Toward the end of her first radio show, Rosemary says “putting the “hope” in Hope Valley” as the show’s tagline. After hearing this statement, I thought about how Hope Valley has, indeed, provided hope to multiple characters. Because of Hope Valley, Henry Gowen turned his life around and has now become the town’s “Voice of Reason”. This little town has witnessed several miracles, such as the fires at the church/school and the saloon not causing any injuries. By working together, the residents of Hope Valley have accomplished great things, like overcoming the chickenpox outbreak back in season seven. I remember, in season two, when the town changed its name from Coal Valley to Hope Valley. That decision was made to help the town’s residents move forward from the tragedy at the mines. Since then, Hope Valley has transformed beyond the name change. Not only does “hope” have a presence in this town, “hope” has found many reasons to thrive!
Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.
Season: 12
Episode: 2
Name: You Get What You Give
Major stories:
Before school one day, Allie shares her concerns with Elizabeth about not having a special interest and what life will look like after graduation. Elizabeth reminds Allie how “journeys don’t always start with a destination”. At school, during a lesson about civics, Elizabeth realizes how popular comic books have become among her students. To keep her students focused, Elizabeth takes them on a field trip to a nearby forest. The purpose of this field trip is to not only emphasize the importance of Lucas and Lee’s national park project, but to also teach Elizabeth’s students about the significance of nature. During this field trip, the students find an animal print in the dirt. Elizabeth suggests using clay to make a mold of the print, in order to determine which animal the print belongs to. Later in the episode, at Elizabeth’s house for dinner, Allie reveals to Nathan, Bill, and the rest of the guests the print came from the Great Timber Wolf, which was native to the area. She also comments on how good these wolves’ hearing is. This fact leads Elizabeth to speculate if the wolves left the area because of the mines.
With the first episode of Rosemary’s radio show just around the corner, Rosemary struggles to find a story that will last an hour-long episode. While Ned and Florence provide some ideas, Rosemary keeps looking for a more “exciting” story. Meanwhile, Captain Billie comics have become a popular product at the Mercantile. When some children can’t afford to purchase the new issue of the comic, Henry suggests the children help Ned so they can earn money to purchase the comic. When Florence and Elizabeth discover this piece of information, they believe comic books have become an obsession. Elizabeth and Florence’s conversation inspires Rosemary to create her first episode about comic books’ popularity. When the premiere of the first radio show episode arrives, things don’t go according to plan. Rosemary hoped the discussion on comic books would be a debate. But most of the guests on the show agree that comic books have their benefits. To add a contrasting perspective at the last minute, Florence joins the show, only to prove she read some of the Captain Billie comics. At the conclusion of the radio show, Rosemary receives applause. This encourages Rosemary to make more episodes in the foreseeable future.
In Capital City, Lucas and Lee hear Edwin’s idea to save Lucas’ reputation. Edwin explains how Lucas needs to appeal to the corporate, urban, and rural vote. To win over the corporate vote, Edwin suggests naming the national park after the Irwin family, one of the wealthiest, most influential families in Canada. Lee quickly reminds Edwin that Lucas promised to name the national park after Goldy. Later in the episode, Edwin introduces Lucas to Edie Martell, a member of the Cattlemen’s Association. During this meeting, Edie explains how most of the allotted national park land was originally cattle pasture. To create a compromise, Edie recommends using the land as a summer pasture and reserving a sliver of the remaining land for the national park. When Lee learns of Edie’s proposed compromise, he is frustrated by Lucas’ willingness to be a “people pleaser”. He then comes home early and returns to Rosemary and Goldy.
Even though Oliver is getting settled in Hope Valley, Nathan wonders how he can help Oliver become a Mountie. Elizabeth suggests giving Oliver some encouragement and a win. At Hope Valley’s Mountie office, Oliver plans on organizing some case files. Nathan encourages Oliver to do a case file comparison. Oliver goes above and beyond by organizing the case files in great detail. When Nathan reviews Oliver’s work, he is impressed with Oliver’s efforts. So, Nathan gives Oliver more case files to organize. The next day, Nathan marvels at Oliver’s job well done. To acknowledge Oliver’s hard work, Nathan invites Oliver to Elizabeth’s potluck dinner.
Minor stories:
Mei and Mike come home from their honeymoon. Sadly, everything that could go wrong on their honeymoon did; from lost luggage to food poisoning. Things don’t get better when they go to Mike’s apartment. Water takes over the living space due to an open window. Throughout the episode, Mike and Mei argue over who left the window open. But eventually, they realize their relationship is more important. Toward the end of the episode, the couple makes up over dinner.
Due to the bountiful hazelnut harvest, Henry needs help collecting the hazelnuts. He recruits some of Elizabeth’s students, with the promise of comic book and magazine money. Joseph also volunteers to help Henry. Elizabeth’s students enjoy crushing hazelnuts to the beat of music. Playing music while working was Emily’s idea, as she read it increases productivity. She also warns Henry to not oversaturate the market with hazelnuts. This advice came after Joseph suggested Henry start his own hazelnut business. After the hazelnuts have been collected, Henry decides to create a hazelnut business under one condition; Joseph run the business alongside Henry. Joseph and Henry agree to this idea and shake hands. They also agree to hire Emily.
Some thoughts to consider:
- In the previous episode, Nathan is told Oliver is at the bottom of his class. But after he and Bill talk to Oliver, they think something isn’t adding up. Looking back on how detail-oriented Oliver was in this episode, it makes me wonder if he either learns differently than what Mountie training is offering or he is better suited for a specific area of the Mountie profession? One reason why I wonder this is Oliver did admit he was a “slow reader”.
- Am I the only Heartie who is concerned about Henry getting involved in another business? My concern comes from his unreliable track record. When the show began, Henry was the town’s villain working with the coal mines. This business endeavor was a tragic disaster. Then, Henry joined Hope Valley’s oil business for several seasons. The foundry ended up going under at the beginning of season ten. I like Henry as a character, so seeing him succeed would be awesome. For now, though, I’m cautiously optimistic.
- It seems like ant hills turned into mountains in this episode of When Calls the Heart. First, Mike and Mei spend most of the story arguing over who left the window open. I know married couples experience conflict, especially in Hallmark productions. However, I was more interested in seeing Mei and Mike navigate living together for the first time, as well as blending their interior design styles. I’m aware comic books are the overarching theme this season. But the reaction from some of the characters seems, in my opinion, overblown. It does make me wonder if comic books will lead to an overarching story?
What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you have any theories about Oliver? Tell me in the comment section!
Have fun in Hope Valley!
Sally Silverscreen
18 Cinema Lane 