Two weeks ago, I published a Word on the Street story about Michelle Vicary returning to Hallmark as the company’s head of programming. But this is not the only recent change happening at Hallmark. Lynette Rice, of Deadline, reports how the company “eliminated 30 jobs on Wednesday”. The desire “to “transition our workforce to meet the needs of the business today”” was the provided reason for the cut jobs. Jimmy Holcomb, who was Hallmark’s Vice President of Production, is one of the laid off employees. His role at the company was overseeing “the physical production of MOWs, series, and specials for Hallmark Media’s broadcast channels”. He is “credited for creating new ventures for Hallmark Media throughout the world” as well. Meanwhile, Peter White, also from Deadline, reports how Lifetime “cut the majority of its non-scripted team”. The article states the reason for the cut jobs is “Lifetime is focusing more on its television movie business”. Affected by this decision is Nicole Vogel, who was the network’s VP for Programming and Development. At the time of the article’s publication, “The only remaining member of the unscripted team is now Brie Miranda Bryant, SVP, Original Programming”.
When I wrote about Michelle Vicary coming back to Hallmark in my last Word on the Street story, I addressed the network’s declining viewership. At that time, two Hallmark Channel films, A Machu Picchu Proposal and Providence Falls: Chance of a Lifetime, attracted less than a million viewers. Five movies in a row have received under a million viewers at the publication of this Word on the Street story. These newer titles are Providence Falls: An Impossible Promise (592,000 viewers), Providence Falls: Thief Of Fate (592,000 viewers), and Mystery Island: Play for Keeps (350,000 viewers). Similar to what I said in my last Word on the Street story, I’m not surprised Hallmark is making decisions like cutting jobs, especially when no movie in 2025, so far, has seen two million viewers or more.
Though I haven’t seen many Lifetime movies this year, most of the ones I have seen have been decent. However, I am aware of Lifetime’s reputation for distributing a large quantity of films with poor quality. Almost every year, at least one Lifetime movie ends up on my end of the year worst movies list. In 2024, three movies were placed on that list; Revenge Best Served Chilled, My Life Is on the Line, and Boy in the Walls. With this recent prioritization of made-for-tv movies, I’m hoping emphasis is not only placed on quality over quantity, I’m also hoping production value is raised as well.
What are your thoughts on these pieces of movie news? What other changes do you think are in store for Lifetime and Hallmark? Tell me in the comment section!
Way back in 2021, I wrote a Word on the Street story about Michelle Vicary’s departure from Hallmark. At the time, she was the company’s executive for programming and production. Now, four years later, Michelle has returned with a new title. In a recent article from Variety, Emily Longeretta reports how Michelle will now become Hallmark’s “head of programming”, allowing her to “oversee all production and original programming across Hallmark’s content platforms”. Her new role comes at a time when Hallmark has been attempting to bring their assets under one umbrella as “One Hallmark”. Their goal is to “deliver incredible content, incredible products and incredible experiences that leverage the full breadth of the brand” by “tying all of those things together in really unique ways”. When reflecting on Michelle’s importance in the company, Darren Abbott, Hallmark’s Chief Brand Officer, stated, “She was really the missing piece of the puzzle, I think, around the way I’m thinking about the brand.”
In the 2020s, so far, Hallmark’s viewership has been gradually declining. As of the publication of this Word on the Street story, 2025 hasn’t seen any movie premiere achieve two million viewers or more. In fact, the latest film release, Providence Falls: Chance of a Lifetime only attracted 695,000 viewers. This is now the second movie in a row to garner less than a million viewers, as the previous premiere, A Machu Picchu Proposal, received 964,000 viewers. Based on everything I just said; I’m not surprised Michelle Vicary came back to Hallmark. She worked at Hallmark when the network was in its prime, so I’d like to think she knows how to bring the company back to success. Though only time will tell how Michelle’s leadership will impact Hallmark as well as its consumers.
What are your thoughts on this piece of movie news? Are you happy to see Michelle Vicary return to Hallmark? Tell me in the comment section!
Back in June, a third movie in the Haul Out the Holly series was announced. According to an article from the blog, It’s a Wonderful Movie, the film is Halloween themed, as two “spooky new neighbors”, Luna and Marvin, move to the neighborhood of Evergreen Lane. At the time of the announcement, no release date had been revealed. However, the official IMDB page for the third chapter, titled Haul Out the Halloween, has the release date listed as October 15th, 2025. As of the publication of this Word on the Street story, Hallmark has not confirmed this date. If Haul Out the Halloween will indeed premiere on October 15th, this could indicate when Hallmark Channel’s ‘Countdown to Christmas’ line-up will begin. With October 15th falling on a Wednesday and with the first Christmas films of 2024 and 2023 premiering on October 18th and October 20th, I speculate 2025’s first ‘Countdown to Christmas’ film could premiere as early as October 17th.
On Hallmark Channel’s website, a new movie has received a September 27th release date. The film is titled Adventures in Love & Birding, with Andrew Walker and Rachel Boston co-leading. The movie is about the following:
“A single mom agrees to be the partner of a bird enthusiast for a birding competition but misunderstands the assignment and tells everyone she’s his new girlfriend instead of just his teammate.”
Because the phrase “misunderstands the assignment” is included in this synopsis, I wonder if Rachel Boston’s character is a teacher? Maybe she is teaching her students about birds, leading to her involvement in the competition?
Image of crow at sunset created by Rayudu NVS at freeimages.com. Photo by <a href=”/photographer/rayudu238-57835″>rayudu NVS</a> from <a href=”https://freeimages.com/”>FreeImages</a>. Image found at freeimages.com.
