lucas confesses how the Benson Hills Oil Company recently closed, causing hundreds of employees to lose their jobs. When Henry brings up Jeanette’s hotel bid, saying it looked legitimate, Lucas shuts out that possibility, simply asking Henry to trust him on that choice.

Money plant image created by Dooder at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/infographic”>Infographic vector created by Dooder – Freepik.com</a>. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/watering-the-coin-plant_1076121.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Similar to season eleven’s seventh episode, “Facing the Music”, there are no minor stories in this episode.

String of musical notes image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/pentagram-vector_710290.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com. 

Some thoughts to consider:

In the previous episode, Tom went on a date with Faith at The Café. Toward the end of this episode, at the Voices of the Valley party at the Queens of Hearts Hotel, Tom gets asked by Faith to dance before Elizabeth asks Nathan to dance. I like the idea of Tom and Faith sharing a romantic relationship, especially since Max Lloyd-Jones and Andrea Brooks had nice on-screen chemistry. But if these characters are going to share a relationship, one of two things have to happen; either Tom needs to make more frequent appearances on the show or Faith needs to live closer to Tom.

Similar to last week’s episode, this episode of When Calls the Heart was stronger than other episodes this season! The featured stories were intriguing and weren’t as drawn out as season eleven’s previous episodes, so far. With only four episodes left, it makes me wonder how some of these stories will be resolved?

In my re-cap for this season’s second episode, I mentioned how curious I was to see how Henry’s story turned out in season eleven. This thought came after witnessing Henry adopting a happier and calmer personality, as well as developing a genuine interest in Hope Valley’s agriculture and foliage. Now that Henry starting working for Lucas, he has become Hope Valley’s Voice of Reason. In my opinion, this is a pleasant new direction for Henry’s story! It gives him a sense of purpose while acknowledging how far Henry has come.

Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you like Henry becoming Hope Valley’s Voice of Reason? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Waiting for Tom Thornton

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Last September, I wrote a list sharing which ten characters
I’d love to see return to When Calls the Heart. My number one choice was
Tom Thornton, as his last appearance was all the way back in season five. So,
when I discovered Tom was returning to the show, my interest in the rest of
season eleven piqued! When Tom told Elizabeth and Jack Jr. what he did for a living,
he said he “sold happiness”. I would like to point out how Tom has been doing
that all along. Though I can only speak for myself, Tom has always made me
happy whenever he appeared on the show. Despite his more recent appearances
being brief, these moments were special and cherished. Looking back on Tom’s
story, I’m starting to realize how his and Henry’s story share several similarities.
Both characters had a troubled past, made a conscious effort to change, and now
have brighter futures!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 11

Episode: 7

Name: Facing the Music


Major stories:

Tom Thornton has returned to Hope Valley in honor of Jack’s
birthday. After visiting his brother’s grave, Tom reconnects with familiar faces,
like Faith and Elizabeth, and meets new ones, such as Allie, Angela, and
Nathan. Tom’s career has taken a new path, this time selling sheet music for a
man named Mr. Sweeney. When the members of Hope Valley’s choir discover Tom is
looking for acts for an upcoming music festival, they become interested in
participating in the event. Tom informs them how only one spot remains in the
festival, so they would have to audition. The choir agrees to audition over the
phone, with the audition itself being a success. Because the choir received the
aforementioned last spot in the festival, Tom tells them they have to pay the $65
entry fee. Even though the choir agrees to chip in five dollars each, Elizabeth
and even Nathan are concerned by how quickly things are happening. When Nathan
and Elizabeth confront Tom about the entry fee, Tom reassures them how the
entire endeavor is legitimate. However, a phone call from Mr. Sweeney at the
Mercantile indicates how things are not going according to plan. Toward the end
of the episode, Elizabeth discovers Tom checked out of the Queen of Hearts
hotel and is on his way to Union City. She and Nathan find Tom waiting at the
train station. Tom confesses Mr. Sweeney not only stole the $65 dollars from
Hope Valley’s choir, but has stolen money from the festival’s other
participants. Tom turns to Elizabeth and Nathan for help with this situation.


Rosemary and Bill bring their lead on Luca’s case to Nathan.
Nathan would like to look into Clayton Pike’s connection to Union City
Holdings, but states how the Mounted Police are working on other cases.
Rosemary still cannot speak to Clayton himself, but feels the next best thing
would be to speak to his mother, Hazel. With Hazel living in Union City, Nathan
agrees to help Rosemary organize an interview. He also informs Bill and
Rosemary how Clayton is transferring prisons soon, so he’ll try to get an
interview for Rosemary. The original plan was for Rosemary to travel to Union
City for her interview with Hazel. But plans change when Hazel ends up visiting
Rosemary in Hope Valley. During the interview, Hazel claims she and Clayton
were at a political event around the time Lucas was shot. She even shares how
Clayton was taking care of her after she had injured her hip. Hazel received
money for surgery a week before Lucas became injured. She says a friend of
Clayton’s gave her the money, sharing how Clayton and the friend met at church.
While Hazel was at the hospital, Montague paid her visit and gave her flowers.


Lucas is having difficulty finding investors for the hotel.
Though Montague’s and Jeanette’s offer are still on the table, Lucas would
rather not work with them. Out of desperation, Lucas asks Lee to help find
investors. Though Lee agrees to help, he even has no luck finding a solution. As
a last resort, Mr. Mitchell, who now works for Lucas, suggests using an
emergency fund to start the hotel. Henry, who has recently started working for
Lucas, believes this is a bad idea. His belief is based on how the money in the
emergency fund came from the people of places like Hope Valley. Henry tells
Lucas to step away from the hotel if no other options are available. But toward
the end of the episode, Lucas ends up calling Montague.

Since Tom Thornton came back to When Calls the Heart, I figured adding this picture of Tom and Jack to my re-cap made sense. Image created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel.

Minor stories:

Because so much emphasis was placed on the major stories,
there are no minor stories in this episode.

Birthday party set-up image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/food”>Food photo created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

·       Last month, Net (from It’s a Wonderful Movie)
shared an announcement about two new Signed, Sealed, Delivered movies.
One of these movies, currently titled “Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon
and Back”, revolves around the POstables going on a road trip to find a rock
star. You’re probably wondering what this Signed, Sealed, Delivered
movie has to do with this episode of When Calls the Heart. During his
time in Hope Valley, Tom briefly sang a song at the Queen of Hearts hotel. I’m
not sure if Max Lloyd-Jones sang in that scene or if the singing belonged to a
voice double. But if Max sang himself and if Signed, Sealed, Delivered’s
creative team wanted to utilize more talent from Hallmark’s community, I hope
Max stars in “Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back” as the
aforementioned rock star!


·       I’m disappointed the music festival ended up
becoming a scam. With When Calls the Heart receiving a twelfth season, Hope
Valley’s choir traveling to Salt Lake City could have served as a two-part
season premiere. If When Calls the Heart’s creative team was interested
in creating movies again, the music festival may have been the plot of the
film. According to the trailer for the next episode, it looks like Hope Valley
will host their own music festival. With all this said, it feels like the show’s
writers forced the original music festival to fall through just to keep the
story in Hope Valley.


·       This episode is, so far, the best one from season
eleven! It was great to see Tom come back to the show. But it was also great to
see the script less drawn out than other episodes this season. There was more intrigue
from each featured story, which kept me invested in what was happening on
screen. I’m definitely looking forward to seeing how the story plays out in
next week’s episode!

Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Are you excited to
see Tom Thornton return to Hope Valley? Let me know in the comment section!


Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen