June’s theme for Buzzwordathon is ‘other’. That means the word itself, not words like ‘brother’ or ‘mother’, has to appear somewhere in the title. Since I happened to own a copy of The Raven and Other Poems, I had the perfect book for Buzzwordathon! Having read Edgar’s work in the past, I knew what to expect from this collection of poems. But the one poem that caught me by surprise is ‘The Coliseum’! From how I interpreted it, the narrator is describing an abandoned facility. Through a series of voices, the narrator is reminded how the history, stories, and people associated with the titular coliseum should be remembered, otherwise they will be lost forever. Using carefully selected prose, Edgar accomplishes the delivery of this idea. Lines such as “Of lofty contemplation left to Time” and “Here, where a hero fell, a column falls!” illustrate how the coliseum’s best years are behind it. The fifth and final stanza is devoted to the voices of the coliseum’s past, with one statement from the voices being “Not all our power is gone – not all our fame”. This stanza allows the reader to contemplate the importance any location holds.
As the title suggests, ‘The Raven’ is one of the poems featured in this book. If I had to be honest, though, I found this poem a bit overrated. The story itself was simplistic and surface-level, revolving around the narrator questioning the identity and whereabouts of the titular Raven. The poem was also very repetitive, with the words “nevermore” and “nothing more” used consistently. While reading ‘The Raven’, I was reminded of the film adaptation from 1963. Though that movie had its flaws, I found myself appreciating it more. The 1963 adaptation included a plot in the script, which gave the story some depth. This creative decision also prevented the narrative from becoming repetitive.
I typically don’t seek out poetry. The genre’s open-endedness and limited amount of closure are two reasons why. Other than ‘The Coliseum’, I didn’t connect with the other poems in this book. This is because I found the majority of poems ok or fine. As I read The Raven and Other Poems, I noticed Edgar wrote about one of three topics; death, dreams, and Paradise/Heaven. That caused the poems to lack variety. The uniqueness of ‘The Coliseum’ is why I liked that poem, with the poem itself focusing on history. The abandoned coliseum set the stage for an eerie location, yet doesn’t rely on the typical spookiness expected in Edgar’s work. I’d be curious to see ‘The Coliseum’ adapted as a movie or mini-series.
Overall score: 3 out of 5
Have fun during Buzzwordathon!
Sally Silverscreen
Disclaimer: As I mentioned in this review, some of Edgar’s poems include the subject of death. Reader discretion is encouraged.
18 Cinema Lane 