Back in May, I wrote a Word on the Street story about two new films in the Mystery Island series; Mystery Island: Play for Keeps and Mystery Island: House Rules. At the time, the fourth movie, Mystery Island: House Rules, had not received a premiere date. But Hallmark Channel’s website has now chosen September 14th as the film’s date of release. The movie’s official synopsis is the same on both its IMDB page and its Hallmark Channel page. Plus, Hallmark Channel revealed a collection of promotional photos for Mystery Island: House Rules as well. This fourth installment comes a month after Mystery Island: Play for Keeps, which premieres August 17th.
What are your thoughts on these pieces of movie news? Are you looking forward to either Haul Out the Halloween, Adventures in Love & Birding, or Mystery Island: House Rules? Let me know in the comment section below!
It’s been a while since I’ve written a list article. In fact, the last time I wrote any kind of list article was when I published my list of the top ten best stand-alone films back in March. It has also been a while since I published anything Hallmark related, as I reviewed Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back in April. To make up for lost time, I decided to create a list of thirteen questions I have for When Calls the Heart’s 13th season! With the announcement of any new television season comes a series of questions and speculation from the fans. Though these questions will not be answered until next year, a list like mine gives Hearties something to think about while they wait for the show to come back. This list is going to contain spoilers for When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season as well as some of the series’ other seasons. If you are a Heartie who is not caught up with the show, please read my list at your own discretion.
When Calls the Heartseason twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel
1. Will Elizabeth and Jack Jr. permanently reside in Cape Fullerton?
In the season twelve finale of When Calls the Heart, Jack Jr. and Elizabeth are forced to make an emergency trip to Cape Fullerton due to Jack Jr. receiving Insulin that wasn’t properly refrigerated. But earlier in the episode, Elizabeth receives a letter from Charlotte Thornton. In this letter, Charlotte encourages her grandson and daughter-in-law to move to Cape Fullerton, so Jack Jr. can live closer to Diabetes-related medical facilities. Since the season twelve finale ended with Elizabeth and Jack Jr. traveling to the train station, it’s currently unknown how long Jack Jr. and Elizabeth plan to stay out of Hope Valley. If they were to make Cape Fullerton their permanent home, this creative decision would lead to a collection of other questions. Would Elizabeth continue teaching at a new school or would she retire from the teaching profession? What would Jack Jr. and Elizabeth’s new home look like? Would the show’s overarching story alternate between Cape Fullerton and Hope Valley, similar to how season two alternated between Hope Valley and Hamilton?
2. Will Allie and Nathan make Cape Fullerton their permanent residence?
With Nathan on his Mountie rounds, Elizabeth cannot quickly tell him of her and her son’s sudden departure to Cape Fullerton. So, before leaving Hope Valley, she writes a letter to Nathan explaining what happened. To Elizabeth’s surprise, Nathan and Allie join her and Jack Jr. as they make their way to their destination. When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season concludes with the two families traveling beyond Hope Valley. Like I said for question number one, season twelve’s finale ended with Jack Jr. and Elizabeth on their way to the train station. This means we also don’t know how long Nathan and Allie plan on staying in Cape Fullerton. If they end up permanently leaving Hope Valley, there would be a lot of questions associated with that creative decision. Would Nathan join the Mounties in Cape Fullerton or would he retire from the Mountie profession? Would Allie complete her education at a new school or graduate from the Jack Thornton School in Hope Valley? How would they adjust to their new environment?
3. Are we going to see more frequent appearances of Charlotte and/or Tom Thornton?
As I mentioned for question number one, Charlotte encourages Jack Jr. and Elizabeth to move to Cape Fullerton. I remember Elizabeth saying in the season twelve finale how, in Cape Fullerton, Charlotte owns a boarding house. If Jack Jr. and Elizabeth were to make Cape Fullerton their permanent residence, how often would Charlotte appear in When Calls the Heart’s thirteenth season? Would the character get re-cast or would Brooke Shields reprise her role? When Tom Thornton was on the show in seasons five and eleven, he never mentioned if he still lives in Hamilton like he did in season two. In fact, I don’t recall the script ever revealing where Tom currently resides. So, if Charlotte were to make more frequent appearances in season thirteen, does this mean Tom could also appear on the show more often as well? In my opinion, seeing the Thornton family more consistently on When Calls the Heart would be a breath of fresh air!
One of the biggest surprises in season twelve was Fiona’s decision to sell her barber shop. While the sale was successful, the identity of the buyer or their intention for the space was never revealed. What the new purpose of the building will be is, at this point, any Hearties’ guess. However, I wonder if this is how Rosemary finally gets her long-awaited theater? Elizabeth and Nathan are shown leaving a movie theater in the twelfth season’s seventh episode, “Dance the Night Away”. From a production perspective, this makes the chances of Rosemary receiving her theater seem a little more realistic. If the creative team wanted to add a theater to Hope Valley using the set space they already have, the set design department could tear down the barber shop’s back and side walls. From there, they could build upon the barber shop by expanding the walls and adding more length as well as depth to the space. Another realistic way a theater could be incorporated in Hope Valley is for the set design department to repurpose the school/church’s interior as the inside of the theater.
5. Will Edie actually start her law firm in Hope Valley?
Edie Martell was one of the new characters introduced in When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season. During a conversation she shared with Lucas, I recall Edie discussing her desire to open a law firm in Hope Valley. As of the publication of this list, no official announcements have been made regarding Edie’s return to the show. But if she does stay in Hope Valley, will her law firm become a reality? From what I remember, When Calls the Heart has never featured a law firm in Hope Valley before. Now that I say that, it makes me question how Hope Valley’s residents have settled their legal matters prior to Edie’s arrival?
6. Has the national park project become abandoned like season eleven’s hotel project?
At the beginning of When Calls the Heart’s eleventh season, Lucas announced he was planning on building a hotel using land gifted to him from Lee. But as the season carried on, Lucas’ hotel project became abandoned in favor of a new project; a national park. Reintroduced at the beginning of season twelve, I had my concerns the national park project would become the next abandoned large-scale project. Seeing how little progress was made throughout season twelve, I think those concerns were proven correct. Speaking only for myself, I’m becoming tired of major plans on When Calls the Heart being left unfinished. This kind of makes the show’s creative team look like they’re making promises they know they can’t keep. Though I’d like to see the national park project completed in season thirteen, it’s one of those creative decisions where I’ll believe when I see it.
When Calls the Heartseason eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel
7. Will Hope Valley finally see their first female Mountie?
My second question on this list was will Allie and Nathan make Cape Fullerton their permanent residence? If they do, that means Hope Valley will need a new Mountie to look after the town. This would be the perfect opportunity for When Calls the Heart to introduce the show’s first female Mountie! I’ve said before on 18 Cinema Lane how a female Mountie’s inclusion in the show’s story fits the narrative the series has had since the beginning. During When Calls the Heart’s soon-to-be thirteen season lifespan, Hope Valley has had a female mayor and several female business owners. The town also has a female doctor as well as a female pharmacist. With all that said, I truly believe Hope Valley’s first female Mountie would provide an interesting and exciting dynamic to When Calls the Heart!
8. Will a subplot revolve around Angela’s experiences at college?
Angela, Joseph, and Minnie took a tour of the Schwartzman School in season twelve’s ninth episode, “Buried Treasure”. In my re-cap for that episode, I wondered how Angela’s story would be included in future seasons if she attended the school. Would some scenes cut away to the Schwartzman School, alternating the show’s story between the school and Hope Valley? Or would Angela be temporarily written off When Calls the Heart, with her story told through dialogue from the Canfield family? Season twelve’s finale revealed Angela will, indeed, attend college. She even receives a quilt as a graduation present. With Angela Canfield and the show itself embarking on a new chapter, it’ll be interesting to see how these stories are told in season thirteen!
9. Now that Emily has graduated, will she continue to work for Joseph and Henry’s hazelnut business?
Toward the beginning of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season, Joseph and Henry start their own hazelnut business. Over the season, the business successfully grows, with Emily playing a pivotal role in the business’ operation. But now that Emily has graduated from the Jack Thornton School, where does her story go from here? Does she continue to work for Henry and Joseph’s hazelnut business, saving money to eventually go to college? Or will Hearties learn through dialogue Emily already left for college by the start of the new season? If season thirteen shows Emily leaving for college, will another student of the Jack Thornton School help run the business or will When Calls the Heart’s creative team introduce a new character? Joseph and Henry’s hazelnut business was such a pleasant surprise in season twelve, so I’m curious to see what’s in store for next year!
10. Will season thirteen contain an overarching mystery?
An overarching story in season twelve was the mystery of the gold coin. What started as a simple search for who originally owned a unique looking coin turned into a discovery of buried treasure. Based on responses from the Hearties and my own personal opinion, the gold coin mystery was one of the best parts of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season! This positive reception makes me wonder if the show’s creative team will feature another overarching mystery in season thirteen? Are Bill and Rosemary going to solve another case or will different characters become amateur detectives? If an overarching mystery is written into season thirteen’s script, would it connect to characters and stories from past seasons? Personally, I hope When Calls the Heart’s new season contains a mystery, as it would add intrigue and excitement to the overall story!
11. Is an unresolved story going to be completed in season thirteen?
Back in season ten, Rosaleen Sullivan returned to Hope Valley. While there, she overcame her resentment toward Henry, even making a peace offering by inviting him to church. Meanwhile, Henry apologized to Rosaleen for the mining tragedy that claimed her father. This joint story provided a conclusion for both Henry and Rosaleen, with Rosaleen moving forward from the past and Henry finally achieving redemption. When Calls the Heart will soon enter its thirteenth season. Television shows lasting that long are bound to contain unresolved stories. If a story from season one could become resolved in season ten, I wonder if any uncompleted stories from When Calls the Heart will be finished in season thirteen?
12. Is another student going to receive the Hope Valley Scholarship?
After learning Rosaleen doesn’t have enough money to attend nursing school, Henry created the Hope Valley Scholarship. This scholarship allows current and former students of the Jack Thornton School to achieve their academic dreams. Since its introduction in season ten, however, I haven’t heard of any other student receiving this scholarship. With Angela, Timothy, and Emily having recently graduated and with Allie’s graduation on the horizon, I wonder if the Hearties will see another Hope Valley Scholarship recipient? Now that Henry is co-owner of a successful hazelnut business, does some of his financial earnings go toward the scholarship? Will one of Hope Valley’s residents organize a fundraiser to raise additional scholarship funds? If the Hope Valley Scholarship were incorporated into season thirteen’s script, maybe it could provide an overarching story on When Calls the Heart.
13. Will Oliver receive the birthday party he’s never had?
Oliver Garrett made his official debut in the twelfth season of When Calls the Heart. During their trip to a nearby river, Oliver reveals to Allie how he’s never had a birthday party. This is likely due to his experiences in the foster care system. As season twelve went on, I actually thought the season would end with Oliver finally receiving a birthday celebration. But in a season where a birthday party was already featured (Allie’s, in this case), I can see why When Calls the Heart’s creative team would save Oliver’s birthday party for a future season. In the season twelve finale, Oliver was promoted to Mountie Deputy. That creative decision gives him a reason to stay in Hope Valley. If Oliver does remain in Hope Valley, as well as on the show, I wonder if he will get that birthday party he’s never had?
When Calls the Heartseason ten poster created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel
Lately, I’ve been reading books for the Eurovisionathon readathon as well as conducting research for my upcoming Sally Solves a Mystery article. But I wasn’t going to miss the opportunity to review Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back! Leading up to the premiere of Hallmark’s newest presentation, I was going to write a Word on the Street story sharing my thoughts on the film’s trailer. This did not happen because Hallmark gave the movie almost nonexistent marketing. On Hallmark Channel’s website, there were no promotional photos, trailer, or official poster presented for Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back. Only three images on IMDB (Internet Movie Data Base) make up any promotional campaign this film received. Even on social media, the only people I saw talking about the film were POstables (fans of the Signed, Sealed, Delivered series). Despite this minimalistic marketing approach, I was looking forward to Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back. That’s because I was curious to see who would portray the rock star character and how that character would impact the mystery.
Correcting the predecessor’s mistakes: When I reviewed Signed, Sealed, Delivered: A Tale of Three Letters last year, one of my criticisms was Shane and Oliver’s relationship problems. In my review, I said the couple’s woes got to the point where they didn’t seem compatible like in previous films. It looks like Signed, Sealed, Delivered‘s creative team took this criticism seriously, as Oliver and Shane appeared more compatible in Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back! Throughout the movie, the couple are shown genuinely supporting and loving one another, making their moments together feel reminiscent of past installments. Even when Oliver is facing a bit of an identity crisis, Shane never gives up on her husband. She cheers Oliver on from the (figurative) sidelines and lets Oliver deal with his situation on his own terms. Because Signed, Sealed, Delivered’s creative team placed more emphasis on the loving interactions between Shane and Oliver, they fixed a mistake from the previous chapter!
A humble celebrity: In some Hallmark productions, the story will include a public figure (either a celebrity or royalty) who needs to learn humility by the end of the movie. But in Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back, that celebrity was already humble. Nate Holloway is the rock star I mentioned in this review’s introduction. When the POstables turn to Nate for help with their letter-related mystery, he is reluctant to give away any information. This is because he’s protecting a close friend who chooses privacy over fame. Though he eventually shares his friend’s identity with Oliver and Shane, Nate reveals how his friend has written all his hit songs. However, Nate also shares how he sets aside money for his friend, showing acknowledgement and appreciation for his musical success. Through the screenwriting and William Wilder’s performance, Nate Holloway was such a pleasant surprise in Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back!
A mystery within a mystery: The mystery of Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back involves the POstables tracking down the sender of a mysterious letter. Not only do the POstables turn to Nate for help, they go on a multi-state road trip in order to solve the mystery. While the story continues, however, another mystery emerges from the initial, previously stated one. This second mystery isn’t revealed until about the film’s half-way point. I liked this creative decision of presenting a mystery within a mystery! The way Signed, Sealed, Delivered’s creative team incorporated these mysteries into their script allows the audience to stay invested in the movie, as well as maintain intrigue!
Forced humor: Back in February, when I reviewed Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, I talked about how the film’s humor felt forced. In that review, I said Delores’ antics and gimmicks came across as too over-the-top and silly. I also said Delores’ interactions with other characters felt like they belonged in a sit-com. The creative team behind Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back made this same mistake; presenting humor that feels forced. One example is when Oliver, Shane, Rita, and Norman meet up for brunch. During this gathering, the friends discuss who is having a baby. This discussion quickly turns into miscommunications about who is pregnant and how many babies they are having. The scene itself is drawn out to about a little over a minute, lasting longer than necessary. The conversation sounded very repetitive as well. Norman, Rita, Shane, and Oliver talked in an animated fashion, making their discussion feel over-the-top. What I just described sounded like a scene out of a sit-com. All it was missing was a laugh track.
Far-fetched resolutions: Hallmark’s presentations, more often than not, make their audience suspend a certain amount of disbelief. Sometimes, this suspension of disbelief can be so great, the audience can’t take that movie seriously or believably. This happened on a few occasions in Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back. At the Dead Letter Office, Norman is trying to figure out the identity of the letter’s sender. A few seconds after analyzing the handwriting, Norman is able to conclude certain aspects of the sender’s identity, such as their age. While I’m aware the Signed, Sealed, Delivered series is a fictionalized version of postal detective work, I found the discovery of Norman’s resolution too far-fetched. I couldn’t take Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back seriously because of moments like the one I brought up.
An emphasis on Oliver’s subplot: Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back features a main plot (the mystery with its accompanying mystery that I mentioned earlier in this review) and two subplots. These subplots are the preparations for a fundraising gala and Oliver receiving a box from his biological father. The creative team behind the 2025 film decided to place the most emphasis on Oliver’s subplot. Personally, I found this subplot the least interesting part of the movie. No new information is revealed from this box, especially for viewers who have consistently followed the Signed, Sealed, Delivered series. The box itself and Oliver’s response to it have very little connection to the other plots in the script. Any time Oliver’s subplot came up in the movie, I wanted the story to go back to showing the characters either planning the gala or solving the mystery. The box did not present a strong conflict that needed to be resolved by the end of the story.
While Shane, Rita, Oliver, and Norman discuss the mysterious letter in Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back, Rita says the letter itself says so much and nothing at all at the same time. Rita’s statement is the best way I can describe this newest chapter in the Signed, Sealed, Delivered series. On the one hand, there are aspects of the film I liked. The movie improved upon some of the predecessor’s flaws, like making Oliver and Shane’s relationship seem more compatible. I also liked how Nate was a humbler celebrity and how the story contained a mystery within a mystery. On the other hand, several creative errors held the film back from becoming a stronger picture. The creative team behind Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back chose to emphasize Oliver’s subplot, which I found the least interesting part of the story. Far-fetched resolutions and forced humor prevented me from taking the movie seriously. Looking back on the Signed, Sealed, Delivered films from this year and last year, I think the series should have stayed in retirement. These titles lack the cozy charm that made the series stand out from others on Hallmark Mystery. How can we expect more films from Signed, Sealed, Delivered when Hallmark provided very little marketing for this movie?
Overall score: 6 out of 10
Have you seen Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back? Do you think the Signed, Sealed, Delivered series will continue? Please tell me in the comment section!
Now we’ve come to the end of another double feature, as both chosen titles, Young at Heart and An Old Fashioned Christmas, have been watched and reviewed! In the introduction, I brought up the following question:
Did these two movies deserve a second chance?
For my answer, I’ll say Young at Heart was more deserving of a second chance than An Old Fashioned Christmas. With Young at Heart, I not only received an opportunity to check out more projects from Frank Sinatra’s and Alan Hale Jr.’s filmography, I was also given an official introduction to Doris Day’s movies. I found a good excuse to see more musicals, as well as films from the 1950s. Overall, I enjoyed Young at Heart more than Hallmark’s 2010 presentation. As someone who loves An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving, the sequel left a lot to be desired. Despite being titled An Old Fashioned Christmas, the film didn’t feel like a Christmas film. Instead of prioritizing the messages and themes of the holiday, the script primarily focused on stories that could have taken place any time of year. It also doesn’t help how so much of the story revolves around a love triangle. Looking back on An Old Fashioned Christmas, it makes me wonder if the sequel’s poorer quality, as well as becoming forgotten by time and Hallmark themselves, is the reason why I’ve, more often than not, seen DVD copies of the movie included in Christmas movie box sets?
Thank you for joining me for the second part of my Second Chance Christmas Double Feature! Unlike my review of Hallmark’sFrankenstein, this review of An Old Fashioned Christmas will contain a few spoilers. If you’re curious about why I chose An Old Fashioned Christmas for this double feature, you can check out the introduction in the link below.
An Old Fashioned Christmasposter created by RHI Entertainment, The Government of Ireland, Parallel Film Productions, MNG Films, Muse Entertainment Enterprises, and Hallmark Channel
1. How were you introduced to An Old Fashioned Christmas and why was it selected for this double feature?
I have declared An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving as one of my favorite Hallmark movies. Years ago, when I discovered the 2008 film received a sequel, I was eager to check that movie out. But as time went on, Hallmark gave the sequel fewer airings during their Christmas line-ups, making it more difficult to watch the film. I’ve always looked for the right time to write about An Old Fashioned Christmas. I even included it on two lists; 2022’s top ten movies I’d love to review and 2023’s top ten Christmas movies I’d love to review. On both lists, I said I found a few DVD copies of the 2010 title. But, more often than not, these DVDs were included in Christmas movie box sets, which, typically, are expensive. Fortunately, An Old Fashioned Christmas was uploaded on Youtube, which is how I watched it.
2. You’ve mentioned An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving being one of your favorite Hallmark movies. Did An Old Fashioned Christmas contain any elements that made you like the 2008 film?
One of the reasons why I love An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving is how immersive the production is! The attention to detail and historical accuracy created the illusion of taking the audience to another time and place. This same strength was found in An Old Fashioned Christmas! One simple, yet effective, example were the props. Anytime Tilly and Isabella shared a meal with the Shannon family, the table was covered with fine china dishes, crystal goblet-style glasses, and even a shiny silver teapot. These specific props reflected the story’s time period, which appears to be the late 1800s. They also symbolized the prestigious family history of the Shannons.
3. Is the theme of “second chances” incorporated in An Old Fashioned Christmas’ story? If so, how?
One of the reasons why Tilly wanted to travel to Ireland was to meet her father’s side of the family. After she gets to know her paternal grandfather and uncle, Tilly writes a letter in the hopes Isabella will make amends with Sean (Tilly’s grandfather). So, in An Old Fashioned Christmas, not only is Tilly given a second chance to connect with her father’s side of the family, Isabella received a second chance to build a bridge between herself and Tilly’s grandfather.
4. Was there anything about An Old Fashioned Christmas you liked or didn’t like?
Similar to Young at Heart, the dialogue was one of the best parts of An Old Fashioned Christmas! Because of the thought and effort put into this film-making aspect, conversations between characters sounded intelligent and eloquent. During breakfast one morning, Lady Shannon asks, “Wouldn’t it be lovely for Americans to have titles”? This question relates to how her son, Cameron, will become an Earl someday. Isabella responds by saying, “Actually, we do. We all share the same title: American”. The way Isabella answered Lady Shannon’s question carried a sense of confidence and grace, simply stating a major difference between her world and the world of the Shannon family. I also thought Isabella’s response to Lady Shannon’s question was pretty clever.
Speaking of Lady Shannon’s son, Cameron, I found him to be the worst character in An Old Fashioned Christmas. He always acted like he had something to prove. Plus, Cameron attempted to get the last word in every argument or conversation. The longer I watched An Old Fashioned Christmas, the more annoying Cameron became. I recognize the film’s creative team was trying to create a male character different from Gad (Tilly’s fiancé). However, this goal can be achieved without making that male character completely unlikable.
5. On 18 Cinema Lane, you’ve covered plenty of Christmas films. How is An Old Fashioned Christmas similar to or different from other Christmas pictures written about on your blog?
As I answered for question number three, meeting her father’s side of the family was the reason Tilly wanted to travel to Ireland. Like I also answered for question number four, Isabella responded to Lady Shannon’s question by stating Americans share the same title: American. The story of an American protagonist traveling to Ireland to learn more about her father’s side of the family felt very reminiscent of Christmas at Castle Hart. Another similarity these films share is how a majority of their stories take place in an Irish castle.
6. Did you develop any thoughts and/or questions while watching this film?
What makes An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving such a great movie is how the story embraces the Thanksgiving holiday. The film boasts a Thanksgiving dinner and showcases themed decorations, like a handmade blanket. But the 2008 picture also weaves the messages and themes of the holiday into the story and dialogue, truly making An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving feel like a Thanksgiving movie. An Old Fashioned Christmas definitely looked like a Christmas movie, as decorations and themed activities were sprinkled throughout the film. However, it did not feel like a Christmas picture. That’s because the majority of the story emphasized the love triangle between Tilly, Gad, and Cameron. An Old Fashioned Christmas is a Hallmark presentation where the protagonist says they are going to do something, but spends the majority of the film not doing what they said they were going to do. One of the reasons for Tilly and Isabella’s trip to Ireland was for the Earl of Shannon to mentor Tilly in her writing, in the hopes of getting Tilly’s work published. But throughout the one hour and fifteen-minute movie, Tilly barely accomplishes any writing goals. In fact, the only writing Tilly does is composing letters to her mother.
7. How would the story of An Old Fashioned Christmas change if it revolved around another holiday?
I just mentioned for question number six how the majority of An Old Fashioned Christmas’ story emphasized the love triangle between Tilly, Gad, and Cameron. Other stories, such as the Earl of Shannon mentoring Tilly, didn’t really have anything to do with the Christmas holiday. Therefore, changing the plot of An Old Fashioned Christmas to another time of year wouldn’t make a difference.
8. Did An Old Fashioned Christmas deserve a second chance? If so, why?
Now that I have seen An Old Fashioned Christmas, this is, honestly, a tough question to answer. On the one hand, I received some closure for how the story continues after An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving. I also developed my own, honest opinion about the sequel. But, on the other hand, An Old Fashioned Christmas, kind of, let me down. The Christmas holiday almost seems like an afterthought in the 2010 title. There were underutilized aspects of the story, like Tilly pursuing her writing dreams. So, to answer this question, I’m thankful I received an opportunity to check out An Old Fashioned Christmas. However, I don’t think it was worth the wait.
9. After watching An Old Fashioned Christmas, is there anything you can take away from your movie viewing experience?
If you ignore the fact An Old Fashioned Christmas was created as a sequel to An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving, this is an ok film. The attention to detail and historical accuracy create a visually immersive experience. The dialogue was also well written and delivered. But if you intend to watch An Old Fashioned Christmas as a sequel to An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving, you will be underwhelmed. With Tilly, Gad, and Isabella as the only returning characters, the family dynamic between Tilly’s family and Isabella is absent. Like I said for questions number six and seven, the majority of An Old Fashioned Christmas’ story emphasizes the love triangle between Gad, Tilly, and Cameron. It did not help that Cameron was such an unlikable character. Honestly, this movie will likely be a one-time watch for me. Since I still love An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving, I’ll just stick with the 2008 picture.
In the finale of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season, Elizabeth receives a letter from her mother-in-law, Charlotte Thornton. Within the letter, Charlotte encourages Elizabeth and Jack Jr. to move to Cape Fullerton, in order to live closer to Diabetes related medical facilities. Turning to Rosemary for advice, Elizabeth is unsure of what to do. Rosemary reassures her friend how she’ll know what to do if the time comes. As I watched this episode, I considered talking about how When Calls the Heart’s future is unknown, similar to how Elizabeth and Jack Jr.’s future is unknown. But, during the airing of the season finale, an official commercial declared a thirteenth season coming in 2026. So, in a way, the Hearties received closure. However, while we know another chapter is on the horizon, we don’t yet know what will happen in that chapter. So, for now, there is still some uncertainty. Like any season finale, this episode of When Calls the Heart leaves Hearties with a variety of questions. The unknowns of the next season may cause some fans to be concerned over their favorite characters. What we do know is how the show will likely go into production from mid-summer to late autumn, with the season possibly premiering during the first half of 2026. This speculation is based on the schedules of past seasons. We also know we’ll get answers to, at least, some of our questions when the time comes.
Just a reminder: If you did not see the season finale of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.
When Calls the Heartseason twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel
Season: 12
Episode: 12
Name: Must be Gold
Major stories:
The stolen gold coins are still at large. Not wanting to leave a mystery unsolved, Rosemary interviews Edie, hoping she knows something about the treasure. Unfortunately, Edie knows about as much as Rosemary: nothing. But after Rosemary reexamines a map with Bill and Nathan, they figure out the treasure’s likely hiding place; a wishing well. Edie and Lucas also come to this conclusion when they visit Ernie’s ranch. Among a jar of coins, they find a double-headed eagle gold coin, similar to the one found earlier in season twelve. Remembering how Ernie always put coins in the wishing well, Edie leads Lucas there. When all five people discover they’re at the wishing well for the same reason, they work together to dig up a large metal box. Later, at Hope Valley’s Mountie office, it is discovered the box contains the missing gold coins. Edie also discovers Ernie left her a secret message on the back of the map, explaining how he came to possess the treasure. Because there is a reward for the return of the coins, Lucas suggests Edie claim the reward to pay off Ernie’s loan.
As graduation approaches, Minnie is anxious about Angela’s departure to college. Both Elizabeth and Mei have picked up on Minnie’s recent mannerisms. They, along with Mike and Florence, agree to create a surprise for Minnie and her daughter. Throughout the episode, Mei and Mike collect answers to a series of questions about Angela’s favorite things. These answers are used to create a quilt for Angela to bring to college. Minnie is both emotionally moved and appreciative of the gesture. Meanwhile, after graduation, Jack Jr. passes out. This is the result of a recent batch of Insulin not being refrigerated properly. Elizabeth decides to make an emergency trip to Cape Fullerton, in order to help Jack Jr. feel better. Because Nathan is on Mountie rounds, Elizabeth writes a letter explaining what happened. As Elizabeth and Jack Jr. journey to the train station, Allie and Nathan join them on the trip, in support of both Jack Jr. and Elizabeth.
