A Movie Blogger Tier Ranks Halloween Commercials

When I published my review of 1920’s The Scarecrow, it became my 1,050th published post! To commemorate this milestone, I wanted to create a list article. But, with Halloween just around the corner, I decided to make my post more festive. Recently, a Youtuber named Cameron (from the Youtube channel, Cameron Chaney – Library Macabre) created a tier rank list of sixty-six classic Halloween commercials. Inspired by his video, I made my own tier rank list! For my list, however, I curated a collection of thirty-one commercials, since there are thirty-one days in the month of October. With the exception of one advertisement, I purposefully chose ads that weren’t on Cameron’s list. This was done to make my list look and feel distinct from Cameron’s video. Since Halloween is what you make it, my tier rank list showcases the different ways a Halloween commercial can be festive. Throughout this list article, I will provide links to the videos of the commercials, in case my readers are interested in watching any of the ads I discussed. If a commercial is from a compilation video, I will include the time stamps for that commercial. I even numbered the commercials on each tier to make it easier for my readers to follow along with the tier rank list. Before I reveal which commercials I chose and which tiers I placed them in, let me explain each of the five tiers and what they mean.

  • Nightmare Fuel – Sometimes, Halloween festivities can be scary, from watching horror movies and visiting a haunted house. These commercials on this tier highlight the “scarier” side of Halloween. If you choose to watch the ranked commercials as you follow along with the list article, please view the commercials from the “Nightmare Fuel” tier at your own discretion, as these commercials can be disturbing for a variety of reasons.
  • Binx Approved – This tier references Binx, the memorable black cat from the 1993 film, Hocus Pocus. For many people, this movie is a beloved and iconic part of their Halloween celebrations. Any commercial placed on the “Binx Approved” tier earned that spot either by being the perfect representative of Halloween, “iconic” (because of the commercial itself or because of what the commercial is advertising), or possessing the right amount of Halloween spirit.
  • Harris Trinsky and the “Geeks” go Trick-or-Treating – When I wrote my editorial about Harris Trinsky (from Freaks and Geeks) and Eddie Munson (from Stranger Things) being two sides of the same coin, I referenced Freaks and Geeks’ Halloween episode, ‘Tricks and Treats’. In that episode, Harris joined the “geeks” (Bill, Sam, and Neil) on their trick-or-treating excursion. For this tier, the Halloween commercials are festive in a light-hearted, hilarious, or sweet way (as Freaks and Geeks is classified as a comedy on IMDB). It’s also possible for the commercials in the “Harris Trinsky and the “Geeks” go Trick-or-Treating” tier to contain less Halloween spirit than the ads from the “Binx Approved” tier.
  • McDonald’s Boo Buckets – Since 1986, Boo Buckets have served as a special treat for children around Halloween. Providing a festive way to hold a Happy Meal, the Boo Buckets became McDonald’s signature way of celebrating the Halloween holiday. Commercials on this tier are child/family-friendly, either because of the nature of the commercial or because the advertised product has children’s wellbeing in mind. Out of all the tiers on this list, the most adorable commercials can be found on the “McDonald’s Boo Buckets” tier.
  • Brick Heck in a Corn Maze – In the season one episode of The Middle, ‘Thanksgiving’, all Brick Heck wanted was to walk through a corn maze. Inspired by this simple wish, as well as this Fall/Autumn tradition, the “Brick Heck in a Corn Maze” tier recognizes the commercials that are more complimentary of the Halloween season. However, these advertisements are either not Halloween themed or Halloween is not the central focal point. For various reasons, though, it would have made sense to see these commercials from the “Brick Heck in a Corn Maze” tier air around Halloween.
As I explained in the introduction of this article, I purposefully created my tier rank list to look and feel distinct from Cameron’s video. Screenshot taken by me, Sally Silverscreen.

Nightmare Fuel

1. When A Stranger Calls – “Movie Trailer”

Year Aired: 1979

(38:02 – 38:32)

I’ve mentioned before on 18 Cinema Lane how the most effective “scary movies” are the ones that involve real-life situations. This trailer for When A Stranger Calls addresses that concept by showing a scene where the movie’s protagonist, Jill, discovers an intruder has entered the house she’s babysitting at, as well as making a call from inside that house. Including that scene in the trailer plays into the fear of someone violating a safe place like home and manipulating that safe place for their own advantage. What makes the trailer even more frightening is the addition of suspenseful music and the reactions from the audience, “filmed during actual performance” according to the trailer itself. Seeing the looks of concern and fear on the faces of the audience, while also hearing their screams, creates a sense of relatability for the featured audience and the viewer of the trailer, emphasizing a situation on screen that would be terrifying for anyone.

2. Taco Bell – “Monster Eyes”

Year Aired: 1997

(8:55 – 9:25)

This commercial becomes more disturbing the longer you think about it. In an attempt to create a backstory for their Monster Eye Straws, Taco Bell presents an ad where a man owns a collection of sentient dismembered monster heads for the purpose of collecting their eyes in order to create the straws. These monster heads appear terrified when the man arrives to retrieve their eyes, with one of the heads saying, “I hate this part”, implying this situation has happened before. As the man reaches for the eyes, he has a gleefully sinister look on his face. Even the man’s dog appears to know something doesn’t seem right. The straws themselves are a creative and visually unique souvenir for Halloween. But I don’t think a backstory was necessary, especially a backstory as disturbing as the one featured in Taco Bell’s 1997 ad.

3. DiGiorno Pizza – “Bates Motel”

Year Aired: 2000

(1:06:02 – 1:06:32)

In this commercial from 2000, DiGiorno Pizza decided to parody the 1960 Alfred Hitchcock film, Psycho, to promote their “new” Half & Half pizza. Two characters from the film, Norman and his mother, are having a conversation about the pizza off-screen, emphasizing how two people can enjoy the half cheese and half pepperoni pizza being advertised. The only times Norman and his mother appear on screen are when Norman can be seen as a silhouette in a window and when his mother goes into the kitchen to cut the pizza in half. But what makes this commercial unsettling is the idea of the commercial’s events taking place within the context of Psycho. I won’t spoil this movie for any of my readers who haven’t seen the 1960 film. But if you have seen it, you would know why I placed DiGiorno’s advertisement in the “Nightmare Fuel” tier.

4. Anti-smoking PSA – “Tobacco is Whacko”

Year Aired: 2002

(4:01 – 4:31)

I know some PSAs (public service announcements) are intentionally created to scare viewers away from doing something (smoking in this case). However, that doesn’t take away from how disturbing the message’s delivery is in this anti-smoking PSA from 2002. The combination of the darkened alley, eerie music, and little dialogue create an atmosphere that looks like it came straight out of a horror movie. The sinister man with discolored teeth randomly giving a tongue piercing to a teenage boy adds to the disturbing nature of the PSA. Piercings, in the context of the PSA, are intended to visually represent cigarettes leaving their mark on the smoker. But when I saw it while researching commercials for this tier rank list, I immediately knew the “Nightmare Fuel” tier was a deserving place for the PSA to go.

5. Universal’s Halloween Horror Nights – “The Director”

Year Aired: 2003

(1:45:51 – 1:46:18, 1:47:03 – 1:47:33)

When the Youtube channel, Expedition Theme Park, claimed The Director was the “most extreme” and “controversial” icon at Universal Studios’ Halloween Horror Nights, they were not overexaggerating. What sets The Director apart from other Halloween related characters is how he craves putting his “actors” in pain. His reasoning is that the creative decision “tells the story truthfully”. In the “To be continued” ad, The Director talks about his “work” with a mixture of pride and nonchalance, his attitude adding disturbance to his persona. While the “To be continued” ad shows glimpses of a jester being held against his will, the “You Oughtta Be in Pictures” ad clearly presents The Director inflicting pain on that same jester. The purpose of these ads (promoting the thirteenth edition of Universal’s Halloween Horror Nights) isn’t revealed until the end of the commercial, forcing viewers of the advertisement to wonder, “What the heck am I watching?”. To put it simply, the ads featuring The Director certainly put the “horror” in Halloween Horror Nights.

6. Snickers – “November 1st”

Year Aired: 2007

(6:01 – 6:45)

Similar to Taco Bell’s “Monster Eyes” commercial, Snickers’ ad from 2007 becomes more disturbing the longer you think about it. The featured man in the ad is in danger due to a ladder falling while he’s removing Halloween decorations from his home, leaving him hanging onto the roof’s edge. This situation presents a relatable fear for the advertisement’s viewers. What makes the commercial more frightening is how the featured children unanimously agree not to help the man. As he’s yelling for someone to assist him to safety, the children just stare at him with blank looks on their faces, even watching him fall. While the man’s fate isn’t revealed, on-screen text tries to provide an explanation why the children didn’t help him, stating “Next Halloween Give Out the Good Stuff”. Victim-blaming and the children allowing the man to remain in danger for a petty reason make the commercial feel mean-spirited in a disturbing way. I, honestly, don’t want to know what Snickers was thinking when they were making this ad.

Binx Approved

1. It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown – “Original CBS Promo”

Year Aired: 1966

For sixty years, It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown has been an iconic staple in Halloween entertainment programming. In fact, it has become one of the most popular and marketable pieces of Halloween media. So, you can imagine my shock when Cameron didn’t put any commercials featuring the Peanuts on his tier rank list. That gave me an opportunity to place an ad for It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown on my list, especially the “Binx Approved” tier. Out of all the commercials available on Youtube, I decided on the original promo from 1966, pleasantly surprised by how it was archived at all. Though the footage is grainier than other versions of the advertisement, it perfectly captures both the Fall/Autumn season and Halloween season. From Lucy tricking Charlie Brown into kicking the football to Snoopy (as the Red Baron) crashing the Halloween party, the timeless and wholesome nature of It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown has helped the 1966 presentation earn the title of “classic”.

2. Hallmark – “Halloween Boo Bazaar – Skeleton”

Year Aired: 1986 & 1987

Though Cameron included four Hallmark commercials on his tier rank list, this “Halloween Boo Bazaar” ad featuring a rapping skeleton was not one of them. What’s interesting about this commercial is how there are two different versions, each airing a year apart. While the changes make the advertisements look distinct from one other, they share the same purpose: showcasing the various products offered through Hallmark’s Halloween Boo Bazaar collection. The skeleton’s rap song, as well as the visuals, make viewers aware of the available costume apparel, like beanies, tails, and headbands. There are also wands, plush pumpkins, and decorations that appear to flow through the wind. Balloons are even present in the 1987 version of Hallmark’s commercial. The quicker procession of the products from Halloween Boo Bazaar makes Halloween seem unstoppable, with the holiday spirit constantly thrown at the viewer. Both versions of Hallmark’s commercial possess an authentic quirkiness that is rarely seen in marketing today.

3. Carvel Ice Cream Bakery – “Halloween Cake”

Year Aired: 1991

(3:28 – 3:58)

Cameron selected a Halloween Carvel Ice Cream ad for his tier rank list. But the version he picked featured a talking pumpkin cake named Dumpy. Carvel’s commercial from 1991, the advertisement I chose for my tier rank list, is, in my opinion, leagues better. The first half of the TV spot looks and feels like scenes taken from a Universal Studios Monster movie. This is achieved through a combination of black-and-white photography, cinematography, suspenseful music, and inclusion of lightning. When Carvel’s Halloween ice cream cake is shown on-screen, it presents a more classic pumpkin design. Turning vanilla ice cream cones into “Ghosty Cones” was such a creative idea! Even Carvel’s logo changing colors from red, yellow, and purple to black and white when lightning struck added a touch of spookiness to the commercial. Compared to the “Dumpy the Pumpkin” ad, the 1991 television spot appears to be cinema.

4. Hocus Pocus – “Movie Trailer”

Year Aired: 1993

With a tier named “Binx Approved”, of course I was going to include a trailer for Hocus Pocus on my tier rank list. Like It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, the 1993 movie has not only become an iconic staple in Halloween entertainment programming, it has also become one of the most popular and marketable pieces of Halloween media. Anyone who has seen Hocus Pocus would know the film is packed with Halloween spirit, despite the trailer making little to no references to the holiday. Though the movie features suspenseful, frightening, and even sad moments, the TV spot places more emphasis on the movie’s light-hearted tone. The announcer refers to Hocus Pocus as “a bewitching new comedy” as well. With both Hocus Pocus and It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown earning the title of “classic”, I now wonder what a crossover between the two films would look like?

5. Big K-Mart – “Star Wars Halloween”

Year Aired: 1999

(27:05 – 27:35)

Anyone who has dressed up for Halloween has likely chosen a costume based on their favorite character at least once in their life. That character may have been so popular, their popularity influenced which Halloween costumes would be sought after. This Big K-Mart ad from 1999 beautifully emphasizes this concept more than other Halloween commercials featuring character-based costumes I’ve seen. With Star Wars: Episode I — The Phantom Menace being a new and popular movie at the time the advertisement aired, it makes sense for Big K-Mart to showcase the costumes they had to offer by having the featured children dress up as some of the characters from the film. But the star of the ad is a young girl whose favorite character is Queen Amidala, inspired by the knowledge that girls can be heroes too. This part of the commercial captures that childhood belief that when you have a really cool costume, anything is possible.

6. Party City – “Halloween Costume Warehouse”

Year Aired: 1999

(9:46 – 10:16)

Staying on the subject of Halloween costumes, this commercial claims Party City is the “Halloween Costume Warehouse”. Through the straight-forward nature of the 1999 ad, a voice-over and the visuals inform the viewer how Party City is not only the costume destination, but also the decoration hotspot. Shots of dancing skeletons, happy ghosts, and even an outer space alien are sprinkled throughout the commercial to give viewers a sample of the types of decorations Party City had to offer at the time. When it comes to costumes, the announcer excitedly states that there are “over four hundred children and adult costumes to choose from”. Images of character-based costumes are brought up in the advertisement, providing a nice time capsule of what was popular during 1999’s Halloween season. A wall of costume accessories and a spooky looking room full of masks place emphasis on the various offered items to help customers complete their Halloween look. Dressing up in costumes and displaying decorations are two of the most beloved traditions of the Halloween holiday. Party City’s ad captures that belief in a simple yet effective way.

7. Disneyland – “Halloween Time”

Year Aired: 2009

When Halloween and Disney theme parks are put in the same sentence, Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party usually comes to mind. But, according to my research, this event only takes place in Walt Disney World and Disneyland Paris, with the event itself being conceived because of Universal Studios’ Halloween Horror Nights. Disneyland’s “Halloween Time” commercial from 2009 showcases how the California park adapts to the holiday. Brief shots of The Twilight Zone: Tower of Terror and The Haunted Mansion highlight established attractions typically associated with Halloween. Space Mountain adopts a “Ghost Galaxy” version of its ride and “all new fireworks” are incorporated into the park’s collection of festivities. Assisting the commercial in presenting Disneyland’s Halloween spirit is a group of eight of the most well-known villains from the world of Disney animation. What I like about Halloween themed theme park advertisements, including Disneyland’s ad, is seeing how a park approaches the holiday. With Disney possessing a collection of recognizable attractions and characters, Disneyland gave viewers a commercial that, within the realm of Halloween themed amusement park ads, is “iconic”.

Harris Trinsky and the “Geeks” go Trick-or-Treating

1. Easter Seals – “Halloween Safe Coupons”

Year Aired: 1985

(29:18 – 29:48)

Vincent Price is no stranger to 18 Cinema Lane, as I have reviewed several of his films prior to this post. Therefore, I had to put one of Vincent’s commercials on my tier rank list. I selected Easter Seals’ “Halloween Safe Coupons” commercial from 1985 for a few reasons. The first is how, at the time the advertisement aired, the coupon booklets were available at AMC Theatres (now I wonder if AMC Theatres offered any coupons in those booklets?). The emphasis on a light-hearted tone, especially when Vincent says, “Halloween doesn’t have to be spooky” and “Halloween should be warm and friendly”, is the second reason. Even though these coupon booklets were intended for trick-or-treaters, Vincent’s dialogue is delivered directly to the viewer, assuming they will be handing out candy at their doorstep. While thinking about this commercial, it makes me wonder what reaction Harris and the “geeks” would have had if they received these coupons on Halloween?

2. Roy Rogers – “Halloween Big Chicken Deal”

Year Aired: 1987

(3:10 – 3:39)

When I think of Halloween, Roy Rogers and chicken dinners don’t come to mind. But because Roy Rogers commercials were far and few between in my research for this post, I figured including this 1987 commercial would be a unique addition to my tier rank list. The advertisement is bursting with Halloween festiveness; from a man dressed up as a chicken yelling “Trick or Treat” to a Halloween party taking place and even a party guest wearing a costume based on Universal Studios’ version of Frankenstein. But so much emphasis is placed on Roy Rogers’ “Big Chicken Deal”, Halloween feels more like a backdrop than a focal point. With all that said, including the commercial’s light-hearted tone, I thought the “Harris Trinsky and the “Geeks” go Trick-or-Treating” tier was the right place to put the advertisement.

3. USPS – “Universal Monsters Stamps”

Year Aired: 1997

(27:42 – 28:13)

The Universal Monsters and Halloween typically go hand in hand (or stamp, in this case). So, dedicating special edition stamps to these cinematic icons makes sense. Featuring the Universal Monsters stamps in a commercial where the featured people are watching a scary movie adds festiveness to the television spot. But I wish there was more Halloween spirit in this advertisement. Sure, one of the men in USPS’s (United States Postal Service) ad calls the stamps “spooky”. However, when other special edition stamps are showcased toward the end of the commercial, maybe Halloween themed or Fall/Autumn related stamps could have been offered as well.

4. Craftsman – “Skeleton”

Year Aired: 2007

(46:06 – 46:21)

I don’t recall ever seeing a holiday commercial specifically for hardware tools. That is why I wanted to place this Craftsman ad from 2007 onto my tier rank list, as it was another unique addition. Even though the commercial is short and straight to the point, it still possesses festiveness. Using tools to create a skeleton was such a creative and visually memorable idea. Even having a Craftsman toolbox opening to eerie music looks reminiscent of Dracula opening up his casket. Craftsman’s commercial now makes me wonder what other ways hardware tools could be presented in a holiday advertisement?

5. Universal’s Halloween Horror Nights – “Ripped from the Silver Screen”

Year Aired: 2009

(46:21 – 47:05)

For the 2009 edition of Universal Studios’ Halloween Horror Nights event, a movie theme called “Ripped from the Silver Screen” was adopted. So, it was fitting for this commercial to take place at a movie theater. But because the advertisement is for a Halloween event, the theater’s concession stand is left is disarray. Even the muffled version of the “Let’s All Go to the Lobby” jingle gives eeriness to the space created in the commercial. As the ad continues, it’s alluded the Wolfman (from Universal Studios’ collection of their Monsters), Chucky (from the Child’s Play/Chucky franchise), and Billy (from the SAW franchise) were the reason for the state of the theater’s concession stand. While Universal Studios’ commercial perfectly captures the horror movie approach they chose for their Halloween Horror Nights event and even though there was good mise-en-scène (such as a close-up shot of Chucky hiding in a popcorn machine), the ad was light on Halloween spirit. Compared to other Universal’s Halloween Horror Nights commercials, however, the “Ripped from the Silver Screen” TV spot is not as tonally dark.

6. Party City – “The Way You Look Tonight”

Year Aired: 2017

(1:10:28 – 1:11:28)

Remember when I discussed Easter Seals’ “Halloween Safe Coupons” commercial and I included Vincent’s quote about how “Halloween should be warm and friendly”? Well, in this 2017 ad, Party City took that idea and sprinted with it. Throughout the commercial, the featured people are either spending Halloween with the loved ones or feeling good about themselves because of “the way they look tonight” (yes, directly referencing the song in the advertisement was definitely intentional). The various scenes effectively showcase the types of costumes Party City offered at the time of the commercial’s airing. Selecting a sweet, wholesome tone also helps the ad put the “happy” in Happy Halloween. When I saw the young zombie boy wearing a knife headband, I couldn’t help but be reminded of Harris Trinsky’s costume in the Freaks and Geeks Halloween episode, ‘Tricks and Treats’, “a guy with a knife through his head.”

McDonald’s Boo Buckets

1. General Mills – “Count Chocula and Franken Berry”

Year Aired: 1971

With how iconic General Mills’ Monster cereals have become within the Halloween season, I was surprised Cameron didn’t put any commercials featuring Count Chocula, Franken Berry, and even Boo Berry on his tier rank list. That made me want to place, at least, one of these commercials on my list, as I originally considered putting it in the “Binx Approved” tier. But when I discovered the very first Monster cereals commercial had been archived on Youtube, I decided to place that advertisement on the tier of “McDonald’s Boo Buckets”. The 1971 commercial appears to be created with parents in mind, as the words, “vitamin charged”, lay over footage of both the Count Chocula cereal and the Franken Berry cereal. However, the commercial also seems created with children in mind, with a young boy ending Franken Berry’s and Count Chocula’s argument over who’s cereal is better by happily walking away with both boxes. Throughout the fifty-five year history of General Mills’ Monster cereals, another iconic face, Boo Berry, was introduced in 1972, followed by lesser-known characters, Fruit Brute, Yummy Mummy, and Carmella Creeper making their debuts in 1974, 1988, and 2023 respectively.

2. McDonald’s – “Halloween Safety Cup Cuffs”

Year Aired: 1971

(6:35 – 7:04)

This is another ‘70s commercial I was surprised to see absent from Cameron’s tier rank list. So, I chose to put McDonald’s ad on my list! Through my research for this post, one trend I took note of was how some commercials capitalized on trick-or-treaters’ safety. This was achieved either by delivering safety tips or creating products that would help keep children safe. In the case of the 1971 commercial, McDonald’s made safety cuffs that were given to customers wrapped around soft drink cups. According to Ronald McDonald himself, the cuffs are coated in “shiny aluminum foil with bright orange stripes so they reflect light”. But because of the quality of the advertisement, it’s difficult to see how effective the safety cup cuffs are. I’ve never seen McDonald’s safety cup cuffs in person either, so I don’t know how reflective the “shiny aluminum foil” truly is.

3. Romper Room – “Weebles Haunted House”

Year Aired: 1976

(15:25 – 15:54)

When I found this commercial from 1976, I knew I had to incorporate it on my tier rank list. That’s because the commercial, as well as the playset itself, overflows with cuteness! The “glow in the dark Weeble ghost” looks reminiscent of Casper the Friendly Ghost. There’s even an adorable, smiling ghost in a mirror on the playset’s wall. The other Weeble figures featured in the advertisement boast sillier faces, emphasizing the fun and whimsical side of Halloween. Playing over the commercial is a light-hearted jingle describing the Weebles Haunted House. The tone of the jingle, as well as the singer and announcer toward the end of the commercial, doubles down on how Halloween can be enjoyable even for the youngest of children. Two children who are shown in the commercial appear to have a good time playing with the Weebles playset. Close-up shots of the Haunted House show the children helping their Weeble figures explore the house, such as the ghost Weeble pushing a bookshelf to reveal a secret room. I couldn’t help but smile as I watched this commercial because of how it exudes joyfulness!

4. Pumpkin Kutter – “Pumpkin Kutter, Scoop, and Light”

Year Aired: 1989

(2:26 – 2:54)

While conducting research for this tier rank list, I noticed very few commercials revolving around carving pumpkins, even though this is a popular activity around Halloween. That’s the reason why I chose to put this 1989 commercial on my list. Similar to the Weebles Haunted House advertisement, the two children featured in the Pumpkin Kutter tv spot appear to have a good time carving pumpkins. Also similar to the McDonald’s Halloween Safety Cup Cuffs commercial, the Pumpkin Kutter, Scoop, and Light were created with children’s safety in mind. As both a voice-over and on-screen text point out, the Pumpkin Kutter doesn’t have sharp edges, making it safer for children to carve their own pumpkins. Though the commercial does remind viewers through on-screen text that adult supervision is advised and how “improper use could result in injury”. The aforementioned voice-over acknowledges how the Pumpkin Light “replaces dangerous candles with glowing results”. These products, along with the Pumpkin Scoop, help children gain a little bit of independence while also strengthening their fine motor skills.

5. McDonald’s – “Halloween Happy Meal”

Year Aired: 1993

(15:58 – 16:13)

The McDonald’s Boo Buckets have been a beloved tradition for forty years, adopting different looks while still retaining their festive spirit. There was even a Boo Buckets commercial in Cameron’s tier rank list video, earning a place in his highest tier. I chose the 1993 version of McDonald’s Boo Buckets commercial for my tier rank list because of the ad’s emphasis on the products’ versatility. A small collection of scenes shows the different ways the Boo Buckets can be used, ranging from storing a Happy Meal to holding Halloween candy. A little girl uses her Boo Bucket’s lid as a cookie cutter in one scene, a feature confirmed by the commercial’s narrator. Like the faces of the Weebles figures from the Weebles Haunted House commercial, the sillier faces on the 1993 version of McDonald’s Boo Buckets highlight the light-hearted, fun, and whimsical side of Halloween.

Brick Heck in a Corn Maze

1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups – “Movie Theater”

Year Aired: 1984

(1:09 – 1:39)

Because I am a movie blogger, I had to put this Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups commercial on my tier rank list, as it takes place in a movie theater. Even though the young man and woman appear to be watching a scary movie (based on their body language and the sound effects within the commercial) and even though trick-or-treaters can receive Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups on Halloween, the commercial itself is not Halloween themed. The voice-over and the jingle toward the end of the commercial emphasize the candy being advertised. Plus, there are no direct references to the holiday. But it would make sense to air this Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups commercial around Halloween because of the type of movie the young woman and man are supposedly watching and the random fog surrounding the theater’s concession stand.

2. PLUS (Project Literary US) – “Stephen King – Check it Out”

Year Aired: 1992

(31:02 – 31:32)

Stephen King’s stories and adaptations have usually been associated with Halloween, especially IT. This commercial from 1992 even incorporates spooky elements to highlight that fact, such as the sound of heavy breathing, suspenseful music, and a woman in a darkened aisle appearing frightened (before realizing Stephen just wanted to enthusiastically tell her “hi”). But Halloween is not prioritized within this advertisement. In fact, the central focus is the services a library has to offer, with these services pointed out by Stephen himself. Since I’ve never seen a library commercial before, I figured the PLUS (Project Literary US) commercial would be a unique addition to my tier rank list. Putting it in the “Brick Heck in a Corn Maze” tier was also fitting, considering Brick loves to read.

3. Coca-Cola – “Monsters of the Gridiron Contest”

Year Aired: 1993

(6:47 – 7:17)

With football season overlapping with Halloweentime, it would be fitting to find this commercial airing on television leading up to Halloween. But none of the people featured in the advertisement, including the announcer, ever bring Halloween up. Sure, there are two NFL (National Football League) football players dressed up in elaborate costumes. And the contest is called ‘Monsters of the Gridiron’. However, Coca-Cola’s commercial emphasizes football, with the majority of the contest’s prizes related to the NFL, such as tickets to the Super Bowl. Though the idea of seeing a player from your favorite football team dressed up for Halloween sounds like a cool, festive concept.

4. Target – “The Twilight Zone: Tower of Terror Sweepstakes”

Year Aired: 1994

Unlike the commercials I’ve discussed in this tier so far, this 1994 Target commercial is Halloween themed, as the voice-over informs the viewer the Studor family’s (the family featured in the commercial) “shopping trip for Halloween supplies was unlike any other”. But that’s the only reference to the holiday made in this entire advertisement. The majority of the commercial is devoted not just to The Twilight Zone, but also the Walt Disney World ride, The Twilight Zone: Tower of Terror (which was new at the time of the commercial’s airing). As soon as the Studor family receive their game card, the imagery changes from color to black-to-white. The music and sound effects playing in the background help present the illusion the commercial’s events are taking place within the world of The Twilight Zone. Even the announcer’s voice sounds similar to Rod Serling’s voice. Reflecting on the creative effort that was put into this commercial, it kind of makes me wish the 1997 TV movie, Tower of Terror, felt more reminiscent of The Twilight Zone television show.

5. Skittles – “Gargoyles”

Year Aired: 2000

(0:37 – 0:52)

Similar to Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups’ “Movie Theater” commercial, Skittles’ “Gargoyles” commercial isn’t Halloween themed, yet advertises candy trick-or-treaters could receive on Halloween. Despite the lack of references to the holiday, Skittles’ ad looks and feels complimentary of the Halloween season. The combination of a darker color palette, eerie music, a bell chiming, and two gargoyles coming to life create a spooky ambience. The visually striking presentation of the commercial leaves me, as a viewer, wanting to know more about this little world Skittles created. What woke the gargoyles from their stoney slumber; the young boy’s imagination or the candy itself? I’d love to see a movie based on this commercial!

6. Phantom of the Megaplex – “Original Promo”

Year Aired: 2000

If you’ve followed 18 Cinema Lane long enough, you would know how much I love Phantom of the Megaplex. Since the film’s release in 2000, Disney Channel has incorporated Phantom of the Megaplex into their Halloween themed programming line-ups. I’ve even heard some say they like to watch this movie around Halloween. However, Phantom of the Megaplex is not Halloween themed. Not only did the film premiere on November 10th, I believe the story takes place in the summer. But I can understand why this DCOM (Disney Channel Original Movie) would be chosen as someone’s Halloween viewing, as Phantom of the Megaplex contains enough spooky and mysterious elements to compliment the holiday.

