Tag: education

Take 3: A Circle of Children (1977) Review

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Back in 2022, I wrote a list of the Top 10 Movies I’d Love to Review. Each chosen film was categorized based on how accessible they are. Reflecting on this list, I realized that as of early January 2026, the only more “accessible” titles not yet covered on my blog were A Circle of Children and Lovey: A Circle of Children Part II. With the Film. Release. Repeat. Blogathon (an event about remakes and sequels) on the horizon, I finally found a reason to review the 1978 sequel. However, I’ve never seen its predecessor, A Circle of Children. So, in preparation for my review of Lovey: A Circle of Children Part II, I’m also writing about the first film. As I said in my list of the Top 10 Movies I’d Love to Review, both A Circle of Children and Lovey: A Circle of Children Part II are based on the true story of a teacher named Mary MacCracken. Like I also said in my list, Mary’s books were not only the source material for these movies, Mary was also one of the screenwriters for both films. But over these eight years of 18 Cinema Lane’s existence, I haven’t found a made-for-tv movie from the 1970s I actually like. Will A Circle of Children change that? Let’s begin the first movie review of 2026 to find out!

A Circle of Children (1977) title card created by Edgar Scherick Productions, 20th Century Fox Television, and CBS

Things I liked about the film:

The acting: In A Circle of Children, the protagonist, Mary, visits the mother of a student named Brian O’Connell. During Mary’s conversation with Mrs. O’Connell, Brian’s mother consistently has a worn look on her face. Not only did Mrs. O’Connell’s eyes look heavy, her mouth was set in a straight line as well. Her voice almost sounded monotone, lacking emotion over her situation. Though she admits to Mary that she’s tired, Mrs. O’Connell was able to express how tired she was without relying too much on dialogue. That’s because Judy Lewis, the actress who portrayed Mrs. O’Connell, effectively utilized vocal inflection, facial expression, and even her eyes to emphasize what her character was going through.

Speaking of Brian O’Connell, I want to talk about Matthew Labyorteaux’s performance! I am familiar with his portrayal of Albert on Little House on the Prairie. Therefore, Matthew’s acting capabilities are already known to me. Mary teaching Brian to speak presents a great display of Matthew’s acting talents. When Mary is using a tape recorder in order to help Brian learn to speak, Brian has a blank look on his face. But when a teacher named Dan sings a song to the students, he offers the microphone to Brian. This time, Brian has a determined look on his face, as he intensely looks at the microphone and makes a great effort of trying to repeat Dan’s song. The next scene shows Brian receiving a second chance to speak into the microphone. His eyes become really wide and a smile spreads across his face, excited by the opportunity given by Mary and Dan. As I watched A Circle of Children, it made me believe Little House on the Prairie’s creative team chose wisely when they cast Matthew as Albert!

Since A Circle of Children is based on the true story of Mary MacCracken, I must discuss Jane Alexander’s portrayal of Mary. Throughout the movie, Jane’s performance brought empathy and relatability to her role. One great example happens when Mary encourages Brian to say his name. Brian puts together a puzzle resembling a short story he was reading earlier in the film. Because one of the characters in that story was named Brian, Mary uses this fact to motivate Brian to say his name for the first time since coming to the Children’s School for Special Education. When this plan fails, Mary develops a look of defeat on her face. Her mouth is turned into a frown and her eyes present a mixture of sadness and concern. This medium shot of Mary’s face not only says so much without saying anything at all, it also shows the audience how much she cares about the students, especially Brian.

The chemistry of Mary and Dan: When Mary first visits the Children’s School for Special Education, she meets a teacher named Dan. Over the course of A Circle of Children, Dan and Mary develop a friendship that is shown in only a handful of scenes. Despite this, their chemistry highlights how the two have become kindred spirits, bringing thoughtfulness and understanding to their friendship. The chemistry between Mary and Dan works because the on-screen chemistry between Jane Alexander and David Ogden Stiers (the actor who portrays Dan) works! The strength of their acting abilities allows David and Jane to effectively present a friendship that looked and felt believable. Because of how well they seemed to get along, I was hoping Dan and Mary’s friendship would gradually become a romance. Mary and Dan’s chemistry was such a pleasant surprise in A Circle of Children!

Creating a complex character: One of the teachers at the Children’s School for Special Education is Helga. At first, she and Mary don’t see eye to eye due to how Helga treats the students. Some examples include making a child plunge the toilet and intentionally hiding a young girl’s (literal) security blanket. But as the story goes on, Mary, as well as the audience, learns Helga actually has good intentions for the students. In fact, she wants the children to succeed just as much as Mary does. It would have been so easy for A Circle of Children’s creative team to present Helga as a one-dimensional mean teacher. Instead, the screenwriting and Rachel Roberts’ performance created a character that was complex, representing how, sometimes, approaches to education aren’t straightforward. Helga’s complexity made her a memorable character as well!

Preschool classroom image created by Vectorpocket at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by vectorpocket – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What I didn’t like about the film:

Only becoming familiar with characters: A Circle of Children consists of a large cast of characters. That’s because most of the characters are students from the Children’s School for Special Education. But A Circle of Children has a run-time of an hour and thirty-six minutes, leaving the audience with not enough time to truly get to know the characters. The film’s run-time actually forces the audience to either only become familiar with the characters or not getting to know them at all. Had A Circle of Children received a longer run-time, more opportunities to show Mary getting to know her students and help them could have been provided in the story.

Scene transitions that weren’t smooth: If a movie features smooth transitions between scenes, they can not only help the audience process the story unfolding, they can also maintain the film’s overarching pace. But in the case of A Circle of Children, choppy scene transitions sometimes created emotional whiplash. In one glaring example, Mary and her husband, Larry, confess to their daughter, Liz, of their recent separation. This confession is so upsetting, Mary herself appears to be on the verge of crying. However, the very next scene shows Mary being interviewed for a teaching aide position at the Children’s School for Special Education. This scene is intended to be less sad than the scene I previously described. To me, the transition between these two scenes felt jarring because the transition itself was choppy and abrupt.

Solutions happening for the sake of plot and time convenience: Within the first fifteen minutes of A Circle of Children, a young girl named Sarah is enrolled at the Children’s School for Special Education. According to Sarah’s mother, Sarah is unable to stand or walk. She’s also so attached to a blanket that she continuously screams at the top of her lungs if the blanket is taken away from her. For half the movie, though, Sarah is a static character. She’s either shown lying on the floor sucking her thumb or screaming because she can’t find her blanket. But at a Christmas party that takes place a little more than halfway through the movie, Sarah not only randomly starts walking, she also willingly trades her blanket for a doll. While I was happy to see Sarah achieving progress, I wish this progress was gradually woven into the script. Because Sarah suddenly achieved progress after being a static character for half the movie, the moment itself felt like it was written into the story for the sake of plot and time convenience.

String of musical notes image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/pentagram-vector_710290.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com. 

My overall impression:

In the introduction of this review, I said I haven’t found a made-for-tv movie from the 1970s I actually like. Sadly, A Circle of Children will not be the film to change that. The 1977 production isn’t a bad movie. In fact, it has its merits, especially when it comes to the acting performances. But I found the story itself to be too “slice of life” for my liking. Plus, there were other flaws that stood out to me, such as the run-time and choppy scene transitions. Looking back on A Circle of Children, however, I will admit my gratitude for its existence at all. This movie is like a time capsule when it comes to Special Education, giving viewers a glimpse into how this specific topic was approached in the 1970s. Though the film only shares one teacher’s perspective, it does express themes of helping others reach their full potential, working together to achieve a common goal, and not giving up on others. The creative team behind A Circle of Children definitely had their hearts in the right place. Now that I’ve finally seen this movie, it’ll be interesting to see where the story in Lovey: A Circle of Children Part II goes from here.