Because of Oliver’s progress and his help arresting the Garrisons, Nathan reveals how he’ll help Oliver graduate early. Not only that, Nathan also tells Oliver he’ll be stationed at Fort McNeil. Realizing the possibility of leaving Hope Valley (and Allie) behind, Oliver fails his examinations on purpose. When Elizabeth confronts him about his exam performance, Oliver confesses how living in Hope Valley has made him feel normal, as he never really had a childhood. However, Elizabeth figures out Oliver’s most important reason for staying in town; Allie. Eventually, Nathan realizes Elizabeth is correct in her speculation. In an effort to make a compromise, Nathan offers Oliver a promotion to Mountie Deputy.
Is it just me or did this episode, kind of, feel like a series finale? As I mentioned in this re-cap’s introduction, When Calls the Heart will receive a thirteenth season. But the scene showing Elizabeth turning off the light in her house, her letter to Nathan, and Elizabeth’s last line about finding a way to come back to Hope Valley gave an unintended sense of finality to the episode. Now that we know another season is on the horizon, this episode leaves a lot of questions. Will Elizabeth and Jack Jr. permanently move to Cape Fullerton? If so, will season thirteen take place in more than one location, similar to season two? Will Charlotte Thornton return to When Calls the Heart?
During Elizabeth’s graduation speech, she says she remembers the little faces of the graduates; Angela, Timothy, and Emily, on her first day of teaching in Hope Valley. However, this information is incorrect. While Timothy and Emily have been Elizabeth’s students since the earliest days of Elizabeth’s time in Hope Valley, Angela made her debut on When Calls the Heart in season eight. I know television shows have their continuity errors from time to time. But I was surprised no one from the show’s creative team caught this error.
Like I said in this re-cap, Angela receives a quilt, with each square representing her favorite things. The name of the town, ‘Hope Valley’, is embroidered in braille and the images on the quilt are sewn with a raised material, so Angela can feel their shapes. But this is not the only thoughtful present on this episode of When Calls the Heart. At the graduation party, Elizabeth thanks Mike and Mei for sacrificing their second honeymoon to help Jack Jr. Elizabeth, along with some of Hope Valley’s residents, pay for Mei and Mike’s third honeymoon to Miami.
When season twelve started, I had my concerns that the national park project wasn’t going to get completed. Now that the season is over, my concerns were proven correct. I’m aware large projects, like creating a national park, take time to come to fruition. But after the short-lived hotel project from season eleven, I am becoming tired of major plans on When Calls the Heart being left unfinished. Perhaps the national park will make its debut in season thirteen. But, at this point, only time will tell.
I’ve heard a quote about God giving His toughest battles to His strongest warriors. What reminded me of that quote is Faith and Mei telling Elizabeth how strong Jack Jr. is. This exchange between Elizabeth, Mei, and Faith also caused me to think about how strong the other characters on When Calls the Heart are. With Hope Valley’s residents possessing their own perspectives, dreams, and lives, strength is going to look different for each character. Last season, Toby’s strength was overcoming his struggles in math. Earlier in season twelve, Jack Jr. helped Lily find her strength on their first day of school. Dottie even had the strength to start her own business within When Calls the Heart’s first few years. Since the start of the show, there have always been tough battles woven into each story. But because of how strong the characters are, battles have been both fought and won.
Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.
When Calls the Heartseason twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel
Season: 12
Episode: 11
Name: Having Faith
Major story
Since Jack Jr.’s Diabetes diagnosis, he has become weaker and more tired. Hope Valley’s residents do whatever they can to help Elizabeth, from Bill tracking down Pal (who became lost, but was found toward the end of the episode) to Rosemary delivering food to the family. During this period, Mei finds an article about a study in Toronto using a new treatment called Insulin. Hoping to get Jack Jr. included in the study, Mei and Faith encourage Elizabeth to write a letter advocating for her son. Volunteering to raise awareness for Jack Jr.’s health, Mike and Mei travel to Toronto on Elizabeth’s behalf. Unfortunately, Jack Jr. can’t be included in the study because he’s a young child. The Insulin also can’t be easily transferred due to the medicine needing to be refrigerated shortly after it is manufactured. However, Faith and Mei are encouraged to start their own clinic, if they can find ten Diabetes patients. Ten patients are eventually found before the end of the episode. Despite a railroad delay, Mei and Mike bring the Insulin back to Hope Valley. After receiving the medicine, Jack Jr. experiences positive results. Hope has, once again, saved the day!
Because of Jack Jr. becoming too sick to play baseball, some of Elizabeth’s students organize a radio broadcast of a local baseball game. Toby and Cooper are the sportscasters, while Oliver and Allie deliver what’s happening on the field for the radio program. Watching this scene reminded me of when Hallmark Channel would organize the Kitten Bowl and the Kitten Summer Games. For readers who are unfamiliar with these events, the Kitten Bowl and Kitten Summer Games were television specials featuring kittens playing sports themed games, in an effort to raise awareness for pet adoption. Looking back on these programs, I wish some of the stars of When Calls the Heart had become sportscasters for the Kitten Bowl and Summer Games. Perhaps the kittens could have been named after some of the show’s characters.
Before Mei and Mike left for Toronto, Joseph conducted a prayer with some of Hope Valley’s other residents. He also hosted a small service where the town’s animals were blessed. Hearing prayer and seeing church services incorporated into the script was a breath of fresh air. This is because these elements are infrequently found on the show. If When Calls the Heart receives a thirteenth season, I hope Joseph uses faith more often.
During a conversation at the Queen of Hearts saloon, Lucas makes a comment about how he will likely lose his re-election. If his statement is true, I wonder if this is the creative team’s way of keeping Lucas in Hope Valley? I also wonder what Lucas will do if he’s no longer Governor? From what I remember, he sold the saloon/hotel to Lee either during season ten or shortly before that season.