7. IHOP – “Fall Pancakes”

Year Aired: 2018

(5:16 – 5:49)

IHOP (International House of Pancakes) has hosted several themed promotions on their menu over the years. In 2018, one themed promotion was based on the Fall/Autumn season. As a talking pumpkin explains in the commercial, some of the menu choices included “eggs your way, hickory smoked bacon, and a side of Cinn-a-Stack Pancakes topped with cream cheese icing”. The menu also included “Pumpkin Spice Pancakes made with real pumpkin”. The talking pumpkin isn’t the only pumpkin featured in the commercial, as several orange and white pumpkins surround the entrance of someone’s house. This same entrance is decorated with other fall related décor as well, such as bales of hay, corn stalks, and even a set of lanterns. However, as I already mentioned in this discussion of IHOP’s commercial, the restaurant’s promotion was Fall/Autumn themed, with no mention of Halloween. But because the holiday falls (see what I did there?) in the middle of the Fall/Autumn season, it would have been appropriate to air IHOP’s advertisement throughout the month of October.

Have fun on Halloween!

Sally Silverscreen

A Movie Blogger’s Ten “Hot Takes” on Television

I published a list article last December about my ten “hot takes” on film. That was the first time I had ever written a list exclusively about movie “hot takes”. Since publishing that article, it has been well received by 18 Cinema Lane’s readers, obtaining over one thousand views. This success inspired me to write another “hot takes” list. But this time, I’ll be discussing my ten “hot takes” on television, as I have talked about TV shows and television related topics from time to time on my blog. Like my movie “hot takes” list, all my TV “hot takes” have never been brought up on 18 Cinema Lane before, in order to keep the list interesting and fresh. Also, like my movie “hot takes” list, I organized each television “hot take” based on how “hot” each take could be perceived. Before I begin this list, I’d like to state how my list is not intended to be mean-spirited or negative. It’s just simply a way to express my opinion.

Campfire with marshmellows and shooting stars image created by macrovector at freepik.com.

10. Harris Trinsky Should Have Appeared in the Freaks and Geeks episode, ‘Chokin’ and Tokin’’

Last year, I published an editorial explaining the similarities between Harris Trinsky (from Freaks and Geeks) and Eddie Munson (from Stranger Things). One of my main talking points was how Harris (as well as Eddie) showed his leadership through putting others before himself, using the example of Harris’ attempts to protect the younger “geeks” (Bill, Sam, and Neil) from Alan (the “freshman tormentor”/bully of the “geeks”) in the Freaks and Geeks’ Halloween episode, “Tricks and Treats”. But another episode I think Harris should have appeared in is “Chokin’ and Tokin’”. In this episode, Alan believes Bill is lying about having a peanut allergy. To prove Bill is telling the truth, Alan contaminates Bill’s sandwich with peanuts, causing Bill to have a severe allergic reaction. Had Harris appeared in “Chokin’ and Tokin’”, the audience could have seen how Bill’s emergency affected him, especially since a) Harris knows what Alan is capable of when it comes to his bullying behavior, b) Harris was bullied when he was a freshman (to the point his tailbone became broken), and c) Harris knows about Bill’s peanut allergy (Bill admitted this while Harris and the “geeks” went trick-or-treating in the episode, “Tricks and Treats”). The dynamic of the friendship between Harris and the “geeks” not only could have been further explored, the audience also could have learned more about Harris, better understanding why he is an older brother figure to the “geeks”. I think this aspect of the story would have been more compelling than the redemption arc Freaks and Geeks’ creative team tried giving Alan in “Chokin’ and Tokin’”, which I, personally, don’t believe was affective. This “hot take” is placed at the bottom of my list due to Freaks and Geeks lasting only one season.

9. Moses Valentine, from Miss Scarlet, Should Have Received His Own Spin-off Show

While I have talked about Miss Scarlet before on my blog, I’ve never talked about my favorite character from the show, Moses Valentine. For three seasons, he possessed a captivatingly commanding presence, using his charm and street smarts to help Eliza Scarlet (the show’s titular character) solve mysteries. In the third episode of Miss Scarlet’s sixth season, ‘The Delivery’, the story primarily revolves around Moses as he searches for a missing diamond. Not only was this the best episode from the sixth season (in my opinion), it made me wish Moses had received his own spin-off show. From seasons four to six, Moses has been living in Paris. This backdrop could have given the spin-off show a colorful landscape and an eccentric group of characters, allowing the show to be distinct from Miss Scarlet’s London environment. It was revealed in ‘The Delivery’ and the fifth episode of Miss Scarlet’s sixth season, ‘The Night Shift’, that Moses is not only married, he also has a son. His family would have offered a unique dynamic from Miss Scarlet, as Eliza is not married and isn’t a mother. There could have even been a crossover episode between Moses’ spin-off show and Miss Scarlet, where Eliza visits Moses in Paris and helps him solve a mystery. But, sadly, a Moses centered spin-off show will likely not happen because the seventh season of Miss Scarlet will be the show’s last.

8. I Don’t Think Lauren Should Have Won the Reach for the Stars Competition in the Matlock episode, ‘The Starlet’

Toward the beginning of the Matlock episode, ‘The Starlet’, a talent contest called the Reach for the Stars Competition takes place. Whoever wins the competition will receive a two-year studio contract, a brand-new car, and $25,000. The final four contestants, Morgan, Dana, Abby, and Lauren, have their talent performances featured in ‘The Starlet’. While Morgan captivated by singing an energetic pop song, Abby sang a country song that sounded like it came straight from the heart. Dana’s performance of a song on saxophone was solid, adding her strong contribution to the soundtrack of the 1980s. But Lauren’s performance, which helped her win the Reach for the Stars Competition, was, in my opinion, unimpressive compared to the aforementioned three performances. Lauren performed a dance routine that was, to put it simply, basic. Its contents were a few arm movements, stepping in place several times, and some simple turns. I know Lauren’s victory was intended to create a domino effect for the events that took place in ‘The Starlet’. I also recognize what the creative team behind this Matlock episode was trying to say about connections being prioritized over talent when it comes to success, as Lauren’s mother, Janet, won the very first Reach for the Stars Competition. But I still don’t think Lauren should have won the contest based on talent performance alone.

7. I wish Tommy Vaughn Hadn’t Been the Murder Victim in the Murder, She Wrote episode, ‘Murder in Tempo’

In the Murder, She Wrote episode, ‘Murder in Tempo’, Dr. Seth Hazlitt organizes a benefit concert in an effort to save a local forest called Cabot Woods, with a band named In Tempo being the stars of the concert. One of In Tempo’s band members, Tommy Vaughn, has a dinner plate full of personal issues; from alcohol dependency that led him to rehab to dealing with a stalker prior to coming to Cabot Cove and even almost getting shot during the band’s concert rehearsal. But during his interactions with a Cabot Cove resident named Rachel, there are glimmers of hope that Tommy could, potentially, turn his life around. In a conversation he shared with Rachel, Tommy confesses his father passed away in an alcoholic ward, admitting his father’s issues made him look at the world pessimistically. He also acknowledges how he’s developed a poor reputation and how he needs to seek medical attention when he experiences problems with his vocal cords. Tommy even agreed to perform at the benefit concert because he truly believed in the cause of saving Cabot Woods, refusing to quit the concert despite pressure from the band’s manager, Wylie Trey. I’m aware Murder, She Wrote possesses a limited number of recurring characters and ‘Murder in Tempo’ premiered within the show’s last season. But I’d like to think if Tommy’s life had been spared, he would have received a second chance to obtain a happier next chapter to his story. Tommy could have even appeared in one of Murder, She Wrote’s made-for-TV movies or one of the books from the Murder, She Wrote book series. While advocating for the preservation of Cabot Woods, Jessica Fletcher says, “But even small battles are important”. Sadly, Tommy never got the chance to win at least one of his “small battles”.

Since one of my television “hot takes” relates to Murder, She Wrote, I thought featuring the book cover for Murder, She Wrote: Dying to Retire in this list article made sense. Murder, She Wrote: Dying to Retire book cover found on Goodreads

6. One of the HGTV Dream Homes Should Have Been Built in Hawaii

For almost thirty years, HGTV (Home and Garden Television) has hosted their annual Dream Home sweepstakes, with a completely furnished house as the grand prize. Eighteen of the fifty United States have hosted a prize home in varying styles and diverse landscapes. But, in my opinion, one of those states should have been Hawaii. The “gimmick” of HGTV’s Dream Home sweepstakes is for someone to win a “dream” home in a “dream” location. For years, Hawaii has been known as a “dream” travel destination for many people, yet owning a home in Hawaii is a “dream” few people can achieve for a variety of reasons. Realistically, I’m not sure what the logistics would be in order to make an HGTV Dream Home in Hawaii a reality. On paper, however, a Hawaiian Dream Home would fit the intent of HGTV’s contest.

5. I wish Sophia’s Son, Phil, Had Made, At Least, One On-Screen Appearance on The Golden Girls

Looking back on all the times I’ve watched The Golden Girls, one consistent story element always comes to mind; how Sophia singles out her son, Phil, whenever she brought up her children. Because it seemed like he was mentioned often on the show, I always wondered if what was said about him by the other characters was true. This curiosity made me want to see, at least, one on-screen appearance of him, in order to learn more about Phil from his perspective. Unfortunately, this never happened as Phil died off screen, with his death acknowledged in the season six episode, ‘Ebbtide’s Revenge’. It would have been fascinating to see Phil’s interactions not only with Sophia, but with the other “golden girls” as well. Plus, this role would have given an up-and-coming or underrated actor a chance to start or progress his career, especially considering The Golden Girls is one of the most successful and beloved television shows of all time. It also would have been interesting to see how The Golden Girls’ audience responded to Phil’s appearance on the show, if perhaps he had become a fan favorite. Though to quote the iconic Tootsie Pop commercial, “the world may never know”.

4. I Don’t Find the Gilligan’s Island episode, ‘The Hunter’, Funny or Entertaining

Gilligan’s Island is a show that is known for being light-hearted and hilarious, typically presenting the characters in low-stakes situations despite being stranded on the titular island. But the episode, ‘The Hunter’ is quite different from what the show is known for. Jonathan Kincaid is introduced in this episode as a big-game hunter. When he is unable to find any animals on the island to hunt, Jonathan then decides to hunt the other characters. The story of ‘The Hunter’ is tonally inappropriate for the type of program Gilligan’s Island is. With the show’s laugh track still featured in this episode, it makes the characters’ fear seem like it is played for laughs instead of being taken seriously. I was so horrified by ‘The Hunter’, I couldn’t find anything entertaining or funny about it. I, honestly, questioned what the creative team behind Gilligan’s Island was thinking creating and airing the episode. Because ‘The Hunter’ has been received better than other episodes of Gilligan’s Island, obtaining a 7.3 out of 10 on IMDB, this “hot take” is ranked higher on my list.

3. I Don’t Understand the Hype Surrounding ‘Shark Week’

According to Wikipedia, Shark Week debuted almost forty years ago on Discovery Channel with educational intentions, emphasizing conservation and debunking misconceptions. But as time went on, the annual event grew a life of its own. The term “shark week” has been added to the pop cultural lexicon, with people knowing what that is even if they’ve never watched any program associated with the event. Merchandise has been created to capitalize Shark Week, from shirts to scouting patches and even stuffed animal sharks from Build-A-Bear Workshop. But despite the promotion and fanfare it’s received, I don’t understand the hype surrounding Shark Week. With the amount of information available about sharks now than there was thirty-eight years ago, it almost seems unnecessary to reserve only one week to shark related education. In fact, shark related education can be accessed any time of year. Because sharks are such a specific subject, the event could run the risk of running out of content or programming. Plus, there are other animals who would also benefit from receiving education about them and conversation efforts for them. Yet they don’t receive their own special week.

2. If Eddie Munson Had Been Introduced on Stranger Things Sooner, The Show’s Creative Team Would Have Prioritized His Popularity, Similar to Steve Urkel (from Family Matters)

Once upon a time, on December 15th, 1989, Steve Urkel made his debut on the sitcom, Family Matters. What started as Steve asking one of the show’s key family members, Laura Winslow, to a dance turned into Steve becoming one of the most popular characters in television history. As Steve’s popularity grew, he received more screen-time and significance in the story. He not only became very marketable, having products based off Steve like Urkel-O’s Cereal and a talking doll, Family Matters also became defined by Steve’s iconic catchphrase, “Did I do that?”. But Steve’s popularity came at the expense of the titular Winslow family and their matters, which defied the original intent of the sitcom. If Eddie Munson had been introduced on Stranger Things sooner, I believe the show’s creative team would have allowed a similar scenario to happen. Like Steve Urkel, Eddie Munson became very popular after appearing in one season of his respective show. Also, like Steve, Eddie became very marketable, with products ranging from a replica of his Hellfire Club shirt to books about Eddie’s side of the story. But Eddie made his debut in Stranger Things’ fourth out of five seasons, with Eddie also passing away at the end of the fourth season. Though if Eddie had debuted in either season one or two, Eddie’s popularity would have given the show’s creative team an excuse to not only keep him on the show, but to also upgrade his status from ‘recurring’ to ‘main’ character. But, similar to Steve on Family Matters, the emphasis on Eddie’s popularity could have run the risk of other characters and stories getting overshadowed, potentially leaving mysteries and story-threads unresolved. There’s also a chance Stranger Things‘ creative team could have turned Eddie into “too much of a good thing”, giving Eddie elements to his story that may not make sense, such as receiving a catchphrase that seems unnecessary.

1. Writing Jack Thornton Off When Calls the Heart is the Show’s Biggest Mistake

    When the creative team behind When Calls the Heart decided to write Jack Thornton (one of the show’s main characters) off the show by having him die off screen, that was one of the most controversial creative decisions in Hallmark Channel history, as characters are typically not written off the network’s programs in this fashion. But looking back on this creative choice eight years later, writing Jack off When Calls the Heart has proven, in my opinion, to be pointless. If Jack had stayed on the show, other creative decisions I’m, personally, not a fan of wouldn’t have been made. Some of these decisions are the love triangle between Elizabeth, Lucas, and Nathan (that lasted three seasons), as well as backtracking Elizabeth’s decision to fall in love with and become engaged to Lucas. When it comes to the argument for why Elizabeth should be in a romantic relationship with Nathan, the McGarries (fans of Elizabeth and Nathan) have claimed that because Elizabeth falls in love with a Mountie in the book series the show is based on, she has to fall in love with a Mountie on the television show. With that logic in mind, if it was so important for Elizabeth to be in a romantic relationship with a Mountie, why write Jack off the show at all? I’m aware of Daniel Lissing’s (the actor who portrayed Jack) desire to leave the show to pursue other projects. However, I think recasting Jack would have attracted less backlash than writing him off the show. When Jack was still on When Calls the Heart, it seemed like his relationship with Elizabeth organically complimented the show’s overarching story. It also helped that Daniel and Erin Krakow (the actress who portrays Elizabeth) had stronger on-screen chemistry together. But now that Elizabeth and Nathan’s relationship has been prioritized since season eleven, its promotion, in my opinion, not only feels forcefully manufactured, it has come at the expense of other characters and stories, such as Rosemary, once again, not receiving her theater and new characters like Fernando becoming underutilized.