Overall score: 6 out of 10

Have you seen A Circle of Children? Are you looking forward to my review of Lovey: A Circle of Children Part II? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun at the movies!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: One Shared Ingredient

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

During their trip to the Mercantile, Mei and Mike are searching for walnuts or almonds. This ingredient is intended for a moon cake and butter tart recipe. But when almonds and walnuts are nowhere to be found, the couple adopt a different, more accessible ingredient: hazelnuts. Not only does this decision work in Mike and Mei’s favor, other Hope Valley residents choose to use hazelnuts in their recipes too. In this episode of When Calls the Heart, hazelnuts become a shared ingredient among the characters. However, this is not the first time ingredients have been shared. When I introduced my re-cap for this season’s second episode, I talked about the presence “hope” has had within Hope Valley. I even gave an example of how hope impacted the lives of the show’s characters. Thinking about Hope Valley as a recipe, “hope” is an ingredient the characters have shared since the show’s beginning. It has taken on different forms (depending on the situation), being applied to each character’s life in a personalized way. How “hope” is shared is dependent on the character in question, from Elizabeth giving her students valuable advice to Lucas coming up with ways to save the day.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 12

Episode: 10

Name: Through the Valley

Major stories:

Lucas has been served with a lawsuit from the ranchers. When he shares the news with Edie, she declares how she no longer works for McGinty. After Nathan is informed of the lawsuit, he and Lucas confront McGinty over it. During this confrontation, McGinty shares how Allie and Oliver trespassed on his property. Later that day, when Nathan asks Allie about McGinty’s claim, Allie confesses how she and Oliver, indeed, trespassed on McGinty’s land. Even though Allie believes she was in the wrong, Elizabeth tries to take some of the blame, due to presenting project-based learning to her students. But Oliver steps in and reveals how a path near McGinty’s land was blocked by ash trees. He believes the ash trees were stolen from Lee’s property, as the only ash trees near Hope Valley are owned by Lee. Oliver’s suspicions end up being correct, with Bill and Henry later confronting McGinty about Oliver’s findings. To avoid time in jail, McGinty drops the trespassing charges he gave to Oliver and Allie.

When it’s time for Elizabeth’s students to share their progress on their projects, Emily doesn’t have anything to bring to class. After school, she explains to Elizabeth how working at Henry and Joseph’s hazelnut business has prioritized her time. This inspires Elizabeth to help Emily find her project through her work with the hazelnuts. Because of how sawdust has helped the hazelnuts grow, Emily decides to create a project about the positive effects on conserving sawdust. But when she picks up a book she ordered at the Mercantile, Florence and Ned reveal how several students have submitted their applications for college. Embarrassed by her forgetfulness, Emily shares what happened with Elizabeth. When Emily tells Elizabeth she wanted to be just like her, Elizabeth reassures her student how a career in business would be a better fit for her. Meanwhile, Elizabeth is concerned about her son. He has not only been more tired lately, he also has been hungrier. When Jack Jr. passes out one day, Faith suspects he could be dehydrated. But after a series of tests, Faith tells Elizabeth her son has Diabetes.

Heart image created by Dashu83 at freepik.com <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Dashu83 – Freepik.com</a> <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/happy-valentines-day-and-heart-card-with-happy-valentines-day-and-heart_1747001.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> Image found at freepik.com

Minor stories:

Mei and Mike plan on hosting a private harvest feast for just the two of them. They go to the Mercantile in search of walnuts or almonds for their butter tart and moon cake recipes. When almonds and walnuts are not available, Joseph suggests using some of the hazelnuts from his and Henry’s business. The other patrons of the Mercantile believe Joseph’s idea is a good one. So, they adopt hazelnuts in their recipes, turning Mike and Mei’s private feast into a community wide event. Despite this change in plans, the feast is a success! During the feast, Mike reveals to Mei the real reason he wanted the event to remain private; presenting a second honeymoon to Niagara Falls.

Georgie McGill returns to Hope Valley. Because of the recent arrests of Woody and Sunny Garrison, Georgie won’t share any information about the case. She even forbids Bill from sharing information with Rosemary. This upsets Rosemary, but she manages to find a way to write a report without Bill’s help. Meanwhile, Georgie and Bill interrogate Woody. He not only admits to being an accessory to the crime, he tells Bill and Georgie his brother, Jake, gave him a treasure map before he passed away. Woody claims only Jake knew where the stolen gold coins are. After the interrogation, Bill apologizes to Rosemary when he pays her a visit at the Valley Voice’s office. He explains how Georgie likes things done “by the book”. Bill also tells Rosemary how the gold coins’ location is still unknown. At the harvest feast, Georgie and Rosemary come to better terms. One reason is how, according to Georgie, Bill sang Rosemary’s praises to Georgie. However, that’s not the only thing Bill does. Before she leaves Hope Valley, Georgie and Bill share a kiss.

Sunny autumn landscape picture created by Kotkoa at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/autumn-forest_1436222.htm’>Designed by Kotkoa</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Kotkoa – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • It is interesting which stories have become prioritized in this season of When Calls the Heart. As I mentioned in this re-cap, Faith tells Elizabeth her son has Diabetes. While this development leads to an interesting story, I wish that story had been introduced earlier in season twelve. Meanwhile, Ava’s story was drawn-out for more than half the season. Personally, I think her story should have lasted, at most, four or five episodes.
  • When Calls the Heart’s creative team has tried to give Bill a love interest on more than one occasion. First, it was Abigail. Then, it was A.J. After that, it was Mollie. Now, it seems to be Georgie. If Bill does start a relationship with Georgie, I wonder if Jack Wagner will leave the show? As of the publication of this re-cap, there haven’t been any announcements about cast members departing from When Calls the Heart.
  • Throughout the season, I’ve heard some fans entertain the idea of Edie and Lucas becoming a couple. But, in my opinion, the on-screen chemistry between Chris McNally and Miranda MacDougall hasn’t been as strong as other on-screen pairings. Plus, Edie and Lucas shared such limited time together within season twelve. Maybe these things could change if When Calls the Heart receives a thirteenth season. However, I don’t know if Edie will leave when season twelve ends.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you think Bill and Georgie will form a romantic relationship? Let me know in the comment section below!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Figuring It Out Together

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

When Angela takes a tour of the Schwartzman School, she meets a fellow student named Miss Gamble. Angela also meets some of the school’s other students, who share their enthusiasm for solving mysteries. One of these students tells Angela how the best part of mysteries is working together to figure them out. This statement made me think about how problems, conflicts, and even mysteries were solved on When Calls the Heart. If a character needs to figure something out, they will, more often than not, turn to their family or friends for help. Just in season twelve alone, the characters have relied on one another to make things possible. Oliver turned to Elizabeth for guidance when his writing sample needed improvement. Fiona sought out advice from her friends when her life was at a crossroad. Even Lee needed reassurance from Faith when he feared receiving the same medical diagnosis as his father. These three examples showcase another overarching theme on When Calls the Heart; working together to solve Hope Valley’s conflicts, problems, and mysteries!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 12

Episode: 9

Name: Buried Treasure

Major stories:

A man named Woody has recently come to Hope Valley. When he overhears Allie and Oliver talking about their map, Woody asks them to take him to a tree bearing his parents’ initials. Oliver and Allie agree to take Woody there, especially since they were planning on going hiking anyway. During the hike, the trio cross paths with Sonny Garrison, Woody’s cousin who just escaped from prison. He forces Allie and Oliver to join him and Woody on a treasure hunt. Meanwhile, Elizabeth organizes a search party with Mike and Henry when she discovers Oliver and Allie’s whereabouts. Thankfully, Elizabeth is able to find the duo because of Allie’s hair ribbon, which Allie put on a branch. Sonny is upset there is no treasure to be found. In retaliation, he desires to keep Allie, Oliver, and even Elizabeth as hostages. This plan is prevented due to the arrival of Nathan, Bill, and several other Mounties. Later, in Hope Valley, Nathan shares he was able to find Allie and Oliver because of Allie’s hair ribbon, which he returns to his daughter.

