I am back from a two-week hiatus to deliver a brand-new review for The 4th Master of Suspense Blogathon! As a consistent participant in this event, I wanted to, once again, broaden my cinematic horizons by writing about another film from Alfred Hitchcock’s filmography. Before joining the blogathon, I remembered how Patricia (from Caftan Woman) recommended the 1941 movie, Mr. & Mrs. Smith, to me. This year’s edition of the Master of Suspense Blogathon gave me the perfect excuse to, finally, check the film out! Mr. & Mrs. Smith is now the seventh movie from Alfred’s filmography I’ve reviewed. However, most of his films covered on 18 Cinema Lane have been, in my opinion, just ok. Will the 1941 picture stand out among this aforementioned collection? Solve this mystery by reading my review!

Things I liked about the film:
The acting: In Mr. & Mrs. Smith, Carole Lombard portrays the titular Mrs. Smith, Ann Smith/Krausheimer. One aspect of Carole’s performance I liked was how expressive it was! A great example is present during a conversation Ann shares with her husband, David, toward the beginning of the movie. When Ann asks David if he’d marry her if he had a chance to do it again, she appears hopeful. A smile can be seen on Ann’s face and there’s a bright shine in her eyes, paired alongside her easy-going demeanor. But when David matter-of-factly answers Ann’s question by saying, “No”, Ann’s attitude completely changes. Not only do her eyes adopt a “thousand-yard stare”, her mouth is also slightly turned into a frown. Though Ann tries to mask her disappointment by bouncing back to her easy-going demeanor, her facial expressions perfectly capture what’s in her mind and heart.
Robert Montgomery portrays David Smith, the titular Mr. Smith in the 1941 movie. Similar to Carole’s performance, Robert effectively utilized facial expressions to convey emotions, feelings, and thoughts. While he’s at his office, David calls Ann about their upcoming dinner plans. During his conversation with Ann, the combination of David’s smile, playful glances, and a flirty hint in his voice showcases how much he loves his wife. Meanwhile, Jack Carson’s portrayal of Chuck “Chucky” Benson was a standout! Despite appearing in only three scenes, Chuck became memorable due to the consistent charisma and confidence Jack brought to his character. The scene where Chuck calls Gloria and Gertrude/Gertie is such a great example of how distinct Chuck’s personality is compared to David’s, as David’s awkward phone call emphasizes Chuck’s head-strong confidence.
The on-screen chemistry of Carole Lombard and Robert Montgomery: As I already mentioned in this review, David and Ann are the titular Mr. and Mrs. Smith. From the very beginning of the story, it is evident there is true love between them. This is because Robert and Carole’s on-screen chemistry successfully convinces the audience their characters are not only married, but also in love! When David and Ann cuddle together one morning, David holds Ann in a gentle embrace. Their relaxed body language perfectly captures the comfort they share in their relationship. As David asks her questions, Ann simply nods her head and moves her eyebrows. His tone of voice is calm, emphasizing the gentleness of David and Ann’s interaction. This is a very romantic moment because there’s a sense of tenderness, understanding, and respect between them. But because of the story’s conflict, Ann and David share so few romantic moments together, making me wish they had received more in the script.
Jeff’s apartment: One evening in Mr. & Mrs. Smith, David’s friend, Jeff, takes Ann to the 1939 New York World’s Fair. Due to the rain they endure, they go to Jeff’s apartment to escape the cold. When I first saw his apartment on screen, I did not expect it to look the way it did. Because Jeff is a lawyer who appears to enjoy the finer things in life, such as classy suits and fancy restaurants like The Florida Club, I imagined his apartment consisting of dark wood walls, richly upholstered furniture, and maybe a large painting of a horse. But when Jeff’s apartment appeared on screen, it was very bright. The space was surrounded in light colored wood walls. Not only were there light-colored curtains hanging by the windows, there was plenty of lighting featured throughout Jeff’s apartment. Table lamps, dark metal wall sconces, and a dark metal sconced chandelier contribute to the apartment’s brightness. A light-colored fireplace hearth is nicely paired with a darker marble. At least six built-in bookshelves compliment the space, adding a sense of coziness. These combined elements not only make Jeff’s apartment look like a visually appealing cozy cottage, the set design subverted my expectations as well!

What I didn’t like about the film:
Lack of open communication: Toward the beginning of Mr. & Mrs. Smith, David and Ann establish how they are honest with each other and respect one another, showcasing how open communication is a key component of their relationship. But the conflict of the 1941 movie revolves around how Ann and David aren’t officially married due to a misunderstanding with their marriage license. While David tries to persuade Ann to remarry him, Ann desires to move on and fall in love in another man. This difference in perspective was caused by Ann believing David wasn’t honest about the conflict with her. If they had openly communicated to each other similar to how they did toward the beginning of Mr. & Mrs. Smith, Ann and David would have saved so much time and frustration. David and Ann being unable to see eye to eye feels almost like part of their relationship was deceptive.
A prolonged conflict: I’ve mentioned in the past how I’m not a fan of Hallmark films where the story features a character who says they’re going to do something, but spends most of the story not doing the thing they said they were going to do. 1941’s Mr. & Mrs. Smith adopts this exact type of story. As I’ve already said in this review, the conflict revolves around how Ann and David aren’t officially married due to a misunderstanding with their marriage license. At first, David and Ann express a strong interest in getting remarried. But they spend most of the movie’s hour and thirty-five-minute run-time doing everything but that. Because Ann and David stopped prioritizing their desire to get remarried, Mr. & Mrs. Smith’s conflict felt prolonged. It also kind of felt like David and Ann took longer than necessary to reach the intended point.
A rushed ending: I’m not going to spoil 1941’s Mr. & Mrs. Smith, in case any of my readers haven’t seen this movie yet. But what I will say is the ending was, in my opinion, rushed. Like I just said in my review, Ann and David spend most of the movie’s hour and thirty-five-minute run-time doing everything but getting remarried. This creative decision made Mr. & Mrs. Smith’s conflict feel prolonged. While that conflict receives a resolution, it doesn’t happen until the last fifteen minutes of the film. Plus, it was wrapped up too quickly to the point it doesn’t feel satisfying or earned. In fact, I was caught off guard by how rushed the ending was, especially since Alfred Hitchcock is a director who, usually, knows how to conclude a story.

My overall impression:
In my opinion, Alfred Hitchcock’s filmography fluctuates in quality. While I’d say Strangers on a Train is my favorite film directed by Alfred, I was not a fan of The 39 Steps. For me, Mr. & Mrs. Smith falls somewhere in the middle. The acting was solid from the entire cast, especially when it came to the performances of Carole Lombard, Robert Montgomery, and Jack Carson. I liked Robert and Carole’s on-screen chemistry so much, I wish David and Ann had received more romantic moments together. Not only did Jeff’s apartment look visually appealing, it also subverted my expectations. But what hurt Mr. & Mrs. Smith was prolonging the conflict to the point of rushing the ending. It didn’t help how, more often than not, Ann and David lacked open communication, contributing to the story’s prolonged conflict. However, I appreciate Alfred’s attempt at telling a type of story outside his claim to fame. While Mr. & Mrs. Smith wasn’t a suspenseful picture, it did hold my intrigue, as I wanted to know what would happen next.
Overall score: 6 out of 10
Have you seen 1941’s Mr. & Mrs. Smith? Which film from Alfred Hitchcock’s filmography do you wish I’d review? Please tell me in the comment section!
Have fun at the movies!
Sally Silverscreen






