    Since another television “hot take” in this list article relates to Eddie Munson and Stranger Things, I believed including this iconic picture of Eddie in this post was appropriate. Original image created by 21 Laps Entertainment, Monkey Massacre, Netflix, and Upside Down Pictures

    What are your thoughts on my TV “hot takes”? Do you have a TV related “hot take” you’d like to share? Please tell me in the comment section below!

    Have fun on television!

    Sally Silverscreen

    Top Ten Actors and Actresses Who Should Have Starred in a Hallmark Hall of Fame Movie

    I haven’t talked about anything Hallmark Hall of Fame related since last August, when I reviewed the 1990 presentation, Face to Face. To make up for lost time, I decided to write a list article about a topic associated with this collection of Hallmark’s movies. With Hallmark Hall of Fame lasting from 1951 to 2019, numerous actors and actresses have graced television screens in one or several projects from this branch of Hallmark programming. But there are some actors and actresses who never received that opportunity. So, in this list, I will be selecting five actors and five actresses who, in my opinion, should have starred in a Hallmark Hall of Fame movie. While the chosen actresses and actors are categorized in no particular order, they were selected based on two criteria: 1) the trajectory of their career in correlation with the existence of Hallmark Hall of Fame and 2) if their acting talents would have been well utilized within the types of stories Hallmark Hall of Fame told.

    Hallmark Hall of Fame logo created by Hallmark Entertainment and Hallmark Hall of Fame Productions

    1. Stephen Lang

      I will admit I’ve seen only three projects from Stephen Lang’s filmography; Don’t Breathe, Death of a Salesman, and 2009’s Avatar. But from what I remember, Stephen put a great amount of effort and care into his roles. Even based on some of his interviews I have seen and heard, it seems like Stephen takes the roles given to him very seriously. With all this said, I truly believe he would have brought that same amount of care and effort into a Hallmark Hall of Fame title. Plus, according to IMDB, Death of a Salesman is labeled a “tv movie”. Therefore, Stephen has some experience working in the realm of made-for-tv cinema. Had the opportunity to star in a Hallmark Hall of Fame movie presented itself, I wonder what type of role Stephen would have received, let alone what type of movie he would have been cast in?

      2. Jane Seymour

      Throughout her career, Jane Seymour has starred in several Hallmark films; Lake Effects, Dear Prudence, Perfectly Prudence, and A Royal Christmas. You’d think with Jane’s connection to Hallmark, as well as her star power, she would have starred in, at least, one Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation. But surprisingly, this opportunity never came to be. Besides her appearance in Hallmark’s movies, Jane has starred in projects that were related to the historical fiction genre, such as Somewhere in Time and Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman. In fact, I’m surprised Hallmark Hall of Fame and the creative team behind Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman didn’t work together to create a television event related to the show. This idea actually would have made sense, especially since Hallmark Hall of Fame was broadcast on the same network as Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman during the show’s lifespan.

      Hallmark Hall of Fame’s A Tale of Two Cities poster created by Hallmark Hall of Fame Productions, Marble Arch Productions, Norman Rosemont Productions, and Columbia Broadcasting System (CBS)

      3. Michael Wincott

      I recently talked about Michael Wincott in my review of an episode from Miami Vice. Based on his performances I’ve seen, Michael has consistently displayed an understanding, as well as control, over his character’s emotions. His adaptability has also been very chameleon-like. If given the opportunity to star in a Hallmark Hall of Fame film, I believe Michael could have helped create a character with a captivating presence. Even though the movies in the Hallmark Hall of Fame collection were primarily dramatic in tone, various genres were covered within this series. Therefore, I think Michael’s acting talents could have been best utilized in a film from either the historical fiction, western, or mystery genre.

      4. Bai Ling

      I’ve seen several projects from Bai Ling’s filmography, including the 2001 Hallmark movie, The Lost Empire/The Monkey King. The one consistent strength I have noticed within these projects is Bai’s strong sense of emotionality. Whether in a made-for-tv movie or a theatrically released title, Bai’s understanding and utilization of her character’s emotions have added depth to her performances. I could have seen this acting strength incorporated into a Hallmark Hall of Fame movie, especially since, like I mentioned earlier, movies in the Hallmark Hall of Fame collection were primarily dramatic in tone. Since I have seen Bai star in at least one film from the mystery and fantasy genre, it would have been interesting to see what a fantasy or mystery Hallmark Hall of Fame movie starring Bai would have looked like. Or perhaps the Hallmark Hall of Fame collection could have given her a chance to tackle a genre I haven’t seen her appear in before.

      5. Vincent Perez

      If you have followed 18 Cinema Lane long enough, you would know one of the best movies ever reviewed on the blog was Swept from the Sea. Vincent Perez’s portrayal of Yanko is one of the reasons why. There were times in Swept from the Sea where, by utilizing emotion, he was able to say so much without saying anything at all. Vincent’s acting versatility not only made his performance captivating, it was also both heart-warming and heart-breaking. I’ve liked his performance from his other movies I have seen, from his emotional intensity in The Crow: City of Angels to his sincerity in Cyrano de Bergerac. Even in 2004’s Frankenstein (a movie I didn’t like), Vincent’s performance is one of the few good aspects of that film. I guess the 1998 HBO movie, Shot Through the Heart, is the closest thing to seeing Vincent in a Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation I’ll ever get.

      Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Caroline? poster created by Hallmark Hall of Fame productions, CBS, and Republic Pictures Home Video

      6. Jasmine Guy

      Whenever I think of Jasmine Guy, I think of her portrayal of Kathleen on Touched by An Angel. I also think about how strong Jasmine’s performance was on that show. Kathleen became a character I looked forward to seeing appear on screen. This was the result of the expressiveness, sassiness, and charisma Jasmine brought to her role. She even had good on-screen chemistry will Bill Nunn in the Touched by An Angel episode, “Lost and Found”, as it sold the concept of Kathleen and Bill’s character, Frank, being compatible, under different circumstances. Since Touched by An Angel was more dramatic in tone, like the Hallmark Hall of Fame collection, Jasmine’s portrayal of Kathleen gave me an idea how Jasmine’s acting talents could have been utilized within a Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation.

      7. Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje

      Fans of the television show, Lost, will recognize Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje as the actor who portrayed Mr. Eko. Adewale’s performance on that show is one of the reasons why I liked Mr. Eko as a character. His captivating presence commanded attention from the audience, which sometimes made Mr. Eko intimidating. Yet, the kind-hearted and thoughtful persona Adewale gave to Mr. Eko also allowed his character to be approachable, making the audience want to get to know Mr. Eko and see where the story took him next. Adewale’s acting versatility would have been such a valuable asset in a Hallmark Hall of Fame project. What also worked in Adewale’s favor is his chemistry with the other cast members on Lost. This acting element would have been beneficial to any Hallmark Hall of Fame movie, especially since some films from Hallmark Hall of Fame featured ensemble casts.

      Redwood Curtain poster created by Chris/Rose Productions, Hallmark Hall of Fame Productions, American Broadcasting Company (ABC), and Republic Pictures (II)

      8. Hayley Mills

      Hayley Mills was at the height of her popularity in the 1960s. Plus, based on her performances I have seen, Hayley has been able to utilize her expressions and emotions to make her characters seem as believable as possible. With these facts in mind, I’m surprised Hallmark Hall of Fame didn’t try to capitalize on Hayley’s popularity and talent by offering her a role in one of their films. When it comes to Hallmark Hall of Fame’s movies from the 1960s, I haven’t seen any of them. But based on my research, it appears these projects were either adaptations of plays, literature, or historical events. Because Hayley has starred in dramatic films like The Chalk Garden, I believe Hayley’s acting talents could have been incorporated well into one of these genres.

      9. Dulé Hill

      Dulé Hill is best known for his role as Burton “Gus” Guster from the television show, Psych. However, I’m more familiar with his performance on Suits as Alex Williams. Though it’s been a while since I’ve seen Suits, I remember Alex was introduced later in the show’s lifespan. Despite this, Dulé’s adaptability allowed his character to share chemistry with the other characters, making me as a viewer feel like Alex was always meant to be on the show. Dulé’s television experience, as well as his experience alongside an ensemble cast, worked in his favor. These acting qualities and Dulé’s name recognition from Psych could have given a Hallmark Hall of Fame film a built-in audience. Plus, I have heard Dulé is a tap dancer, so maybe Hallmark Hall of Fame could have incorporated his dancing talents into a musical.

      10. Joanne Whalley

      Back in 1994, Joanne Whalley starred in the movie/mini-series, Scarlett. When I reviewed it back in 2021, I said the mini-series/movie was a competently made project where the creative team behind it clearly knew what they were doing. This statement holds true for Joanne’s performance, as she did a fine job with the acting material provided. Since Hallmark was one of Scarlett’s distributors and since the movie/mini-series premiered on the same network Hallmark Hall of Fame’s movies aired on, it would have made sense if Joanne had been chosen to star in a Hallmark Hall of Fame movie. I’ve also seen Joanne star in at least one historical fiction and one fantasy film, which are two genres that have been explored within the Hallmark Hall of Fame collection. But, for whatever reason, the opportunity to work on a Hallmark Hall of Fame project never came to fruition for Joanne.

      Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Christmas Everlasting poster created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel. Image found at https://www.crownmediapress.com/Shows/PRShowDetail?SiteID=142&FeedBoxID=845&NodeID=302&ShowType=&ShowTitle=Christmas+Everlasting

      Have fun at the movies!

      Sally Silverscreen

      A Movie Blogger’s Ten “Hot Takes” on Film

      Back in August, I published my review of the Hallmark Hall of Fame movie, Face to Face. That article became my 425th published movie review. Then, when I published my review of Kind Hearts and Coronets, it became my 950th published post. To honor these milestones, I’m creating a type of list I have never written before. Over the seven years 18 Cinema Lane has existed, I have shared some of my “hot takes” on film. However, I haven’t created a list exclusively about movie “hot takes”. That is why, for this list, I will address my film related “hot takes” I didn’t previously discuss on my blog. This decision was made to keep the list itself fresh and interesting. I will also organize each “hot take” based on how “hot” each take could be perceived. Before I begin this list, I’d like to state how my list is not intended to be mean-spirited or negative. It’s just simply a way to express my opinion.

      Campfire with marshmellows and shooting stars image created by macrovector at freepik.com.

      10. Sister Act 2: Back in the Habit Should Have Been a Christmas Movie

      I’m not saying Sister Act 2: Back in the Habit is a bad movie. I’m not even saying it’s a bad sequel, as I respect how the script tries to tell a new story instead of attempting to recapture the magic of the first film. However, I do believe it was a huge missed opportunity not to have Sister Act 2: Back in the Habit set during Christmas. I can picture Saint Katherine’s Parish, the church featured in the first movie, beautifully decked out in Christmas adornments. And can you imagine what Christmas songs like ‘O Holy Night’, ‘Away in a Manger’, and ‘Joy to the World’ would have sounded like under Deloris’/Sister Mary Clarence’s leadership? If those versions were even half as good as the songs were in Sister Act, the audience would have been in for a musical treat! Though there’s no guarantee making Sister Act 2: Back in the Habit a Christmas movie would have made it better or just as good as its predecessor. Therefore, this is the mildest “hot take” on my list.

      9. Calypso/Tia Dalma and Davy Jones Should Have Shared More Screen-Time Together in Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End

      One of my favorite movie scenes of all time is Calypso/Tia Dalma and Davy Jones’ interaction in Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End. Not only does this scene recontextualize everything the audience knew about Calypso/Tia Dalma up until that point, Naomie Harris and Bill Nighy’s on-screen chemistry made the attraction between Calypso/Tia Dalma and Davy Jones believable. This attraction makes me wish they shared more screen-time together. Throughout Calypso/Tia Dalma and Davy Jones’ interaction, issues are left unresolved and words are left unspoken. Yet their love for each other is still evident. Calypso/Tia Dalma and Davy Jones should have received an opportunity to resolve their issues and honestly communicate with one another. But in a movie like Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End with so many moving parts to it, aspects of the story like Calypso/Tia Dalma and Davy Jones’ relationship were overlooked.

      8. Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch’s Story in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) Should Have Been an Adaptation of Scarlet Witch, Vol. 3: The Final Hex

      For this year’s Eurovisionathon readathon, I read Scarlet Witch, Vol. 3: The Final Hex. As I read the graphic novel, I couldn’t help but feel the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) missed a great opportunity to adapt this story. Based on what I know about the MCU, mentor figures aren’t common. Agatha Harkness could have provided mentorship to Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch like she did in the graphic novel, helping guide her throughout Phase 2 and beyond. Adapting Scarlet Witch, Vol. 3: The Final Hex would have given the MCU a reason to weave Serbian and Roma culture into Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch’s, as well as Pietro Maximoff/Quicksilver’s, narrative. Themes of family, identity, and what it truly means to be a superhero could have also been explored. While I haven’t seen any of the MCU’s projects after Avengers: Endgame, I have heard of the directions Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch’s story have taken. Had Scarlet Witch, Vol. 3: The Final Hex been adapted, maybe her story would have been better than what the audience received.

      7. Cheryl Frasier from Miss Congeniality is More Intelligent Than Most People Give Her Credit For

      The “April 25th” scene from Miss Congeniality is one of the most quotable and meme-able moments in film history. This scene is how most people know Cheryl Frasier (a.k.a. Miss Rhode Island), one of the story’s key characters. The moment where Cheryl chooses “April 25th” as her answer for her idea of a perfect date is presented as giving the wrong answer. Though whenever I think of this scene, I see it very differently. In an interview/question segment of a pageant, contestants must utilize their time wisely to earn enough points to progress to the next segment. With that said, Cheryl utilized critical thinking skills, logic, and looking outside the box to not only select her iconic answer, but to also come up with an explanation for that answer all within a limited period of time. Plus, I can understand how she would describe a date on the calendar, as the question is vague enough to be interpreted in different ways. This is one of the best examples from Miss Congeniality of Cheryl being more intelligent than most people give her credit for.

      6. Pennywise from Stephen King’s IT (1990) is More Annoying Than Scary

      Years ago, I saw Stephen King’s IT for the first time. But I found the experience underwhelming. One contributor was how Pennywise was more annoying than scary. While there were horrifying moments involving Pennywise, these moments were far and few between. One scene that always comes to mind is when Pennywise is in a library. In this scene, he was so over-the-top, loud, and obnoxious, his act got old really fast. I couldn’t take Pennywise seriously as a horror movie villain, as his silliness made him less threatening. Even in the film’s climax, his role was such a let-down, sucking all the suspense out of that scene. Tim Curry, the actor who portrayed Pennywise, is not at fault because he tried his best with the acting material provided. The fault lies with the director and screenwriters of Stephen King’s IT.