Lucas is struggling to find a solution for the national park project. So, he turns to Henry for advice. Henry suggests making an Executive Order, to make the planning process move a bit faster. He also tells Lucas by asking the ranchers for permission, they’re just going to keep finding ways to prevent the project from happening. Lucas shares this plan with Lee. He reveals how the Executive Order could cost him his Governor position, but keeping his promise to Lee is more important. When Lucas shares his plan with Edie, she tells him she will still be his friend. But she also warns Lucas how McGinty will continue finding ways to get what he wants.

Image by hannazasimova on Freepik

Minor stories:

At the Mercantile, Ned informs Ava of another traveler who lost a trunk similar to hers. Even though she insists the trunk belongs to her, Ava tries getting rid of it by throwing it over the hotel balcony. After Mike discovers the trunk in a nearby wagon, Ava comes clean about who she really is. While Ava’s name is actually Ava, she is not the heiress she has claimed to be. Before coming to Hope Valley, Ava was an assistant to Clive Maxwell, a well-known magician. His “trick” was to steal valuable items from the audience. When Clive tried stealing from a Pinkerton, he put blame on Ava. So, she ran away to Hope Valley to protect her name and because she read such good things about the town through Elizabeth’s book. Since Ava confessed, Nathan agrees to recruit a Mountie to escort Ava to court, in order to testify against Clive.

Angela, Joseph, and Minnie take a tour of the Schwartzman School. While there, they meet a student named Miss Gamble. Angela is led by Miss Gamble through the school facility and even meets some of the other students. Minnie, Angela, and Joseph were given a good first impression of the Schwartzman School. But when they arrive home, Angela has her doubts about living independently and going to school in another town. To encourage her daughter, Minnie reminds Angela of the time when she was nervous about sledding down a hill. Angela was eager to go sledding by herself after she and her mom went sledding. Minnie tells Angela to, at least, give living independently a try.

Image of magic show essentials created by Macrovector at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/card”>Card vector created by macrovector – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • Back in my re-cap for this season’s seventh episode, I said I was worried all the build-up in Ava’s story may lead to an underwhelming reveal of who Ava truly is. While I’m thankful the Hearties finally received closure to this mystery, I think my worries proved somewhat true. Ava’s actual backstory was interesting. However, it wasn’t shocking or exciting enough to justify being drawn-out for nine out of twelve episodes. In fact, some of those nine episodes had me forgetting there was a mystery surrounding Ava in the first place. If When Calls the Heart receives a thirteenth season, I hope this screenwriting flaw is improved.
  • As I said in this re-cap, and even in this re-cap’s introduction, Angela and her parents take a tour of the Schwartzman School. If she decides to attend the school, I wonder how Angela’s story will be included in future seasons? Will some scenes cut away to the Schwartzman School or will Angela be temporarily written off the show? Perhaps Hallmark would consider giving Angela her own spinoff series?
  • Is it just me or does it seem like Earl Wyatt has vanished from Hope Valley without a trace? Since his last appearance in this season’s sixth episode, none of the other characters have brought him up. He hasn’t appeared in any scenes either. This sudden disappearance makes me wonder how his story will conclude at the end of season twelve? Maybe the creative team’s intention for Earl is have him stick around in Hope Valley for another season?
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you think Angela will attend the Schwartzman School? Please tell me in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: The World is Hope Valley’s Microphone

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Whenever a new tool, idea, or concept has been introduced in Hope Valley, it has been used for the greater good of the town. The more recent addition of radio technology serves a perfect example. In this episode of When Calls the Heart alone, the radio has educated listeners, provided a platform for debates and discussions, even entertained. The radio has become a positive inclusion to Hope Valley. Other ideas have made Hope Valley a better place, from the iconic Jack Thornton School to the town’s Christmas festivities. While some of these ideas are not frequently presented on the show, they have left their mark on the history of When Calls the Heart. I haven’t given much thought to the overarching theme of new ideas serving Hope Valley’s greater good until I reflected on this episode, as well as the show as a whole.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 12

Episode: 8

Name: The Show Must Go On

Major stories:

Rowlin Rockwell (Randell’s cousin), from Benson Hills Broadcasting, pays Rosemary and Fiona a visit in Hope Valley. He informs the ladies of the Daily Dialogue’s low listenership numbers, even lower than a radio show about animal sounds. In order to impress Rowlin, Rosemary quickly comes up with the idea of bringing her production of The Importance of Being Earnest to the radio. Rowlin is so impressed with this idea, he tells Rosemary she has to present the play the next day. At rehearsal later that day, when Rosemary announces this change in plans, Mike confesses he has a sore throat. Ava recommends Mike pay the hot springs a visit. Lee and Bill also take Ava’s advice. But the next day, Mike, Bill, and Lee end up sick with Laryngitis. This stresses Rosemary out because this means about half of the play’s cast is too unwell to perform. After some encouragement from the ladies of Hope Valley, Rosemary decides to host an all-female radio production of The Importance of Being Earnest instead. The performance ends up being a success! Even Rowlin’s family liked it!

Lucas hosts a meeting with the local ranchers about Allie and Oliver’s proposal. The most vocal objection comes from a rancher named McGinty. He doesn’t believe the ranchers should move their cows to a new pasture to cater to the local wildlife. The other ranchers agree with him, even Edie stands by McGinty’s opinion. But later in the episode, Edie reveals to Lucas McGinty has tricked the other ranchers, including her uncle, into signing a loan to use his land. This is the result of a mudslide destroying a path to a pasture years ago. At the meeting, Allie recognizes McGinty’s boots, believing he helped cover up cow tracks near the river back in this season’s sixth episode. Meanwhile, Nathan shares with Bill how Toddy claims a rancher gave him small batches of gold coins for five to six years. When the rancher passed away, Toddy stopped receiving the coins. Nathan tells Bill the remaining coins were sold in Amsterdam and the identity of the rancher is Ernest “Ernie” Martell, Edie’s uncle. When Bill and Nathan question Edie about Ernie’s acquisition of the coins, she claims to have no idea what they are talking about.

Masks of comedy and tragedy images created by freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Elizabeth is scheduled to appear on an episode of the Daily Dialogue. During the recording of the episode, Elizabeth discusses her project-based learning idea with Eileen Bennett, a Superintendent from the Department of Education. Eileen doesn’t think Elizabeth’s idea is bad. However, Eileen believes the classroom’s purpose is to prepare students to be academically competitive. This lack of whole-hearted support makes Elizabeth feel discouraged. For most of this episode of When Calls the Heart, Elizabeth focuses on assisting Rosemary with the play. But after the radio performance, Elizabeth discovers a collection of letters from teachers who listened to her Daily Dialogue episode. The letters are supportive of Elizabeth’s idea, with some teachers even adopting project-based teaching. Using Nathan’s suggestion, Elizabeth reads some of the letters on The Valley Voice Radio Hour.

After selling her barber shop, Fiona still plans on marrying a man named Harold. She confesses to Faith her reason for wanting to get married; Harold is a lawyer who could help Fiona make a difference. Fiona even asks Faith to be her Maid of Honor. Later in the episode, Elizabeth shares with Fiona her reason for breaking up with Lucas in season ten; the relationship didn’t feel right in her heart. She also encourages Fiona to follow her heart and tells her how she should spread her wings to fly. After the radio performance of The Importance of Being Earnest, Rowlin is not only thrilled with the success of the play, he also likes the successful response of Elizabeth’s Daily Dialogue episode. He reveals to Fiona and Rosemary he just acquired a license for a new radio station in Port Townsen and wants to recruit them to be in charge of the station’s programming. While Rosemary turns down the offer, Fiona accepts. Before leaving for her new adventure, Fiona mentions calling off her engagement to Harold. As a going away present, Faith gives Fiona a locket, so she can fill the locket with what her heart desires.

