Whenever a new tool, idea, or concept has been introduced in Hope Valley, it has been used for the greater good of the town. The more recent addition of radio technology serves a perfect example. In this episode of When Calls the Heart alone, the radio has educated listeners, provided a platform for debates and discussions, even entertained. The radio has become a positive inclusion to Hope Valley. Other ideas have made Hope Valley a better place, from the iconic Jack Thornton School to the town’s Christmas festivities. While some of these ideas are not frequently presented on the show, they have left their mark on the history of When Calls the Heart. I haven’t given much thought to the overarching theme of new ideas serving Hope Valley’s greater good until I reflected on this episode, as well as the show as a whole.
Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

Season: 12
Episode: 8
Name: The Show Must Go On
Major stories:
Rowlin Rockwell (Randell’s cousin), from Benson Hills Broadcasting, pays Rosemary and Fiona a visit in Hope Valley. He informs the ladies of the Daily Dialogue’s low listenership numbers, even lower than a radio show about animal sounds. In order to impress Rowlin, Rosemary quickly comes up with the idea of bringing her production of The Importance of Being Earnest to the radio. Rowlin is so impressed with this idea, he tells Rosemary she has to present the play the next day. At rehearsal later that day, when Rosemary announces this change in plans, Mike confesses he has a sore throat. Ava recommends Mike pay the hot springs a visit. Lee and Bill also take Ava’s advice. But the next day, Mike, Bill, and Lee end up sick with Laryngitis. This stresses Rosemary out because this means about half of the play’s cast is too unwell to perform. After some encouragement from the ladies of Hope Valley, Rosemary decides to host an all-female radio production of The Importance of Being Earnest instead. The performance ends up being a success! Even Rowlin’s family liked it!
Lucas hosts a meeting with the local ranchers about Allie and Oliver’s proposal. The most vocal objection comes from a rancher named McGinty. He doesn’t believe the ranchers should move their cows to a new pasture to cater to the local wildlife. The other ranchers agree with him, even Edie stands by McGinty’s opinion. But later in the episode, Edie reveals to Lucas McGinty has tricked the other ranchers, including her uncle, into signing a loan to use his land. This is the result of a mudslide destroying a path to a pasture years ago. At the meeting, Allie recognizes McGinty’s boots, believing he helped cover up cow tracks near the river back in this season’s sixth episode. Meanwhile, Nathan shares with Bill how Toddy claims a rancher gave him small batches of gold coins for five to six years. When the rancher passed away, Toddy stopped receiving the coins. Nathan tells Bill the remaining coins were sold in Amsterdam and the identity of the rancher is Ernest “Ernie” Martell, Edie’s uncle. When Bill and Nathan question Edie about Ernie’s acquisition of the coins, she claims to have no idea what they are talking about.

Minor stories:
Elizabeth is scheduled to appear on an episode of the Daily Dialogue. During the recording of the episode, Elizabeth discusses her project-based learning idea with Eileen Bennett, a Superintendent from the Department of Education. Eileen doesn’t think Elizabeth’s idea is bad. However, Eileen believes the classroom’s purpose is to prepare students to be academically competitive. This lack of whole-hearted support makes Elizabeth feel discouraged. For most of this episode of When Calls the Heart, Elizabeth focuses on assisting Rosemary with the play. But after the radio performance, Elizabeth discovers a collection of letters from teachers who listened to her Daily Dialogue episode. The letters are supportive of Elizabeth’s idea, with some teachers even adopting project-based teaching. Using Nathan’s suggestion, Elizabeth reads some of the letters on The Valley Voice Radio Hour.
After selling her barber shop, Fiona still plans on marrying a man named Harold. She confesses to Faith her reason for wanting to get married; Harold is a lawyer who could help Fiona make a difference. Fiona even asks Faith to be her Maid of Honor. Later in the episode, Elizabeth shares with Fiona her reason for breaking up with Lucas in season ten; the relationship didn’t feel right in her heart. She also encourages Fiona to follow her heart and tells her how she should spread her wings to fly. After the radio performance of The Importance of Being Earnest, Rowlin is not only thrilled with the success of the play, he also likes the successful response of Elizabeth’s Daily Dialogue episode. He reveals to Fiona and Rosemary he just acquired a license for a new radio station in Port Townsen and wants to recruit them to be in charge of the station’s programming. While Rosemary turns down the offer, Fiona accepts. Before leaving for her new adventure, Fiona mentions calling off her engagement to Harold. As a going away present, Faith gives Fiona a locket, so she can fill the locket with what her heart desires.

Some thoughts to consider:
- Now that When Calls the Heart is more than halfway through season twelve, I’ve noticed parts of the story introduced earlier in the season have been abandoned. Back in this season’s third episode, Lee reveals to Faith how his father died of an unnamed medical condition. He even shares his concerns of developing the medical condition himself. Since then, the story has not acknowledged this part of Lee’s medical history. With four episodes left in season twelve, I’m not sure how that can be resolved?
- In this season’s second episode, Allie was concerned about not having a special interest. But what started as a chance encounter with an animal print in the dirt led to Allie’s interest in the Great Timber Wolf. Allie’s story in season twelve has been well-written. It has provided her with character development, helped her make a new friend, and connected with one of the season’s major stories. I do wonder if Allie will, indeed, find a way for the Great Timber Wolves to return?
- As I mentioned in this re-cap, Elizabeth receives letters from teachers who support her project-based learning idea. Some teachers even claimed they were already utilizing project-based teaching in their classroom. Based on those letters, I got the impression those teachers were using project-based teaching before Elizabeth came up with her idea. With that said, why did Elizabeth submit her idea for publication if her idea already exists?

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you think the Great Timber Wolves will return near Hope Valley? Let me know in the comment section!
Have fun in Hope Valley!
Sally Silverscreen












![20191110_131037[1]](https://18cinemalane.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/20191110_1310371-e1573410229997.jpg)