      Group of Christmas figures image created by Pikisuperstar at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/christmas”>Christmas vector created by Pikisuperstar – Freepik.com</a>. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/hand-drawn-cute-christmas-character_3188970.htm’>Designed by Pikisuperstar</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

      5. Gabby Gabby from Toy Story 4 is a Poorly Written Character

      When I saw Toy Story 4 in 2019, I thought Gabby Gabby was a poorly written character. Six years later, I still feel this way about her. It seemed like the creative team behind Toy Story 4 couldn’t decide if Gabby Gabby should be the story’s villain, anti-hero, or simply misunderstood. So, instead of giving her one role and sticking to that creative decision, the creative team gave her all three roles. When Gabby Gabby received a redemption arc, I didn’t feel that was earned. How am I supposed to root for her when I don’t even know what her true role in this story is supposed to be? Last year, when I published my list of ten movie trends I don’t understand, I explained how adopting the ‘villains receiving the spotlight’ trend gives the audience mixed messages and makes villainous characters less straight-forward. Reflecting on that list and Toy Story 4, I wonder if how Gabby Gabby was written is the result of that trend?

      4. ‘Elizabeth’ is the Most Overused Name in Historical Fiction/Period Drama Movies and TV Shows

      In 2019, I created a list of the top ten worst clichés from Hallmark movies. The clichés featured in that list were those that were poorly or overly used. If I created a similar list about the worst clichés from historical fiction/period drama movies, characters named ‘Elizabeth’ would be near the top of the list. Personally, I find it hard to believe directors, producers, and screenwriters would keep selecting ‘Elizabeth’ despite having thousands of names at their disposal. The name, ‘Elizabeth’, keeps finding its way into scripts no matter the story’s time period. Some examples include Felicity: An American Girl Adventure, the Pirates of the Caribbean series, any version of Pride and Prejudice, and When Calls the Heart’s Christmas/seasonal films. This specific cliché is also present among historical fiction/period drama tv shows, ranging from Emily of New Moon to The Waltons. I don’t know when the cliché started being utilized or if it will ever stop. But if someone is considering creating a historical fiction/period drama movie or tv show, I hope they think outside the box when it’s time to name their characters.

      3. I Don’t Find National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation Funny

      I’ve only seen National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation once. Though it’s been years since I’ve seen it, I didn’t find it funny. I don’t remember laughing at any joke. Even when I see clips of the movie in other pieces of media, it doesn’t get a reaction out of me. I’m aware how comedy, as well as film itself, is subjective. But I just don’t understand the hype around National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation. If I revisited the movie, maybe I’d change my mind on it. For now, though, National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation is not a must-watch title for me this Christmas season.

      2. Bucky Barnes Should Have Received His Own Superhero Title Instead of Becoming the Next Captain America

      Around the time Avengers: Infinity War was released, I was one of those fans who wanted to see Bucky Barnes become the next Captain America. I even expressed this wish in my very first movie blogger’s Christmas wish-list. But looking back almost ten years since Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame premiered, I believe instead of becoming the next Captain America, Bucky should have received his own superhero title. As he grew into it over time, Bucky could have shaped this brand-new title to become truly his. So, when people think of that specific title, they’ll think of Bucky and vice versa. There would be no preconceived ideas or expectations due to the lack of comparisons to measure Bucky to. With his own superhero title, he could have received official Avenger status as well, which is why I wanted Bucky to become the next Captain America in the first place. I know he took up Captain America’s shield in Marvel’s comics. However, Bucky adopting his own, unique superhero identity would have added a fascinating chapter to Phases 4 and 5.

      1. The Breakfast Club and Clue are Two of the Most Overrated Movies of the 1980s

      It’s been years since I’ve seen The Breakfast Club or Clue. But from what I remember, I wasn’t a fan of either title. The Breakfast Club contained way too much swearing for my liking and I found its story too simplistic. When it came to Allison Reynolds’ reason for being in detention, the script was building up to what ended up being an underwhelming revelation. Meanwhile, in Clue, I laughed at only one joke throughout the entire film. The movie prioritized showing the characters running around and yelling/screaming at each other, which I find less hilarious and more headache-inducing. Having multiple endings based on when and where someone saw the film might work at the movie theater. Including all three endings in Clue, however, not only felt overwhelming, it also felt like the movie’s creative team couldn’t decide which ending best fit their script, leaving that ultimate decision to the audience. Perhaps if I revisited The Breakfast Club or Clue, my opinion on these titles might change. As of the publication of this list, though, I find Clue and The Breakfast Club overrated.

      Avengers: Endgame Bucky Barnes poster created by The Walt Disney Company and Marvel Studios. © Disney•Pixar. All rights reserved. Marvel and Avengers Characters: ©2017 Marvel. Image found at https://www.marvel.com/articles/movies/mcu-heroes-unveil-avengers-endgame-character-posters

      What are your thoughts on my movie “hot takes”? Do you have a film related “hot take” you’d like to share? Please tell me in the comment section below!

      Have fun at the movies!

      Sally Silverscreen

      Thirteen Questions for When Calls the Heart’s 13th Season

      It’s been a while since I’ve written a list article. In fact, the last time I wrote any kind of list article was when I published my list of the top ten best stand-alone films back in March. It has also been a while since I published anything Hallmark related, as I reviewed Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back in April. To make up for lost time, I decided to create a list of thirteen questions I have for When Calls the Heart’s 13th season! With the announcement of any new television season comes a series of questions and speculation from the fans. Though these questions will not be answered until next year, a list like mine gives Hearties something to think about while they wait for the show to come back. This list is going to contain spoilers for When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season as well as some of the series’ other seasons. If you are a Heartie who is not caught up with the show, please read my list at your own discretion.

      When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

      1. Will Elizabeth and Jack Jr. permanently reside in Cape Fullerton?

      In the season twelve finale of When Calls the Heart, Jack Jr. and Elizabeth are forced to make an emergency trip to Cape Fullerton due to Jack Jr. receiving Insulin that wasn’t properly refrigerated. But earlier in the episode, Elizabeth receives a letter from Charlotte Thornton. In this letter, Charlotte encourages her grandson and daughter-in-law to move to Cape Fullerton, so Jack Jr. can live closer to Diabetes-related medical facilities. Since the season twelve finale ended with Elizabeth and Jack Jr. traveling to the train station, it’s currently unknown how long Jack Jr. and Elizabeth plan to stay out of Hope Valley. If they were to make Cape Fullerton their permanent home, this creative decision would lead to a collection of other questions. Would Elizabeth continue teaching at a new school or would she retire from the teaching profession? What would Jack Jr. and Elizabeth’s new home look like? Would the show’s overarching story alternate between Cape Fullerton and Hope Valley, similar to how season two alternated between Hope Valley and Hamilton?

      2. Will Allie and Nathan make Cape Fullerton their permanent residence?

      With Nathan on his Mountie rounds, Elizabeth cannot quickly tell him of her and her son’s sudden departure to Cape Fullerton. So, before leaving Hope Valley, she writes a letter to Nathan explaining what happened. To Elizabeth’s surprise, Nathan and Allie join her and Jack Jr. as they make their way to their destination. When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season concludes with the two families traveling beyond Hope Valley. Like I said for question number one, season twelve’s finale ended with Jack Jr. and Elizabeth on their way to the train station. This means we also don’t know how long Nathan and Allie plan on staying in Cape Fullerton. If they end up permanently leaving Hope Valley, there would be a lot of questions associated with that creative decision. Would Nathan join the Mounties in Cape Fullerton or would he retire from the Mountie profession? Would Allie complete her education at a new school or graduate from the Jack Thornton School in Hope Valley? How would they adjust to their new environment?

      3. Are we going to see more frequent appearances of Charlotte and/or Tom Thornton?

      As I mentioned for question number one, Charlotte encourages Jack Jr. and Elizabeth to move to Cape Fullerton. I remember Elizabeth saying in the season twelve finale how, in Cape Fullerton, Charlotte owns a boarding house. If Jack Jr. and Elizabeth were to make Cape Fullerton their permanent residence, how often would Charlotte appear in When Calls the Heart’s thirteenth season? Would the character get re-cast or would Brooke Shields reprise her role? When Tom Thornton was on the show in seasons five and eleven, he never mentioned if he still lives in Hamilton like he did in season two. In fact, I don’t recall the script ever revealing where Tom currently resides. So, if Charlotte were to make more frequent appearances in season thirteen, does this mean Tom could also appear on the show more often as well? In my opinion, seeing the Thornton family more consistently on When Calls the Heart would be a breath of fresh air!

      Heart image created by Dashu83 at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Backgroundimage created by Dashu83 – Freepik.com</a>. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/happy-valentines-day-and-heart-card-with-happy-valentines-day-and-heart_1747001.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

      4. What will become of Fiona’s barber shop?

      One of the biggest surprises in season twelve was Fiona’s decision to sell her barber shop. While the sale was successful, the identity of the buyer or their intention for the space was never revealed. What the new purpose of the building will be is, at this point, any Hearties’ guess. However, I wonder if this is how Rosemary finally gets her long-awaited theater? Elizabeth and Nathan are shown leaving a movie theater in the twelfth season’s seventh episode, “Dance the Night Away”. From a production perspective, this makes the chances of Rosemary receiving her theater seem a little more realistic. If the creative team wanted to add a theater to Hope Valley using the set space they already have, the set design department could tear down the barber shop’s back and side walls. From there, they could build upon the barber shop by expanding the walls and adding more length as well as depth to the space. Another realistic way a theater could be incorporated in Hope Valley is for the set design department to repurpose the school/church’s interior as the inside of the theater.

      5. Will Edie actually start her law firm in Hope Valley?

      Edie Martell was one of the new characters introduced in When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season. During a conversation she shared with Lucas, I recall Edie discussing her desire to open a law firm in Hope Valley. As of the publication of this list, no official announcements have been made regarding Edie’s return to the show. But if she does stay in Hope Valley, will her law firm become a reality? From what I remember, When Calls the Heart has never featured a law firm in Hope Valley before. Now that I say that, it makes me question how Hope Valley’s residents have settled their legal matters prior to Edie’s arrival?

      6. Has the national park project become abandoned like season eleven’s hotel project?

      At the beginning of When Calls the Heart’s eleventh season, Lucas announced he was planning on building a hotel using land gifted to him from Lee. But as the season carried on, Lucas’ hotel project became abandoned in favor of a new project; a national park. Reintroduced at the beginning of season twelve, I had my concerns the national park project would become the next abandoned large-scale project. Seeing how little progress was made throughout season twelve, I think those concerns were proven correct. Speaking only for myself, I’m becoming tired of major plans on When Calls the Heart being left unfinished. This kind of makes the show’s creative team look like they’re making promises they know they can’t keep. Though I’d like to see the national park project completed in season thirteen, it’s one of those creative decisions where I’ll believe when I see it.

      When Calls the Heart season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

      7. Will Hope Valley finally see their first female Mountie?

      My second question on this list was will Allie and Nathan make Cape Fullerton their permanent residence? If they do, that means Hope Valley will need a new Mountie to look after the town. This would be the perfect opportunity for When Calls the Heart to introduce the show’s first female Mountie! I’ve said before on 18 Cinema Lane how a female Mountie’s inclusion in the show’s story fits the narrative the series has had since the beginning. During When Calls the Heart’s soon-to-be thirteen season lifespan, Hope Valley has had a female mayor and several female business owners. The town also has a female doctor as well as a female pharmacist. With all that said, I truly believe Hope Valley’s first female Mountie would provide an interesting and exciting dynamic to When Calls the Heart!

      8. Will a subplot revolve around Angela’s experiences at college?

      Angela, Joseph, and Minnie took a tour of the Schwartzman School in season twelve’s ninth episode, “Buried Treasure”. In my re-cap for that episode, I wondered how Angela’s story would be included in future seasons if she attended the school. Would some scenes cut away to the Schwartzman School, alternating the show’s story between the school and Hope Valley?  Or would Angela be temporarily written off When Calls the Heart, with her story told through dialogue from the Canfield family? Season twelve’s finale revealed Angela will, indeed, attend college. She even receives a quilt as a graduation present. With Angela Canfield and the show itself embarking on a new chapter, it’ll be interesting to see how these stories are told in season thirteen!

      9. Now that Emily has graduated, will she continue to work for Joseph and Henry’s hazelnut business?

      Toward the beginning of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season, Joseph and Henry start their own hazelnut business. Over the season, the business successfully grows, with Emily playing a pivotal role in the business’ operation. But now that Emily has graduated from the Jack Thornton School, where does her story go from here? Does she continue to work for Henry and Joseph’s hazelnut business, saving money to eventually go to college? Or will Hearties learn through dialogue Emily already left for college by the start of the new season? If season thirteen shows Emily leaving for college, will another student of the Jack Thornton School help run the business or will When Calls the Heart’s creative team introduce a new character? Joseph and Henry’s hazelnut business was such a pleasant surprise in season twelve, so I’m curious to see what’s in store for next year!

      Heart shaped balloons image created by Katemangostar at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by katemangostar – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

      10. Will season thirteen contain an overarching mystery?

      An overarching story in season twelve was the mystery of the gold coin. What started as a simple search for who originally owned a unique looking coin turned into a discovery of buried treasure. Based on responses from the Hearties and my own personal opinion, the gold coin mystery was one of the best parts of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season! This positive reception makes me wonder if the show’s creative team will feature another overarching mystery in season thirteen? Are Bill and Rosemary going to solve another case or will different characters become amateur detectives? If an overarching mystery is written into season thirteen’s script, would it connect to characters and stories from past seasons? Personally, I hope When Calls the Heart’s new season contains a mystery, as it would add intrigue and excitement to the overall story!

      11. Is an unresolved story going to be completed in season thirteen?

      Back in season ten, Rosaleen Sullivan returned to Hope Valley. While there, she overcame her resentment toward Henry, even making a peace offering by inviting him to church. Meanwhile, Henry apologized to Rosaleen for the mining tragedy that claimed her father. This joint story provided a conclusion for both Henry and Rosaleen, with Rosaleen moving forward from the past and Henry finally achieving redemption. When Calls the Heart will soon enter its thirteenth season. Television shows lasting that long are bound to contain unresolved stories. If a story from season one could become resolved in season ten, I wonder if any uncompleted stories from When Calls the Heart will be finished in season thirteen?

      12. Is another student going to receive the Hope Valley Scholarship?

      After learning Rosaleen doesn’t have enough money to attend nursing school, Henry created the Hope Valley Scholarship. This scholarship allows current and former students of the Jack Thornton School to achieve their academic dreams. Since its introduction in season ten, however, I haven’t heard of any other student receiving this scholarship. With Angela, Timothy, and Emily having recently graduated and with Allie’s graduation on the horizon, I wonder if the Hearties will see another Hope Valley Scholarship recipient? Now that Henry is co-owner of a successful hazelnut business, does some of his financial earnings go toward the scholarship? Will one of Hope Valley’s residents organize a fundraiser to raise additional scholarship funds? If the Hope Valley Scholarship were incorporated into season thirteen’s script, maybe it could provide an overarching story on When Calls the Heart.