Colorful dinosaur image created by Rawpixel.com at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/various-animal-toy-figures-in-a-colorful-background_3011200.htm’>Designed by Rawpixel.com</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Rawpixel.com – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • Now that When Calls the Heart is more than halfway through season twelve, I’ve noticed parts of the story introduced earlier in the season have been abandoned. Back in this season’s third episode, Lee reveals to Faith how his father died of an unnamed medical condition. He even shares his concerns of developing the medical condition himself. Since then, the story has not acknowledged this part of Lee’s medical history. With four episodes left in season twelve, I’m not sure how that can be resolved?
  • In this season’s second episode, Allie was concerned about not having a special interest. But what started as a chance encounter with an animal print in the dirt led to Allie’s interest in the Great Timber Wolf. Allie’s story in season twelve has been well-written. It has provided her with character development, helped her make a new friend, and connected with one of the season’s major stories. I do wonder if Allie will, indeed, find a way for the Great Timber Wolves to return?
  • As I mentioned in this re-cap, Elizabeth receives letters from teachers who support her project-based learning idea. Some teachers even claimed they were already utilizing project-based teaching in their classroom. Based on those letters, I got the impression those teachers were using project-based teaching before Elizabeth came up with her idea. With that said, why did Elizabeth submit her idea for publication if her idea already exists?
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you think the Great Timber Wolves will return near Hope Valley? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Change of Plans

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

As I stated in my last re-cap post, the premiere of this episode of When Calls the Heart aired on a different day at a different time. Even though this change in schedule was temporary, it likely gave the fans quite a surprise. But Hearties were not the only ones who had to change their plans. In this episode, Nathan and Elizabeth wanted to go to the hot springs before autumn arrived. Their trip never happened, as Elizabeth developed a cold. Every television show has experienced a change in plans at least once. When Calls the Heart has been no exception. What matters, though, is how one adapts to their plans changing. From Daniel Lissing departing from the show to working around the Writers’ and Actors’ Strikes of 2023, When Calls the Heart’s creative team has adapted the best they could. The show’s ability to adapt has rewarded them with twelve seasons and a devoted fanbase. That has been one of the many strengths of When Calls the Heart!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 12

Episode: 6

Name: When Autumn Leaves Begin to Fall

Major stories:

Allie is upset the salmon from a nearby river haven’t spawned. She claims if the salmon don’t spawn, the bears and wolves will have nothing to eat. Oliver volunteers to help Allie solve this mystery. When they get to the river, it is discovered cows from a pasture close by have been using the river for drinking water, causing the silt to rise and disturb the salmon. During their trip, while hiding in a ‘no trespassing zone’, Allie and Oliver witness two men covering up cow tracks located next to the river. After the men leave, Oliver confesses how he chooses to follow the rules because his mother is in prison. Later in the episode, Allie makes a guest appearance on Rosemary’s new radio segment; The Daily Dialogue. On the inaugural segment, Allie raises her concerns about the salmon with Lucas. She even shows him a map of where the cows have traveled. When Allie visits Oliver at the stables, she shares how Lucas will look into the salmon situation. Allie also tells Oliver how her father (not Nathan) is currently in jail.

A forensic investigator named Georgie McGill comes to Hope Valley to help Bill solve the mystery of the coin. Because she’s been working on the case of the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907 for years, Georgie is eager to lend a helping hand. She and Bill agree to visit a prisoner named Sonny, who they believe could give them information about the coin and/or Toddy Davis. Once they get to prison, the duo learn more from Sonny. According to the prisoner, Toddy hosts operations in stolen goods in Fullerton and Union City. He also works with rare coins, like the one that mysteriously arrived in Hope Valley. Bill and Georgie made a step in the right direction. But now the question remains; where did Toddy get the coin?

Detective work image created by Photoroyalty at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/investigation-background-design_1041877.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Photoroyalty – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Joseph receives an informative brochure about a school Angela is interested in attending. He has also requested a tour of the school. When Minnie discovers the brochure, she doesn’t like how she and her husband haven’t discussed it first. She also shares her concerns about Angela being in a new environment all by herself. Joseph, on the other hand, has an open mind when it comes to his daughter’s future. Eventually, Minnie checks out the brochure for herself. After being impressed with the school’s accolades, Minnie confesses to Joseph how all she wants is for Angela to live a good, independent life. Joseph reassures his wife how intelligent and confident their daughter is. They agree to pray about Angela’s educational journey. Meanwhile, Ava’s trunk has been found at a station in Buxton. But when the trunk arrives at the Queen of Hearts hotel, the trunk is filled with men’s clothing.

At the beginning of the episode, Elizabeth and Nathan plan on taking Jack Jr. and Allie to the hot springs before autumn begins. But the very next day, Elizabeth develops a cold. Throughout the episode, Rosemary and Nathan take turns caring for Elizabeth. From time to time, Elizabeth dreams about Nathan and her being together. Rosemary also volunteers to substitute Elizabeth’s class, where her students create get well cards. While Elizabeth, Rosemary, and Fiona read the cards, Elizabeth shares her project-based learning idea with Fiona. When Fiona suggests Elizabeth write about her teaching idea and publish her work, Elizabeth takes this suggestion into consideration.

Breakfast tray image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/composed-healthy-fruit-and-coffee-on-tray_1441643.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • Ever since Earl Wyatt came back to Hope Valley, some of the characters have talked about him antagonistically. Even in this episode, the way Allie was talking about going on a hike with Oliver seemed like she was intentionally trying to make Earl jealous. Personally, I don’t understand the dislike toward Earl. Throughout his time in season twelve, he has, so far, done no wrongdoing. In fact, the first thing Earl did when he returned to Hope Valley was apologize to Opal for bullying her all those years ago. As of the half-way point of When Calls the Heart’s twelfth season, the negativity toward Earl Wyatt doesn’t seem warranted.
  • Based on fan reception, Ava hasn’t received a warm welcome on the show. Hearties don’t trust her and think she’s up to no good. However, I could see Ava’s story going either way. Sure, she could be a scammer, especially since her arrival in Hope Valley conveniently mirrors Elizabeth’s introduction. But maybe Ava is, indeed, telling the truth. Like I mentioned in this re-cap post, Ava’s trunk is filled with men’s clothing. Perhaps this was a genuine mistake, as another traveler could have had a trunk similar to Ava’s. If Ava is being honest, I wonder if she’ll become a series regular on When Calls the Heart?
  • As I said in this re-cap post, Oliver shares how his mother is in prison. This is the reason why he chooses to follow the rules, as he doesn’t want to prove his doubters right. Oliver also tells Allie how he’s never had a birthday party. The more Oliver’s backstory is revealed, the more it feels reminiscent of Perry Miller’s story from the television show, Emily of New Moon. Not only was Perry’s mother in prison, he also tried to create a better future for himself, like Oliver. Come to think of it, I don’t recall Perry ever having a birthday party on Emily of New Moon.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Who do you think gave Toddy the mysterious coin? Please let me know in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Just Like in the Book, But Real

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Ava is a new character introduced in this episode of When Calls the Heart. She claims she wanted to come to Hope Valley to experience what Elizabeth wrote about in her book. In a conversation with Elizabeth, Ava says the town is “just like in the book, but real”. Though Ava’s adventure is not as simplistic as she expected. While the story of When Calls the Heart (and its respective source material) are fictional, the time period the characters exist in actually happened. Places like Hope Valley did exist; where neighbors looked out for each other, children grew up, and people fell in love. It can, sometimes, be easy to forget these facts because most of When Calls the Heart’s audience is far removed from the 1910s to 1920s and the Hearties are so caught up in what is happening on screen. What’s also easy to forget is how different life was during the early 20th century. But the timelessness of family, friendship, and community can thrive in any era! Another thing that can thrive is good-storytelling.

