It’s been a little while since I reviewed a made-for-TV mystery film, as my article for Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery was published two months ago. I cover UP Network movies so infrequently and UP Network doesn’t often create mystery titles. These are the reasons why I chose to review Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise! This is not the first time a mystery story has featured Amish characters. Hallmark released An Uncommon Grace back in 2017 and Harvest of Fire from Hallmark Hall of Fame. Meanwhile, it’s not the first time Galadriel Stineman has appeared in a movie incorporating the Amish culture. In 2020, she starred in a Hallmark production called Follow Your Heart.Looking back on the films I referenced, I liked Follow Your Heart and An Uncommon Grace. However, I thought Harvest of Fire was just fine. Where does Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise rank among these movies? Let’s solve this mystery by beginning my review!
Things I liked about the film:
The incorporation of Amish culture: In the introduction of this review, I mentioned seeing the Hallmark Hall of Fame film, Harvest of Fire. The 1996 presentation places so much emphasis on introducing the audience to Amish culture, the story’s mystery becomes overshadowed. With Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise, the creative team finds a nice balance between prioritizing the mysteries and introducing Amish culture to their audience. Throughout the 2025 film, elements of Amish culture are woven into the dialogue and interactions of the characters. When Cheryl meets Naomi for the first time, Cheryl admits she knows very little about the Amish. She then asks Naomi how Amish people greet one another. Naomi playfully teases Cheryl’s lack of knowledge by telling her Amish people shake their feet. However, this teasing is in good humor, never intending to shame Cheryl for not knowing the appropriate greetings among the Amish. Naomi and Cheryl’s interaction feels like a natural conversation between two people. The way the creative team wrote Amish culture into their project actually encourages the audience to learn through communication.
The messages and themes: During her time in Sugarcreek, Cheryl agrees to work at her aunt’s Swiss Miss country store. On her first day as a cashier, everything seems to go wrong. The next day, Cheryl tells Naomi about her first day at the Swiss Miss. To encourage Cheryl to not give up, Naomi reminds her how the previous day’s blunders could be seen as lessons to learn. Not only is Naomi’s advice a good message to share with the audience, this piece of advice plays an important role in other parts of the story. This aspect of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise kind of reminded me of Hallmark’s Signed, Sealed, Delivered series.
Avoiding clichés and tropes: If someone has seen many made-for-TV mystery movies, there are certain tropes and clichés they would come to expect. One of these tropes is having the female and male protagonist working together to solve the mystery, with these characters eventually forming a romantic relationship. The female protagonist, Cheryl, gets involved in solving the story’s mysteries in Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise. But the movie’s male protagonist, Levi, did not help in the amateur investigation. Instead, Naomi worked alongside Cheryl on one of the story’s cases. Having Cheryl and Naomi work together in Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise was a creative way to avoid some of the tropes and clichés of made-for-TV mystery films. If this movie becomes the first chapter in a series, I’d be curious to see what other clichés and tropes the creative team chooses to avoid?
What I didn’t like about the film:
A mystery that was solved too quickly: There are two mysteries in Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise: who is leaving unpriced stuffed animals in the Swiss Miss country store and the kidnapping of a baby. When it comes to the first mystery, I actually liked its creativity. But I was taken by surprise by how quickly that mystery was solved. After the stuffed animals’ origin was discovered, the subject was dropped from the script. Because of how this mystery connected to the story, I thought it could have created a domino effect for the characters and the world of Sugarcreek. But that did not happen. I think the mystery of the stuffed animals should have been drawn out for a longer period of time, to keep the audience invested in that part of the story.
Lack of urgency: As I just mentioned in this review, there are two mysteries in Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise. One of those mysteries was the kidnapping of a baby. When a mystery movie includes a kidnapping in its script, that story will usually contain a strong sense of urgency. This is because the characters are racing against the clock to rescue the victim. But in Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise, there was no sense of urgency. That flaw caused the story to change its focus from the kidnapped baby to proving a character’s innocence. The lack of urgency also made the film feel drawn out a bit longer than its run-time.
The underutilization of Kathy: Portrayed by Andi Anderson, Kathy is one of the residents of Sugarcreek. Cheryl first meets Kathy when she goes to Kathy’s café. I was hoping a friendship would be formed between Kathy and Cheryl, with Kathy even helping Cheryl solve the film’s mysteries. Unfortunately, Kathy appeared in only two scenes throughout the entire movie. Giving Kathy such an extremely limited involvement in the story was, in my opinion, a missed opportunity. If Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise lends itself to a movie series, I hope Kathy receives a larger role in the story.
My overall impression:
Even though it’s not the halfway point of 2025 yet, most of the movies I’ve seen this year, so far, have been mid-tier. These titles have either been ok or decent. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise is contributing to that perspective. If UP Network is serious about creating a series out of this movie, they need to fix the lack of urgency. I would also like to see UP Network give Kathy a greater role in the story and not solve mysteries too quickly. Looking back on the 2025 presentation, however, I think there is potential for Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise to lead a series. Out of the films I brought up in this review’s introduction; Follow Your Heart, An Uncommon Grace, and Harvest of Fire, these titles were stand-alone films. In fact, the only movie series I can think of that features the Amish culture is Hallmark’s Beverly Lewis trilogy, consisting of The Shunning, The Reckoning, and The Confession. UP Network has an opportunity to bring something new to the table of made-for-TV mystery films. But as of the publication of this review, there have been no official plans announced for Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries.
Overall score: 6 out of 10
Have you seen Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise? Would you like to see this movie start a new series? Tell me in the comment section!
Have fun in Sugarcreek!
Sally Silverscreen
18 Cinema Lane 