      13. Will Oliver receive the birthday party he’s never had?

      Oliver Garrett made his official debut in the twelfth season of When Calls the Heart. During their trip to a nearby river, Oliver reveals to Allie how he’s never had a birthday party. This is likely due to his experiences in the foster care system. As season twelve went on, I actually thought the season would end with Oliver finally receiving a birthday celebration. But in a season where a birthday party was already featured (Allie’s, in this case), I can see why When Calls the Heart’s creative team would save Oliver’s birthday party for a future season. In the season twelve finale, Oliver was promoted to Mountie Deputy. That creative decision gives him a reason to stay in Hope Valley. If Oliver does remain in Hope Valley, as well as on the show, I wonder if he will get that birthday party he’s never had?

      When Calls the Heart season ten poster created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

      Have fun in Hope Valley!

      Sally Silverscreen

      Ten Movie Trends I Don’t Understand

      Days before Christmas, I reviewed I Heard the Bells for my 500 Blog Follower Dedication Review. But this is not the only honor the movie achieved. I Heard the Bells became my 400th published movie review! To commemorate this milestone, I decided to write my sixth list article of 2024. Trends, whether in fashion or when it comes to the most popular toy of the Christmas/holiday season, exist for a reason. This statement also applies to the world of cinema. Sometimes, however, there are film related trends that leave me confused, wondering why film-makers continuously use them in their projects. So, for this list, I will be discussing ten movie trends I don’t understand! The intent of this list is to gain a better understanding for why the listed trends either existed or still exist, as I am genuinely curious about their purpose.

      Image of 2010 and 2020 on chart created by Macrovector at freepik.com. Infographic vector created by macrovector – www.freepik.com

      1. Food Fights

      From about the late ‘80s to the mid-2000s, children’s/family media, especially movies, were fond of food fights. From 1996’s Matilda (where the children at Crunchem Hall Elementary School hurl their lunches at Miss Trunchbull) to the Disney Channel film, Eddie’s Million Dollar Cook-Off (where I remember two food fights taking place), film-makers saw food fights as a way to add excitement and hilarity to their film. But long after the janitor has cleaned up the mess, what sinks in is the realization that these film-makers likely spent hundreds of dollars on large quantities of food only to waste it. This realization not only makes me wonder why food fights were once a staple of children’s/family media, I also question how often food fights happen in real life.

      2. Keeping Secrets

      Around the time the aforementioned food fight trend was common, another popular movie trend was younger characters being encouraged to keep secrets. When I reviewed 1985’s Return to Oz, I brought up Princess Ozma telling Dorothy that she can go back to Oz whenever she wants, as long as she keeps it a secret. By bringing up that part of the film, I addressed how Princess Ozma’s statement could be misinterpreted as damaging messages such as holding back on creativity helping one become “normal” and bottling up ideas and feelings being accepted. As I mentioned in my review of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, bullying is not addressed in the script, including in Alice’s part of the story. One reason why is how Imogene forces Alice to keep the bullying a secret. If you’re going to create a story for a younger audience, you need to be mindful when it comes to addressing serious, real-world issues because of how impressionable a younger audience can be. With that said, I kind of find it concerning how common the trend of younger characters keeping secrets was in children’s/family media.

      3. New York City as a Selling Point

      I brought up this trend back in 2021, when I reviewed Sherlock Holmes in New York. As I shared my overall impression of the 1976 film, I talked about how movie studios used their project’s New York setting as a selling point. Clear examples show New York City or New York City locations included in a film’s title, like A Troll in Central Park, The Muppets Take Manhattan, and Home Alone 2: Lost in New York. I don’t understand this need to single out a story’s New York location. Personally, I think the movie should show instead of tell their story is set in New York. What I also don’t understand is why the trend of using New York as a selling point occurred between about the mid- ‘70s to the mid-2000s.

      4. Villains Receiving the Spotlight

      2024 started with the release of Madame Web (a Spider-verse villain movie without the presence of Spider-Man) and ended with the premiere of Kraven the Hunter (a Spider-verse villain movie without the presence of Spider-Man). I bring up these movies to highlight a trend I first noticed in the 2010s that carried over to the 2020s. This trend is villains receiving the spotlight; whether this means villains are given their own movie, villains are presented as more “sympathetic”, or villains make arguments with seemingly valid points. When a movie studio adopts this trend, it gives their audience mixed messages. Within Spider-Man’s comic books, Kraven is known as a villain. The tagline of Kraven the Hunter is “Villains aren’t born. They’re made”. But based on what I’ve heard about the film, Kraven is presented as more of an anti-hero. Not only does giving villains the spotlight confuse the audience, it also makes villainous characters less straight-forward.

      5. “Thrown Together” Movie Posters

      A “thrown together” movie poster is the contents of a movie (like cast photos, story locations, and even a scene from the film) thrown together on that movie’s poster. The collage I just described appears overwhelming and leaves the audience with little surprises. I first became aware of this trend when Disney/Marvel used this style for their Avengers: Age of Ultron poster. After that movie came to theaters in 2015, the “thrown together” movie poster trend became the go-to style of cinematic advertising. It even got to the point where Hallmark adopted this trend, as the posters for Christmas Everlasting and Love Takes Flight are notable examples. Based on what I’ve seen, it seems like the “thrown together” movie poster trend is fading in the 2020s, as studios and networks have chosen more artistic styles for their movie posters. But I still wonder why the “thrown together” movie poster trend was ever popular.

      New York City skyline with letters image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/new-york-skyline-typographic-silhouette_719554.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

      6. Men Drinking Black Coffee

      In Great American Family’s A Little Women’s Christmas, Fritz orders a black coffee at a café in Alcott Grove. At that same café, Jo orders a sugary, seasonal coffee drink. This scene made me realize how often I’ve seen men ordering and/or drinking black coffee in movies. Not only do they order/drink black coffee, they usually get criticized for doing it. Similar to the previously mentioned food fight trend, I wonder how the men drinking black coffee trend reflects real life.

      7. Cabins & Bed and Breakfasts

      These trends are specific to Lifetime and Hallmark movies. In the world of Hallmark films, it seems common for characters to either own a Bed and Breakfast or know someone who knows a Bed and Breakfast. These Bed and Breakfasts are usually found in small towns. Meanwhile, on Lifetime, it seems like many characters either own a cabin or know someone who owns a cabin. The cabins themselves are typically treated as a vacation destination. I know both networks share the same flaw; telling the same types of stories and reusing the same ideas. This makes me wonder if that flaw is the reason for the abundance of Bed and Breakfasts on Hallmark and cabins on Lifetime.

      8. Rival Girl Scouting Troop

      This trend isn’t as common as other trends on my list. But I’ve seen it happen enough times to point it out. Troop Beverly Hills, The Cookie Mobster, and Smart Cookies share something in common; the “underdog” girl scouting troop must face a “rival” girl scouting troop. The rival girl scouting troop is always presented as bratty, wealthy, and popular. Their only purpose in the aforementioned movies is to win cookie season. The rival girl scouting troop trend is, in my opinion, an unnecessary conflict. The main and only conflict should be the protagonist girl scouting troop trying to achieve a goal within their own troop (such as having a successful cookie season). The rival girl scouting troop trend is yet another movie trend that makes me wonder how often it happens in real life.

      9. The Sound of a Baby Crying in an Apartment Building’s Hallway

      When one of a movie’s scenes takes place in an apartment building’s hallway, the sound of a baby crying can be heard. This trend has been present in so many movies, I wonder why that particular sound has been the go-to sound for film-makers. All walks of life can live inside an apartment building. This fact provides film-makers with a variety of sounds; such as dogs barking, music, or noise from a television. So, it confuses me when film-makers continuously use the same sound over and over again.

      10. Calling out “Hello” in an Empty Room

      Out of all the movie trends on my list, the calling out “hello” in an empty room trend is the most common one. From theatrical pictures to made-for-TV films, a character will call out “hello” when they enter an empty room. Predictably, no one calls “hello” back. But the character who called out “hello” will be taken by surprise by another character. The calling out “hello” in an empty room trend can usually be found in mystery, action, or thriller movies. When film-makers select this trend, they make suspenseful moments more predictable. It also makes characters who call out “hello” look absent-minded.

      Coffee cup drawing image created by Valeria_aksakova at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Valeria_aksakova – Freepik.com</a>. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/painted-cup-of-coffee-with-natural-coffee-beans-on-a-chalkboard_1013935.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

      Have fun at the movies!

      Sally Silverscreen

      Top 10 “Icks” from Hallmark Hall of Fame Movies

      To address the elephant in the room (or on the blog in this case), the lack of blog posts this past week is due to how much time I’ve spent collecting research for my upcoming Sally Solves a Mystery article. While I have been working to solve a television-related mystery, the subject of Hallmark Hall of Fame movies came to mind. I’ve seen over fifty films from the Hallmark Hall of Fame collection. At this point, I, as a viewer, know what I like and don’t like when it comes to storytelling from this particular branch of Hallmark entertainment. These preferences are what inspired me to create this list of the top ten “icks” from Hallmark Hall of Fame movies! For my list, I will share which aspects of Hallmark Hall of Fame films I am not a fan of, providing examples from various titles in this collection. Before I begin the list, I want to address how this list is not meant to be mean-spirited or negative. My article is, simply, a way to express my opinion.

      Taking out the trash photo created by Katemangostar at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/unhappy-woman-holding-trash-with-disgusting-smell_1305783.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/person”>Person image created by Katemangostar – Freepik.com</a>. Image found on freepik.com.

      1. Underutilizing Talent

        In past movie reviews, I have pointed out when I felt an actor or actress’s talents were underutilized. What I’ve meant by this is an actress or actor’s talents not being incorporated into a film to the fullest extent. This can range from an actor or actress being miscast to an actor or actress having a limited presence in the movie, the latter serving two examples for this list. Marguerite Moreau’s involvement in 2002’s The Locket is one of the reasons why I wanted to check the film out. Because she was cast as the movie’s main supporting actress, I expected Marguerite to have a more consistent presence in the film than she actually did. As I said in my review of The Locket, Marguerite’s character barely appeared in the movie’s second half. Based on her performances I have seen from a variety of movies and television shows, I think Karina Arroyave’s acting talents could have lent themselves to a larger role in 2000’s Missing Pieces. Sadly, Karina’s on-screen appearances were so short, they seemed like “don’t blink or you’ll miss her” moments. While she was given a little more screen-time in the 1993 film, Blind Spot, I still feel Karina’s acting talents were underutilized.

        2. Films That Feel like Televised Plays

        When I choose to watch a Hallmark Hall of Fame movie, I expect to see a cinematic production of an original or pre-existing story. Some of these pre-existing stories happen to be plays. But there are times when a project’s creative team didn’t take advantage of how expansive film-making can be. Instead, they kept their adaptation as limited as the boundaries of the stages these plays came from. Like I pointed out in my review of the 1987 film, Foxfire, the cast is smaller and the story is condensed, forcing the characters to remain near or in Annie’s house. With the story surrounded by the natural beauty of Appalachia, I wish the movie’s emphasis had been placed on showcasing a variety of locations from this region. The 1972 remake of Harvey made similar creative choices, such as showing fewer locations throughout the story. This is different from the 1950 version of Harvey, where Elwood moves to multiple places.

        3. Oversimplifying Adoption/Foster Care

        Back in 2022, when I published my list of the top ten worst movies I saw that year, 1994’s A Place for Annie ended up as a Dishonorable Mention. One reason why I didn’t like this film is how the subject of adoption/foster care was oversimplified. For those who have never seen or heard of the movie, A Place for Annie is about a woman taking in a baby who is HIV positive. Over the course of the story, the woman, portrayed by Sissy Spacek, is in the process of adopting the baby. But she experiences an unexpected conflict when the baby’s biological mother shows up. The way Sissy’s and Mary-Louise Parker’s characters were portrayed and written presented a “good” mother vs. “bad” mother dynamic, even right down to the way each character dressed. Sissy’s character, Susan, becomes upset at the idea of Mary-Louise’s character, Linda, reuniting with her daughter, even though the intended purpose of foster care is for children to be reunited with their biological families. Because of the oversimplification of adoption/foster care in A Place for Annie, I couldn’t take the movie seriously.

        4. Characters Not Receiving Their Full Potential

        Speaking of articles from 2022, I’ll now bring up my list of top ten characters who didn’t reach their full potential. When I published this list, I explained when a character doesn’t receive their full potential, they aren’t given the opportunity to reach their goals, make their dreams come true, and allow their stories to be told to a satisfying extent. This list featured two characters from Hallmark Hall of Fame movies; Barry Klemper from The Boys Next Door and Amédée Chevalier from O Pioneers!. In the case of these characters, their stories were adapted from pre-existing source material. While I haven’t seen or read a stage version of The Boys Next Door, I have read O Pioneers!. I can understand why Willa Cather made certain creative decisions related to Amédée, as well as Hallmark Hall of Fame’s desire to keep the adaptation as close to the source material as possible. However, I still wish Amédée had received his full potential.

        5. Rehashed Stories

        For this part of my list, I am not talking about Hallmark Hall of Fame productions that are adapted from pre-existing plays or books. I am referring to Hallmark Hall of Fame movies that seem to copy stories from other films. Earlier in this list, I referenced the 1972 and 1950 versions of Harvey. After watching both versions, it feels like I watched the same movie twice, due to little variation between the two versions. I also felt this way about the 1996 film, The Summer of Ben Tyler. The movie seemed so similar to To Kill a Mockingbird, I wondered if Hallmark Hall of Fame was trying to remake the aforementioned film. I know story ideas are bound to get repeated over time. But, in my opinion, the Hallmark Hall of Fame productions should strive to create unique, distinct projects.

        Harvey (1972) poster created by Foote, Cone and Belding Productions, Hallmark Hall of Fame Productions, Talent Associates-Norton Simon, and National Broadcasting Company (NBC)

        6. Terrible Grandparents

        Grandparents, like any family member in a protagonist’s life, should, in my opinion, be a kind, friendly character that the audience can root for. Unfortunately, some protagonists aren’t so lucky. For the fifth annual Gold Sally Awards, when I created the inaugural Edwin P. Christy Award for most annoying character in film, I gave that award to Grandpa Marcus from 1995’s Journey. I explained how obsessed he became of his photography hobby, to the point where he became negligent of his grandchildren’s safety. In one scene, Grandpa Marcus makes his grandson, who doesn’t appear old enough to obtain a driver’s permit yet, drive a car so Grandpa Marcus can take pictures. The grandchildren make a joking comment about how their grandpa will photograph their car accident if something should happen to them, with the scene itself meant to be played as a wholesome, hilarious moment.