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season twelve poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 12

Episode: 5

Name: Mom’s the Word

Major stories:

Nathan confirms the mysterious coin is from the Rocky Mountain train robbery of 1907. Jed also confesses where he received the coin; from a man named Toddy Davis in a poker card. As Rosemary and Bill brainstorm how to reach Toddy for information, Nathan volunteers to go undercover. For about half the episode, Bill and Rosemary create a new identity for Nathan. Before leaving Hope Valley for his undercover mission, Nathan adopts the backstory of an estate dealer trying to reclaim his wealth. Within the second half of the episode, Nathan loses a poker game to Toddy. But after the game, when Nathan brings up the coin, Toddy confesses how rare coins are one of his interests. He even gives Nathan one of his business cards.

Lee and Lucas are still avoiding each other. This friction between friends bothers Joseph and Mike. So, they come up with a plan to bring Lucas and Lee together. Joseph tricks Lee into going on a hike. Meanwhile, Mike lies to Lucas about taking him on a horseback riding trip. Once all four men reach a spot next to a river, Lucas and Lee quickly realize what’s going on. But before they can do anything about it, Mike and Joseph leave with all four horses, instructing Lee and Lucas to walk back to Hope Valley and work out their differences. So, Lucas and Lee do as they’re told. During this walk, Lee shares how he didn’t like it when Lucas took Edwin’s advice over his own. Lucas confesses how Lee’s sudden departure from Capitol City caught him off guard. Back in Hope Valley, Rosemary visits the Queen of Hearts saloon, looking for Lee. A few seconds later, Lucas and Lee are shaking hands, agreeing to work together again.

Horse with saddle photo created by Topntp26 at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/stallion-black-equine-race-sky_1104246.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Topntp26 – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Elizabeth introduces project-based learning to her students. Even though the primary theme is nature, the students are eager for Elizabeth’s idea. Since Allie is still interested in the Great Timber Wolves, her project is about finding a way to bring them back around Hope Valley’s surrounding areas. Oliver even volunteers to help Allie with the mapping portion of her assignment. Before introducing the concept of project-based learning, Nathan shares his concerns with Elizabeth about Allie developing a crush on Earl. Elizabeth insists she isn’t getting involved in business that is not hers. She says the exact same thing when Rosemary suggests Elizabeth become a mother figure to Allie. Nathan’s concerns are confirmed when Allie asks Earl to go on a picnic with her. This is when Earl tells Allie he doesn’t like her in a romantic sense. When Allie shows up at Elizabeth’s house, Elizabeth senses Allie is upset. Allie eventually tells Elizabeth what Earl told her. Understanding Allie’s heartbreak, Elizabeth says how “the right one” will, indeed, come along someday. She also encourages Allie to call her “Elizabeth” at home.

Fiona comes back to Hope Valley! While the town’s residents are excited about Fiona’s return, Fiona doesn’t plan to stay long. In a conversation amongst Mei and Faith, Fiona shares how she is in the process of selling the barber shop. She also says she plans on marrying a man she’s been corresponding with some quote some time. Fiona didn’t come to Hope Valley alone, providing Ava with a ride to town. Ava claims to be a debutante whose parents are on vacation. She also claims all her luggage, including her money, was stolen. So, for the time being, Ava stays at the Queen of Hearts hotel, where her bill becomes concerning. The reason for Ava’s trip to Hope Valley is to experience what Elizabeth wrote about in her book. Ava shares how she wants to become a teacher as well. Elizabeth invites Ava to join her class on a nature walk. Unfortunately for Ava, this trip turns sour because Ava walks into poison oak. Despite this mishap, Elizabeth encourages Ava to stay in Hope Valley.

Breaking heart image created by Kjpargeter at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/broken-heart-valentine-background_1041991.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Kjpargeter – Freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • In the commercial for the next When Calls the Heart episode, it was announced there was a scheduling change. This upcoming episode will premiere on February 8th at 10pm/9c. I first learned this information on the blog, It’s a Wonderful Movie. So, if you haven’t seen It’s a Wonderful Movie’s announcement or When Calls the Heart’s commercial, I wanted to inform other Hearties so they didn’t miss the episode.
  • When I re-capped last week’s episode, I wondered if When Calls the Heart’s creative team wanted to create another love triangle featuring Allie, Earl, and Oliver. With Earl expressing no interest in dating Allie, there won’t be any more love triangles anytime soon. I have to give When Calls the Heart’s creative team credit for avoiding a second love triangle. But I also have to give some credit to Earl. Allie could have started dating Earl, only to have that relationship be strung along and Allie receive false hope. But Earl decided to be honest about his feelings and tell Allie the truth.
  • So far, the coin mystery is one of the best parts of season twelve! It has prevented episodes from becoming complete “filler”, consistently giving me something to look forward. But the more Rosemary is involved in the case, I wonder where she will find the time for her radio show? Rosemary did such a good job with her first episode, gathering various perspectives on comic books. I hope the radio show makes a return this season.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you like the show’s new character, Ava? Tell me in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Drawing Up a Grand Vision

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

One day at school, Opal shares a drawing of what Hope Valley’s
planned hotel could look like. She explains to Elizabeth how the drawing was
inspired by Lucas’ “grand vision” of what the hotel could be. The idea of Lucas
having a “grand vision” reminded me of how television shows are created. Every
show starts with a story. Within that story are characters, settings, and
conflicts. All these pieces come together to create a “grand vision”, a dream
of what the show could become. Through the various creative departments, a show’s
creative team work towards making that dream come true. If a show is
successful, a show’s audience help keep that dream alive. While Opal shares her
drawing, she and Elizabeth are not the only characters present in that scene.
Emily and Anna also marveled at Opal’s artistic abilities. It seems like
yesterday when Anna, Emily, and Opal were Elizabeth’s first students. This full
circle moment is such a great example of how the dream of When Calls the
Heart has thrived!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season eleven poster created by Hallmark Media, Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 11

Episode: 5

Name: Stronger Together


Major stories:

Maisie is still close-minded on her views about the hotel. Mike
is overwhelmed by the lack of progress and Lee is frustrated by Maisie’s stubbornness.
But this tension goes beyond sibling rivalry. Maisie confesses to Mei how she
feels her constituents are not on the same page as her. This revelation
disappoints Mike, as he feels everyone promoting the hotel share the same goal.
Meanwhile, Lucas recruits Henry to share his perspective as a former businessman.
To prevent Lucas, Mike, and Lee from feeling cornered by Maisie’s demands, Henry
suggests merging Hope Valley and Benson Hills. Lucas loves the idea so much, he
proposes it at the meeting with Maisie. Henry, Mike, and Lee already support the
merging of Benson Hills and Hope Valley. However, Maisie still isn’t convinced.
Until the next election, Lucas decides to declare co-mayors; one for Hope Valley
and one for Benson Hills. Maisie still gets to continue being the mayor of
Benson Hills and is shocked to learn Lee has become Hope Valley’s mayor.


After learning about Henry’s idea, Lucas shares it with
several of Hope Valley’s residents. When they learn the Jack Thornton School
would become part of the valley school district, some of the residents are hesitant
by the merging of Hope Valley and Benson Hills. To ease their worries, Lucas
explains how the merging of the towns would provide Hope Valley more economic
opportunities as well as more opportunities for growth. This explanation lends
itself to a unanimous vote for Hope Valley to be joined with Benson Hills. Later
in the episode, Lucas learns from Bill how the person who hurt him fired their
gun at close range. Through a reclaimed memory, Lucas confesses how he grabbed
the gun from the shooter in order to get the gun away from them.