During their trip to the Mercantile, Mei and Mike are searching for walnuts or almonds. This ingredient is intended for a moon cake and butter tart recipe. But when almonds and walnuts are nowhere to be found, the couple adopt a different, more accessible ingredient: hazelnuts. Not only does this decision work in Mike and Mei’s favor, other Hope Valley residents choose to use hazelnuts in their recipes too. In this episode of When Calls the Heart, hazelnuts become a shared ingredient among the characters. However, this is not the first time ingredients have been shared. When I introduced my re-cap for this season’s second episode, I talked about the presence “hope” has had within Hope Valley. I even gave an example of how hope impacted the lives of the show’s characters. Thinking about Hope Valley as a recipe, “hope” is an ingredient the characters have shared since the show’s beginning. It has taken on different forms (depending on the situation), being applied to each character’s life in a personalized way. How “hope” is shared is dependent on the character in question, from Elizabeth giving her students valuable advice to Lucas coming up with ways to save the day.
Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.
When Calls the Heartseason twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel
Season: 12
Episode: 10
Name: Through the Valley
Major stories:
Lucas has been served with a lawsuit from the ranchers. When he shares the news with Edie, she declares how she no longer works for McGinty. After Nathan is informed of the lawsuit, he and Lucas confront McGinty over it. During this confrontation, McGinty shares how Allie and Oliver trespassed on his property. Later that day, when Nathan asks Allie about McGinty’s claim, Allie confesses how she and Oliver, indeed, trespassed on McGinty’s land. Even though Allie believes she was in the wrong, Elizabeth tries to take some of the blame, due to presenting project-based learning to her students. But Oliver steps in and reveals how a path near McGinty’s land was blocked by ash trees. He believes the ash trees were stolen from Lee’s property, as the only ash trees near Hope Valley are owned by Lee. Oliver’s suspicions end up being correct, with Bill and Henry later confronting McGinty about Oliver’s findings. To avoid time in jail, McGinty drops the trespassing charges he gave to Oliver and Allie.
When it’s time for Elizabeth’s students to share their progress on their projects, Emily doesn’t have anything to bring to class. After school, she explains to Elizabeth how working at Henry and Joseph’s hazelnut business has prioritized her time. This inspires Elizabeth to help Emily find her project through her work with the hazelnuts. Because of how sawdust has helped the hazelnuts grow, Emily decides to create a project about the positive effects on conserving sawdust. But when she picks up a book she ordered at the Mercantile, Florence and Ned reveal how several students have submitted their applications for college. Embarrassed by her forgetfulness, Emily shares what happened with Elizabeth. When Emily tells Elizabeth she wanted to be just like her, Elizabeth reassures her student how a career in business would be a better fit for her. Meanwhile, Elizabeth is concerned about her son. He has not only been more tired lately, he also has been hungrier. When Jack Jr. passes out one day, Faith suspects he could be dehydrated. But after a series of tests, Faith tells Elizabeth her son has Diabetes.
Mei and Mike plan on hosting a private harvest feast for just the two of them. They go to the Mercantile in search of walnuts or almonds for their butter tart and moon cake recipes. When almonds and walnuts are not available, Joseph suggests using some of the hazelnuts from his and Henry’s business. The other patrons of the Mercantile believe Joseph’s idea is a good one. So, they adopt hazelnuts in their recipes, turning Mike and Mei’s private feast into a community wide event. Despite this change in plans, the feast is a success! During the feast, Mike reveals to Mei the real reason he wanted the event to remain private; presenting a second honeymoon to Niagara Falls.
Georgie McGill returns to Hope Valley. Because of the recent arrests of Woody and Sunny Garrison, Georgie won’t share any information about the case. She even forbids Bill from sharing information with Rosemary. This upsets Rosemary, but she manages to find a way to write a report without Bill’s help. Meanwhile, Georgie and Bill interrogate Woody. He not only admits to being an accessory to the crime, he tells Bill and Georgie his brother, Jake, gave him a treasure map before he passed away. Woody claims only Jake knew where the stolen gold coins are. After the interrogation, Bill apologizes to Rosemary when he pays her a visit at the Valley Voice’s office. He explains how Georgie likes things done “by the book”. Bill also tells Rosemary how the gold coins’ location is still unknown. At the harvest feast, Georgie and Rosemary come to better terms. One reason is how, according to Georgie, Bill sang Rosemary’s praises to Georgie. However, that’s not the only thing Bill does. Before she leaves Hope Valley, Georgie and Bill share a kiss.
It is interesting which stories have become prioritized in this season of When Calls the Heart. As I mentioned in this re-cap, Faith tells Elizabeth her son has Diabetes. While this development leads to an interesting story, I wish that story had been introduced earlier in season twelve. Meanwhile, Ava’s story was drawn-out for more than half the season. Personally, I think her story should have lasted, at most, four or five episodes.
When Calls the Heart’s creative team has tried to give Bill a love interest on more than one occasion. First, it was Abigail. Then, it was A.J. After that, it was Mollie. Now, it seems to be Georgie. If Bill does start a relationship with Georgie, I wonder if Jack Wagner will leave the show? As of the publication of this re-cap, there haven’t been any announcements about cast members departing from When Calls the Heart.
Throughout the season, I’ve heard some fans entertain the idea of Edie and Lucas becoming a couple. But, in my opinion, the on-screen chemistry between Chris McNally and Miranda MacDougall hasn’t been as strong as other on-screen pairings. Plus, Edie and Lucas shared such limited time together within season twelve. Maybe these things could change if When Calls the Heart receives a thirteenth season. However, I don’t know if Edie will leave when season twelve ends.
18 Cinema Lane 