        Leonora Nelson is a bitter, mean-spirited woman in the 1997 film, Ellen Foster. At her daughter’s burial, Leonora blames her son-in-law for her daughter dying. She yells and screams at her son-in-law just seconds after her daughter’s casket was buried. As the story progresses, Leonora’s hatred for her son-in-law grows. Her actions range from smashing his Purple Heart medal with a hammer to telling her granddaughter, the titular Ellen Foster, she hates her because she looks like her father. I recognize Leonora is intended to be an awful character, serving as one of the many obstacles Ellen had to overcome. But that doesn’t take away from how, in my opinion, Leonora Nelson is one of the worst characters in Hallmark movie history.

        7. Productions That Feel Like Hallmark Channel Films

        Hallmark Hall of Fame movies began to premiere on Hallmark Channel in 2014. While there are films from this time period I like, such as Love Takes Flight and The Beach House, I am aware how, more often than not, these projects bear a formula similar to those from Hallmark Channel. One such example is how a romance is usually the center of a given story. The identities of films like The Beach House and Love Takes Flight are not as unique as Hallmark Hall of Fame movies from years past. Take, for instance, Missing Pieces and Caroline? from 1990. Both of these films revolve around mystery stories. However, each title presents its own distinct identity, with these two movies bringing something different to the Hallmark Hall of Fame collection.

        8. Unsupportive Parents

        Similar to what I said earlier about grandparents, parents of protagonists should, in my opinion, at least be supportive. Sadly, a protagonist’s parents may be unsupportive for a variety of reasons. In my list of top ten characters who didn’t reach their full potential, I mentioned how Barry Klemper’s father destroyed the momentum Barry had in The Boys Next Door. Long before his father showed up, Barry dreaded the meeting because of how unsupportive his father is. On the day of the meeting, Barry’s father intimidated and belittled his son, even making Barry feel incapable of performing a simple golf maneuver. There are times, however, when a protagonist’s unsupportive parents do not intend to be unsupportive. Heidi and Winston’s mother is a perfect example. In the 1990 movie, Caroline?, Winston and Heidi’s mother is overprotective due to Heidi having a disability. Her good intentions not only lead Heidi to be treated younger than her age, but also prevent Heidi’s academic needs from being met.

        9. Glossing Over Serious Subjects

        The Hallmark Hall of Fame collection has covered its fair share of serious subjects, ranging from the aforementioned adoption/foster care to terminal illnesses. But sometimes, a Hallmark Hall of Fame production will miss a good opportunity to address an important topic by glossing it over. The subject of racism is woven into the text of The Flamingo Rising book, with racism causing the protagonist, Abraham, to have self-image related issues. When the book was adapted into a Hallmark Hall of Fame movie in 2001, all mentions of racism were eliminated from the script. This decision was likely made to keep The Flamingo Rising movie “Hallmark appropriate”. At a very random moment in the 1996 film, Calm at Sunset, Russell Pfeiffer admits he has a drug addiction. There was no lead up to this revelation and the revelation itself was never addressed afterward. Calm at Sunset is based on a book I haven’t read. Therefore, I don’t know how the subject of addiction was addressed in the source material compared to the adaptation.

        10. A Dysfunctional Family for the Sake of It

          Six years ago, when I published my list of the top ten worst Hallmark movies of all time, I put the 2004 film, Back When We Were Grownups, at number one. As I mentioned in that list, the story’s family seems dysfunctional just for the sake of it. From what I remember, there was no clear reason for the family to be dysfunctional. This is very different from another Hallmark Hall of Fame production, 1998’s Saint Maybe. In that movie, a death in the family causes a ripple effect which leads to the family becoming dysfunctional. The dysfunctional nature of the family serves as motivation for various characters to make impactful changes in their lives. Comparing these two Hallmark Hall of Fame films, which are both adaptations of Anne Tyler’s books, I think Saint Maybe did a better job at showcasing how a dysfunctional family live their lives and work through their problems.

          Group of unhappy image created by Rawpixel.com at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by rawpixel.com – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

          Have fun at the movies!

          Sally Silverscreen

          Revisiting my Hallmark Hall of Fame Tier Rank List!

          Three years ago, I created a tier rank list of every Hallmark Hall of Fame movie I’d seen. These films were categorized by my overall impression of each presentation. In honor of 18 Cinema Lane turning five, I promised my readers I would revisit one of my past articles. I’ve seen more Hallmark Hall of Fame movies since I published my original tier rank list, so that’s the article I’ve selected! Along with adding more Hallmark Hall of Fame productions, I changed the names of each tier category. This decision was made to better reflect whether a film is worth its retail price of twenty dollars a DVD compared to its quality. The new tier category names are the following:

          Bottom of the Barrel – Not Even Worth a Dime

          Ok – Catch it on TV/Youtube

          Decent/Fine – Bought It at a Garage Sale for a Dollar

          Good – Get It On Sale for Half Off

          Great – Where Do I Pay Full Price?

          For each movie I added or moved to a different tier, I will share my thoughts on them. If I wrote about a movie on my blog, I will add the link to this article.

          Screenshot taken by me, Sally Silverscreen

          Bottom of the Barrel – Not Even Worth a Dime

          Durango

          Reviewed for the Legends of Western Cinema Week Blogathon, I stated Durango should have been a David and Goliath story. That’s because a David and Goliath reference was placed within the last nineteen minutes of the movie, the creative team’s attempt to include a higher stake into the story. But this attempt didn’t work because the majority of the film had lower stakes. The protagonist and his plan to transport cattle worked out perfectly, too perfectly for the standards of the western genre. This takes away any room for concern the audience could have for the characters and their well-being.

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Durango Review

          Journey

          As I explained in my list of the top ten worst movies I saw in 2022, the audience was not given a reason to care about the characters and their story in Journey. This flaw was achieved because the film’s creative team didn’t provide explanations for the characters’ choices. It also did not help how annoying Grandpa Marcus was, his photography hobby becoming an obsession. A major theme of Journey is memories being irreplaceable. That theme was poorly delivered in Journey, as Marcus’ hobby creates a plot hole within the story. Also, I’ve seen Hallmark Hall of Fame movies express this theme better, such as The Lost Valentine.

          A Place for Annie

          When it comes to movies that are products of their time, they can fit into one of two categories: movies that serve as visual time capsules and those that are dated on arrival. A Place for Annie, sadly, falls into the latter category. The majority of the story focuses on the medical information of HIV/AIDS that was known during the late ‘80s to mid ‘90s. That focus causes the film to show its age more obviously. The way foster care/adoption is discussed in this story is so oversimplified, I couldn’t take that part of the movie seriously. Similar to what I said about Journey, the theme of adoption is expressed better in other Hallmark Hall of Fame stories, like Redwood Curtain.

          The Corsican Brothers

          Alexandre Dumas’ stories are, more often than not, filled with adventure, intrigue, and suspense. But in the case of The Corsican Brothers, these elements were lacking. Granted, I still haven’t read the book this movie is based on. Though I do wonder how similar the 1985 adaptation is to the source material? If the original story primarily revolves around Louis attending fancy events in Paris, that would explain why the adaptation is so underwhelming. However, the original story could explain some of the confusing parts of the movie, such as the woman giving some of the characters fates.

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s The Corsican Brothers Review

          Ok – Catch it on TV/Youtube

          The Summer of Ben Tyler

          The 1996 movie, The Summer of Ben Tyler, feels like Hallmark Hall of Fame wanted to create their own version of To Kill a Mockingbird. Upon reflection of this film, it doesn’t seem like the creative team displayed a strong understanding for what made Harper Lee’s story work. If anything, it feels like ideas are copied from Harper’s novel and pasted into the Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation, making The Summer of Ben Tyler a little too similar to To Kill a Mockingbird. This is a case of if you’ve seen one movie, you’ve basically seen the other. So, if you’ve seen the adaptation of To Kill a Mockingbird, you’ve already seen The Summer of Ben Tyler.

          Decoration Day

          The way I feel about Decoration Day is similar to Promise; the majority of the story is very “slice-of-life”. To me, this makes both films less memorable than other Hallmark Hall of Fame titles. However, I did find Gee Pennywell’s dilemma over receiving the Congressional Medal of Honor the most interesting part of the movie. In fact, I wish Decoration Day had solely revolved around that dilemma.

          Foxfire

          Hallmark Hall of Fame has a history of adapting plays into films. Sometimes, a movie’s creative team will take advantage of the expansive nature of cinema, allowing the story to move beyond the boundaries of the stage. For Foxfire, though, the story was confined to the four walls of Annie’s house. A smaller cast and a condensed story also caused the 1987 Hallmark Hall of Fame project will feel more like a televised play. If I choose to watch Hallmark Hall of Fame film, I expect to watch a film. Foxfire subverted my expectations, but in a disappointing way.

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Foxfire Review

          Calm at Sunset

          Calm at Sunset is one of those movies where better, more interesting ideas were woven into the fabric of this story. One example is when the protagonist spots a cruise ship and imagines the types of people aboard that ship. Honestly, I wish Calm at Sunset was about that cruise ship instead. Similar to what I said about The Corsican Brothers, I haven’t read the book this movie is based on, so I don’t know which parts of the production came straight from the source material. If the book is pretty close to the film, it would explain why the adaptation was lackluster.

          Witness for the Prosecution

          Based on the adaptations of Agatha Christie’s books I’ve seen, the protagonist will play an active role in solving the mystery. Witness for the Prosecution is the exception to this statement, as Wilfred focuses more on the legal case he’s working to resolve. In a story where the protagonist doesn’t actively solve the story’s mystery, it can be difficult to get the audience invested in the story itself. Because Wilfred’s case is the primary focus of the story, the film is more dialogue heavy, putting emphasis on telling instead of showing. Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Witness for the Prosecution is a mystery that is light on the mystery.

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Witness for the Prosecution (1982) Review

          The Flamingo Rising

          In my editorial about the adaptation of The Flamingo Rising, I explained how the story should have been adapted into a television show or a multi-part mini-series. This is because the story itself is drawn out over the course of the protagonist’s life. Reflecting on the adaption, it felt like Hallmark Hall of Fame tried to fit The Flamingo Rising into their brand of storytelling. In this attempt, several parts of the source material were omitted or changed due to them not being “Hallmark appropriate”. As I did in the aforementioned editorial, I questioned why Hallmark Hall of Fame would choose to adapt Larry Baker’s story over a story that was more “Hallmark appropriate”?

          Four Reasons Why ‘The Flamingo Rising’s Adaptation is Different from its Book

          O Pioneers!

          Having read the source material and seen the adaptation of O Pioneers!, I can say the movie is respectful toward the book. With that said, if you’ve seen the film, you’ve already read the novel. Speaking of the adaptation, I said in my review how the story should have been adapted into a mini-series or a television show. With so many characters and so many parts of the story, maybe O Pioneers! would have benefitted from receiving more time. The 1992 Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation is a western that didn’t leave a memorable impression on me.

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s O Pioneers! Review

          Harvey

          I’ve stated before on 18 Cinema Lane how the 1972 adaptation of Harvey is better than the original from 1950. While this statement is still true, the 1972 and 1950 versions of this story felt like a copy of one another. It makes me wonder why Hallmark Hall of Fame would choose to adapt Harvey if they knew they were going to make a lot of the same creative decisions as the original film? Despite the similarities, I did like the changes in the 1972 adaptation. One example is how the made-for-tv movie chose a dramatic tone for their version of the story instead of being both a drama and comedy.

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Harvey (1972) Review

          Decent/Fine – Bought It at a Garage Sale for a Dollar

          The Locket

          For a movie titled The Locket, the locket itself is treated as an afterthought. What the story focuses on instead is the protagonist and his hardships. But from what I remember, the 2002 project addressed the importance of elder care. Since that topic is rarely brought up in Hallmark’s programming, I appreciate that creative decision. Marguerite Moreau is one of the reasons why I chose to watch The Locket. Her performance was so good, she ended up outshining the other actors in the movie! Unfortunately, Marguerite was kind of under-utilized in this film, as her on-screen appearances were not as consistent as I expected.

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s The Locket Review + 225 & 230 Follower Thank You

          Saint Maybe

          I said in my review of Saint Maybe how the adaptation is faithful to the source material. However, there are changes the film made from the book. One notable example is how religion/faith is downplayed in the Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation. Meanwhile, religion/faith played a significant role in the novel. For years, Saint Maybe was included in Hallmark Movies & Mysteries’ ‘Miracles of Christmas’ marathon. Now that I have seen the adaptation, I understand why the network would make this decision. Personally, I wouldn’t call Saint Maybe a Christmas story/movie, as the story itself takes place over several years.

          Take 3: Anne Tyler’s Saint Maybe Review (National Read a Book Day Double Feature Part 1)

          The Lost Child

          The Lost Child serves as a good introduction to Native American culture, specifically the Navajo culture. Through dialogue and character interactions, the audience receives a glimpse into life on a Navajo reservation. For the story itself, The Lost Child didn’t leave a strong impression on me. The most interesting part of the film, Rebecca’s search of her family, wasn’t emphasized as much as her adjustment to reservation life. Also, Rebecca’s search for her twin brother was abandoned after she meets her biological family.

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s The Lost Child Review + 395 Follower Thank You

          Loving Leah

          I’ve finally seen Loving Leah in its entirety! The way I feel about the 2009 movie is similar to The Lost Child; it’s a good introduction to Jewish religion and culture. Throughout the story, the audience receives a glimpse into the many aspects of Jewish life. Like The Lost Child, Loving Leah didn’t leave as strong of an impression as other Hallmark Hall of Fame titles. From what I remember, the story was a little too drawn out. But from what I also remember, it was nice to see the protagonists’ relationship unfold. With all that said, the movie was pleasant!

          Good – Get It On Sale for Half Off

          An American Story/After the Glory

          Since publishing my review of An American Story/After the Glory, it has become one of my most popular reviews, garnering 1,838 views and counting! The innovative and compelling nature of the project is likely the reason why this particular title is so well-received on 18 Cinema Lane! Like I said in my review, An American Story/After the Glory felt kind of ahead of its time. This feeling is achieved by incorporating the discussion of veterans’ mental health into the script. The way veteran related topics are included in the story is reverent and respectful. An American Story/After the Glory is definitely one of Hallmark’s better military themed productions!

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s After the Glory Review + 195 Follower Thank You

          The Love Letter

          The Love Letter is one of Hallmark Hall of Fame’s more unique titles, as fantastical elements are rarely found in this collection of films. Yet this part of the story worked in the 1998 movie, helping to create a love story that was simple yet intriguing! The characters were not only well written, but also well-acted! Since the protagonists were multi-dimensional, their connection throughout the film was interesting to watch. I also liked the historical accuracy in The Love Letter, as the attention to detail was handled with care!

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s The Love Letter Review

          Redwood Curtain

          In my five years of movie blogging, I have discovered very few films that were better than their respective source material. Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Redwood Curtain is one of those films, as I found myself liking it over the play! The movie’s creative team took advantage of the expansive nature of cinema, broadening the horizons in Geri’s life. More characters were added to the story, giving them characterization that the play didn’t provide. Geri’s personality was more likable in the movie, which made me like her as a character. Redwood Curtain is a Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation I wish was re-released on DVD.