Elizabeth and Nathan’s interaction before Hope Valley’s
Easter egg hunt concerns Allie. This is because she doesn’t want to see Nathan
get rejected by Elizabeth again. When Allie shares her feelings with Nathan, he
reassures her how she has nothing to worry about. In Hope Valley, Nathan sees
Elizabeth and Lucas interacting with one another. That interaction gives Nathan
the impression Elizabeth may resume her relationship with Lucas. But later, at
the saloon, Lucas tells Nathan how he and Elizabeth are just friends. Lucas also
shares how he and Jeanette were never engaged, telling Nathan the exact same
thing he told Elizabeth. In a private conversation between Elizabeth and
Nathan, Nathan confronts Elizabeth about her feelings for him. Because their
conversation was interrupted, Elizabth didn’t provide an answer. Toward the end
of the episode, Elizabeth tells Nathan how “friends don’t look at friends
this way”.

Small, western town image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by freepik – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.


Minor stories:

Anna pays Elizabeth a visit at the Jack Thornton School. As she is currently enrolled in teaching college, Anna has come back to Hope Valley to work as Elizabeth’s teaching assistant. During recess, Anna confesses to Elizabeth how teaching college is more difficult than she imagined, remembering how easy Elizabeth made teaching appear. Elizabeth reminds Anna how she is her own person and how becoming a good teacher takes time. One responsibility Anna is given is handing out the math tests with their results. Toby is excited about passing the test. After school, Angela and Cooper confess to Elizabeth how they wrote a letter to Jacob in Joseph’s name. Joseph received a response from his brother, with Jacob expressing interest in visiting Joseph and finally getting an apology. Elizabeth encourages Cooper and Angela to talk to their father about the letter. That evening, Angela and Cooper tell Joseph the truth, sharing how his words about family inspired them to reach out to Jacob. Joseph forgives his children and, later, recalls with Minnie how he and his brother used to sing in a choir.

Hand-written letter image created by Veraholera at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Veraholera – Freepik.com</a>. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/love-letter-pattern_1292902.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.


Some thoughts to consider:

·       
As I mentioned in this re-cap, Lee became Hope
Valley’s new mayor. He promises Rosemary to not let his new role overshadow his
family. But this is just one important matter on his plate. Not only does Lee
own the town’s saw mill and saloon, he’s also the editor of The Valley Voice. Lee
is a husband and new father as well. I’d like to think Lee can balance all
these responsibilities. However, I’m not sure how.

·       
I know this season is almost at the half-way
point, but, so far, Elizabeth and Nathan’s story is the weakest one. Almost all
the other stories introduced in season eleven’s premiere contain some amount of
intrigue. With Nathan and Elizabeth’s story, it is too drawn out and doesn’t
have enough substance. I wouldn’t be surprised if Elizabeth and Nathan finally
share their feelings for each other in season eleven’s finale.

·       
An exciting development from this episode was
the idea of Hope Valley and Benson Hills merging. While this sounds like a
great idea on paper, I wonder how this idea will be brought to life on screen.
Will the story revolve around two separate places, similar to season two? Is
the creative team behind When Calls the Heart planning on building a whole
new town for Benson Hills? At this time, another season of the show has not
been announced. But if When Calls the Heart receives a twelfth season,
it’ll be interesting to see how these questions are answered.

Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Do you like the idea of Hope Valley and Benson Hills merging? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen








Sunset Over Hope Valley: Welcome Home, Rosaleen!

On By 18cinemalane2 Comments

Once upon a time, Hearties were introduced to Rosaleen Sullivan, Mollie’s daughter who attended Coal Valley’s school. In season one, the town didn’t have a school building, Elizabeth was just starting her teaching career, and Rosaleen was beginning to cope with the loss of her father. Since then, so much has changed. Coal Valley is now Hope Valley. Elizabeth is a mother and planning on getting re-married. And this episode shows Rosaleen returning to town! From a story-telling perspective, having Rosaleen come back makes sense. Since When Calls the Heart is currently in the middle of a milestone season, it provides an opportunity for reflection. Rosaleen’s arrival does make me wonder if other former Hope Valley residents will return to the show? But until that question can be answered, let’s start this re-cap of When Calls the Heart!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season ten poster created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 10

Episode: 7

Name: Best Laid Plans

Major stories:

Rosaleen Sullivan has returned to Hope Valley. Because she is a nanny for a family moving to South Carolina, Rosaleen can only stay in town for a week. During her interactions with Elizabeth, Rosaleen shares how she’d like to become a nurse. But she feels she doesn’t have enough money to attend nursing school. While in town, Rosaleen spots Henry. She still feels resentment toward him, due to the mining tragedy that killed her father. Mollie reminds her daughter how Henry has changed since the tragedy took place. Elizabeth wants Rosaleen to reach her full potential. So, she approaches Lucas and proposes a job offer for Rosaleen at the saloon. But Elizabeth isn’t the only character looking out for Rosaleen. Henry comes to Lucas with an idea; creating the Hope Valley Scholarship. This scholarship would allow current and former students of the Jack Thornton School to achieve their academic dreams. When Rosaleen, Florence, and Mollie hear about the scholarship, they are thrilled by the news. Little do they know Henry created the scholarship, as he wished to remain anonymous.

Madeleine and Bill signed the official papers on Bill’s property, making Madeleine the owner of the cabin and its surrounding land. But Madeleine and Jaime must return to Philadelphia to take care of Sebastian’s remaining legal matters. While waiting for their return, Bill gathers house-warming presents to give to Madeleine and Jaime. This is done in an effort to make the cabin feel like their home. When he is questioned over a butter churn, Bill states how it can be used as a flowerpot. Other Hope Valley residents consider donating their items to Jaime and Madeleine. Elizabeth even thinks about donating two baking pans to the family. When Bill and Nathan go to the cabin to drop off the presents, they discover others are residing in the cabin. While there, they meet a man named Montague who claims to now own the land. He also claims to be Madeleine’s fiancé.

Lucas has recently purchased a surprise for Hope Valley. But the only people who are in on Lucas’ secret are Ned, Mike, and Fiona. The surprise is Hope Valley’s first radio. Though excited by this new piece of technology, none of the four characters can make the radio work. Mike and Ned believe the inner workings of the radio are the problem. Fiona, on the other hand, thinks the radio needs an antenna. She goes to Joseph to gather scrap copper and steel. Fiona not only wants the antenna to be functional, but also durable. After several failed attempts to make the radio work, Fiona’s antenna is put to the test. When the antenna is attached to the saloon’s balcony and the radio is turned on, music can be heard! Everyone in Hope Valley celebrates this new gift be hosting an impromptu dance at the saloon.

Library image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/stack-of-books-on-library-desk_2509490.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/school”>School image created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

Joseph wants to become Hope Valley’s full-time pastor. This will allow him more preaching opportunities, as well as to perform pastor related duties in Eagle Creek. When he visits Lee to tell him about his professional plans, Lee offers him a partner position at the lumber mill. Before Joseph can turn the offer down, Lee assumes Joseph has accepted the offer. Joseph is now in an awkward position because of the misunderstanding. Later in the episode, the Canfield family attends a dinner at the Coulters’ house. Joseph and Minnie see this as a chance to clear up the misunderstanding. After dinner, Joseph is honest with Lee about his full-time pastor plans. Though disappointed about losing a good employee, Lee is supportive of Joseph’s calling. Toward the end of the episode, Lee offers the partner position to Richard, who accepts.

While making his rounds near Hope Valley, Nathan comes across a man named Mr. Hunter. Mr. Hunter appears lethargic, seeming not to understand what Nathan is saying. They go immediately to Hope Valley’s infirmary, where Faith discovers Mr. Hunter is dangerously close to suffering from heatstroke. During his initial treatment, Mr. Hunter asks where the “real” doctor is. In order to get Mr. Hunter to follow medical directions, Mike pretends to be the “real” doctor of Hope Valley. Toward the end of Mr. Hunter’s treatment, Mei arrives at the infirmary to give Mr. Hunter his medication. After Mr. Hunter asks if Mei is the “real” pharmacist, Faith tells Mr. Hunter the truth. She not only confesses that she is, indeed, Hope Valley’s doctor, but she also shares how she knew what was wrong with Mr. Hunter. Both Faith and Mike stand up for Mei as well. Mr. Hunter apologizes for his statements.