          ‘Redwood Curtain’: From Stage to Screen

          Great – Where Do I Pay Full Price?

          Caroline?

          As of the publication of this list, Caroline? is, so far, the best movie I’ve all year! That’s because the 1990 production is a close to perfect example of what a Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation can and should be. From the younger actors’ performances to the differentiation of time, I could tell there was a lot of effort and care put into this project! Even though the story of a long-lost family member’s return is nothing new, the way Caroline? was written was creative, allowing this story to have its own identity. This movie is one I wish more Hallmark fans acknowledged!

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s Caroline? Review + 460 Follower Thank You

          A Tale of Two Cities

          During my blogging years, I have seen Charles Dickens adaptations I have liked. The 1980 version of A Tale of Two Cities is definitely one of those films! Despite the movie being two hours and thirty-six minutes, the story never felt too long. The immersive nature of the story helped the pacing, as I was invested in what was happening on screen. This Hallmark Hall of Fame production was so good, it makes me want to read the source material! It’s also another film from this collection that deserves more recognition!

          Take 3: Hallmark Hall of Fame’s A Tale of Two Cities Review

          Have fun at the movies!

          Sally Silverscreen

          The Top Ten ‘When Calls the Heart’ Characters I’d Love to See Return

          When I published my review for the adaptation of The Grapes of Wrath, that post became my 750th published article! Since then, I’ve been trying to find the right topic to write about to commemorate the milestone. My most recent re-cap of When Calls the Heart has, within a 24-hour period, become the most popular article I’ve ever written on 18 Cinema Lane, garnering over 8,000 views and counting! Since my readers have an interest in When Calls the Heart related content, I decided to create a list of the top ten characters I’d love to see return to the show! With the arrival of Rosaleen Sullivan, I wondered which other characters could come back. As the show is now is in tenth season, it wasn’t difficult to think of characters to include on this list. From characters debuting in one of When Calls the Heart’s seasonal films to beloved faces who have spent years in Hope Valley, here is my list of the top ten characters I’d love to see return to the show!

          When Calls the Heart: Home for Christmas poster created by Hallmark Channel and Crown Media Family Networks. Image found at https://www.crownmediapress.com/Shows/PRShowDetail?SiteID=142&FeedBoxID=845&NodeID=302&ShowType=&ShowTitle=When+Calls+the+Heart+Home+for+Christmas.

          1. Tom Thornton

          I have mentioned in the past how Tom Thornton is my favorite character from When Calls the Heart. He was even included in my “Flaming Hot…5 Reasons Why” Tag post! Tom returned to the show in season five, attending Jack and Elizabeth’s wedding. But so much has changed since then, with Tom losing his brother and becoming an uncle. Since the end of season five, I have wondered how Tom has dealt with life after receiving both good and bad news. I also speculated how his life might have changed since his story was last included on the show. It would be nice to see Tom find true love again and maybe even get married on When Calls the Heart! With season ten still on television and season eleven on the horizon, only time will tell.

          2. Carson Shepherd

          Ever since Carson left Hope Valley, I feel like Faith’s story has been put on hold. While her career seems to be thriving, she hasn’t moved forward in the relationship department. There’s still so much left unsaid between Faith and Carson. I don’t feel like their conflict ever truly got resolved. Even though Hope Valley already has a doctor in town, it would be nice to see Carson and Faith work together again. Maybe they could rekindle their relationship as well.

          3. Phillip

          Phillip was one of Elizabeth’s students. He left Hope Valley in order to receive eyesight saving surgery. Since then, Phillip or his father have never returned to town. I always wondered if the surgery was a success. I also wondered what became of Phillip and his family. Did Phillip’s father remarry? Did Phillip remain an only child? Erin Krakow and Niall Matter, the actor who portrayed Phillip’s father, Shane, have worked together on several Hallmark projects. If Phillip couldn’t appear on the show, Niall could reprise his role as Shane. This way, Shane could give viewers an update on his son through dialogue.

          4. Walter

          Walter made his Hope Valley debut in the movie, When Calls the Heart: Home for Christmas. In that film, he was a traveling salesman, struggling to make money. Since the movie’s release in 2019, Walter hasn’t returned to Hope Valley. He hasn’t been brought up by any of the characters either. I do wonder if he is still a traveling salesman or if he found a new calling, similar to Joseph Canfield’s story. If Walter were to come back to town, the audience would receive some closure to his story.

          5. Christopher and Rachel

          In season eight, it was revealed Henry had a son named Christopher. That season showed father and son reconnecting. But Henry was not the only character Christopher connected with. Fans saw Christopher and Lee’s niece, Rachel, falling in love. The younger couple stayed on When Calls the Heart for one season. Early in season nine, Henry learns Rachel and Christopher plan to get married in the near future. However, these wedding plans haven’t been brought up since last season. Though Lucas and Elizabeth’s wedding will, hopefully, take place in season eleven, I hope Rachel and Christopher consider getting married in Hope Valley. Maybe they could be the first couple to host either an outdoor wedding or a Christmas wedding!

          Since Tom Thornton is included in this list, I figured putting this picture of Tom and Jack in this article made sense.  Image created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel.

          6. Dottie

          Dottie was one of the original residents of Coal Valley, losing her husband in the coal mining tragedy that took place prior to the show’s events. Over the course of the series, Dottie started her own business; a dress shop where Rosemary worked before creating the town’s newspaper. As the dress shop expanded outside of Hope Valley, Dottie left town to manage those stores. Because of her departure, the dress shop closed and became the ice cream parlor and pharmacy. Since Rosaleen Sullivan came back to the show, it would be nice to see Dottie return. I remember Dottie, Mollie, and Florence were good friends in When Calls the Heart’s earlier seasons, so it would be wonderful to see them reunite!

          7. Hattie

          Hattie is another student of Elizabeth’s that disappeared. When she and her mother moved to Hope Valley, Hattie was grieving the loss of her friend. During her time as a student of the Jack Thornton School, Hattie was one of the children who first brought up Hope Valley’s ice cream parlor. But she mentioned the ice cream parlor back in season five and since then, the story seems to have forgotten Hattie exists. I haven’t seen Hattie on the show in a long time. Plus, none of Elizabeth’s students bring Hattie up either. If Rosaleen can receive closure on her story, I think it’s only fair for Hattie to receive closure for her story too.

          8. Cody and Becky

          Cody and Becky were introduced to Hearties in the film, When Calls the Heart: New Year’s Wish. Since their introduction, Abigail adopted the siblings and the family lived in Abigail’s Café. Because of Lori Loughlin’s involvement in the infamous college admissions scandal, not only was Abigail written off the show, Becky and Cody were written off the show as well. Before this happened, Becky was attending college and Cody was still enrolled at the Jack Thornton School. Even if it was just for one episode, I would like to see Cody and Becky revisit Hope Valley. From what I remember, Cody and Robert were close friends. So, seeing them go on an adventure together would serve as a potential story for a future episode!

          9. Laura

          Besides Rosaleen Sullivan, Laura was one of Elizabeth’s first students back in season one. In recent seasons, Laura was not only attending college, but she was also babysitting Jack Jr. While watching this current season, I realized Laura hasn’t appeared in any scenes. Elizabeth didn’t mention her either. I’m curious about Laura’s whereabouts and how her story turns out. If both Laura and Rosaleen appeared on the show together, maybe the show’s fans could witness a school reunion in the future, especially since the Jack Thornton School never hosted a reunion before!

          10. Charles Kensington

          As I was creating this list, I thought about all the characters who could create drama in the town. The first character that came to mind was Charles Kensington. A childhood friend of Elizabeth, Charles came onto the show in season two. He only appeared in that season, never brought up or shown on screen again. I would love to see how his life turned out after Elizabeth refused his offers. An interaction between Charles and Lucas would be very interesting as well.

          When Calls the Heart season ten poster created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

          Have fun in Hope Valley!

          Sally Silverscreen

          Top Ten Characters Who Didn’t Reach Their Full Potential

          For my World Television Day Blogathon, I was originally going to review one of the books in the Murder, She Wrote series. But with the recent passing of Angela Lansbury, I thought it would be a bit too soon. Therefore, I decided to write about the top ten characters who didn’t reach their full potential instead. What does it mean for a character to reach their “full potential”? In my opinion, it means a character is given the opportunity to reach their goals, make their dreams come true, and allow their stories to be told to a satisfying extent. Unfortunately, some characters are denied these opportunities for various reasons. This list will address the characters I wish had received their full potential. For the sake of this discussion, I will focus on characters who appeared in television shows or made-for-tv movies. While there are some characters I have talked about before, I tried to include those I never talked about on 18 Cinema Lane. There will also be spoilers for the television shows and movies discussed in this list.

          Created by Sally Silverscreen at Adobe Creative Cloud Express

          1. Matthew Rogers from Little House on the Prairie

          Yes, I’m starting this list with a character I’ve written part of an editorial about. However, I feel there’s an argument to be made for Matthew not reaching his full potential. On Little House on the Prairie, he was introduced in the show’s last season. Within that season, Matthew only appeared in a total of three episodes, departing in the series finale. This left him with little to no time to reach his full potential. Meanwhile, characters such as Albert Ingalls, Willie Oleson, and even Nancy Oleson had their potential recognized because they were introduced in earlier seasons. Had Matthew made his debut in, say, season seven, his chances to reach his full potential may have been stronger.

          2. Jamey Farrell from 24

          24 was released during a very interesting time. It was almost ten years after the premiere of Jurassic Park, a film that showed Dr. Ian Malcolm breaking the mold of a “geek/nerd”. But 24 was also released almost ten years prior to Iron Man, when the idea of the “cool geek/nerd” would be fully embraced by the media. Before Robert Downey Jr. accepted the role of Tony Stark/Iron Man, Karina Arroyave portrayed Jamey on 24. A beautiful, intelligent, and charismatic woman, Jamey had the potential to be the Dr. Ian Malcolm of the show. In fact, I think if the show’s writers had allowed her to reach her full potential, Jamey could have been the reason why the media embraced the “cool geek/nerd” idea a lot sooner than they did. As the events of 24’s first season unfolded, though, Jamey’s sparkling personality became watered down and her unique attire morphed into looking just like every other employee. Becoming a villain and dying after appearing in ten episodes ended all chances of Jamey reaching her full potential.

          3. Jiggy Nye from Felicity: An American Girl Adventure

          Another character I’ve written an editorial about joins this list. In the 2005 made-for-tv film, Jiggy was presented more as a victim than a villain. This is because he didn’t come across as a big enough threat to the protagonist. It also doesn’t help how Jiggy’s backstory was poorly incorporated into the script. Felicity: An American Girl Adventure is based on a six-book series. Like any adaptation, changes were made between books and film. When it comes to Jiggy’s part of the story, though, it seems like he received the short end of the stick. From a writing perspective, he deserved so much better.

          4. Libby from Lost

          Out of all the characters from Lost to not receive their full potential, especially those from season two, Libby is the one you can make the strongest argument for. Introduced as one of the “Tailies”, there was so much mystery and intrigue surrounding her and her story. When Libby and Hurley started a romantic relationship, things seemed to be going well with her character development. Sadly, Libby’s story was short-lived, as she died toward the end of the second season. Because of her departure, none of the mysteries surrounding her were ever addressed. Libby never even received any flashbacks.

          5. Amédée Chevalier from Hallmark Hall of Fame’s O Pioneers!

          I first mentioned Amédée in my review of the 1992 Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation. In his limited appearance in the movie, he had so much potential. From his athleticism to his charisma, Amédée could go anywhere and be anyone he wanted. Sadly, his story was cut short due to dying off-screen of appendicitis. From the information I’ve found about Amédée, he only made three appearances in the book. This makes me wonder if his full potential was always meant to be denied?

          Happy reading place image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

          6. Captain Lynch and Judy from Crusoe

          Long before 18 Cinema Lane existed, there was a television adaptation called Crusoe. In the season premiere, Captain Lynch and Judy arrived on Robinson’s island. Similar to Libby from Lost, Judy and Captain Lynch were surrounded in mystery and intrigue. But toward the end of the season premiere, these characters departed from the show. While Captain Lynch died, Judy was taken away by the Royal Naval Police, never to be seen again. It also didn’t help how Crusoe survived for only one season.

          7. Barry Klemper from Hallmark Hall of Fame’s The Boys Next Door

          I always thought there was an argument to be made for Barry Klemper’s full potential in the 1996 Hallmark Hall of Fame presentation. A photogenic and articulate man, Barry had a passion for golf, which he kept alive at his job at a driving range. Had he received a more one-on-one, individualized approach to his care, I honestly think Barry could have lived a, somewhat, independent life. But all that momentum Barry had was destroyed when his father showed up and intimidated him. This interaction caused Barry to spend the remainder of the story in a psychiatric hospital. The Boys Next Door is based on a play that I have not read or seen in its entirety, so I’m not sure how respectful the adaptation is to its source material. All I know is Barry Klemper not reaching his full potential is, in my opinion, heart-breaking.

          8. Moon from Cedar Cove

          The proprietor of Moon’s Café, Moon is one of the most important characters of the 2013 Hallmark Channel show. Along with coffee and baked goods, Moon serves up wisdom to those who will provide a listening ear. I even recall one episode where he claimed he was adopted. This tidbit could have opened the doors to a compelling story for Moon. But during Cedar Cove’s three season run, Moon, more often than not, was overshadowed by the other characters and their stories. Since the show ended in 2015, there have been no announced plans to release a Cedar Cove movie or reunion special. Hallmark’s lack of interest in revisiting their first scripted show leaves Moon with no more chances to reach his full potential.

          9. Harris Trinsky from Freaks and Geeks

          After watching some episodes of Freaks and Geeks, Harris has become my favorite character from the show. His “wise beyond his years” perspective makes him a character the “geeks” can trust and others can respect. Harris also had a lot going for him, from his intelligence to his interest in Dungeons & Dragons. Unfortunately, Freaks and Geeks lasted for only one season. The fact Harris was a recurring character didn’t help his case either, as he appeared in ten of the show’s eighteen episodes.

          10. Jesse and Clara from When Calls the Heart

          When I was creating this list, I, at first, didn’t think there were any characters from When Calls the Heart who didn’t reach their full potential. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized Jesse and Clara fit my list’s criteria. Clara came to Hope Valley in season two, still healing from a broken heart. Season three saw the arrival of Jesse, seeking a second chance after living a life of crime. When Clara and Jesse became a couple, they had their whole lives and relationship ahead of them. But the longer they stayed on the show, the more overshadowed they became. Jesse and Clara were given few good stories during their time on When Calls the Heart. They were also denied the outdoor wedding of their dreams. Clara and Jesse were written out of the show after season seven.

          Image of Colorado road created by welcomia at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/mountain”>Mountain photo created by welcomia – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

          Have fun on television!

          Sally Silverscreen