String of musical notes image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/pentagram-vector_710290.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a> <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com. 

Some thoughts to consider:

  • Toward the end of this episode, Nathan and Faith have a heart-to-heart conversation about the state of their relationship. They both agree to just remain friends, abandoning the pursuit of a romantic relationship. I think this decision is for the best because, this season, I haven’t found Faith and Nathan’s interactions interesting. That is due to these interactions feeling forced.
  • Speaking of Faith, her story in this episode was so disappointing. Her patient could have been Harry’s father. Throughout the story, we could have seen at least one bonding moment between father and son. The audience could have also learned more about these two characters. Therefore, this particular story was a missed opportunity.
  • At the beginning of the episode, Rosemary discusses with Lee the idea of hiring a babysitter for their daughter. Rosaleen also mentioned in this episode how she is a nanny. With all that said, why don’t the Coulters hire Rosaleen to babysit Goldy? It would be a situation where everyone benefits. The Coulters would have found a trusted babysitter to look after their daughter while they are at work. And Rosaleen would earn money for nursing school while also living closer to her mother.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Which character would you like to see earn the Hope Valley scholarship? Please tell me in the comment section!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen

Take 3: Anna and the King Review

On By 18cinemalane9 Comments

I know what you’re thinking, “What does Anna and the King have to do with the number five”? Well, I’m glad you asked! As Rebecca has stated in the announcement post for the Fifth Broadway Bound Blogathon, all entries had to have something to do with the number five, to commemorate the event’s fifth anniversary. For my selection, Anna and the King, which stars Bai Ling, was released in 1999, five years after The Crow premiered. From what I’ve heard, The Crow was Bai Ling’s first American/English film. Last year, when I reviewed the 1956 adaptation of The King and I, I mentioned Anna and the King was a non-musical version of the story. As I write this review, I realize I haven’t seen many non-musical film adaptations of musicals. Sure, I’ve heard of these types of productions. But, off the top of my head, a non-musical adaptation doesn’t immediately come to mind. So, with this review, I will expand my cinematic horizons!

Anna and the King poster created by Fox 2000 Pictures, Lawrence Bender Productions, and 20th Century Fox

Things I liked about the film:

The acting: Anna and the King is a drama film with a more serious tone. Therefore, Jodie Foster’s portrayal of Anna is sterner in nature. However, Anna also comes across as being fair. A great example of this is when she is disciplining both her son and King Mongkut’s eldest son. In the evening, when the royal family is bringing Anna dinner, Jodie presents a mild-mannered sweetness that feels genuine. As she’s realizing the dinner is for her and not King Mongkut’s son, Anna never displays any meanness toward her student, as she truly wants to teach him a valuable lesson. King Mongkut himself is also a stern, yet fair character. Chow Yun-fat balances the seriousness and loving sides of his character consistently throughout the film. In one of their many conversations, King Mongkut is asked by Anna if his wives ever get jealous of one another. Even though this question is a personal one, King Mongkut never appears offended. Instead, his calm, collected, and approachable demeanor make the conversation less awkward than it could have gotten. One of these aforementioned wives is Tuptim. Portrayed by Bai Ling, Tuptim is an emotional character that expresses herself in subtle ways. It’s not until she faces a life-or-death moment where more of her emotions are drawn forward. While I won’t spoil Anna and the King for those of my readers who might be interested in seeing it, Bai delivers on the emotional intensity needed for a moment like the one I just mentioned. But even outside of that moment, Bai knows how to use emotion in her and her character’s favor.

The set design: Anna and the King is a beautiful looking film! One of the reasons why is its set design. Everywhere you look, exquisite detail and impressive structure helped elevate the world around Anna and King Mongkut. The royal family takes a trip in a massive river boat. This boat was a deep blue with gold etched artwork. At the head of the boat, a set of giant golden dragons adorn this beautiful mode of transportation. On the walls of King Mongkut’s palace, a full-length mural consistently coats the interior perimeter of rooms and even a hallway. The mural itself appears painted, depicting the natural landscape of Siam. Smaller elements like the ones I mentioned added to the overall beauty of the set design!

The costume design: Similar to the 1956 adaptation, the costume design in Anna and the King was simply elegant! One notable example was Anna’s reception gown. At this event, Anna wore a full length, white gown. The off the shoulder bodice and sparkly skirt was not only eye-catching, it also felt reminiscent of Belle’s gown from the 1991 animated film, Beauty and the Beast. At this same reception, King Mongkut’s wives also wear beautiful gowns. Tuptim’s was especially pretty, a simple yet classy red dress. What also complimented Tuptim’s ensemble was a sparkly gold and bronze crown that adorned her dark hair. The exquisiteness of the costume design carried the spirit of The King and I story!

The Fifth Broadway Bound Blogathon banner created by Rebecca from Taking Up Room

What I didn’t like about the film:

The war story-line: Because Anna and the King is a non-musical version of The King and I, there needs to be something to replace the musical numbers. In the 1999 adaptation, that replacement was a subplot about a war between the Siamese and the Burmese. While it was interesting to explore the tense side of ruling a country, I found this subplot to be the weakest one. That subplot was drawn-out, getting resolved at the very end of the movie. With the run-time being two hours and twenty-eight minutes, the war story-line felt longer than it really was.

Under-utilized characters: Anna and the King contains a larger cast of characters. Therefore, some of them are bound to receive less screen-time than others. Tuptim was, once again, one of those characters. After seeing how under-utilized Rita Moreno’s talents were in the 1956 adaptation, I was hoping Bai Ling would receive more screen time. Sadly, she only appeared in a handful of scenes. In the 1956 adaptation, Tuptim created a play based on Uncle Tom’s Cabin, giving her a reason to stay on screen a little bit longer. Because there is no Uncle Tom’s Cabin play in the 1999 adaptation and because only King Mongkut’s oldest son reads Uncle Tom’s Cabin, Tuptim, in Anna and the King, has less reasons to stay on screen.

No musical Easter eggs: Before I wrote this review, I was well aware Anna and the King was not a musical film. But because the film is an adaptation of a musical, it was a missed opportunity to not include musical related Easter eggs. In the 1956 adaptation, King Mongkut says “Et cetera, et cetera, et cetera” on multiple occasions, whenever he had something important to say. In the 1999 adaptation, however, King Mongkut never says the aforementioned quote. One of the songs from the 1956 adaptation is ‘Shall We Dance?’. During both versions of this story, King Mongkut and Anna dance with one another. However, it would have been nice to hear one of them say “shall we dance.”

Hand-written letter image created by Veraholera at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background vector created by Veraholera – Freepik.com</a>. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/love-letter-pattern_1292902.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

My overall impression:

Anna and the King is a fine, competently made film. The movie’s creative team clearly knew what they doing, displaying the clear direction they wanted to take their adaptation. But compared to the 1956 musical, I find myself liking the musical more. Without the musical numbers, it feels like the story is missing something. Even though the 1999 adaptation found a replacement for the lack of musical numbers, I was wishing they hadn’t been omitted. I would have even accepted Easter eggs related to the musical, such as quotes from the songs woven into the dialogue. But despite its shortcomings, Anna and the King does attempt to make meaningful changes that were not in the 1956 musical. One of these changes is giving Anna’s son, Louis, and some of King Mongkut’s children their own unique personalities and a little more involvement in the overall story. As for Bai Ling’s involvement in the film, I wish she was given more on-screen appearances. But because Anna and the King is based on The King and I, which also showed Tuptim in only a handful of scenes, maybe I was naïve to think more material was available?

Overall score: 7.2 out of 10

Have you seen Anna and the King or The King and I? Can you think of any musicals that received a non-musical adaptation? Let me know in the comment section!

Have fun at the movies!

Sally Silverscreen

Sunset Over Hope Valley: Growing Pains

On By 18cinemalaneLeave a comment

Every show experiences “growing pains”. Characters come and go each season. Even when they stick around, characters change as the seasons go by. Stories begin and end, some of them taking longer than a season. But no matter how a show begins, its landscape is not the same as when the show ends/continues. This can be said about When Calls the Heart. So much has happened within this show’s lifespan. There has even been a lot going on in the ninth season, despite it not reaching the halfway point yet. Whether you’ve been watching When Calls the Heart since the very beginning or have just recently tuned in, we can all agree that this is not a stagnant show. With all that said, it’s time to start this re-cap of When Calls the Heart!

Just a reminder: If you did not see this episode of When Calls the Heart, there will be spoilers within this re-cap.

When Calls the Heart season nine poster created by Crown Media Family Networks and Hallmark Channel

Season: 9

Episode: 4

Name: Straight from the Heart

Major stories:

Mr. Landis has returned to Hope Valley. As he’s about to approach the Jack Thornton School, Elizabeth reminds him how she went to Hamilton and received her certification to teach Angela. Problem is, she was supposed to obtain that certification in her respective school district, which is not located in Hamilton. Because of this error on Elizabeth’s part, Mr. Landis claims her certification is invalid. He ends up sitting in on Elizabeth’s class because of this news. During a spelling test, Cooper accidently breaks his pencil. When he receives a new pencil, Cooper tells Elizabeth he doesn’t like Mr. Landis. While he didn’t state in that moment why he didn’t like Mr. Landis, Elizabeth believes it has to do with the superintendent causing Angela and her trouble. One day, during class, Elizabeth and Mr. Landis discuss the situation in private. Elizabeth feels that as long as the school is not officially a part of the Valley school district, she gets to control the school how she wishes. But Mr. Landis disagrees, saying her school will have to join the district sooner or later. Before Mr. Landis leaves, he discovers his hat was glued to a table. Even though the students think the prank is funny, both Elizabeth and Mr. Landis are not pleased. The next day, Cooper confesses to gluing Mr. Landis’ hat. In an after-school meeting, Cooper says he isn’t sorry for pulling the prank. But he is sorry for causing Elizabeth and his sister any trouble. His parents agree to have Cooper earn extra money to purchase a new hat for Mr. Landis.

Bill is still suspicious about Wyman. He continues to inspect Wyman’s gun, which was confiscated in the previous episode. When the gun doesn’t reveal any clues, Bill turns to Lee and Rosemary in an attempt to find answers. Rosemary says she has newspaper related connections in several towns, volunteering to find any information about Wyman’s whereabouts. With Rosemary’s help, Bill discovers Wyman was detained in Brookfield before returning to Hope Valley. He wasn’t held for long, though, because he didn’t receive any official charges. While Wyman was in Brookfield, he tried to take advantage of businessowners, similar to how Wyman tried to take advantage of Jesse in season eight. A businessowner was also shot, currently in a coma. Later in the episode, Wyman comes into Hope Valley with Julius Spurlock. When Nathan and Bill ask the men to hand over their weapons, Julius and Wyman conveniently don’t have them in their possession. Lucas even warns the men to stay away from Elizabeth and Jack Jr.

Chalkboard image created by Freepik at freepik.com. <a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/mathematical-operation-written-on-blackboard_1357576.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Minor stories:

 Toward the beginning of the episode, Mei visits Nathan at the jail. She wants to know if Nathan would like to work with Newton. Nathan agrees, with this decision working out in the long run. Through these interactions with Mei and Newton, Nathan is able to regain his connection with his horse. Mei reminds him situations like this one take time and trust. To thank Mei for her help, Nathan invites her to dinner at any restaurant of her choice. Mei accepts this offer, choosing the saloon as their destination. At the dinner, Mei arrives with an ointment. She claims this will help relax the muscles in Nathan’s shoulder, which is still in a sling. But before the dinner took place, Mei asked Bill for his help. She hires him as her attorney, claiming she’s a fugitive against her husband. This statement was never clarified in this episode.

Because Laura is sick with the flu, Elizabeth is left without a babysitter for Jack Jr. After overhearing a conversation between Florence and Ned, Lucas volunteers to help. Despite having little to no childcare experience, Lucas tries his best to make the most of his time with Elizabeth’s son. During the day, he takes Jack Jr. for a wagon ride in Hope Valley. They ride past Henry, who wonders where Fiona is. This is because Henry wants to tell Fiona he is staying with the petroleum plant, especially if the investors agree with his decision. Lucas and Jack Jr. also meet up with Rosemary. Lucas tells Rosemary Jack Jr. appears to be feeling down. When she suggests giving him ice cream, Lucas dissuades this idea, as Elizabeth told him not to give Jack Jr. any ice cream. Rosemary then suggests visiting Faith for help. Faith discovers Jack Jr. has inflamed gums, though the situation can be easily taken care of. She also reassures Lucas that he is doing the best he can looking after Jack Jr. Elizabeth is pleased with Lucas’ babysitting efforts. But she’s not pleased he installed a phone in her house without her permission. Over an ice cream date, Elizabeth explains to Lucas why she doesn’t want a phone. Lucas does apologize and explain the benefits of having this piece of technology. After this, Elizabeth reconsiders having a phone.

Joseph has accepted a bookkeeping job at Lee’s lumberyard. While discussing this new job with Minnie, he brings up the idea of purchasing half of the company. Joseph believes by doing this, he would have something for himself. This statement causes Minnie to consider her responsibilities at the café. They both agree to focus on the future instead of dwelling on the past. Cooper’s behavior in school concerns both Minnie and Joseph. Their son’s attitude toward Mr. Landis also concerns them. While at the café one day, Joseph and Minnie discuss how to handle the situation. As a car drives up to the café’s porch, Joseph notices the car’s damaged front end. When he questions the driver how the car got in that condition, the driver runs away. Joseph not only chases the driver, but also catches him. It is revealed this driver is the one who hit Nathan and Newton. The driver is taken to jail, with his identity never being revealed in this episode.

Old fashioned telephone image created by Kues1 at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/vintage”>Vintage photo created by kues1 – http://www.freepik.com</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

Some thoughts to consider:

  • I know Mr. Landis’ presence is meant to cause drama and conflict within the overarching story. However, it’s kind of a shame that he is portrayed as a villain. As far as I can tell, Mr. Landis is just doing his job. If anyone is to blame, it’s, in my opinion, Elizabeth. She spent the previous season avoiding the process to obtain the aforementioned credentials to teach Angela. Yet, during this same season, Elizabeth somehow found the time to maintain her love life and write her book. Even when she did obtain these credentials, Elizabeth didn’t seem to take the time to learn how to receive them properly. If anything, she needs to take responsibility for her actions.
  • I’m kind of disappointed the mystery of Nathan’s car accident was wrapped up so quickly. This story could have been drawn out for a little bit longer. The guilty party could also have been discovered by an unlikely character, leading to a shocking reveal. But the reveal in this episode was anti-climactic. We don’t even know who committed the crime. The mystery reminds me of Dylan’s arrival in season eight’s premiere.
  • In this episode, we learn a little bit of information about Mei. But by this point in the season, I was hoping we’d get more information about her. Granted, we’re not halfway through the season yet. So, there’s still plenty of time for Mei’s story to be told. I just hope her story isn’t drawn out for too long.
Sunset image created by Photoangel at freepik.com. <a href=”https://www.freepik.com/free-photos-vectors/background”>Background image created by Photoangel – Freepik.com</a>.<a href=’https://www.freepik.com/free-photo/red-sunset-clouds-over-trees_1254327.htm’>Designed by Freepik</a>. Image found at freepik.com.

What are your thoughts on this episode? Which story has been your favorite so far? Please tell me in the comment section below!

Have fun in Hope Valley!

Sally Silverscreen